Logo

    A.B. Stoddard: Only in America

    en-usAugust 23, 2024
    What themes did Kamala Harris emphasize in her speech?
    How did Kamala Harris's background influence her message?
    What was the significance of the Republican speakers at the convention?
    How does Harris position herself against President Trump?
    What impact does Harris's identity have on her political messaging?

    Podcast Summary

    • American DreamThe American Dream emphasizes hard work, unity, and overcoming adversity, as highlighted in Kamala Harris's DNC speech. Harris, as the first Black woman nominated for VP, shared her personal story of growing up as an immigrant and emphasized the importance of embracing the country's history and focusing on its hope and opportunity.

      Learning from the Democratic National Convention speech given by Kamala Harris is her strong emphasis on the American dream and the importance of hard work, unity, and overcoming adversity. Harris, as the first Black woman to accept a major party's nomination for vice president, shared her personal story of growing up as an immigrant and the challenges she faced. She highlighted the importance of embracing the country's history, flaws, and all, and focusing on the hope and opportunity it offers. Harris's message resonated with many, as she presented herself as a unifying figure, emphasizing the shared experiences and stories of Americans, regardless of their backgrounds. Overall, her speech was a powerful reminder of the enduring power and appeal of the American dream.

    • Authenticity in politicsKamala Harris's unexpectedly heartfelt and engaging DNC speech showcased her resilience and contrasted her personal experiences with Trump's divisiveness, resonating with audiences and marking a departure from her past calculated image.

      Kamala Harris's Democratic National Convention speech was a surprising and compelling display of authenticity and resilience. Harris, who has been criticized for being calculating and robotic in the past, delivered a heartfelt and engaging speech that contrasted her own experiences of overcoming challenges with the divisiveness of Trump's complaints. Her story, which has not been shared extensively before, added to the compelling nature of the speech and gave viewers a new perspective on her candidacy. Harris's delivery was also notable for its buoyancy, gratitude, confidence, and genuine engagement with the material. Overall, the speech exceeded expectations and provided a captivating moment in the campaign. Harris's earlier reluctance to share her story suggests that this moment of vulnerability and authenticity was a significant departure for her, and it resonated with audiences in a way that her previous performances had not.

    • Harris's DNC speechKamala Harris introduced herself as a moderate with a personal story, attacked Trump, and presented a united Democratic Party message focusing on American values and freedom.

      Kamala Harris's Democratic National Convention speech effectively introduced herself, presented a moderate tone, and attacked Trump in a meaningful way. Harris defined herself through sharing her personal story while maintaining confidence and strength. Her tone was inclusive and focused on American values, such as freedom, family, and opportunity. She successfully paired traditional Republican themes with progressive values, creating a unique and authentic message. The speech aimed to showcase the Democrats as a party embracing patriotism and freedom, while contrasting Trump's negative portrayal of America. This convention marked a shift from the divisive primary season and presented a united front for the Democratic Party.

    • Harris's foreign policy stanceKamala Harris's presidential campaign speech highlighted her moderate stance on immigration and foreign policy, emphasizing her commitment to defending American interests and standing up to autocratic leaders, with strong stance on Ukraine and NATO, and effective handling of Israel-Gaza issue earning her praise from a wide range of voters.

      Kamala Harris's presidential campaign speech showcased her moderate stance on various issues, particularly immigration and foreign policy. She emphasized her commitment to defending American interests and standing up to autocratic leaders, asserting that they are rooting for President Trump because he shares their authoritarian tendencies. Harris's strong stance on Ukraine and NATO, as well as her effective handling of the Israel-Gaza issue, were highlights of her speech, earning her praise from a wide range of voters. Overall, Harris's speech demonstrated her ability to appeal to both moderate and progressive voters by balancing tough foreign policy with compassionate domestic policies.

    • Kamala Harris' DNC speech contrastKamala Harris effectively contrasted herself with Trump by positioning herself as a leader for the people, while Trump was portrayed as only looking out for himself. Harris emphasized her love for America and her desire to improve it, while Trump was criticized for his intentions to pardon extremists, jail journalists, and political opponents.

      Learning from the discussion about Kamala Harris' Democratic National Convention speech is that she effectively contrasted herself with Donald Trump by positioning herself as a leader for the people, while Trump was portrayed as only looking out for himself. Harris emphasized her love for America and her desire to improve it, while Trump was criticized for his explicit intentions to pardon extremists, jail journalists, and political opponents. The theme of the speech was Harris' commitment to the country and her intention to protect the rule of law and the peaceful transfer of power. Harris' speech was also notable for its clarity and lack of ideological leaning, which was seen as a departure from previous Democratic attempts to appeal to the left. Overall, Harris' speech was successful in presenting a clear contrast between herself and Trump and in emphasizing her commitment to the American people.

    • Harris's positioning as a challengerVice President Harris effectively positions herself as a challenger to President Trump by highlighting differences, emphasizing her role as a sitting VP, and creating contrast through her identity and communication skills.

      Kamala Harris is effectively positioning herself as a challenger to President Trump by highlighting her differences from the current era and emphasizing her role as a sitting vice president. Her identity as a black woman also helps in creating a contrast. Harris has managed to express gratitude towards Joe Biden while also subtly expressing her desire to move on from the current era. Her speeches and the Democratic National Convention have been designed to keep the base engaged while also trying to attract voters from other camps. A notable moment came from Republican Adam Kinzinger's speech criticizing Trump for not embodying conservative principles. Overall, Harris's ability to create a contrast and her effective communication skills have made her a formidable challenger.

    • Republican Party shiftThe presence of Donald Trump significantly altered the Republican Party, making it smaller and more cult-like, while the Democrats are seen as the party of patriotism. Republican speakers who criticized Trump and endorsed Biden were crucial in defining this divide and helping Biden attract center-right voters and conflicted Republicans.

      The Republican Party as it once was known has been significantly altered by the presence of Donald Trump. Speakers like Jeff Duncan, Adam Kinzinger, and Olivia Troye, who came forward to criticize Trump and endorse Joe Biden, were crucial in defining the Democrats as the party of patriotism and the current Republican Party as small and cult-like. Biden's campaign benefits from this division, as he needs to attract center-right voters and Republicans who feel conflicted or ashamed about voting for Trump again. The absence of any Trump cabinet officials or sitting Republican elected officials at the Democratic National Convention was a stark reminder of this shift. The bravery of these Republican speakers in speaking out against Trump was commended, and their endorsements of Kamala Harris were seen as important steps in building a buffer for Biden against the Republican Party's liability in the Electoral College.

    • Trump's InterviewFormer President Trump's erratic behavior during a Fox News interview contrasted Biden's measured speech, while the Fed's interest rate cut announcement could benefit Harris's campaign

      During a recent Fox News interview, former President Trump made headlines for his erratic behavior and controversial statements. He criticized Joe Biden's convention speech, accusing him of neglecting important issues like fracking, crime, poverty, and border security. Trump also claimed that Biden was not doing well in the polls and boasted about his own success. The interview ended abruptly when Trump called into Newsmax and suggested going to Caracas with the anchors. The interview showcased Trump's unstable and unpredictable demeanor, which was a stark contrast to Biden's measured and focused speech. Additionally, the Federal Reserve's announcement of upcoming interest rate cuts is expected to ease economic anxiety and potentially help Kamala Harris's campaign in the fall.

    • Democratic National ConventionThe Democratic National Convention was a historic and emotional event, a proud moment to be an American citizen, and a reminder of the importance of acknowledging strengths and achievements in politics.

      Despite the ongoing political debates and concerns, it's important to appreciate historic moments like the Democratic National Convention. While it's crucial to hold politicians accountable, we can also acknowledge their strengths and achievements. The convention was a historic and emotional event, and it was a proud moment to be an American citizen. So, take some time to enjoy the weekend and recharge before getting back to advocating for change. The podcast, "The Briefing Room," will continue to cover political issues, and if anything significant happens over the weekend, listeners can catch the hosts on YouTube. As the song goes, "They come to America, they come to America," and we all have a role to play in shaping its future. The podcast is produced by Katie Cooper, with audio engineering and editing by Jason Brown.

    Recent Episodes from The Bulwark Podcast

    Jeffrey Goldberg: Trump Doesn't Believe in America

    Jeffrey Goldberg: Trump Doesn't Believe in America
    The former president doesn't think our country is exceptional, and the political press won't hold him to any standard because it has zero expectations of him. Plus, Lindsey Graham is an empty shell, John Kelly was nearly driven mad working for Trump, and JD Vance can't stop spinning conspiracies. 

    Jeffrey Goldberg joins Tim Miller for the weekend pod.

    show notes

    Jeffrey's new book, “On Heroism: McCain, Milley, Mattis, and the Cowardice of Donald Trump"
    Atlantic piece on Trump's diminished speech abilities
    JVL's Triad newsletter from Thursday
    Orlando Sentinel's straightforward headline about a Trump threat
    Tim's playlist 

    The Bulwark Podcast
    en-usSeptember 13, 2024

    Mark McKinnon: Taking Back the Freedom Agenda

    Mark McKinnon: Taking Back the Freedom Agenda
    While Republicans paint a vision of America as a dystopian hellscape, Kamala is helping herself to the sunny optimism of Reagan and the Bushes. Plus, Taylor is breaking MAGA's brains and driving up voter registrations, Sarah Palin is no longer the worst VP candidate, and Laura Loomer is even too crazy for MTG. Mark McKinnon joins Tim Miller.
    The Bulwark Podcast
    en-usSeptember 12, 2024

    S.E. Cupp: A Sucker and a Loser

    S.E. Cupp: A Sucker and a Loser
    Kamala laid trap after trap during the debate, and because he's so impulsive, Trump walked into every single one. And while he seethed, she was the normal and sane one—who came so prepared she was name-dropping missiles and tanks. It was a good night. S.E. Cupp joins Tim Miller, who also shares his scoops from the spin room.

    show notes:

    S.E.'s show, "Battleground"
    The Bulwark Podcast
    en-usSeptember 11, 2024

    Symone Sanders Townsend and Olivia Nuzzi: Kamala v the Weirdo

    Symone Sanders Townsend and Olivia Nuzzi: Kamala v the Weirdo
    Trump and Kamala are meeting for the first time at tonight's debate, because in 2021, he took his ball, went home, and skipped the inauguration. Seven weeks after the change in the ticket, Trump still doesn't seem to know how to fight her— while Kamala will likely be focused on her message of fighting for the people vs Trump fighting for himself.

    show notes:

    Olivia's piece, "I Examined Donald Trump’s Ear — and His Soul — at Mar-a-Lago
    Symone's MSNBC show, "The Weekend" 
    The Bulwark Podcast
    en-usSeptember 10, 2024

    Bill Kristol and Colin Allred: What's So Hard about This, Pres. Bush?

    Bill Kristol and Colin Allred: What's So Hard about This, Pres. Bush?
    This is not a close call, Bush 43: Follow your vice president's lead and say you're voting for Kamala. Meanwhile, stay alarmed that this is a close race, and don't forget that JD cares more about guns than kids. Plus, after 12 years of Ted Cruz not caring about his state, have Texans had enough? Tim Miller spoke with Rep. Colin Allred at TribFest in Austin, and Bill Kristol joined for a political news roundup.

    show notes
    Tim on Kamala's new "Best People" ad featuring ex-Trump appointees

    The Bulwark Podcast
    en-usSeptember 09, 2024

    Live from Dallas

    Live from Dallas
    Before a packed house in D-Town, Tim Miller and Adam Kinzinger covered it all, from Trump's incoherent muttering about childcare to his graveside camera-mugging. Plus big boos for Cruz, advice for Colin Allred, and should Kinzinger run for Congress from Texas? Our first of two live shows from the Lone Star State.
    The Bulwark Podcast
    en-usSeptember 06, 2024

    David Frum: Villains and Monsters

    David Frum: Villains and Monsters
    After the decade we've been living through, we will remember the people like Liz Cheney, who have made the choices that really matter. Meanwhile, will the MAGA influencers who say they were unwitting Russian propagandists give their millions back? Plus, Tucker's praise and promotion of Holocaust denialism, Vance's pathological feelings about women, and the continuing tragedy of guns everywhere in America. 

    David Frum joins Tim Miller.
    show notes:

    Frum's recent piece on the Gaza protesters

    The Bulwark Podcast
    en-usSeptember 05, 2024

    Neera Tanden and Heidi Heitkamp: Trump Playing the Media, Again

    Neera Tanden and Heidi Heitkamp: Trump Playing the Media, Again
    The media still haven't figured out how to cover Trump, so they don't scrutinize even his most shocking statements—like when he claimed he had the right to interfere in the '20 election. Plus, Kamala's strong Indian mom, the Dems' improved response to sexist and racist attacks, winning rural voters, Mark Robinson's porn habits, and how it looks in Trump country. 

    Neera Tanden and Sen. Heidi Heitkamp join Tim Miller.

    show notes:

    Heitkamp's One Country Project
    Heitkamp's "Hot Dish" podcast

    The Bulwark Podcast
    en-usSeptember 04, 2024

    Brian Schatz and Mona Charen: Democrats Don't Trust Happiness

    Brian Schatz and Mona Charen: Democrats Don't Trust Happiness
    Kamala is showing that she's good at politics by uniting the party's coalition and making appeals to the center. But many Democrats can't help themselves and are just waiting for all hell to break loose. Plus, building affordable homes, conserving the republic vs. preserving conservative policies—and Walz, the everyman. Sen. Brian Schatz and Mona Charen join Tim Miller.

    show notes:

    Mona's piece, "What Are We Conserving?"
    Pat Toomey on CNBC today
    The Bulwark Podcast
    en-usSeptember 03, 2024

    Bill Kristol: Stay on Offense

    Bill Kristol: Stay on Offense
    Kamala looks to have a very narrow lead in the polls, but she needs to do more to drive Trump down—a good target would be his announcement that he's voting against protecting abortion rights in Florida. Plus, his sudden concern for Pence and Vance's copious podcast blathering. 

    Bill Kristol joins Tim Miller for a special Labor Day pod. 

    show notes:

    USA Today piece about Will Selber
    Hersh Goldberg-Polin's childhood bedroom with art about Jerusalem 

    The Bulwark Podcast
    en-usSeptember 02, 2024