Logo

    Is Ukraine’s incursion into Russia a gamble that could pay off?

    en-gbAugust 13, 2024
    What significant event occurred in the Ukraine-Russia conflict recently?
    How has the Ukrainian advance affected Russian civilians?
    What is the Guardian's new cooking app called?
    What are the risks of Ukraine's military strategy against Russia?
    What reactions did Putin have to the Ukrainian offensive?

    Podcast Summary

    • Ukraine-Russia ConflictUkrainian forces entered Russian territory, marking a new phase in the conflict with potential psychological and strategic implications, while thousands of Russians were evacuated due to military advancement, raising concerns for civilians' safety.

      The ongoing conflict between Ukraine and Russia took a significant turn as Ukrainian forces advanced into Russian territory for the first time since World War II. This development marks a new phase in the war, with potential psychological and strategic implications. Meanwhile, in a stark contrast, the Guardian introduces its new cooking app, Feast, offering a diverse range of delicious meals for all, regardless of cooking experience. While the war unfolds, thousands of Russians have been evacuated from border regions due to the military advancement. This event not only signifies a shift in the geopolitical landscape but also raises concerns about the safety and security of civilians on both sides.

    • Ukrainian offensive into Russian territorySurprise invasion by Ukraine into Russian territory marked a new escalation in the conflict, reaching several kilometers in, prompting a swift and tough response from Russia, with unclear implications

      The Ukrainian offensive into Russian territory came as a surprise to civilians on both sides and marked a new escalation in the ongoing conflict. The first reports of the invasion emerged from Russian military bloggers and quickly gained confirmation from Ukrainian and Russian officials. Despite initial claims that the incursion had been repelled, it became clear that Ukraine had made significant gains, reaching several kilometers into Russian territory. The response from Russia has been swift and tough, with President Putin calling it a major provocation. The implications of this offensive are unclear, with some seeing it as a mistake or a miscalculation, while others view it as a first step towards victory. Regardless, the invasion has brought the war home to a small part of the Russian population in a way that it hasn't done before.

    • Ukrainian tacticsUkrainian forces use sophisticated combined arms warfare, maintain 'fog of war' to surprise Russians, and aim to grab territory and create panic for a faster retreat

      Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky took several days to acknowledge Ukrainian forces' involvement in the counter-offensive due to the importance of maintaining the "fog of war" against Russia. Ukrainian tactics involve sophisticated combined arms warfare, using a mix of tanks, infantry, missiles, air defense, and electronic warfare. The Ukrainians have found a lightly defended area and are rapidly advancing, trying to pin down Russian forces while the rest encircle them for surprise attacks. The goal is to grab territory, keep the enemy guessing, and potentially create panic for a faster retreat. Previously, Ukrainian progress was shared publicly through flag-raising videos, but this time, there's been a disciplined effort to limit information to preserve the element of surprise. Russian official channels and military bloggers have provided most of the information about the conflict.

    • Ukraine-Russia conflict political impactThe military advances by Ukrainian forces and the resulting need for Russian defense may have significant political implications, as Ukraine demonstrates the effectiveness of their military aid and boosts morale.

      The ongoing conflict between Ukraine and Russia involves more than just the disputed 300 square kilometer territory, as the Ukrainian forces have been able to make significant advances and even attack Russian targets up to 25 miles from the border. This has required Russia to move some of its forces to defend the area, potentially weakening their presence in other regions. The military impact is significant, but the political impact may be even greater, as Ukraine is able to demonstrate the effectiveness of the military aid they have received from Western backers, boosting morale and showing that they are still actively fighting.

    • Ukraine-Russia tensionsUkraine's military actions against separatists gained widespread support, putting Russia on defensive and potentially leading to heavy military response

      Ukraine's military actions against Russian-backed separatists in eastern Ukraine has gained widespread support among Ukrainians and put Russia on the defensive. This psychological effect is significant both in Ukraine and in the Kremlin, where Russia is reportedly transferring troops from other areas to respond. The situation remains unstable, and Russia's response is expected to be tough, potentially involving heavy military action. Meanwhile, unrelated to the geopolitical tensions, The Guardian invites readers to discover delicious meals through its new cooking app, featuring vegan dishes, comfort foods, and bold flavors from expert cooks.

    • Russia-Ukraine conflict risksThe ongoing conflict between Russia and Ukraine poses significant risks for both parties, with potential damage to Putin's credibility and escalation concerns for Western backers if Ukraine uses offensive tactics with their military aid.

      The ongoing conflict between Russia and Ukraine carries significant risks for both parties, politically and militarily. The longer the incursion continues, the more damaging it could be for Putin's credibility and the Russian people. Ukraine, on the other hand, is trying to demonstrate the value of Western military aid by using it offensively against Russian forces. However, this could raise concerns among Western backers, as the equipment was originally intended for defensive use within Ukraine's borders. Until recently, Western countries had been reluctant to allow high-value military equipment to be used in Russia's internationally recognized borders due to escalation fears. The situation is fraught with risk, as the battle could potentially shift in favor of either side, making it crucial for both parties to carefully consider their next moves.

    • Ukraine's border defenseWestern backers have become more supportive of Ukraine's offensive actions, providing additional military aid including high-mile rocket artillery, allowing Ukraine to defend its borders and push back against Russian aggression.

      The vulnerability of Ukraine's borders against Russian incursions has been highlighted, as Ukraine was previously unable to defend against large Russian force concentrations due to restrictions on using powerful Western weapons. However, there have been signs of changing positions from Western backers, including the US, Germany, and the UK, who have been more supportive of Ukraine's offensive actions against Russian forces. This shift in stance has led to the provision of additional military aid, including the use of high-mile rocket artillery, to help Ukraine defend its borders and push back against Russian aggression. The success of Ukraine's recent offensive in taking back territory from Russia suggests that they may be able to make further gains, but the thinly defended nature of the area in question indicates that the situation remains complex and uncertain.

    • Ukraine-Russia conflict moralePresident Zelensky's morale boost for Ukrainian people crucial, but continued offensive tactics against Russia could risk exhaustion and panic among civilians, keeping the situation uncertain

      The ongoing conflict between Ukraine and Russia is unpredictable, with Ukraine currently gaining ground but the psychological factor and potential for a Russian response remaining significant. The morale of the Ukrainian people is a key factor for President Zelensky, and continuing offensive tactics against Russia could be popular but risky, as Ukraine faces a larger and more populated enemy. Despite recent successes, the exhaustion of troops and potential for a panic among civilians could shift the tide of the conflict. The situation remains fluid and uncertain, with the potential for unexpected developments.

    • Ukraine war impact on young populationThe ongoing Ukraine war is causing significant stress on young population due to conscription and extreme danger, but recent counteroffensive gives renewed hope and motivation despite risks.

      The ongoing war in Ukraine is taking a heavy toll on the young population, with many being conscripted and sent to the front lines where they face extreme danger. This reality is putting significant stress on the morale of the population, especially as the war seems to be going in Russia's favor. However, the recent Ukrainian counteroffensive has given the population a renewed sense of hope and motivation, despite the risks involved. For President Zelensky, launching this offensive is a big gamble, as there's a chance it could be successful and lead to significant gains, but there's also a risk of losing ground and troops if the Russians counterattack effectively.

    • Ukraine's military advancement risksUkraine's military advancement deeper into Russian territory could lead to a dangerous escalation, potentially involving nuclear weapons. Western allies advise caution to prevent unwanted conflicts and maintain peace.

      Key takeaway from the discussion with Dan Saba, Defense and Security Editor for The Guardian, is the potential risks and consequences of Ukraine's military advancement deeper into Russian territory. While it's unlikely that Russia will use nuclear weapons, there's a possibility of a stronger counter-reaction from Russia that could lead to a dangerous escalation. The Western allies might advise Ukraine to exercise caution and avoid overconfidence to prevent potential mistakes. It's essential to tread carefully to maintain peace and prevent any unwanted conflicts. This is an important reminder of the complex geopolitical dynamics at play in the ongoing conflict in Ukraine. The discussion underscores the need for diplomacy and dialogue to resolve disputes peacefully. It's crucial to stay informed and be aware of the potential risks and consequences of military actions.

    Recent Episodes from Today in Focus

    Related Episodes

    In Moscow's Shadows 85: War and Peace (and how both are changing)

    In Moscow's Shadows 85: War and Peace (and how both are changing)

    What broader lessons about the changing nature of war, peace and power can we draw from the Russo-Ukrainian conflict? A more conceptual and rambling episode than usual...

    The Meduza article on FSO polling I mentioned is here.

    You can also follow my blog, In Moscow's Shadows, and become one of the podcast's supporting Patrons and gain question-asking rights and access to exclusive extra materials right here


    Support the show

    WMD in Ukraine with David Lasseter

    WMD in Ukraine with David Lasseter

    Today on the RealClearDefense podcast "Hot Wash", host John Sorensen and RCD Editor David Craig continue coverage of the Russian invasion of Ukraine by speaking to David Lasseter, former Deputy Assitant Secretary of Defense for Countering Weapons of Mass Destruction and a visiting Fellow at the National Security Institute. He is also recently the author of an article on RealClearDefense, “Putin’s Disinformation & Opportunity: Weapons of Mass Destruction.” 

    Putin has put Russia's nuclear forces on alert, but are chemical and biological weapons more likely threats in Ukraine? How does Putin’s history of using disinformation affect calculations calculations of possible escalations?

    Follow RealClearDefense on Twitter

    Read David Lasseter's article in RealClearDefense, “Putin’s Disinformation & Opportunity: Weapons of Mass Destruction

    Subscribe to the RealClearDefense Podcast "Hot Wash"

    Subscribe to the Morning Recon newsletterfor a daily roundup of news and opinion on the issues that matter for military, defense, veteran affairs, and national security.