Logo

    Is there any point in taking multivitamins?

    enJuly 18, 2024
    Who is Ratman in the Guardian Pop Culture podcast?
    What did the study on multivitamins find regarding longevity?
    What does The Guardian's Feast Up app offer?
    Why are randomized clinical trials important in nutrition studies?
    What dietary patterns did Professor Joanne Manson discuss?

    Podcast Summary

    • Multivitamins health benefitsA recent study found that daily multivitamin use did not increase longevity and may even slightly increase mortality risk for healthy individuals.

      While the Supercell creator Ratman is an intriguing figure to learn about in the latest Guardian Pop Culture podcast episode, and the new Feast app offers a variety of delicious and expert-cooked meals for all levels, a recent study questioning the health benefits of multivitamins made headlines. The study of over 400,000 healthy Americans found that daily multivitamin use did not increase longevity and may even slightly increase mortality risk. With nearly half of UK adults taking supplements, understanding the potential risks and benefits is crucial. The multivitamin market can be confusing, so staying informed and consulting healthcare professionals is advised.

    • Multivitamins and mortalityObservational studies linking multivitamin use to increased mortality risk should be interpreted with caution due to potential confounding factors and difficulty isolating cause-and-effect relationships.

      The recent observational study suggesting multivitamins don't help healthy people live longer and may even increase mortality risk should be interpreted with caution. People take multivitamins for various reasons, including health concerns and symptom relief, making it challenging to isolate cause-and-effect relationships in observational studies. The correlation between multivitamin use and mortality may not necessarily mean causation. While adjusting for certain factors can help, it's impossible to account for all potential confounding factors. Randomized clinical trials, which can provide stronger evidence of causality, are essential for answering many of these questions when feasible.

    • Multivitamins and cancerMultivitamins may reduce cancer incidence and all-cause mortality with no increased risk of death, contributing to overall health and brain health.

      While more research is needed on multivitamins and other dietary supplements, the current evidence suggests a small but significant benefit for reducing total cancer incidence and all-cause mortality, with no increased risk of death. This benefit may be due to the fact that an optimal nutrition, including multivitamins, is essential for overall health and brain health, as shown by studies reporting a benefit in slowing age-related memory loss and cognitive decline. Despite the borderline significant reductions in all-cause mortality reported in large-scale studies like the US Physicians Health Study 2 and the US Preventive Services Task Force meta-analysis, the safety record of long-term use of multivitamins in randomized clinical trials is good. However, it's important to note that individual responses to multivitamins and other dietary supplements may vary, and further research is needed to determine who specifically benefits from their use.

    • Supplementation for specific groupsOlder adults, individuals with certain conditions, and pregnant women may benefit from multivitamin supplementation, but excessive intake can lead to health risks, so stick to recommended daily intakes.

      While multivitamins can provide essential vitamins and minerals for those with nutrient-deficient diets, the need for supplementation is not universal. Older adults, individuals with certain conditions like macular degeneration, Crohn's disease, ulcerative colitis, and celiac disease, and women planning a pregnancy are more likely to benefit. However, excessive intake of megadose supplements can lead to overdosing on certain minerals and vitamins, which may pose health risks. It's crucial to stick to the recommended daily intakes to avoid potential harm.

    • Multivitamin risksConsumers should approach multivitamin marketplace with caution, check for seals of quality control and third-party testing, and remember supplements don't replace a healthy diet and lifestyle

      While multivitamins and other dietary supplements can offer health benefits, it's crucial for consumers to approach the marketplace with caution. Some vitamins, like high doses of vitamin E and A, can have adverse effects, such as increased risk of stroke or kidney stones. It's important to note that these risks come from much higher doses than what's typically found in multivitamins. With so many options available, it can be difficult for consumers to know what's right for them. However, it's essential to remember that dietary supplements don't undergo the same safety and efficacy reviews as pharmaceuticals. Therefore, it's a "buyer beware" scenario. Consumers should check for seals of quality control and third-party testing to ensure the product contains what it claims and is free of contaminants. Ultimately, multivitamins and supplements should never replace a healthy diet and lifestyle, but they can be a beneficial complement in certain cases. And yes, Joanne, I take a multivitamin myself as a form of insurance and because of its proven benefits and good safety profile.

    • Healthy Eating, DietIncorporating more whole foods and healthy eating patterns, like the Mediterranean diet, can reduce the risk of chronic diseases and improve overall wellbeing. Try The Guardian's Feast Up app for new meal ideas.

      If you're listening to Science Weekly and finding value in it, please consider leaving a review to help spread the word. Your rating makes a difference in helping others discover the podcast. Additionally, The Guardian is offering a new cooking app called "Feast Up" for those looking to expand their culinary skills. Whether you're a seasoned cook or just starting out, this app provides access to a variety of delicious and easy-to-make meals from expert Guardian cooks. From vegan dishes to hearty comfort foods, there's something for everyone. Try it out today with a 14-day free trial. Meanwhile, on Science Weekly, we were fortunate to have a conversation with Professor Joanne Manson. She discussed the importance of diet in preventing chronic diseases and the role of healthy eating patterns like the Mediterranean diet. She also touched on the benefits of certain foods like nuts and whole grains, and the potential drawbacks of processed foods and sugar. In summary, taking care of your health involves making informed choices about your diet. By incorporating more whole foods and healthy eating patterns, you can reduce your risk of chronic diseases and improve your overall wellbeing. And if you're looking for new and delicious meal ideas, be sure to check out The Guardian's Feast Up app.

    Recent Episodes from Guardian

    The final Grenfell inquiry report and what it means for families – Politics Weekly UK

    The final Grenfell inquiry report and what it means for families – Politics Weekly UK
    The 2017 Grenfell Tower fire in London was the result of ‘decades of failure’ by central government, the public inquiry into the catastrophe has found. The Guardian’s John Harris looks at the findings of the report with the social affairs leader writer Susanna Rustin. And, as Labour continues to warn ‘things will get worse before they get better’, we are joined by the economists James Meadway and Ann Pettifor to discuss whether a painful period of austerity-lite is the only way through the storm. Help support our independent journalism at theguardian.com/politicspod
    Guardian
    enSeptember 05, 2024

    The race to understand mpox

    The race to understand mpox
    Last month the World Health Organization declared the recent mpox outbreak that began in the Democratic Republic of the Congo a public health emergency of international concern. As scientists race to find out more about the new strain, Ian Sample talks to Trudie Lang, professor of global health research and director of the global health network at the University of Oxford, to find out what we still need to learn in order to tackle and contain the virus. Help support our independent journalism at theguardian.com/sciencepod
    Guardian
    enSeptember 05, 2024

    The arrest of Telegram’s founder, and what it means for social media

    The arrest of Telegram’s founder, and what it means for social media
    The arrest of Telegram’s founder and CEO in Paris last month has thrown the spotlight on the messaging app and its approach to content moderation. Madeleine Finlay hears from Russian affairs reporter Pjotr Sauer and technology journalist Alex Hern about how the case could influence how social media companies approach problematic content on their platforms. Help support our independent journalism at theguardian.com/sciencepod
    Guardian
    enSeptember 03, 2024

    Politics Weekly Westminster: Labour’s doom-and-gloom message

    Politics Weekly Westminster: Labour’s doom-and-gloom message
    The Guardian’s Pippa Crerar and Kiran Stacey talk about whether Labour can move away from the doom-and-gloom messaging and towards a more hopeful tone? Plus, MPs will get their first chance to vote on leadership contenders this week. Help support our independent journalism at theguardian.com/politicspod
    Guardian
    enSeptember 02, 2024

    Summer picks: the science of ‘weird shit’

    Summer picks: the science of ‘weird shit’
    The psychologist Chris French has spent decades studying paranormal claims and mysterious experiences, from seemingly impossible coincidences to paintings that purportedly predict the future. In this episode from April 2024, Ian Sample sits down with French to explore why so many of us believe in what he terms ‘weird shit’, and what we can learn from understanding why we are drawn to mysterious and mystic phenomena. Help support our independent journalism at theguardian.com/sciencepod
    Guardian
    enAugust 29, 2024

    Carla Denyer and the Green party: four MPs v the climate crisis

    Carla Denyer and the Green party: four MPs v the climate crisis
    The Green party made history in the general election, winning four seats for the first time. But how much will it be able to achieve in parliament when facing the gravity of the climate crisis? The Guardian’s John Harris sits down with Carla Denyer, the Greens’ co-leader and MP for Bristol Central, to ask her what comes next for the party. Help support our independent journalism at theguardian.com/politicspod
    Guardian
    enAugust 29, 2024