Logo
    Search

    Podcast Summary

    • A pizza delivery turns into a bank robberyUnpredictable events can involve seemingly ordinary situations and unexpected characters, leading to complex investigations

      The world can be unpredictable and events can take unexpected turns. The story of the Erie, PA bank robbery is a prime example of this. A seemingly ordinary pizza delivery turned into a bizarre crime scene involving a ticking time bomb, a frozen body, and a cast of unconventional characters. The delivery man, Brian Wells, found himself in a deadly situation, either as an unwilling participant or a coconspirator. The events of that day left the community in shock and the FBI with a complex investigation. It serves as a reminder that appearances can be deceiving and that life can take unexpected twists and turns.

    • Unexpected bank robbery with a bombAn unpredictable situation unfolded when a pizza delivery man was revealed to be a bank robber wearing a bomb, leading to a tense standoff and tragic outcome.

      A seemingly ordinary pizza delivery man, Brian Wells, turned out to be a bank robber wearing a bomb around his neck. The standoff lasted for over 30 minutes, with police keeping a safe distance as the timer ticked down. The situation escalated when a second beep was heard, indicating that the bomb was about to detonate. Despite the efforts of the FBI and bomb squad, Brian Wells tragically lost his life when the bomb exploded, leaving the community in shock. The incident highlights the unpredictability of dangerous situations and the importance of quick thinking and decisive action by law enforcement.

    • The Mysterious Death of Brian WellsThe tragic death of Brian Wells during a bank robbery left his family believing he was innocent, but investigators couldn't rule anything out due to a bomb collar around his neck, adding to the confusion and intense media scrutiny.

      The tragic death of Brian Wells during a bank robbery in Erie, Pennsylvania, left many unanswered questions. Despite appearing to be the culprit, Brian was believed by his family to be a victim, as he seemed desperate and in need of help during the standoff. The discovery of a bomb collar around his neck added to the confusion, and the intense media scrutiny put pressure on investigators to solve the case quickly. For Trey Borzileri, a documentary filmmaker, this shocking event provided the perfect story for his career. However, the puzzle of Brian's last hours remained complex, with many pieces still to be put together. Despite Brian's declaration of innocence, investigators couldn't rule anything out. Ultimately, the search for answers continued, with the possibility that someone could have disarmed the bomb in time.

    • Brian Wells' tragic bank robbery involved a hoax bomb and a complex scavenger huntA hoax bomb led an innocent man on a deadly scavenger hunt, ultimately resulting in his tragic demise. The investigation revealed a suspect with a history of working with explosives.

      The Brian Wells bank robbery case involved a complex scavenger hunt with instructions leading to various locations and keys to unlock a collar bomb. The bomb was a hoax, designed to ensure Wells' death. The investigation revealed that he had been lured into the robbery under false pretenses and was likely unaware of the true nature of the device around his neck. The notes found in the car were extensive, with detailed instructions and dire warnings. The investigation followed Wells' steps, but it was determined that he would not have had enough time to complete the scavenger hunt and save himself. A suspect was later identified through a list of names and phone numbers found in Wells' apartment. The man, known as JJ, had a history of working with explosives. The case is a chilling example of a diabolical plot that led to an innocent man's tragic demise.

    • A complex investigation with unexpected twists and turnsDespite challenges and risks, investigators worked diligently to uncover the truth behind a bank robbery and bombing, including a dangerous surgical procedure to recover important evidence.

      The investigation into the bank robbery and bombing in Erie, Pennsylvania, was a complex and dangerous case with unexpected twists and turns. A voluntary search of a suspect's home led to a dead end, while a new suspect with a macabre history emerged. The discovery of multiple bodies and a bizarre bomb with a locking collar added to the mystery and danger. The bomb squad had to recover every piece of the device to understand the bomb maker's skills and mentality, but the collar, still locked around the victim's neck, posed a risk and was important evidence. The decision was made to perform a surgical decapitation to remove the collar safely and intact. The family of the victim felt he was being victimized even in death. The investigation was a grueling and painful process for all involved.

    • A complex and deadly bombing incident at Mamma Mia's PizzeriaAn advanced bomber with a devious mind left multiple bodies in their wake, requiring collaboration between law enforcement and behavioral profilers to understand their motives.

      The bombing incident at Mamma Mia's Pizzeria involved a complex and deadly device, built by someone with advanced skills and a devious mind. The investigation led to the discovery of multiple bodies, including a "black widow" suspect and a delivery driver who had been living in a hoarder's house with a frozen body in the garage. The case was full of unexpected twists and turns, with the 911 call from a confessing suspect adding to the chaos. The investigation required collaboration between law enforcement and behavioral profilers to understand the mind of the perpetrator. The case was a reminder of the unpredictability and danger of criminal minds.

    • A chilling investigation into the complexities of human relationships and hidden darknessA local intellectual confessed to helping hide a frozen body, leading investigators to reexamine a series of bizarre incidents involving pizza delivery men and a possible connection to a murder.

      The small city of Erie, PA, was shaken by a series of bizarre incidents involving the deaths of pizza delivery men and the discovery of a frozen body. The prime suspect, Bill Rothstein, was a local intellectual and educator with a complicated history with the infamous Marjorie Deal Armstrong. Rothstein confessed to police that Marjorie had shot and killed her latest boyfriend, Jim Roden, and he had helped hide the body in his freezer. The discovery of the frozen body led investigators to reexamine the Pizza Bomber case, revealing a possible connection between the two crimes. The saga of Bill Rothstein and Marjorie Deal Armstrong was a chilling reminder of the complexities of human relationships and the potential for darkness lurking beneath the surface of seemingly ordinary lives.

    • Former Substitute Teacher Confesses to Helping Dispose of Body in Pizza Bombing CaseA former substitute teacher, Bill Rostein, confessed to helping dispose of a body and leading investigators to crime scenes in the Brian Wells' 'pizza bombing' case. His suicide note mentioning the case was initially claimed as unrelated, but the discovery of a body in his garage raised suspicions, and he eventually confessed to his involvement.

      Bill Rostein, a former substitute teacher, confessed to helping Marjorie Deal Armstrong dispose of a body, leading investigators to suspect their involvement in the Brian Wells' "pizza bombing" case. Rostein willingly guided investigators to both crime scenes and even demonstrated how he destroyed the murder weapon. He also had a suicide note mentioning the pizza bombing, which he claimed was unrelated to the Wells case to prevent unnecessary investigation. However, the discovery of the body in Rostein's garage near the TV Tower site where Wells made his last delivery raised suspicions, and FBI agent Clark believed the cases were related. Rostein, who considered himself the smartest person in the room, eventually confessed to his involvement.

    • The investigation shifted from Bill Rothstein to Marjorie Deal ArmstrongDespite being a prime suspect due to the FBI's profile, dying Bill Rothstein refused to talk. The investigation then focused on Marjorie Deal Armstrong, a complex woman with a history of mental instability and sudden deaths, who eventually killed a man in 1984.

      Bill Rothstein, a former high school shop teacher with a garage full of metal working tools, was a prime suspect in the pizza bombing case due to the FBI's profile of the unknown bomb maker. However, Rothstein, who was out on bond for abusing a corpse, refused to talk about the case and had a secret of his own – he was dying of terminal cancer. With Rothstein's death, the investigation turned to Marjorie Deal Armstrong, a complex and interesting woman with a past full of sudden deaths and mental instability. Marjorie, who had a tremendous magnetism and was intellectually compatible with Rothstein, started acting strangely and turning to astrology. She suffered from bipolar disorder and other mental illnesses, and her life spiraled down, culminating in her killing a man for the first time in 1984.

    • Marjorie Deal Armstrong's Troubled PastDespite her history of mental instability and past tragic relationships, Marjorie Deal Armstrong was able to evade legal responsibility for her actions and continue to make headlines

      Marjorie Deal Armstrong, a woman with a history of mental instability and multiple tragic relationships, was charged with murder after shooting her boyfriend six times. Her attorney, Leonard Ambrose, attempted to have her committed multiple times due to her extreme hoarding and mental illness. Despite these attempts, she was declared competent to stand trial. Marjorie eventually met and married another man, Richard Armstrong, who also met an untimely death. She was cleared of any wrongdoing in his death, but later sued the hospital for malpractice and won a large settlement. With her name in the news again due to a new murder investigation, Marjorie pointed the finger at someone new, leading investigators to look into her connections with a local crack dealer, Ken Barnes.

    • Old interview reveals new suspect in pizza bomber caseAn old interview with an inmate revealed a new suspect in the pizza bomber case, leading investigators to reconsider their initial suspects and expand their investigation.

      The investigation into the pizza bomber case took an unexpected turn when an old interview with Kenneth Eugene Barnes resurfaced. Barnes had revealed during the interview that Marjorie Deal, the primary suspect in the frozen body case, had asked him to kill her father for her inheritance. Marjorie, who was in prison at the time for a different crime, had confided in an inmate, Kelly Makala, about the pizza bomber case. Kelly, who had police training, recorded their conversations. In these recordings, Marjorie implicated Bill Rothstein, her former fiance, in the pizza bombing, claiming he built the bomb. This new information led investigators to reconsider their suspects and expand their investigation.

    • Prisoner's confession to guard about a conspiracy involving a bombing and murderA delayed prison guard's report of a convict's confession led to a two-year investigation, but eventually, independent confessions from other inmates provided crucial evidence to solve the case.

      Marjorie Deal Armstrong, a convicted criminal, confessed to a prison guard, Kelly, about her involvement in a conspiracy that led to the bombing death of pizza delivery man Brian Wells, and the murder of her boyfriend, Jim Roden. She claimed that the group, which included Ken Barnes, Floyd Stockton, and possibly others, planned the crime to obtain $250,000 from a bank to pay Barnes for killing her father and allow Marjorie to inherit. However, the notes taken by Kelly were not turned over to investigators for two years, and when they were, the FBI struggled to find corroborating evidence. Eventually, Barnes and another inmate, Floyd Stockton, independently confessed, providing crucial evidence that broke the case open.

    • New witness identifies suspects in pizza bombing caseA new witness led to the identification of suspects in the pizza bombing case, resulting in their indictment. However, the involvement of an unwitting accomplice led to tragic consequences.

      The pizza bombing case, which had long puzzled investigators, was finally solved when a new witness came forward and identified Bill Rothstein and Marjorie Deal Armstrong making the call that set the robbery in motion. This call led the conspirators, including Rothstein, Barnes, Stockton, and Panetti, to the scene where they planned to rob a bank using Brian Wells as their unwitting accomplice. However, things went awry when Wells was caught, and the conspirators were forced to improvise, ultimately leading to the tragic outcome where Wells died believing he was part of a scavenger hunt and not a bank robbery. The involvement of Brian Wells in the case was complex, as he had connections to the woman who introduced him to the robbers, and he may not have fully understood the gravity of the situation. The case resulted in indictments against Marjorie Deal Armstrong, Ken Barnes, and two unindicted coconspirators, including Brian Wells. The Wells family vehemently denied his involvement and felt he was a victim in the situation.

    • Suspected mastermind's trial for pizza bombingDespite compromised evidence and questionable witnesses, the trial of Marjorie Deal Armstrong, the suspected pizza bomber, was crucial in determining the truth behind the crime.

      The evidence against Brian, including the presence of prostitutes' names in his notebook and his unusual behavior on the day of the crime, suggests that he was an unwilling participant in the pizza bombing. The trial of Marjorie Deal Armstrong, the suspected mastermind, was sensational and relied heavily on compromised witnesses and jailhouse snitches. Marjorie vehemently denied her involvement and accused the star witness, Ken Barnes, of being a liar. The case against her was complex and the jury's decision was crucial in determining the truth behind the infamous pizza bombing.

    • Marjorie Dale Armstrong's desire for revenge and money led to the collar bombingMarjorie Dale Armstrong masterminded the collar bombing to kill her father and secure funds, while Bill Rothstein executed the bank robbery scheme. Marjorie's defiant attitude during trial crumbled under cross-examination, leading to her conviction.

      Marjorie Dale Armstrong, with her erratic behavior and strong personality, was the mastermind behind the collar bombing as she wanted to kill her father and needed money for it. However, the execution of the bank robbery scheme was orchestrated by Bill Rothstein. During her trial, Marjorie's impulsive and defiant attitude captivated the courtroom, but her defense crumbled under cross-examination, leading to her eventual conviction. Despite her acquittal in the past, the jury found her guilty on all counts, and she vowed to appeal. Ultimately, Agent Clark's long quest to solve the wicked pizza bombing case came to a close with Marjorie's conviction.

    • The Brian Wells Pizza Bomber Case: Unanswered QuestionsDespite conflicting accounts, evidence suggests Brian Wells had some involvement in the crime, but his family maintains his innocence. Marjorie Deal Armstrong's criminal history raises questions, and her reliability as a witness is in doubt. The key witness's initial alibi is also questionable, leaving the case open-ended with many unanswered questions.

      The Brian Wells pizza bomber case remains a complex and controversial investigation with conflicting accounts of his involvement in the crime. The evidence suggests he had some knowledge of the people involved, but the Wells family maintains he was an innocent pizza delivery man. Marjorie Diehl-Armstrong, a suspect in the case, denied any involvement and even claimed the prosecution's motives were laughable. However, her criminal history raises questions. The key witness, Jessica Huebsick, initially claimed Brian couldn't be involved due to an alibi, but her reliability is in question. Ultimately, Trey Borzillari's documentary "Evil Genius" led to the conclusion that Brian may have been an unwitting victim, but the case remains open-ended with many unanswered questions. The failure to commit Marjorie to a mental institution after her first murder trial is a point of contention, as it may have prevented further tragedies. Marjorie Deal Armstrong died in prison in 2017, leaving behind a legacy of crime and controversy.

    • Understanding the complex relationships and motivations behind Marjorie's deathExploring the intricate roles and emotions of those involved in Marjorie's death sheds light on the difficult questions surrounding her tragic demise.

      That the complex web of relationships and motivations in the sordid affair surrounding Marjorie's death raises difficult questions. Who were these people, like Rusty and Barnes, that could harbor such intense hatred towards someone else to take their life? The intricacy of their roles and emotions adds to the mystifying nature of the situation. Ultimately, it's the struggle to comprehend their actions and the hardest part of the whole ordeal. No one deserves to die in such a manner, but understanding the characters behind the crime may provide some closure.

    Recent Episodes from Dateline NBC

    Talking Dateline: The Secret in Black Rock Canyon

    Talking Dateline: The Secret in Black Rock Canyon

    Andrea Canning talks to Keith Morrison about his episode, “The Secret in Black Rock Canyon.”  In 2006, 16-year-old Cassie Jo Stoddart was found stabbed to death at a relative’s home in Pocatello, Idaho. Detectives quickly learned that Cassie’s last day alive was nothing short of a real-life horror movie, with video to prove it, and the filmmakers-turned-killers were not at all who they expected. Keith and Andrea discuss his interview with one of Cassie’s killers and Keith shares an extra clip from his interview with Dr. James Garabino, a psychologist and expert on teen violence. Plus, Keith and Andrea are joined by the detective who investigated Cassie’s murder, retired Captain John Ganske.

    Listen to the full episode of "The Secret in Black Rock Canyon" here: https://link.chtbl.com/dateline_podcast

    Dateline NBC
    enJune 26, 2024

    Talking Dateline: The Breakup

    Talking Dateline: The Breakup

    Keith Morrison talks to Josh Mankiewicz about Josh’s latest episode, “The Breakup.” In 2010, a California nurse was found dead in her home. Police thought they had a clear suspect, but soon discovered evidence that pointed them in a direction no one saw coming, one that kept our viewers and our correspondents guessing until the end. Keith plays Josh an extra clip from his interview with the detectives as they describe coming face to face with their initial suspect, and Josh answers viewer and listeners questions with Dateline assistant producer Jess Koernig.

    Listen to the full episode of "The Breakup" here: https://link.chtbl.com/dl_thebreakup

    Dateline NBC
    enJune 19, 2024

    Talking Dateline: Dark Intentions

    Talking Dateline: Dark Intentions

    Josh Mankiewicz and Andrea Canning sit down to talk about Andrea’s newest episode, “Dark Intentions.” In 1996, the murder and sexual assault of two women in the same apartment complex rattled the city of Arlington, Texas and stumped police. But when two other women from the area survive sexual assaults, police find evidence that connects all four crimes.Andrea tells Josh what she learned from the women who survived their brutal attacks, and she describes the involved investigation that finally cracked the case. Andrea also plays a podcast-exclusive clip and Dateline producer Haylee Barber joins in to answer viewer questions from social media.

    If you or someone you know has experienced sexual assault, call the National Sexual Assault Hotline at 800-656-4673 or visit online.rainn.org

    Listen to the full episode of “Dark Intentions” here: https://link.chtbl.com/dl_darkintentions

    Dateline NBC
    enJune 12, 2024

    Talking Dateline: The Girl with the Hibiscus Tattoo

    Talking Dateline: The Girl with the Hibiscus Tattoo

    Andrea Canning interviews Keith Morrison about his latest episode, “The Girl with the Hibiscus Tattoo,” based on his original podcast “Murder in the Hollywood Hills.” 21-year-old Kristi Johnson mysteriously disappeared in 2003 after meeting a man at the Century City Mall in Los Angeles who invited her to audition for a Bond movie.  She was found dead days later. Keith talks about the group of women who helped bring Kristi’s killer to justice and shares a clip from his 2023 interview with Kristi’s mother, Terry Hall. Susan Leibowitz, one of the producers of the episode, answers viewer and listener questions.

    Listen to “Murder in the Hollywood Hills” here:https://link.chtbl.com/mithh_social

    Listen to Keith’s interview with Terry Hall available to Dateline Premium subscribers: https://dateline.supportingcast.fm/listen/dateline-nbc-premium/after-the-verdict-death-in-the-hollywood-hills

    Listen to the episode about the murder of Crystal Taylor mentioned by Susan Leibowitz:https://link.chtbl.com/dl_onemoment

    Hear from the forensic sketch artist who worked on the Kristi Johnson and Crystal Taylor cases: https://www.nbcnews.com/dateline/video/how-forensic-artists-aid-investigations-1077038147665

    Dateline NBC
    enJune 05, 2024

    The Girl with the Hibiscus Tattoo

    The Girl with the Hibiscus Tattoo

    A terrifying killer and serial predator is brought down by a courageous group of women after he lures them with false promises of fame and fortune in Hollywood. Keith Morrison reports.

    Listen to Keith’s original podcast on this story, “Murder in the Hollywood Hills” here: https://link.chtbl.com/mithh_social

    Resources: National Sexual Assault Hotline 800-656-4673 or online.rainn.org

    Listen to Andrea Canning and Keith Morrison as they go behind the scenes of the making of this episode in ‘Talking Dateline’:https://link.chtbl.com/tdl_thegirlwiththehibiscustattoo

    Talking Dateline: The Road Trip

    Talking Dateline: The Road Trip

    Josh Mankiewicz chats with Dennis Murphy about his episode, “The Road Trip.” In June 2015, renowned holistic doctor Teresa Sievers was found dead in her Florida home. Police received a tip that sent them across several states to find her killers, but they determined the mastermind was much closer to home. Dennis talks about the killers’ lengthy road trip to the scene of the crime and their intriguing stops along the way. And, Josh and Dennis discuss how one defendant ended up taking a plea deal and testifying against another defendant – his childhood best friend. Plus, Dennis plays a web-exclusive clip from his interview with defense attorney Elizabeth Parker and answers viewer questions about the episode.

    Listen to the full episode of “The Road Trip” here: https://link.chtbl.com/dl_theroadtrip

    Watch the full episode on Peacock. It’s S28 E29.

    Dateline NBC
    enMay 29, 2024

    Related Episodes

    #230 - The Miracle Murder - Tijeras, New Mexico

    #230 - The Miracle Murder - Tijeras, New Mexico

    This week, in Tijeras, New Mexico, when a murder suspect leads detectives to the scene of the crime, even hardened investigators are shocked at what they find there. What led to this? A life of lies, some of which couldn't be taken back, and the only solution was murder. That... or demonic possession. One, or the other!

    Along the way, we find out that there at least a few Italians in New Mexico, that some lies are too big to admit, and that just when we think we've heard it all, along comes this story!!

    Hosted by James Pietragallo & Jimmie Whisman

    New episodes every Thursday!

    Donate at: patreon.com/crimeinsports or go to paypal.com & use our email: crimeinsports@gmail.com

    Go to shutupandgivememurder.com for all things Small Town Murder & Crime In Sports!

    Follow us on...

    twitter.com/@murdersmall

    facebook.com/smalltownpod

    instagram.com/smalltownmurder

    Also, check out James & Jimmie's other show, Crime In Sports! On iTunes, Stitcher, or wherever you listen to podcasts##

    See Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info.

    8 - Somerton Man, James Wagner - American Homicide with Jake Rider

    8 - Somerton Man, James Wagner - American Homicide with Jake Rider
    SPONSORS:

    MANSCAPED: Use Code BET To Get 20% Off Your Order And Free Worldwide Shipping at manscaped.com


    Hankey Law: If you are in need of representation in ND or MN, visit hankeyjustice.com




    Music ⓒ - Kevin MacLeod



    Welcome back to another week of solved and unsolved homicides, don't forget to rate and subscribe to our show!

    James Wagner Go-Fund-Me: https://www.gofundme.com/f/vkgqay-family-first

    University of Idaho Murders: Part 1

    University of Idaho Murders: Part 1
    In the early hours of November 13, 2022, four University of Idaho students were fatally stabbed in their off-campus residence in Moscow, Idaho. On December 30, 28-year-old Bryan Christopher Kohberger was arrested in Monroe County, Pennsylvania, on four counts of murder in the first degree and felony burglary.

    In part 1 of this 2 part series, I cover who each if the victims were, a timeline of events prior to and the day of the murder, and an extensive background and psychological profiling of the suspected killer, Bryan Kohberger.

    Part 2 will include an extensive review of what was release in the arrest warrant affidavit, what was taken during the search warrant, the defenses potential strategy, and other recent findings in the case.

    If you would like to skip certain parts, see below for specific timestamps:

    8:38 - Who were the victims
    21:31 - Timeline of events
    44:30 - Who is Bryan Koeberger

    FIND CHILLER QUEEN ONLINE:
    Website: http://chillerqueenpodcast.com
    IG: https://instagram.com/chillerqueenpodcast
    Twitter: https://twitter.com/chillerpod

    ACCESS PREMIUM CONTENT:
    Rokfin: https://rokfin.com/chillerqueenpodcast
    (subscribe for ad free listening/early episode drops)

    JOIN THE COMMUNITY OF WEIRD:
    Discord: https://discord.com/invite/GHESH8aa

    FIND AVERY ONLINE:
    IG: https://instagram.com/averydopecook
    TikTok: https://tiktok.com/averydopecook

    Thanks so much for listening. Stay weird my friends, and don't forget to question everything...

    VEGAS SPECIAL! - 9 - Esmeralda Gonzalez, James Hartley - American Homicide with Jake Rider

    VEGAS SPECIAL! - 9 - Esmeralda Gonzalez, James Hartley - American Homicide with Jake Rider
    SPONSORS:


    MANSCAPED: Use Code BET To Get 20% Off Your Order And Free Worldwide Shipping at manscaped.com


    Hankey Law: If you are in need of representation in ND or MN, visit hankeyjustice.com


    __________________________________________________________________________

    Welcome back to another week of solved and unsolved homicides, don't forget to rate and subscribe to our show!


    Music ⓒ - Kevin MacLeod