Welcome to today's case. File The Good Mom, Holly Ette Lamon McFadden,
Body of Crime Podcast Website
Link Tree
Podcast Landing Page
Facebook
Henryetta Mass Murder Group - Follow the Facebook Henryetta Mass Murder Group to stay up to date on the latest concerning this case at
Sage & Sol
Free tickets for The Sound of Freedom
Step into the shadows of mystery and controversy on today's riveting episode. Your curiosity will be pushed to its limits as we dissect the dark enigma surrounding one of the most contentious figures in the gruesome saga of the Henrietta Mass murders journey with us into the heart of darkness, were Jesse Lee McFadden, in an alleged act of savage brutality, extinguished the lives of five children and his wife, Holly TenneT McFadden, an unspeakable carnage that culminated in his own chilling, suicide, scattering bodies across the Erie Silence.
The vast 130 acre expanse, they called home as spring blossomed. In May, it unveiled a grim Tableau, Holly. Her three children and two of their friends were found lifeless on their homestead. Catapulting Holly into the public eye as an apparent victim of Jesse's monstrous rampage. Holly, by all accounts, was the idyllic mother.
Her friendly demeanor warmed her parents and her steadfast presence. At Michael and Tiffany's track meets painted the picture of a supportive, loving parent. She shared a love of arts and crafts.
Holly and Riley kindled their creativity together. Holly wasn't just a homemaker, though. She was an entrepreneur with her sister, Heather Pettigrew. They channeled their passion into a local boutique in Henryetta called The Mystique Emporium, selling their metaphysical products, artful crafts, and all natural skincare products.
Holly to the outside world seemed to be the epitome of the good mom, right? As we peel back the veneer of normalcy, a startling narrative emerged that shook the public's perception. Eerie footage from within our home began to flood Oklahoma news channels revealing shocking scenes of drugs and drug paraphernalia, sex toys, chains, and shackles in the bedrooms, locks in the kitchens.
Suddenly, we all stared into the abyss of possible hidden truths behind their closed doors. This jarring revelation begged the haunting question, was Holly truly a good mom? Our relentless quest to unravel the convoluted case of Jesse Lee McFadden unveiled glaring oversights in his early release from incarceration.
Simultaneously, we started a meticulous dissection of Holly's enigmatic relationship with Jesse. What we unearthed painted a chilling picture, starkly contrasting the narrative offered by Holly and her grieving family. In this web of intrigue, pressing questions began to bubble up. How did Holly, a married woman from Arkansas find herself entangled with a convicted rapist and level three sex offender from McAllister, Oklahoma?
What drove her to invite such a vile entity into her life and worse into her children's lives, who clearly matched McFadden's preferred age bracket. Our quest led us to unbiasedly, scrutinize Holly's role in the dreadful events. Did she bravely battle against Jesse's horrific final act, attempting to shield her children and their friends, or did she have a darker role in the unfolding tragedy?
Unfortunately, those who hold the answers are forever silenced, leaving us a delve into the picture painted by the crime scene, and all of the evidence. We speculate, we deduce, and we question based on Holly's enigmatic narrative. Was Holly truly the good mom or was she something more sinister? Join us as we delve into these questions and more in today's gripping episode.
So Holly's story starts in 1988. She was born on February 28th. Holly Tonoutte Limon Mayo, a Pisces, to both Michael Anthony Mayo, who was 22 at the time, and Jeanette Louise Pepper, who was 24 in El Paso, Texas. At this point in time, McFadden would've been about four and a half years old.
Were they associated with the military in any kind of way back then?
Jeanette's father died in El Paso, Texas, and something tells me that that's probably where he got outta the military. I'm not positive, but he was in the military. Okay, that would be my guess. We actually have a, a photo of one of the houses that they lived in, and so if you guys end up joining us for the live, you'll get to see that.
So in 1988, in that same year, at the time that Holly was born, they were not married. Michael and Jeanette were not married. So they got married on August 2nd of that year. She was 24, a couple years older than Michael. And, um, they married in El Paso. And Holly was about six months at that point in time.
Six, six months old. Michael had been previously married, and so Holly's older brother doesn't have the same mom as Holly. So her older brother has a different mother. What's his name? Timothy. Timothy what? Mayo. Oh, Timothy, mit, Mayo. Yeah. Okay. Holly grew up there in El Paso, Texas, at least as a young child.
There is record of both Michael and Jeanette kind of moving around a lot. So there's a pretty good possibility that Holly also moved around a lot with her brother, and then later her sister was a little bit younger than her in 1996. And the reason that we're gonna bring this up is because this has come up throughout the case.
After everything had come out. But in 1996 on October 11th, Brandi Michelle Baker, who is Michael Mayo's. So Holly's dad's half-sister. She was 14 at the time. Holly would've been about, um, eight years old. This is her paternal aunt, married Jason Philip Baker, who was 22 at the time. So Brandy was 14. This is Holly's aunt and Jason Philip Baker married her at the age of 22.
Holly's paternal grandfather and paternal step-grandmother were required due to her age to authorize the marriage. By signing for it. Jason Philip Baker would later be accused of molesting his daughters and fleeing the country. When he voiced his outrage over Holly's life, following the murders, he had to flee the country.
This is the narrative that, you know, the Mayo family has shared. And this came out when he started going to some of the group pages for the murders that occurred in Henrietta. So there's a number of group pages on Facebook where different people have shared different things about the case and whatnot.
And he started jumping on some of the pages and was talking about his knowledge of Holly, like how he married her aunt, when, you know, when Holly was young, about eight years old. And he talked about what he knew about Holly at that point in time, and then how he saw her later when, um, she had met Riley and Michael's father.
And so he just tried to provide a little bit of kind of backstory, but from the sounds of it, he honestly wasn't really present and honestly probably didn't know that much. But the family obviously got very upset when they saw the things that he was saying because he was more on the, um, side of. There's no way that Holly could have not known.
So he had a different stance than the rest of the family. Yeah. What would you expect from a guy who marries a 14 year old at 22, other than to molest other children? That already is, is a problem. 14 and 22 is a big age difference. It is a big age difference. It's also bothersome to me that you would sign for your 14 year old to...
