Logo

    Broken Circle - Update

    enAugust 13, 2024
    What were the initial conditions at Circle of Hope like?
    How did Ashley's feelings towards authority figures change?
    What actions were taken by Amanda regarding the abuse?
    How did the community perceive the facilities despite allegations?
    Why is accountability important in institutions like Circle of Hope?

    Podcast Summary

    • Christian therapeutic facility abuseThorough investigations are crucial to prevent physical and emotional abuse in Christian therapeutic facilities, as unchecked power can lead to long-term damage.

      The trust and safety of a supposedly Christian and therapeutic facility, Circle of Hope, were shattered when a teenager, Ashley, experienced physical and emotional abuse at the hands of the facility's directors. Ashley, who was sent to the facility by her desperate mother due to her rebellious behavior, felt love and fear towards her father-like figure, but the situation took a dark turn when the facility's directors' demeanor changed drastically after her arrival. Despite their initial kindness, they showed no emotions and became abusive, leaving Ashley feeling terrified and helpless. The story highlights the importance of thorough investigations into such facilities and the potential long-term damage caused by the lack of accountability and transparency.

    • Missouri Christian reform schoolParents unknowingly sent their children to a school with harsh discipline and potential for physical abuse, leading to a culture of fear and survival

      The Householder's Christian reform school in Missouri was a place of fear and harsh discipline. Teresa Tucker, unaware of the conditions her daughter Amanda faced, sent her to the school when she became sexually active and tried marijuana for the first time. Amanda's father, Boyd Householder, a former Marine drill instructor, ran the school with an iron fist. The girls lived in constant fear, facing long hours of chores, Bible study, and physical punishment. They were made to scrub floors with toothbrushes, pick weeds in the heat, and stand facing the wall all day. Punishments included push-ups, being kicked while doing them, and standing on the wall. Despite Boyd's denial, former students shared stories of physical abuse. The atmosphere was one of fear and survival.

    • Physical and Emotional Abuse at Circle of HopeFormer students and staff of Circle of Hope revealed accounts of physical and emotional abuse, including violent punishments and power trips, resulting in long-term trauma for girls.

      Circle of Hope, a religious community led by Boyd Householder, was not just known for its strict discipline and chores, but former students and staff revealed shocking accounts of physical and emotional abuse. Girls were subjected to violent punishments, including being tripped, shoved, and restrained, sometimes with the help of other girls. Amanda, who was not a student but helped administer discipline, admitted to having power trips and treating favored girls poorly. The girls' screams during punishments were a traumatizing part of their experiences, and Amanda herself was regularly beaten as a child. Despite these allegations, Householder claimed they only restrained students when necessary and never intentionally caused pain. Amanda's attempts to resist and protect the girls resulted in her being punished and feeling powerless.

    • Child AbuseSpeaking out against child abuse is crucial, and safe spaces are essential for those who have experienced it. Survivors may face complex emotions when confronting past traumas.

      The experiences of Amanda and Ashley, two girls who grew up in the Circle of Hope Girls Ranch, reveal the psychological and physical toll of living in an abusive environment. Amanda, who was restricted in her movements and food intake, felt trapped and powerless, unable to speak out against her family's actions. Years later, she defended her parents online out of guilt. Ashley, on the other hand, suffered sexual abuse from her brother while living at the ranch. She was too afraid to speak out, but eventually managed to tell her mother, leading to her rescue. The girls' stories underscore the importance of speaking out against abuse and the need for safe spaces for those who have experienced it. It's also a reminder of the complex emotions that can arise when confronting past traumas.

    • Religious boarding schools regulationLack of regulation and transparency allows religious boarding schools to operate without accountability, leaving victims of abuse with no recourse and perpetuating a cycle of cruelty.

      Despite numerous reports of alleged abuse at a religious boarding school in Missouri, no action was taken due to lack of regulation and transparency. Ashley, a former student, shared her experience of being a victim of rape and physical abuse, but her mother reported the allegations to Child Protective Services and the sheriff's office with no result. Other parents denied any wrongdoing and hid their children from investigators. The school continued to prosper, and no regulations exist in Missouri to require religious facilities to register their existence with the state education department. Missouri State Representative Carrie Engel, a former social worker, emphasized the lack of oversight and accountability for these institutions. A 2021 NBC News investigation revealed similar gaps in regulation in at least 21 states. The system's entrenched cruelty seemed unbeatable until fresh allegations of abuse from boys and a desperate attempt to alert the police brought renewed attention to the issue.

    • Religious institutions hiding child abuseReligious institutions and leaders can hide and perpetuate child abuse, and it's crucial to hold them accountable for the safety and well-being of children

      The power and influence of religious leaders and institutions can be used to hide and perpetuate abuse against children. In this case, Amanda's father, who ran a religious reform school called Circle of Hope, was accused of molesting students and physically abusing children at another school he worked at, Agape. Despite these allegations, the community continued to view these institutions positively due to their perceived good work. Amanda's own realization of the extent of the abuse came when she had children of her own and began reaching out to former students to listen to their stories. The accounts of abuse at both schools were alarming, with numerous reports of inappropriate touching, beatings, and cover-ups. It's important to remember that institutions and individuals in positions of power must be held accountable for their actions, especially when it comes to the safety and well-being of children.

    • Religious school abuseLack of regulation and oversight led to years of alleged abuse in a religious school. A viral TikTok video brought attention to the situation and resulted in an investigation and removal of girls.

      The lack of regulation and oversight of a religious school allowed alleged abuse to continue unchecked for years. Amanda, a survivor of the abuse, took matters into her own hands by sharing her story on TikTok, which led to a new investigation and the removal of over two dozen girls from the school. The damning TikTok video, featuring Amanda's father instructing students to physically harm each other, was a turning point in bringing attention to the situation. Despite previous reports of abuse, no action was taken until the video went viral. The investigation is ongoing, but it highlights the importance of holding institutions accountable for the safety and well-being of children.

    • Religious school accountabilityLack of transparency and accountability in religious schools can allow for years of abuse to go unchecked, requiring a TikTok video, multiple lawsuits, and criminal charges to intervene

      The lack of accountability and transparency in religious schools can allow for abuse to go unchecked for years. This is exemplified by the case of the Householders and their "Christian-based discipline program" in Missouri. It took a TikTok video, multiple lawsuits, and criminal charges for authorities to intervene and shut down the school. The system's failure to protect children in such an environment is a significant issue that needs addressing. Amanda, a former student, bravely spoke out and led a march for awareness and change. Despite facing accusations and estrangement from her parents, she never gave up. Unfortunately, the school's former director and several staff members have also filed criminal charges, highlighting the extent of the abuse. The school, Agape, eventually closed down due to financial reasons, but the damage had already been done. It's crucial to ensure that religious schools are held accountable for their actions and that students are protected from harm.

    • Business as a place of helpBusinesses can make a difference in people's lives by offering help and support, and individuals can continue to make a positive impact despite personal challenges.

      The man to house order is not just a business, but a place where help is offered. The woman, who once stood up for children in need, continues her mission to help the next generation while seeking forgiveness for herself. This powerful message was shared during our conversation today. It's a reminder that businesses can make a difference in people's lives, and individuals can continue to make a positive impact, even after facing challenges. Let's keep supporting each other and working towards making the world a better place. That's all for now. I'm Lester Holt, and thank you for joining us.

    Recent Episodes from Dateline NBC

    Shining a Light on the Missing with the Team Behind NBC’s “Found”

    Shining a Light on the Missing with the Team Behind NBC’s “Found”

    Josh Mankiewicz sits down with showrunner Nkechi Okoro Carroll and Shanola Hampton, lead actor and producer of the hit NBC drama Found, to talk about bringing attention to the missing. Don’t forget to watch Josh’s all-new Dateline this Friday at 10/9c on NBC, and Found premieres Thursday, 10/3 at 10/9c on NBC and streaming on Peacock.

    Dateline NBC
    enSeptember 12, 2024

    Talking Dateline: Shining Star

    Talking Dateline: Shining Star

    Josh Mankiewicz talks with Dennis Murphy about his episode “Shining Star.” In 2009, criminal defense attorney, Chiquita Tate, was found stabbed to death in her Baton Rouge, Louisiana law office. After an exhaustive investigation, authorities zero in on their suspect. Chiquita’s sister Danita Tate joins the conversation to discuss her advocacy work in educating the community on domestic violence. Josh and Dennis talk Murphy’s Law and how Dateline episodes get their titles.

    Get resources on domestic violence: https://www.thehotline.org/

    Learn more about Juantonja Richmond’s case: https://www.nbcnews.com/news/us-news/police-close-case-two-friends-murdered-georgia-familys-pleas-answers-rcna138033

    Listen to the full episode of "Shining Star" here: https://link.chtbl.com/dl_shiningstar

    Dateline NBC
    enSeptember 11, 2024

    Talking Dateline: Noises in the Night

    Talking Dateline: Noises in the Night

    Josh Mankiewicz and Andrea Canning discuss Andrea’s episode, “Noises in the Night.” In November 2016, 16-year-old cheerleader Emma Walker was found dead in her Knoxville, Tennessee home. An investigation revealed she was killed by a bullet shot from outside her house that pierced the wall of her bedroom.  Andrea and Josh talk about the people who helped investigators bring the killer to justice – his own friends – and reflect on what parents can do to protect their teens from toxic relationships. Later, Andrea shares a podcast-exclusive clip from her interview with two of Emma’s friends. Plus, Josh and Andrea answer viewer and listener questions from social media.

    Listen to the full episode of "Noises in the Night" here: https://link.chtbl.com/dl_noisesinthenight

    Dateline NBC
    enSeptember 04, 2024

    Talking Dateline: Stone-Cold

    Talking Dateline: Stone-Cold

    Dennis Murphy talks with Josh Mankiewicz about his episode, “Stone-Cold.” In 2016 when 45-year-old Nick Morelos was found shot to death in his Tucson, Arizona bedroom, investigators wondered if this hard-charging boss rubbed someone at work the wrong way. What investigators uncovered was a web of complicated relationships that they had to untangle to find Nick’s killer. Later, Josh shares an exclusive clip from his interview with Pima County Sheriff’s Det. Jennifer Garcia, about a key piece of evidence not admissible at trial. Plus, Dennis and Josh are joined by Dateline producer, Chetna Joshi, to answer view and listener social media questions.

    Listen to the full episode of "Stone-Cold" here: https://link.chtbl.com/dl_stone-cold

    Dateline NBC
    enAugust 28, 2024

    Keith Morrison reads “The Dead Alive” by Wilkie Collins

    Keith Morrison reads “The Dead Alive” by Wilkie Collins

    Hey, Dateline fans! As a bonus, we’re giving you episode 1 from season 3 of our podcast Morrison Mysteries.   

    This season, Keith Morrison introduces you to the Meadowcroft family, living on a sprawling American farm. The household is teeming with rivalry and passion, envy and anger. When someone mysteriously disappears, two brothers are accused of murder...but all is not as it seems. Listen to Keith’s reading of “The Dead Alive,” a chilling novel from 150 years ago based on a real trial, to find out what really happened. 

    If you like what you hear, just search “Morrison Mysteries” and subscribe to Dateline Premium. Subscribers receive ad-free listening and early access to subsequent episodes: https://link.chtbl.com/mmst_fdlw

    Dateline NBC
    enAugust 27, 2024

    Talking Dateline: Young Lords of Chaos

    Talking Dateline: Young Lords of Chaos

    Keith Morrison and Josh Mankiewicz sit down to talk about Keith’s episode, “Young Lords of Chaos.’’ In 1996, a group of teens dubbed the ‘Lords of Chaos’ went on a crime spree in Fort Myers, Florida, culminating in the murder of their high school band director, Mark Schwebes. Josh and Keith discuss the choices the teens made as they fell under the spell of their charismatic ringleader, and the local reporter who found himself getting a little too close to the case. They’re also joined by the victim’s sister, Pat Schwebes-Dunbar, who shares how her life has been shaped in the 28 years since her brother’s murder.

    Listen to the full episode of “Young Lords of Chaos” here: https://link.chtbl.com/dl_younglordsofchaos

     

    Dateline NBC
    enAugust 21, 2024

    Related Episodes

    Loving Two People

    Loving Two People

    It's Therapy Thursday!

    In today's episode we will discuss loving two people. Can you love two people in an intimate way? We share our stories as always on how it has impacted our lives throughout our journey.

    Host Candace Fleming
    Co-host Janet Hale

    visit the website at https://www.essentialmotivation.com/
    visit the store at https://shopessentialmotivation.com/
    Instagram instagram.com/essentialmotivationllc

    To be a guest on our show email me at candacefleming@essentialmotivation.com

    Music by Lukrembo: https://soundcloud.com/lukrembo
    Provided by Knowledge Base: https://bit.ly/2BdvqzN

    Support the show

    Host Candace Fleming
    Co-host Janet Hale

    visit the website at https://www.essentialmotivation.com/
    visit the store at https://shopessentialmotivation.com/
    Instagram instagram.com/essentialmotivationllc

    To be a guest on our show email me at candacefleming@essentialmotivation.com
    In the subject line put EMH Guest

    Suicide Prevention Lifeline 988

    Music by Lukrembo: https://soundcloud.com/lukrembo
    Provided by Knowledge Base: https://bit.ly/2BdvqzN

    When Self Respect Takes It's Rightful Place

    When Self Respect Takes It's Rightful Place


    It's Therapy Thursday!!

    In today's episode we will discuss many topics leading us to self respect. Listen to a raw conversation between a mother and daughter about love, respect and more.

    Host Candace Fleming
    Co-host Janet Hale


    visit the website at https://www.essentialmotivation.com/
    visit the store at https://shopessentialmotivation.com/
    Instagram instagram.com/essentialmotivationllc

    To be a guest on our show email me at candacefleming@essentialmotivation.com

    Music by Lukrembo: https://soundcloud.com/lukrembo
    Provided by Knowledge Base: https://bit.ly/2BdvqzN

    If you need immediate help call the suicide prevention hotline at 1800.273.8255
    https://www.nimh.nih.gov/health/topics/suicide-prevention 

    Support the show

    Host Candace Fleming
    Co-host Janet Hale

    visit the website at https://www.essentialmotivation.com/
    visit the store at https://shopessentialmotivation.com/
    Instagram instagram.com/essentialmotivationllc

    To be a guest on our show email me at candacefleming@essentialmotivation.com
    In the subject line put EMH Guest

    Suicide Prevention Lifeline 988

    Music by Lukrembo: https://soundcloud.com/lukrembo
    Provided by Knowledge Base: https://bit.ly/2BdvqzN