Logo
    Search

    Podcast Summary

    • Convicted murderer Drew Peterson's shocking statements from prisonDrew Peterson, a notorious figure, remains unrepentant and unconcerned about the impact of his actions on others, despite being in prison for over a decade for a murder and being a suspect in another disappearance.

      Drew Peterson, a convicted murderer and suspect in another disappearance, continues to make shocking statements despite being in prison for over a decade. His callous attitude towards his wives, one missing and one dead, has left many disgusted. Peterson's interview reveals a man who seems unrepentant and unconcerned about the impact of his actions on those around him. The case of Stacy Peterson's disappearance brought international attention to a quiet community and put a spotlight on a notorious villain. Despite the controversy and allegations, Peterson maintains his innocence and promises to find his missing wife. The story began with the last day Cassandra Kales spent with her sister, Stacy, and the increasing alarm that ensued when she couldn't be reached. The sisters' lives were forever linked, and their stories will continue to be told together.

    • Stacy Peterson's Disappearance Sparks Community EffortCommunity rallied to find Stacy Peterson, a kind and loving woman, who went missing after meeting an older man, leading to revelations about her marriage and her past.

      The disappearance of Stacy Peterson in 2007 sparked a massive community effort to find her, with volunteers and resources pouring in from all over. Stacy was described as a kind, loving, and gentle person, who looked out for her younger sister Cassandra despite their difficult childhood. However, everything changed when Stacy turned 17 and met Drew Peterson, a much older man and a sergeant with the Bolingbrook Police Department. Their relationship led to Stacy living in a fully furnished apartment, which left Cassandra puzzled about how her sister could afford such a lifestyle. The search for Stacy ultimately revealed stories about her marriage to a much older man and his past, which would soon captivate the country. Despite the challenges they faced growing up, the bond between Stacy and Cassandra was unbreakable, and Stacy was determined to be better than their past.

    • The Suspicious Lives of Two Women Married to Drew PetersonLocal crime reporter Joe Hosey raised suspicions when he noticed the eerie parallels between the lives of Stacy Peterson and Kathleen Savio, both good mothers who were married to the same man, Drew Peterson, whose previous wife had died under suspicious circumstances.

      Stacy Peterson, a young woman seeking stability and a family, married Drew Peterson, a cop whose previous wife, Kathleen Savio, had died under suspicious circumstances. Stacy, who was building a happy family with Drew and his two sons, went missing in 2007. The similarities between Stacy and Kathleen, both good and caring mothers, raised suspicions for local crime reporter Joe Hosey, who had previously reported on Kathleen's death. Kathleen's body was found in her bathtub in 2004, and Drew had been trying to drop off his children at her house for days before discovering her lifeless body. The eerie parallels between the two women's lives and their connections to Drew left many questioning the circumstances surrounding both women's deaths.

    • Initial ruling of Kathleen's death as an accidentThoroughly investigating all aspects of a case is crucial, even when initial findings seem suspicious.

      The investigation into Kathleen Savio's death was initially ruled an accident, but later developments in the case raised suspicions and led to a reexamination of the evidence. Reporter Joe Hose's initial coverage of Kathleen's death in 2000 didn't receive much attention, but when Stacy Peterson went missing in 2007, the media descended on Bolingbrook and the story gained national attention. Kathleen's death was revisited and new evidence came to light, leading to a change in the ruling of her death. The case ultimately led to Drew Peterson being charged with the murder of both Kathleen and Stacy. The initial ruling of Kathleen's death as an accident highlights the importance of thoroughly investigating all aspects of a case, especially when initial findings seem suspicious.

    • Drew Peterson's Suspicious Behavior and Media InterviewsDrew Peterson's odd behavior, lack of cooperation, and media interviews fueled growing suspicions and turned him into a clear suspect in his wife's disappearance. Suspicious circumstances, such as a large blue barrel being removed from the house and Drew's phone near the canal where her body was found, added to the mounting evidence against him.

      Drew Peterson's public antics and lack of cooperation with authorities in the search for his missing wife, Stacy, fueled growing suspicions and turned him into a clear suspect in her disappearance. Despite being warned not to discuss the murders, radio hosts continued to ask him about the case, leading to more revelations and controversy. Drew's odd behavior, such as joking about overdue library books and making light of the situation, further repulsed the public and added to the mounting evidence against him. The investigation into Stacy's disappearance uncovered several suspicious circumstances, including a large blue barrel being removed from the house the night she went missing and Drew's phone being near a canal where her body was later found. Despite being officially named a suspect, Drew continued to speak publicly, further fueling speculation and adding to the intrigue surrounding the case.

    • Drew Peterson's volatile relationship with Kathleen SavioDespite Kathleen's pleas for help regarding Drew's controlling and violent behavior, authorities failed to take action, leaving her family feeling unheard and powerless.

      The relationship between Drew Peterson and his third wife, Kathleen Savio, was marked by rapid courtship, manipulation, and escalating violence. Kathleen's concerns about Drew's infidelity and his attempts to intimidate and control her were dismissed by authorities despite her repeated pleas for help. Tragically, Kathleen's death was ruled an accident, but her sister, Sue, refused to give up on seeking justice. Despite facing threats and even being charged with domestic battery herself, Sue continued to push for a reexamination of the case. Ultimately, the failure of law enforcement to take Kathleen's allegations seriously left her and her family feeling unheard and powerless.

    • Allegations of domestic violence and control in Drew's relationshipsDomestic violence is a serious issue that requires immediate action. Ignoring warnings and failing to intervene can have tragic consequences.

      The relationship between Drew and his wives raised concerns for those around them, with allegations of domestic violence and control leading to the mysterious deaths of two women. Stacy, one of Drew's wives, confided in Pastor Neil Shorey about Drew's past violence towards Kathleen Savio and her own fears for her safety. Despite these concerns, no action was taken, and Stacy eventually disappeared. The pastor tried to intervene by reporting the information to the police, but no investigation ensued until years later. The tragic pattern of alleged abuse and the lack of response from authorities highlights the importance of addressing domestic violence and taking action to protect potential victims.

    • Suspicious Death of Kathleen SavioDespite initial ruling of accidental drowning, inconsistencies in Kathleen Savio's death raised suspicions. New evidence pointed to foul play, including absence of struggle, odd body position, and unexplained bloodstains.

      The death of Kathleen Savio, the third wife of Drew Peterson, which was initially ruled an accidental drowning, raised suspicions due to several inconsistencies. State's Attorney Jim Glasgow, who became involved in the case after Stacy Peterson disappeared, found it implausible that a healthy adult could drown in the small bathtub where Kathleen's body was found. He also noticed that there were no signs of struggle or disturbed toiletries, and the position of her body was odd for a drowning victim. Furthermore, the presence of bloodstains in the tub didn't make sense, as the blood should have diluted into the water and disappeared when it drained. The new autopsy performed on Kathleen's body revealed no bruises on her back or arms, which contradicted the initial finding that she had fallen before her death. Instead, she had 16 fresh bruises on all four planes of her body, suggesting that she had not died by accident.

    • Suspect's inconsistent statements and lack of remorseDrew Peterson, under investigation for his wives' deaths, gave inconsistent statements and showed no remorse, fueling suspicion and investigation

      Drew Peterson, a husband under investigation for the disappearance and suspected murder of his third wife, Stacy, and the death of his fourth wife, Kathleen, gave inconsistent statements and showed no remorse during interviews. He repeatedly made offensive comments about both women and seemed to downplay the significance of their deaths. Despite being a seasoned police officer, he denied any involvement and expressed doubt about the circumstances surrounding their deaths. The pattern of his behavior and comments raised suspicions and fueled the investigation against him.

    • Sister's skepticism of Drew's denialCassandra, Stacy's sister, refused to believe Drew's denial of involvement in Stacy's disappearance. Her doubts grew when Drew joked about the situation on the radio, leading to his arrest for Kathleen Savio's murder.

      Drew Peterson's denial of involvement in Stacy Peterson's disappearance was met with skepticism from Stacy's sister, Cassandra. Despite police stopping their search for Stacy's body in a canal, Cassandra continued to believe that her sister's body was there. Her frustration turned to anger when she heard Drew joking on the radio about the situation. When Cassandra confronted Drew, he dismissed her accusations and continued to enjoy the attention he was receiving from the media. However, just a few days later, Drew was arrested for the murder of his third wife, Kathleen Savio, raising further suspicions about his involvement in Stacy's disappearance. Despite the challenges in building a circumstantial case, prosecutors pressed forward with the investigation, ultimately leading to Drew's arrest.

    • Drew Peterson's Media Attention from PrisonPeterson's attorney, Joel Brodsky, sought media attention, but new defense attorney stopped it. Prosecution relied on hearsay testimony from ex-wives, painting Peterson as a violent, controlling husband with a financial motive.

      Infamous figure Drew Peterson continued to make headlines even from behind bars, using media attention to his advantage. His lead attorney, Joel Brodsky, also sought the limelight, while Peterson's new defense attorney, Steven Greenberg, put a stop to his client's media interactions. Prosecutors faced a significant challenge in using hearsay testimony from Peterson's ex-wives, Kathleen and Stacy, in the trial for Kathleen's murder. The unusual ruling allowing this testimony was a major pretrial victory for the prosecution, and their strategy relied heavily on it. They painted Peterson as a controlling and violent husband, with financial motive for the murder. The trial's biggest twist was the use of Stacy's words, who was still missing at the time, to help build the case against Peterson for Kathleen's death. The media circus surrounding the case made it harder for jurors to acquit Peterson, as the public overwhelmingly wanted to see him convicted.

    • Defense attacks state's case in Drew Peterson trialThe Drew Peterson trial showcased the difficulties of relying on circumstantial evidence and the potential risks of hearsay testimony in criminal trials.

      The defense in the Drew Peterson trial argued that the state's case was circumstantial and relied heavily on questionable hearsay testimony. The defense also attacked the credibility of the state's witnesses, suggesting they were motivated by fame rather than the truth. The defense's own witness, Harry Smith, a divorce attorney who represented Kathleen Savio, ended up reinforcing the pastor's damning testimony against Peterson. Despite the defense's efforts, the jury found Peterson guilty of first-degree murder after two days of deliberations. The case highlights the challenges of relying on circumstantial evidence and the potential pitfalls of hearsay testimony in criminal trials.

    • Prosecutor Glasgow faces threats from Drew Peterson in prisonDespite providing a normal life for his siblings, Steven's faith in his father was shattered when Drew Peterson was convicted for Stacy's murder.

      Despite winning a high-profile murder case against Drew Peterson, prosecutor Jim Glasgow continued to face threats from Peterson even in prison. A letter from an inmate revealed Peterson's plan to hire a hitman to kill Glasgow. This led to Peterson's additional conviction and sentence. Steven, Peterson's son, stepped up to care for his younger siblings after their father was sentenced to prison. Despite the challenges, Steven was determined to provide them with a normal life. However, Steven's faith in his father was shattered when Peterson was convicted for Stacy's murder, leading him to accept the painful reality.

    • Impact of crime on families: A long and complex journeyCrime's effects on families extend beyond convictions, with family members dealing with emotions, decisions, and the search for closure.

      Families of crime victims are left to grapple with complex emotions and difficult decisions, even after the perpetrator has been convicted. The Peterson family, in particular, has had to come to terms with the fact that their father and husband, Drew Peterson, is serving time for murdering two women. The family members have varying opinions about their father, with some visiting him in prison and others refusing to forgive him. Despite the challenges, the family has managed to stay together and support each other through the ordeal. Meanwhile, Cassandra Calesaro, Stacy Peterson's sister, continues her search for closure and justice, refusing to give up hope that her sister's body will be found. Drew Peterson, for his part, maintains his innocence and continues to file appeals, leaving many to question his version of events. The case serves as a reminder of the long-lasting impact of crime on families and the complex emotions that come with seeking justice.

    • Drew Peterson's Continued Innocence ClaimDespite being a prime suspect in his wives' disappearances, Drew Peterson insists on his innocence, denying abuse allegations and claiming to be a loving provider. His children grew up without their mothers, and he may spend the rest of his life in prison while the investigations continue.

      Drew Peterson, a man once accused of killing his third wife and making his fourth wife, Stacy Peterson, disappear, continues to maintain his innocence. He believes that everyone else, including the media, the prosecution, and his ex-wives, are making up facts and twisting the truth to make their cases against him stronger. Peterson denies being an abusive husband and claims he was a loving and good provider. However, he acknowledges that his children grew up without their mothers, Kathleen and Stacy. Despite his ongoing appeals, he may be in prison for the rest of his life, while the investigation into Stacy's disappearance remains open, with Drew being the prime suspect.

    • Turning grief into action: Families of Stacy Peterson and Kathleen SavioThe families of Stacy Peterson and Kathleen Savio have turned their grief into action by helping victims create written records of abuse and advocating for survivors, honoring their loved ones by seeking justice and ensuring their memories live on.

      The tragic stories of Stacy Peterson and Kathleen Savio have become a legacy for raising awareness and preventing domestic violence. The individuals involved, including Neel Shorrie and Norma Peterson, have turned their grief into action by helping victims create written records of abuse and advocating for survivors. Kathleen's sister, Sue Dohman, continues to share Kathleen's story to help others. The families of Stacy and Kathleen have found solace in honoring their loved ones by helping others and seeking justice. Cassandra Peterson remains dedicated to finding her sister and bringing her home, while also ensuring that Stacy's memory lives on. The loss of a loved one to domestic violence is immeasurable, and the families' determination to turn their pain into purpose serves as a powerful reminder of the importance of recognizing and addressing the signs of abuse.

    Recent Episodes from Dateline NBC

    Talking Dateline: The Secret in Black Rock Canyon

    Talking Dateline: The Secret in Black Rock Canyon

    Andrea Canning talks to Keith Morrison about his episode, “The Secret in Black Rock Canyon.”  In 2006, 16-year-old Cassie Jo Stoddart was found stabbed to death at a relative’s home in Pocatello, Idaho. Detectives quickly learned that Cassie’s last day alive was nothing short of a real-life horror movie, with video to prove it, and the filmmakers-turned-killers were not at all who they expected. Keith and Andrea discuss his interview with one of Cassie’s killers and Keith shares an extra clip from his interview with Dr. James Garabino, a psychologist and expert on teen violence. Plus, Keith and Andrea are joined by the detective who investigated Cassie’s murder, retired Captain John Ganske.

    Listen to the full episode of "The Secret in Black Rock Canyon" here: https://link.chtbl.com/dateline_podcast

    Dateline NBC
    enJune 26, 2024

    Talking Dateline: The Breakup

    Talking Dateline: The Breakup

    Keith Morrison talks to Josh Mankiewicz about Josh’s latest episode, “The Breakup.” In 2010, a California nurse was found dead in her home. Police thought they had a clear suspect, but soon discovered evidence that pointed them in a direction no one saw coming, one that kept our viewers and our correspondents guessing until the end. Keith plays Josh an extra clip from his interview with the detectives as they describe coming face to face with their initial suspect, and Josh answers viewer and listeners questions with Dateline assistant producer Jess Koernig.

    Listen to the full episode of "The Breakup" here: https://link.chtbl.com/dl_thebreakup

    Dateline NBC
    enJune 19, 2024

    Talking Dateline: Dark Intentions

    Talking Dateline: Dark Intentions

    Josh Mankiewicz and Andrea Canning sit down to talk about Andrea’s newest episode, “Dark Intentions.” In 1996, the murder and sexual assault of two women in the same apartment complex rattled the city of Arlington, Texas and stumped police. But when two other women from the area survive sexual assaults, police find evidence that connects all four crimes.Andrea tells Josh what she learned from the women who survived their brutal attacks, and she describes the involved investigation that finally cracked the case. Andrea also plays a podcast-exclusive clip and Dateline producer Haylee Barber joins in to answer viewer questions from social media.

    If you or someone you know has experienced sexual assault, call the National Sexual Assault Hotline at 800-656-4673 or visit online.rainn.org

    Listen to the full episode of “Dark Intentions” here: https://link.chtbl.com/dl_darkintentions

    Dateline NBC
    enJune 12, 2024

    Talking Dateline: The Girl with the Hibiscus Tattoo

    Talking Dateline: The Girl with the Hibiscus Tattoo

    Andrea Canning interviews Keith Morrison about his latest episode, “The Girl with the Hibiscus Tattoo,” based on his original podcast “Murder in the Hollywood Hills.” 21-year-old Kristi Johnson mysteriously disappeared in 2003 after meeting a man at the Century City Mall in Los Angeles who invited her to audition for a Bond movie.  She was found dead days later. Keith talks about the group of women who helped bring Kristi’s killer to justice and shares a clip from his 2023 interview with Kristi’s mother, Terry Hall. Susan Leibowitz, one of the producers of the episode, answers viewer and listener questions.

    Listen to “Murder in the Hollywood Hills” here:https://link.chtbl.com/mithh_social

    Listen to Keith’s interview with Terry Hall available to Dateline Premium subscribers: https://dateline.supportingcast.fm/listen/dateline-nbc-premium/after-the-verdict-death-in-the-hollywood-hills

    Listen to the episode about the murder of Crystal Taylor mentioned by Susan Leibowitz:https://link.chtbl.com/dl_onemoment

    Hear from the forensic sketch artist who worked on the Kristi Johnson and Crystal Taylor cases: https://www.nbcnews.com/dateline/video/how-forensic-artists-aid-investigations-1077038147665

    Dateline NBC
    enJune 05, 2024

    The Girl with the Hibiscus Tattoo

    The Girl with the Hibiscus Tattoo

    A terrifying killer and serial predator is brought down by a courageous group of women after he lures them with false promises of fame and fortune in Hollywood. Keith Morrison reports.

    Listen to Keith’s original podcast on this story, “Murder in the Hollywood Hills” here: https://link.chtbl.com/mithh_social

    Resources: National Sexual Assault Hotline 800-656-4673 or online.rainn.org

    Listen to Andrea Canning and Keith Morrison as they go behind the scenes of the making of this episode in ‘Talking Dateline’:https://link.chtbl.com/tdl_thegirlwiththehibiscustattoo

    Talking Dateline: The Road Trip

    Talking Dateline: The Road Trip

    Josh Mankiewicz chats with Dennis Murphy about his episode, “The Road Trip.” In June 2015, renowned holistic doctor Teresa Sievers was found dead in her Florida home. Police received a tip that sent them across several states to find her killers, but they determined the mastermind was much closer to home. Dennis talks about the killers’ lengthy road trip to the scene of the crime and their intriguing stops along the way. And, Josh and Dennis discuss how one defendant ended up taking a plea deal and testifying against another defendant – his childhood best friend. Plus, Dennis plays a web-exclusive clip from his interview with defense attorney Elizabeth Parker and answers viewer questions about the episode.

    Listen to the full episode of “The Road Trip” here: https://link.chtbl.com/dl_theroadtrip

    Watch the full episode on Peacock. It’s S28 E29.

    Dateline NBC
    enMay 29, 2024

    Related Episodes

    Drew Peterson

    Drew Peterson

    Looking at his life from the outside, it would appear that Drew Peterson was a real lady’s man.  But looks can be deceiving and Drew Peterson was no lady’s man, he was a cold-blooded killer.  I’m John Dodson, welcome to The Secret Sits.

    Searching for Stacy Peterson - Missing Person Fundraiser (searchingforstacypeterson.com)

    Don’t forget to leave us a Rating and Review on Apple Podcast.

    Support the show

    https://www.buymeacoffee.com/TheSecretSits

    Send show suggestions to:

    TheSecretSitsPodcast@gmail.com

    Follow us on our social media at:
    https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCwnfvpNBYTo9BP1sVuFsfGQ


    TheSecretSitsPodcast (@secretsitspod) / Twitter

    https://www.instagram.com/thesecretsitspodcast/

    https://www.facebook.com/TheSecretSitsPodcast

    https://www.tiktok.com/@thesecretsitspodcast?lang=en

    You can find our podcast on:

    Apple Podcasts
    Stitcher
    Spotify
    Buzzsprout.com
    Goodpods
    Google Podcasts
    Amazon Music
    iHeart Radio
    Pandora
    Podcast Addict
    Podchaser
    Pocket Casts
    Deezer
    Listen Notes
    Player FM
    Podcast Index
    Overcast
    Castro
    Castbox
    Podfriend

    #DrewPeterson #Bolingbrook #illinois #police #VickiConnolly #KathleenSavio #StacyCales #StacyPeterson #CassandraCales #Sisters #LarryKingLive #TodayShow #CNN #ChristinaRaines #MarciaClark #TheFirst48 #Chicago #BLM #AFewBadApples #ThinBlueLine


    Support the show

    The Disappearance of Stacy Peterson

    The Disappearance of Stacy Peterson

    This week, Kelsie walks us through the horrible tragedy of Stacy Peterson. Stacy Peterson married a man who she believed was her soulmate. Someone that she'd live a long, happy, healthy life with. Unfortunately, she married Drew Peterson. Drew's third wife had mysteriously died in an accidental drowning, and then Stacy went missing. Coincidence?
    Make sure you subscribe as we upload episodes every Monday. Thanks for listening!

    Sources for this episode include:

    https://podcasts.apple.com/hr/podcast/the-tragic-disappearance-of-stacy-peterson/id1453918264?i=1000456671860

    - https://www.ranker.com/list/most-bizarre-true-crime-stories-in-history/justin-andress

    - https://www.nbcchicago.com/news/local/i-want-to-tell-the-whole-story-new-controversy-erupts-over-fate-of-drew-petersons-missing-wife-stacy/2837189/

    - https://chicago.suntimes.com/crime/2022/5/20/23132819/drew-peterson-case-stacy-peterson-sister-supports-former-defense-attorney-reveals-where-sister-is 

    - https://www.crimemuseum.org/crime-library/famous-murders/drew-peterson/ 

    - https://sites.temple.edu/klugman/2020/07/20/do-40-of-police-families-experience-domestic-violence/

    https://ncadv.org/STATISTICS 



    Support the show

    Tell Me More - Part 1

    Tell Me More - Part 1

    This week Keeley has a 2 part-er that speaks to intent. Have you ever felt like something isn't right and you know something is coming on down the pipe line. Today's podcast episode is all about intuition.

    If this sounds like something you’ve experienced email us at keeleyace@gmail.com. This is a safe space to share your personal stories that may be read on the podcast. Remember we are in this pit-of-dispair together, let me help you ARMOR up! 

    No Chick Flick Moments