Logo
    Search

    Apple’s ad backlash, 'I’m not your mum' and Zahawi’s exit strategy

    enMay 14, 2024

    Podcast Summary

    • Apple's Insensitive Ad, Mint Mobile's Price CutCompanies must balance innovation and public perception to maintain a positive reputation. Apple faced criticism for an insensitive ad, while Mint Mobile gained positive attention by offering affordable prices.

      No matter how powerful or innovative a company may be, it can still face public backlash over perceived insensitive advertising. Apple, the world's most valuable company with a trillion-dollar market value, recently faced criticism for an ad promoting the new iPad Pro, which showed various objects being crushed to demonstrate the device's capabilities. While the intention was to show the iPad's versatility, the ad was perceived as insensitive and tone-deaf by some viewers. This incident highlights the importance of careful consideration and sensitivity in marketing strategies, especially for large corporations with significant reach and influence. Meanwhile, Mint Mobile, a wireless company, is making headlines for cutting its prices in response to competitors' price hikes, offering a more affordable alternative for consumers. In the world of PR, companies must navigate the delicate balance between innovation and public perception to maintain a positive reputation.

    • Apple's Controversial iPad Pro Ad and Lack of Diversity in PerspectiveApple's leadership's lack of self-awareness and internal critics led to a controversial ad that missed the mark, damaging the company's reputation and relationship with its creative community.

      Apple's recent misstep with their controversial iPad Pro advert highlights a potential lack of self-awareness and diversity of perspective within the tech giant's top leadership. For decades, Apple has been seen as a Teflon company, seemingly immune to negative public relations. However, this ad, which was perceived as crushing creativity, upset the very community Apple has built its business on. Apple initially downplayed the impact, but later apologized and acknowledged missing the mark. The absence of internal critics or external perspectives in Apple's decision-making process may be a problem, as the company's leadership, who are earning millions or even billions, may not feel compelled to challenge the status quo. The incident raises concerns about the company's commitment to creativity and its relationship with its customer base, particularly those in the creative industries. The use of an external ad agency could have potentially prevented this misstep and brought a fresh perspective to the table.

    • Ignoring external perspectives can lead to costly mistakes in advertisingCompanies can prevent costly mistakes and foster effective, inclusive ads by prioritizing open communication, empathy, and a diverse range of voices.

      Relying too much on in-house teams for creative ideas and ignoring external perspectives can lead to costly mistakes in advertising. The Pepsi controversy in 2017 serves as a prime example, where a misguided ad campaign cost the company millions and tarnished their reputation. Conversely, having a diverse range of voices and external perspectives can prevent such errors and foster more effective and inclusive advertising. Additionally, the power of social media and public scrutiny can significantly impact a company's image, as seen in the case of Baidu's PR chief, Shou Yung, who lost her job due to controversial statements made on social media. Ultimately, companies must prioritize open communication, empathy, and a willingness to learn from others to create successful and socially responsible advertising campaigns.

    • Tech Powerhouses on Opposite Coasts of the Pacific OceanThe Pacific Ocean separates tech giants China and US, with Chinese companies listed on Nasdaq. Power dynamics and work culture expectations may shift global tech landscape, requiring PR pros to stay vigilant and prepared for media inquiries.

      The Pacific Ocean serves as a dividing yet interconnected line between the tech powerhouses of China and the United States. With multibillion-dollar tech companies like Tencent, Alibaba, and Baidu listed on the Nasdaq Stock Exchange in New York, the future of technology lies between these two coasts. However, the power dynamics between the young and old, as demonstrated by the recent firing of a Chinese executive, could shift the global tech landscape. Moreover, Chinese companies, unlike their Western counterparts, are known for their PR secrecy, making headlines like the one about the fired executive a significant global criticism. For PR professionals, this means staying vigilant and always prepared for media inquiries. The incident also highlights the growing influence of young people in demanding a better work-life balance and challenging traditional work cultures.

    • The Chinese government's relationship with tech giantsUnderstanding Chinese market & govt stance crucial for global tech co success; public criticism can lead to serious consequences; geopolitical tensions create opportunities for advisory services.

      The relationship between global tech companies, particularly those in China, and their governments plays a significant role in business success and public perception. The recent controversy surrounding Baidu and Shuzhong's comments highlights the importance of understanding the Chinese market and government's stance towards these companies. The Chinese government needs these tech giants to succeed, but public criticism, as seen with Shuzhong's posts, can lead to serious consequences. Meanwhile, geopolitical tensions between China and the West impact the listing of companies like Shein, creating opportunities for advisory services and fees in the hundreds of millions. The global battle for business between China and the West continues, and it's essential for businesses and politicians to keep a close eye on developments in this dynamic landscape.

    • London Stock Exchange's Opportunity Amidst ChallengesThe London Stock Exchange could generate substantial advisory fee revenue from Sheen's potential floatation, but faces challenges like post-Brexit business exodus, fewer public companies, and political uncertainties. The UK government is holding a summit to attract more businesses, emphasizing the importance of understanding China's business landscape.

      The London Stock Exchange is currently experiencing a significant opportunity with Sheen potentially floating on the market, which could result in substantial advisory fee revenue for one of the big PR companies. However, the city is facing challenges such as post-Brexit business exodus, fewer public companies, and political uncertainties. To attract more businesses, the UK government, represented by Chancellor Rishi Sunak, is holding a summit with stock exchange officials. The importance of understanding China's business landscape is emphasized, with publications like The Economist and The Financial Times being recommended for insightful coverage. Despite some criticisms, the UK press, including these publications, plays a crucial role in providing comprehensive global news.

    • Effective communication during transition or changeNadim Zahawi's eloquent, sincere, and persuasive resignation letter showcases the importance of strategic communication and effective messaging during times of transition or change. Addressing controversies promptly and transparently, while maintaining a positive public image and focusing on accomplishments, can make all the difference.

      Importance of effective communication, particularly during times of transition or change. Nadim Zahawi, the Conservative MP who recently announced his resignation, demonstrated this skillfully through his heartfelt resignation letter. Drawing inspiration from William Shakespeare, Zahawi's letter was eloquent, sincere, and persuasive. It showcased his writing abilities, which he has utilized in his book, "The Boy from Bagdad," and served to soften any potential criticism or backlash. Moreover, Zahawi's exit strategy was well thought out. He addressed any potential controversy surrounding his tax affairs promptly and transparently. Then, he revealed his future plans, which included working for the Barclay brothers and writing a book. By doing so, he maintained a positive public image and kept the focus on his accomplishments rather than any controversies. Overall, Zahawi's resignation letter and subsequent actions serve as an excellent example of strategic communication and effective messaging during a time of transition. It's a reminder that the words we use matter, and how we use them can make all the difference in how we are perceived.

    • The Power of PR in Reputation ManagementEffective PR can help individuals and businesses overcome challenges and enhance reputation, even in adversity. Tune into 'When You Make It Rain' podcast for practical PR tips.

      Effective PR can help individuals and businesses overcome challenges and enhance their reputation, even in the face of adversity. The example given is of a former politician who managed to leave politics, go back into business, and improve his reputation despite accusations of tax issues. This demonstrates the power of PR in shaping public perception. Additionally, the speakers encourage listeners to tune in to their podcast, "When You Make It Rain," for practical PR tips and guides to help individuals manage their personal PR. They have covered topics such as surviving office parties, asking for pay raises, and dealing with impostor syndrome. Their latest quick win episode is about apologizing to bosses, employees, and colleagues. Lastly, they mentioned a radio series called "Intrigue to Catch a Scorpion" and promoted Stamps.com as a business solution for efficient mailing and shipping processes.

    Recent Episodes from When It Hits the Fan

    When It Hits The Fan x The Today Podcast x Newscast

    When It Hits The Fan x The Today Podcast x Newscast

    Three podcasts, one question: How influential is the media on the election?

    Newscast, The Today Podcast and When It Hits The Fan are coming together for a special election episode. Hosts from all three podcasts will discuss the role of the media in this summer's political campaign. Do newspapers still matter to political campaigns? Do the TV debates change people’s minds? And how much impact is social media really having?

    The episode features Adam Fleming, Amol Rajan, Alex Forsyth, Marianna Spring, David Yelland and Simon Lewis.

    This episode was a collaboration between the teams that make Newscast, The Today Podcast and When It Hits the Fan.

    When It Hits the Fan
    enJune 25, 2024

    Taylor Swift’s PR stardust, the Putin effect and Southgate’s pundit problem

    Taylor Swift’s PR stardust, the Putin effect and Southgate’s pundit problem

    David Yelland and Simon Lewis discuss Taylor Swift’s 'magical air cover' and the power of having your photo taken backstage or anywhere inside the Eras tour, whether you’re the Royal family or Keir Starmer. But would every politician risk the Taylor test?

    And the latest political fan-hitters - why no-one wants to be a 'Putin ally', the Conservative’s 'Betgate' and how to get your message across if you're the SNP and you know most people listening can’t even vote for you.

    Also, how podcasts, social media and the change in the velocity and ferocity of comment has so damaged the reputation of Gareth Southgate’s England. Is it possible to recover from losing the commentariat?

    Producer: Eve Streeter Editor: Sarah Teasdale Executive Producer: William Miller Music by Eclectic Sounds A Raconteur production for BBC Radio 4

    When It Hits the Fan
    enJune 25, 2024

    Can Starmer do PR?, the Green Party and being Taylor Swift's ex

    Can Starmer do PR?, the Green Party and being Taylor Swift's ex

    David Yelland and Simon Lewis administer the Fan Hitter PR slide rule to Sir Keir Starmer's election campaign. How has the Labour leader dealt with some of his stickier PR moments around his previous endorsement of Jeremy Corbyn, questions on tax and his dad's job as a toolmaker provoking laughter in Grimsby? Also, even though they are currently ahead in the polls, Labour - like the England football team - has to deal with the perennial PR problem of expectation management. Perhaps they could both learn a thing or two from the Royal Family?

    Also, the Green Party's election campaign. How do you keep people listening when your core message - climate change - could be seen as alarmist? One solution is to focus your comms locally, which is what the Greens are doing. As is Nigel Farage...

    And finally, actor Joe Alwyn has spoken out about his previous relationship with Taylor Swift. What can we learn about being dragged into the media spotlight on account of who you love – and then break up with? How best to deal with the global glare of Swifty scrutiny?

    Producer: Eve Streeter Editor: Sarah Teasdale Executive Producer: William Miller Music by Eclectic Sounds A Raconteur production for BBC Radio 4

    When It Hits the Fan
    enJune 18, 2024

    Sunak's D-Day blunder, is Farage using dog whistles?, and Mike Lynch

    Sunak's D-Day blunder, is Farage using dog whistles?, and Mike Lynch

    David and Simon analyse what is arguably the biggest PR moment in British electoral history - Prime Minister Rishi Sunak's decision to leave the D-Day celebrations in Normandy early. Simon takes us behind the scenes at Number 10 to try to work out exactly how things went so wrong for the PM.

    Nigel Farage - he's been accused of 'dog whistle' politics. What are they, and how do they work?

    And - the acquittal of tech tycoon Mike Lynch. What are the lessons to be learned from surviving the nine circles of media hell?

    Producer: Eve Streeter Editor: Sarah Teasdale Executive Producer: William Miller Music by Eclectic Sounds A Raconteur production for BBC Radio 4

    When It Hits the Fan
    enJune 11, 2024

    Private school PR, Lib Dem tactics and Trump's conviction

    Private school PR, Lib Dem tactics and Trump's conviction

    David Yelland and Simon Lewis look at why private schools seem to be losing the PR battle over their VAT exemption. A core principle of PR is to anticipate problems and mitigate them. This one has been coming down the track towards independent schools for years - why did they get it so wrong?

    Also, the Liberal Democrats' election strategy of "tactical disruption" - which mainly involves Sir Ed Davey getting wet and apparently having the most fun of all the leaders on the campaign trail. As David and Simon continue to look at the use of PR by different political parties during the election campaign, they ask if the Liberal Democrats are adopting the PR tactics pioneered by disrupters like Richard Branson’s Virgin Atlantic and Airbnb in the US. It's winning the party precious press coverage, but is there a downside to the election stunts?

    And what does it mean for the concept of a Fan Hitting crisis if being a convicted felon is not necessarily career ending? David and Simon are, of course, talking Donald Trump's guilty verdict in his hush-money trial. Does reputation matter in a post-shame world?

    Producer: Eve Streeter Editor: Sarah Teasdale Executive Producer: William Miller Music by Eclectic Sounds A Raconteur production for BBC Radio 4

    When It Hits the Fan
    enJune 04, 2024

    General Election PR strategy and the Post Office Horizon IT Inquiry

    General Election PR strategy and the Post Office Horizon IT Inquiry

    David Yelland and Simon Lewis debate the first of a series of PR reviews into the up and coming general election. Starting with Rishi Sunak's announcement in the rain last week, they'll be looking at how the parties launched their campaigns, their use of campaign videos and slogans, and how and when the press decide to take sides.

    They also discuss how PR has been put on the stand at the Post Office Horizon IT Inquiry.

    New to When It Hits The Fan, if you have a “Quick Wins” question for Simon and David about managing your personal PR, send them a voice note on WhatsApp with the word “Fan” to +44 3700 100444 followed by your question.

    Producer: William Miller Editor: Sarah Teasdale Music by Eclectic Sounds A Raconteur production for BBC Radio 4

    When It Hits the Fan
    enMay 28, 2024

    Quick Wins: How to say no

    Quick Wins: How to say no

    Quick Wins is a series of short episodes from the When It Hits the Fan team to help you navigate your own personal PR.

    In your professional life as well as your personal life, what you say no to can be more important than what you say yes to. In this episode David and Simon share their advice on how to do it the right way - to a boss who is asking you to overwork, to a job offer that's not the right fit or when you smell a rat. How to set the right boundaries?

    Producer: Eve Streeter Editor: Sarah Teasdale Executive Producer: William Miller Music by Eclectic Sounds A Raconteur production for BBC Radio 4

    When It Hits the Fan
    enMay 23, 2024

    UK water crisis, the Rich List and PR wellbeing

    UK water crisis, the Rich List and PR wellbeing

    David Yelland and Simon Lewis discuss South West Water’s handling of the Brixham water contamination and what this tells us about the fundamental problems in the UK water industry. Why were the people of South Devon told their water was safe when it was not? And when a crisis hits, who is the best person to speak on behalf of a company. Is it the 'chief customer officer'?

    Also, in the week The Sunday Times Rich List is published, Simon and David share some secrets about how the blue chip PR world tries to get people on the list - and also get people off it!

    And does the PR industry look after the mental health of its own people well enough? They take a look at a concerning report.

    Producer: Eve Streeter Editor: Sarah Teasdale Executive Producer: William Miller Music by Eclectic Sounds A Raconteur production for BBC Radio 4

    When It Hits the Fan
    enMay 21, 2024

    Quick Wins: How to say sorry

    Quick Wins: How to say sorry

    Quick Wins is a series of short episodes from the When It Hits the Fan team to help you navigate your own personal PR.

    In this episode, David Yelland and Simon Lewis discuss the power of an apology. Professional - and personal - relationships are based on being able to say sorry at the right time. So how do you mark sure yours hits the mark? Do it before the sun goes down, do it the hard way and always mean it.

    Producer: Eve Streeter Executive Producer: William Miller Music by Eclectic Sounds A Raconteur production for BBC Radio 4

    When It Hits the Fan
    enMay 16, 2024

    Apple’s ad backlash, 'I’m not your mum' and Zahawi’s exit strategy

    Apple’s ad backlash, 'I’m not your mum' and Zahawi’s exit strategy

    This week, two of the world’s biggest tech companies have found themselves in PR crises of their own making. Why did Apple's new iPad Pro 'crush' advert misfire so badly? Meanwhile at Baidu - China’s biggest search engine - its PR boss has lost her job after videos of her promoting a toxic work culture went viral.

    David Yelland and Simon Lewis go to the heart of a secret and little understood reputational war and look at the real battle between the west coast of America and China’s Silicon Valley.

    And - bowing out gracefully. How Nadhim Zahawi’s exit strategy from politics ticked all the PR boxes.

    Producer: Eve Streeter Editor: Sarah Teasdale Executive Producer: William Miller Music by Eclectic Sounds A Raconteur production for BBC Radio 4

    When It Hits the Fan
    enMay 14, 2024