Logo
    Search

    How To Oppose A Supermajority

    enJune 18, 2024

    Podcast Summary

    • Affordable Solutions during InflationCompanies like Mint Mobile lower prices through reverse auctions and PlushCare offers FDA-approved weight loss treatments with insurance coverage. Politicians use fan art and personal stories to engage the public.

      Companies are finding creative ways to offer affordable solutions during inflation. Mint Mobile, for instance, used a reverse auctioneer to lower their prices to just $15 a month for new customers. Meanwhile, PlushCare, a telehealth provider, aims to help people lose weight with FDA-approved medications and insurance coverage. In the political sphere, there's a focus on engaging the public through various means, such as fan art competitions and personal stories. Ed Davey, a Liberal Democrat, is running a campaign that relies heavily on Keir Starmer's leadership, potentially making the Liberal Democrats a significant contender in the general election. However, this could also lead to a main opposition attacking the Labour government from the left, posing a challenge for Peter Mandelson and the team.

    • Liberal Democrats ShiftIf the Liberal Democrats become the official opposition, they might not significantly shift towards the left despite their history of opposition to Labor, as they have a tranche of economic liberals and might not want to alienate potential Conservative defectors.

      The Liberal Democrats, under Ed Davey's leadership, could potentially shift towards the center if they become the official opposition in an anomalous situation where they don't actually oppose the government. However, their critique of Labor would likely continue to be that they're not progressive enough. The Liberal Democrats do have a tranche of economic liberals, especially in affluent areas, which could influence their direction. Despite their history of opposition to Labor from the left, they might not lurch far to the left due to their nature and tactics. If the Conservative Party moves significantly to the right, some former Conservatives might consider joining the Liberal Democrats, but Peter doesn't see himself doing so. In a hypothetical situation with a large Labour government, a significant number of Labour, Conservative, and Liberal Democrat MPs, negotiations on tax and spending would be complex, with each party advocating different amounts. Ultimately, the reality of the economic situation would dictate that a Labour government would have to find a balance.

    • Government Majority in ParliamentA smaller government majority can limit its ability to govern effectively, shadow government departments, raise funds, and face scrutiny, but also allows for reflection and eventual return to a more centrist approach.

      The size of a government's majority in parliament significantly impacts its ability to govern effectively and face scrutiny. Former Tory leader William Hague shared his experience of leading the smallest opposition in post-war politics, where they had only 165 MPs. He noted that it was difficult for the opposition to shadow government departments, raise funds, and have their voices heard. However, Hague also pointed out that this period allowed the opposition to reflect on why they lost the election and gradually return to a more centrist approach. The risk for the Conservative Party, which may have lost seats to reformist parties, is that they might adopt a radical right direction due to lack of funds for research and analysis. Peter Madsen, who has experience joining the Labour Party during a near-death experience, emphasized the importance of moving towards the center instead of the radical right to win elections. Overall, the size of a government's majority plays a crucial role in its ability to govern and face opposition, and understanding this dynamic is essential for political success.

    • Conservative Party's election strategyThe Conservative Party is trying to persuade voters not to give Labour a large majority by emphasizing potential negative consequences, while acknowledging Labour's past successes and their own shortcomings.

      The Conservative Party, under William Hague's leadership, is attempting to persuade voters not to give Labour a large majority in the upcoming election. They argue that a Labour government, led by Keir Starmer, would be detrimental to the country. However, the speakers also acknowledge that Labour, under Tony Blair in 1997, delivered on their manifesto despite a landslide victory. The Conservative Party's strategy is to emphasize the negative consequences of a Labour majority while downplaying their own shortcomings. For Labour MPs-to-be, it is crucial to prioritize and plan for the long term, focusing on structural changes and systemic reforms that will benefit the public. Preparation and clear thinking are essential to hit the ground running once in government and avoid the pitfalls of previous administrations.

    • New leader-civil service partnershipA new leader must establish a strong and collaborative partnership with the civil service, provide direction and purpose, and gain their trust and support through clear communication and a clear plan.

      Effective communication and a clear understanding of roles are crucial for a new government leader and their team when entering office. The relationship between the political team and the civil service can be a delicate one, and it's important for the new leader to establish a strong and collaborative partnership. The civil service is not a self-starting machine, and the new leader must provide direction and purpose. First impressions matter, and demonstrating a clear plan and determination is essential for gaining the trust and support of civil servants. Additionally, a new government leader may not always enter office in their expected role, so being adaptable and prepared for unexpected changes is important. Identifying knowledgeable advisors and being familiar with the policies and parties involved can help ensure a successful transition.

    • Team building for effective governanceSeeking diverse perspectives and engaging with young minds is crucial for effective governance and making informed decisions in policy and system change.

      Building a strong team of advisors is crucial for navigating the complexities of policy and system change. Michael Gove, a former British politician, understood this well and sought out both formal and informal advisors to help him make informed decisions. Listener questions ranged from personal anecdotes about political experiences to inquiries about potential election policies. One young fan, James, shared his ideas for policies such as tubes for cities, voting for 10-year-olds, and attending D-Day celebrations for ex-prime ministers. While some policies were debated, the overall consensus was that having diverse perspectives and engaging with young minds is essential for effective governance.

    • Check against dominant partyThe House of Lords acts as a check against a dominant political party by not being bound to vote for legislation outside their manifesto, providing balance in the UK political system.

      The House of Lords serves as a check against a dominant political party, specifically a large Labour majority, by not having to vote for legislation that is not in a party's manifesto. This constitutional arrangement provides an important balance in the UK political system. If one were to consider reforming the House of Lords, creating an elected chamber with more power could potentially strengthen this check, but it may also limit the winning party's ability to implement their policies. Ultimately, it seems unlikely that Labour leader Keir Starmer would pursue such a move given the potential loss of control over his government's agenda.

    Recent Episodes from How To Win An Election

    Q&A: How To Replace Joe Biden

    Q&A: How To Replace Joe Biden

    After Joe Biden's calamitous performance in the first US presidential debate, will the Democrats have to replace him as their candidate for the White House?


    The political masterminds Daniel Finkelstein and Polly Mackenzie join Matt Chorley to answer your questions, including how to be authentic in politics and when is the right time to launch a leadership bid?


    Send questions, comments and voicenotes to howtowin@thetimes.co.uk, or WhatsApp 0333 00 323 53 with the words 'How To Win'.



    Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.


    How To Win An Election
    enJune 28, 2024

    How Not To Talk About Brexit

    How Not To Talk About Brexit

    It's the subject that none of the parties want to talk about - why hasn't Brexit played a bigger part in the election campaign so far?


    The political masterminds Peter Mandelson, Polly Mackenzie and Daniel Finkelstein join Matt Chorley as the podcast passes one million downloads.


    They discuss whether we'll ever rejoin the EU, whether a Keir Starmer cabinet would contain any big surprises, and why John Prescott has called Peter to apologise.


    Send questions, comments and voicenotes to howtowin@thetimes.co.uk, or WhatsApp 0333 00 323 53 with the words 'How To Win'.





    Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.


    How To Win An Election
    enJune 25, 2024

    Q&A: How Not To Bet On Politics

    Q&A: How Not To Bet On Politics

    We're answering your questions in another bonus episode, including: Does someone at Conservative HQ have a bet on the party being wiped out? If Labour wins, will it keep MPs at Westminster all summer while the Tories are in disarray? And who will win the 2034 election?


    Political masterminds Daniel Finkelstein and Polly Mackenzie join Matt Chorley to discuss all of that, and whether the Tories should follow the example of Marks & Spencer to win back middle class voters.


    Send questions, comments and voicenotes to howtowin@thetimes.co.uk, or WhatsApp 0333 00 323 53 with the words 'How To Win'.



    Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.


    How To Win An Election
    enJune 21, 2024

    How To Oppose A Supermajority

    How To Oppose A Supermajority

    As ministers admit on the airwaves that a Conservative victory looks unlikely, how will a small Tory rump in Parliament oppose a new Labour government?


    The political masterminds Peter Mandelson, Polly Mackenzie and Daniel Finkelstein join Matt to look back at what happened in the aftermath of the 1997 Labour landslide, and to consider which way the Conservative Party will turn next. We've also had our first piece of fan art, and launched a colouring competition.


    Send questions, comments and voicenotes to howtowin@thetimes.co.uk, or WhatsApp 0333 00 323 53 with the words 'How To Win'.



    Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.


    How To Win An Election
    enJune 18, 2024

    How Sunak Should Take The Gloves Off

    How Sunak Should Take The Gloves Off

    With Reform UK now ahead of the Conservatives according to one poll, how should Rishi Sunak respond?


    The political masterminds Peter Mandelson and Daniel Finkelstein think the prime minister could electrify the campaign by tackling Nigel Farage head on.


    They join Matt Chorley to talk about whether the polls could still shift before July 4, and whether Keir Starmer really should start measuring the curtains for 10 Downing Street.


    Send questions, comments and voicenotes to howtowin@thetimes.co.uk, or WhatsApp 0333 00 323 53 with the words 'How To Win'.



    Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.


    How To Win An Election
    enJune 14, 2024

    How Trump Will Win

    How Trump Will Win

    We've got a special guest on the podcast this week, with American pollster and strategist Frank Luntz joining Peter Mandelson, Polly Mackenzie, Daniel Finkelstein and Matt Chorley to discuss why Joe Biden is in trouble in the race against Donald Trump, and why the Tories are facing a Canadian-style wipeout.


    Was it wise for Rishi Sunak to head to a racetrack to launch the Conservative manifesto, and are any of the parties being honest about the economy?


    Send questions, comments and voicenotes to howtowin@thetimes.co.uk, or WhatsApp 0333 00 323 53 with the words 'How To Win'.



    Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.


    How To Win An Election
    enJune 11, 2024

    Q&A: How To Get D-Day Wrong

    Q&A: How To Get D-Day Wrong

    The podcast is going twice-weekly for the rest of the campaign, with the political masterminds answering your questions.


    First up today, how did Rishi Sunak get it so wrong when he decided to leave the D-Day ceremony in France early? Can being a good constituency MP save you from defeat? And what's the point of canvassing?


    Send questions, comments and voicenotes to howtowin@thetimes.co.uk, or WhatsApp 0333 00 323 53 with the words 'How To Win'. Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.



    Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.


    How To Win An Election
    enJune 07, 2024

    How To Fight Farage

    How To Fight Farage

    How will Nigel Farage's decision to stand as a candidate for Reform UK affect the election result, and can things get any worse for Rishi Sunak?


    The political masterminds Peter Mandelson, Polly Mackenzie and Daniel Finkelstein join Matt Chorley to discuss the chances of a Conservative implosion, Peter's last-ditch plan to replace Sunak with Penny Mordaunt, and whether the TV debates could still shift the dial.


    We also hear a new version of the theme music, sung in the style of The Smiths.


    Send questions, comments and voicenotes to howtowin@thetimes.co.uk, or WhatsApp 0333 00 323 53 with the words 'How To Win'.



    Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.


    How To Win An Election
    enJune 04, 2024

    How To Dodge A Dodgy Candidate

    How To Dodge A Dodgy Candidate

    The race is on to get candidates in place for the general election, with the Tories having to deal with more MPs announcing their departure by the day.


    The political masterminds Peter Mandelson, Polly Mackenzie and Daniel Finkelstein join Matt Chorley to discuss who the parties will pick, and who they’ll come to regret.


    And has Rishi Sunak’s campaign actually started better than we’d expected?


    Send questions, comments and voicenotes to howtowin@thetimes.co.uk, or WhatsApp 0333 00 323 53 with the words 'How To Win'.



    Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.


    EMERGENCY EPISODE: How To Call An Election!

    EMERGENCY EPISODE: How To Call An Election!

    It's happened. Rishi Sunak has announced the General Election for 4th July - as predicted by Danny in the last episode of the podcast.


    The political masterminds Peter Mandelson, Polly Mackenzie and Daniel Finkelstein join Matt for an emergency episode, recorded at the Podcast Show in London.


    Send questions, comments and voicenotes to howtowin@thetimes.co.uk, or WhatsApp 0333 00 323 53 with the words 'How To Win'.





    Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.