Logo

    Lynze Cummins | Scared to Death Podcast - Interview

    enAugust 09, 2024
    What inspired the creation of the "Scared to Death" podcast?
    How did Lindsay feel about engaging with horror content initially?
    What type of stories does the speaker find most unsettling?
    Why does the speaker find ghost stories more believable than alien encounters?
    What coping mechanisms does the speaker use during podcast recordings?

    Podcast Summary

    • Podcast planningThoughtful planning, collaboration, and a unique angle are essential for creating a successful podcast, especially in a saturated genre like horror and paranormal.

      The creation of the "Scared to Death" podcast was a result of thoughtful planning, collaboration, and a deep consideration for the endless possibilities of horror and paranormal content. Lindsay Cummins and her husband Dan, who is also the podcast's host, discussed the idea for the show during their transition from LA to Portland. Dan, who had a history of podcasting, wanted to create a structure with three separate shows, one of which would be a creative and fun project with Lindsay. Although Lindsay initially expressed fear due to her sensitivity to horror, Dan's persuasiveness led them to pursue the project. They recognized the importance of having a well-researched and unique angle to ensure longevity in the horror and paranormal podcast space. Overall, the creation of "Scared to Death" involved careful planning, a deep understanding of the content, and a commitment to delivering high-quality and engaging episodes.

    • Aliens vs GhostsPeople may find it easier to accept paranormal phenomena with established parameters and familiar behaviors over those with unknown and seemingly impossible nature

      While some paranormal phenomena, like ghosts, can be more relatable and believable due to their perceived parameters and known behaviors, other phenomena, such as aliens, are harder to accept due to their unknown and seemingly impossible nature. The speaker, who has a production background and is skeptical of alien abductions, finds it challenging to reconcile her goal-oriented and systematic worldview with the unpredictable and inexplicable nature of aliens. She finds ghost stories more believable as they have established parameters and a sense of familiarity. However, everyone's coping mechanisms and beliefs are unique, and what one person finds terrifying, another might find intriguing. The speaker's own coping mechanisms include using crystals, a cross, and a cleansing spray to help her feel prepared and protected during recordings.

    • Supernatural EncountersSpeakers shared stories of encounters with ghosts and unexplained occurrences, emphasizing the importance of storytelling and the excitement of sharing unusual experiences, while also discussing protective measures and the process of collecting fan stories

      The speakers shared experiences of encounters with the supernatural, including a resident ghost named Tilly, unexplained occurrences, and feelings of being watched. They also discussed the importance of storytelling and the excitement of sharing unusual experiences. The speakers also mentioned the use of protective measures such as rituals and symbols. Additionally, they revealed that they work months ahead to collect and condense fan stories for their book, and the satisfaction they get from seeing Dan's reaction to the stories. Overall, the conversation highlighted the shared belief in the existence of the supernatural and the enjoyment of sharing and experiencing strange occurrences.

    • Minute details in scary storiesSpecific, minute details in stories can make them believable, scary, and memorable, particularly in those with masculine narrators admitting fear.

      The most believable and scary stories for the speaker are those with specific, minute details that feel real and vulnerable. She finds that stories from men, particularly those who are traditionally masculine and admit to fear, are the most unsettling. The small details in a story, like a change in routine or a shift in a familiar environment, can make an otherwise forgettable tale memorable and eerie. A particular story that continues to haunt the speaker is about a brother and sister whose strange experiences while their brother-in-law is away leave them questioning reality. While it's unclear if the story is true or a work of fiction, the speaker cannot shake the feeling that there is something more to it.

    • Open to new ideas and taking risksBeing open to new ideas and taking calculated risks can lead to a more engaging and successful podcast experience for both the creators and the audience.

      The success of the "Scared to Death" podcast came from being open to new ideas and taking risks. Initially, the podcast featured Dan telling ghost stories to his co-host, but as fan submissions increased, they decided to incorporate them into the show. At first, the co-host was hesitant, but they weighed the pros and cons and ultimately decided to give it a try. The fan stories added a new dimension to the podcast, making it more personal and engaging for listeners. The co-host also emphasized the importance of hearing the human voice behind the stories, making the experience more believable and emotional. The podcast's format evolved organically, and the team remained open to change, ultimately leading to its success.

    • Paranormal podcast hostingHosts prioritize respecting storytellers and maintaining essence of stories while making accessible to audience, rate stories based on believability, and express fascination with Hat Man due to sleep paralysis connection and shared human experience.

      Despite the skepticism and pressure involved in evaluating and sharing listener stories on their paranormal podcast, the hosts prioritize respecting the storytellers and maintaining the essence of the stories while making them accessible to their audience. They rate stories based on believability and strive to clean up and present them in a way that honors the original intent, while also acknowledging the personal nature of the shared experiences. The hosts do not have a favorite entity or experience that excites them the most, but they express a particular fear and fascination with the Hat Man due to its potential connection to sleep paralysis and the shared human experience of sleeping and the dark.

    • Lindsey's approach to social mediaDespite dealing with negativity and criticism, Lindsey maintains a positive attitude and values social interaction. She identifies as an extroverted introvert, cherishes alone time, and encourages respectful expression of opinions.

      Despite the challenges of being recognized as someone else or dealing with negative comments, Lindsey maintains a positive attitude and values the importance of social interaction. She identifies as an extroverted introvert and uses her energy to bring good vibes to those around her. However, she also cherishes her alone time and finds joy in the idea of having doppelgangers. When faced with criticism, Lindsey tries to understand where it's coming from and doesn't let it bring her down. She encourages people to express their opinions, but asks that they focus on the content rather than personal attacks. Overall, Lindsey's approach to life is to spread positivity, embrace individuality, and learn from the experiences of others.

    • Respecting Others' Preferences and ExperiencesRecognize everyone's unique talents and merits, be empathetic towards creators, and respect others even in the face of differences or the unknown.

      Everyone has unique preferences and experiences, and it's important to respect others even if we don't share the same opinions or tastes. The speaker shares how she learned to be more understanding towards people she doesn't particularly like, recognizing that everyone has their own talents and merits. She also encourages empathy towards creators, acknowledging that they put effort into their work and that negative reviews may not always reflect the truth. The speaker also shares her belief that those who leave harsh criticisms may not be creators themselves. Lastly, she shares two personal stories of seemingly paranormal experiences, emphasizing the importance of being gentle and respectful towards others, even in the face of the unknown or unexplained.

    • Music and Live ExperiencesThe hosts and Lindsey from Scared to Death Podcast shared their love for music and live experiences, mentioning favorite artists and events, highlighting the positive impact music has on their lives

      Lindsey from Scared to Death Podcast and the hosts shared their love for music and live experiences during their conversation. Lindsey mentioned her favorite artists such as Cage the Elephant, Jason Isbell, Leon Bridges, Miley Cyrus, and Fontaine DC. She also mentioned her fondness for live music events and festivals like The Gorge. The hosts also revealed their own music preferences and experiences. Lindsey also spoke about her interview with Jim Harold and her admiration for him. The conversation was filled with positivity, mutual respect, and a shared passion for music and podcasting. It's clear that music plays a significant role in their lives and brings them joy.

    Recent Episodes from Believing the Bizarre: Paranormal Conspiracies & Myths

    George Coghill | Monsterologist - Interview

    George Coghill | Monsterologist - Interview
    It is interview time again and we are super excited to talk with the artist George Coghill, also known as Monsterologist.
    Fun fact: I (Tyler) currently have 3 Monsterologist stickers on my car and we have 5 of his cryptid travel posters up in our podcast studio. We are HUGE fans of his work and have been for a few years now.
    In this interview, George Coghill, the creative force behind Monsterologist, shares his journey from freelance artist to cryptid art entrepreneur, driven by a desire to create the cool monster artwork his 8-year-old self always wanted.
    His unique approach combines childhood fascination with paranormal phenomena, a commitment to authenticity, and a business model that prioritizes passion over profit. Coghill's story is a testament to the power of perseverance, as he turned a simple Bigfoot patch design into a thriving business that resonates with fellow enthusiasts at paranormal conventions across the country.
    Throughout the interview, he offers valuable insights for aspiring creators, emphasizing the importance of pushing through creative blocks and staying true to one's vision, even when success seems unlikely.

    Check out Monsterologist's work here: https://monsterologist.com/

    Patreon: Support Believing the Bizarre and get tons of extra content by joining our Patreon.

    For updates, news, and extra content, follow Believing the Bizarre on social media:
    Instagram
    Facebook
    Twitter
    Discord

    Shop Merch: You can rep Believing the Bizarre and buy some unique merch

    Texas UFO Encounters

    Texas UFO Encounters
    This week we head to Texas to discuss some popular Lone Star State UFO Encounters.
    From the enigmatic Lubbock Lights of 1951 to the perplexing Stephenville incident of 2008, we examine reports of massive, silent crafts and unexplained aerial phenomena that have baffled witnesses and investigators alike.
    In the Levelland UFO case, multiple vehicles mysteriously stalled in the presence of an unidentified object. 
    Perhaps most disturbing is the account of Betty Cash and Vicki Landrum, whose close encounter left them with severe, long-lasting health issues attributed to radiation exposure.

    Patreon: Support Believing the Bizarre and get tons of extra content by joining our Patreon.

    For updates, news, and extra content, follow Believing the Bizarre on social media:
    Instagram
    Facebook
    Twitter
    Discord

    Shop Merch: You can rep Believing the Bizarre and buy some unique merch

    The Grafton Monster

    The Grafton Monster
    The Grafton Monster
    On a fateful night in June 1964, Robert Cockrell's drive home through Grafton, West Virginia, took an unexpected turn when he encountered a massive, headless creature with smooth, rubbery skin.
    This bizarre sighting sparked a town-wide frenzy, with armed locals combing the woods in search of what became known as the Grafton Monster.
    Multiple witnesses described an 8-10 foot tall entity with broad shoulders and a seemingly non-existent head, lending credence to Cockrell's account and fueling the growing hysteria.
    As the monster-hunting craze reached fever pitch, UFO researcher Gray Barker linked the creature to extraterrestrial phenomena, adding another layer of mystery to the tale.
    But just as the investigation seemed to gain traction, both Cockrell and Barker abruptly abandoned their pursuits.
    The sudden cessation of their inquiries raises unsettling questions: What forces compelled them to drop the subject? Did they uncover truths too disturbing to share, or were they silenced by shadowy figures determined to keep the Grafton Monster's secrets buried?

    Patreon: Support Believing the Bizarre and get tons of extra content by joining our Patreon.

    For updates, news, and extra content, follow Believing the Bizarre on social media:
    Instagram
    Facebook
    Twitter
    Discord

    Shop Merch: You can rep Believing the Bizarre and buy some unique merch

    The Filicidal Ghost

    The Filicidal Ghost
    In this episode of Believing the Bizarre, we dive into more listener submission stories.

    From shared dreams of pink goo monsters to pendulum divinations revealing shocking truths about human identity, these stories blur the line between the ordinary and the extraordinary.

    We explore a chilling encounter at an abandoned mansion in Florida, where a father and son stumble upon more than they bargained for. With slamming doors, temperature drops, and a ghostly figure closing curtains, this creepy tale is hard to forget about once the episode is over.

    Next, we talk about Cry Woman's Bridge in Indiana, where a father's childhood encounter comes back to haunt him decades later. 

    Patreon: Support Believing the Bizarre and get tons of extra content by joining our Patreon.

    For updates, news, and extra content, follow Believing the Bizarre on social media:
    Instagram
    Facebook
    Twitter
    Discord

    Shop Merch: You can rep Believing the Bizarre and buy some unique merch

    Bizarre News and Top Zombie Movies Blind Rankings

    Bizarre News and Top Zombie Movies Blind Rankings
    This month's Bizarre News covers a wide variety of strange and unusual topics. Including:

    Story 1 - A resurfaced clip from a 2001 nature documentary showing a shadowy bipedal figure running alongside caribou in remote Quebec has sparked online debates about a potential Bigfoot sighting, with the cinematographer affirming no crew or known individuals were present during filming.

    Story 2 - Surveillance footage from Colombia showed a man mysteriously thrown to the ground by an unidentified flying orb, sparking debate about its nature and leaving the incident unexplained

    Story 3 - A fan's meticulous replicas of The Shining's hedge maze and elevator doors have led to eerie occurrences in her home, raising suspicions of supernatural activity linked to the iconic horror film.

    Story 4 (First picture is eyes open, second picture is eyes shut) - A woman in Canton, Ohio claims to have witnessed and photographed a statue of the Virgin Mary opening and closing its eyes at a local church, though the pastor remains skeptical of the alleged miracle.

    Story 5 - Recent CT scans of the "Screaming Woman," an ancient Egyptian mummy, suggest her haunting expression may be due to cadaveric spasm rather than poor embalming, revealing a possible death in extreme pain and challenging previous assumptions about her mummification.

    Additionally, we play Blind Rankings with Producer Ben and must rank our top 10 Zombie movies of all time.

    Patreon: Support Believing the Bizarre and get tons of extra content by joining our Patreon.

    For updates, news, and extra content, follow Believing the Bizarre on social media:
    Instagram
    Facebook
    Twitter
    Discord

    Want to discuss the episode on the day it drops with Tyler and Charlie? Follow on Twitch and check out the extended Twitch streams every Tuesday.

    Shop Merch: You can rep Believing the Bizarre and buy some unique merch

    The Shadow at Grandma's Funeral

    The Shadow at Grandma's Funeral
    Another Tuesday and another Believing the Bizarre episode!

    We have 3 creepy listener submissions for you this week.

    The first story follows Adrianna, where she see discovers her little cousin hiding under a bed, only to find out that there was no way she could have been there...

    Our second story takes place in the Netherlands. Robin stayed at a hotel, supposedly the only guest, but then woke up in the middle of the night to a lot of strange noises.

    The final story is from Abby. She had countless experiences, from her grandmother seemingly turning sinister, strange noises, shadow figures, and more.

    Trigger Warning: Animal Death 🐎


    Patreon: Support Believing the Bizarre and get tons of extra content by joining our Patreon.

    For updates, news, and extra content, follow Believing the Bizarre on social media:
    Instagram
    Facebook
    Twitter
    Discord

    Want to discuss the episode on the day it drops with Tyler and Charlie? Follow on Twitch and check out the extended Twitch streams every Tuesday.

    Shop Merch: You can rep Believing the Bizarre and buy some unique merch

    The Bloody Shadow

    The Bloody Shadow
    It is listener submission time again!
    Our first story takes us to Rexburg, Idaho, where Sydney experiences a series of unsettling events in her college apartment, including mysterious knocks, moving objects, and a terrifying shadow figure. The haunting escalates until a blessing brings peace, only for Sydney to face another frightening encounter on a mountain trip with friends.
    Jeremy's tale transports us to the dense woods of Portland, Michigan, where he and a friend stumble upon a hidden clearing with an old stone foundation. Their curiosity leads to an encounter with the ghost of a young girl and the discovery of an eerie penny from 1904. The story takes an even stranger turn when they try to return the penny, only to find the trail and clearing have vanished without a trace.
    Our third story comes from Kendall in North Texas, who experiences a vivid dream of a shadow figure in a jester costume entering her bedroom. Her forceful rejection in the dream seems to ward off the presence, but her cat's strange behavior continues to hint at unseen entities. This tale blurs the line between dreams and reality, leaving us to wonder about the true nature of Kendall's experience.
    Finally, we hear from Devin in Mesa, Arizona, whose family moves into a house that becomes the site of numerous paranormal activities. From unexplained break-ins and moving objects to ghostly encounters in the hallway and swimming pool, Devin's story is a rollercoaster of eerie events. The episode concludes with a mysterious incident involving a resin cup in Devin's current home, proving that the bizarre and unexplained can follow us wherever we go.

    Patreon: Support Believing the Bizarre and get tons of extra content by joining our Patreon.

    For updates, news, and extra content, follow Believing the Bizarre on social media:
    Instagram
    Facebook
    Twitter
    Discord

    Want to discuss the episode on the day it drops with Tyler and Charlie? Follow on Twitch and check out the extended Twitch streams every Tuesday.

    Shop Merch: You can rep Believing the Bizarre and buy some unique merch

    Lynze Cummins | Scared to Death Podcast - Interview

    Lynze Cummins | Scared to Death Podcast - Interview
    We are honored and super excited to sit down and chat with Lynze (Lindsay) Cummins from Scared to Death Podcast.

    Lynze shares the origins of Scared to Death, revealing how her husband Dan Cummins envisioned it as part of a trio of shows. She discusses the organic evolution of including listener stories and the challenges of adapting to a public-facing role.

    She also opens up about dealing with negative comments and the importance of maintaining a positive perspective in the face of criticism. The conversation delves into Lindsay's personal experiences with the paranormal, including her certainty that her childhood home was haunted.

    She recounts chilling stories from her neighbors and friends, highlighting how subtle, unexplained occurrences can be the most unsettling. Lindsay also shares her thoughts on various paranormal entities, admitting that the "hat man" phenomenon feels particularly plausible and frightening to her due to its connection with sleep paralysis.

    Stay updated on all things Scared to Death here: https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/scared-to-death/id1477287015

    Patreon: Support Believing the Bizarre and get tons of extra content by joining our Patreon.

    For updates, news, and extra content, follow Believing the Bizarre on social media:
    Instagram
    Facebook
    Twitter
    Discord

    Want to discuss the episode on the day it drops with Tyler and Charlie? Follow on Twitch and check out the extended Twitch streams every Tuesday.

    Shop Merch: You can rep Believing the Bizarre and buy some unique merch

    The Possession of Clara Germana Cele

    The Possession of Clara Germana Cele
    In 1906, Clara, a 16-year-old orphan at St. Michael Mission in Natal, South Africa, began exhibiting strange behaviors. Initially kind and devout, she started talking to unseen entities, claiming she had made a deal with Satan.
    Her behavior escalated to tearing at her clothes, growling, and speaking in languages she had never learned. Clara also demonstrated clairvoyance, revealing private information about the nuns and other students.
    Most alarmingly, she was observed levitating up to five feet in the air. As Clara's condition worsened, displaying inhuman strength and violent outbursts, the church decided to perform an exorcism. Rev. Mansueti and Father Erasmus Horner conducted the ritual over two grueling days in front of 170 witnesses.
    During the exorcism, Clara exhibited supernatural abilities, including body contortions and snake-like transformations. The demon possessing her claimed to be Satan himself, summoned by Clara's dark purpose. The exorcism concluded with Clara levitating one final time before the demon departed, leaving behind a foul stench.
    Although Clara initially recovered and seemed to return to normal, signs of possession resurfaced in 1907. Nuns observed her making strange noises and levitating again. Father Erasmus returned to perform a second exorcism, which lasted 10 days.

    Patreon: Support Believing the Bizarre and get tons of extra content by joining our Patreon.

    For updates, news, and extra content, follow Believing the Bizarre on social media:
    Instagram
    Facebook
    Twitter
    Discord

    Want to discuss the episode on the day it drops with Tyler and Charlie? Follow on Twitch and check out the extended Twitch streams every Tuesday.

    Shop Merch: You can rep Believing the Bizarre and buy some unique merch

    The Bermuda Triangle

    The Bermuda Triangle
    The Bermuda Triangle, also known as the Devil's Triangle, is a vast 500,000 square mile area in the Atlantic Ocean bounded by Miami, Bermuda, and Puerto Rico.
    This region has been the site of numerous mysterious disappearances of ships and aircraft over the years, leading to its infamous reputation. The area is prone to powerful weather patterns and is home to one of the deepest ocean trenches on Earth.
    At least 1,000 people are estimated to have died in the Triangle over the past century. While many paranormal explanations have been proposed, including alien abductions and wormholes, scientists point to natural causes for the Triangle's phenomena.
    Strong ocean currents like the Gulf Stream, methane gas bubbles, magnetic anomalies, and severe weather are among the leading scientific explanations. Navigation errors and equipment failures, exacerbated by the area's challenging conditions, likely account for many of the reported incidents.
    Some of the most famous disappearances in the Bermuda Triangle include the USS Cyclops in 1918, Flight 19 in 1945, and the pleasure craft Witchcraft in 1967. These cases remain unsolved, with extensive searches failing to locate any trace of the missing vessels or aircraft.
    While the Bermuda Triangle continues to captivate the public imagination, many experts argue that the frequency of disappearances in the area is not statistically anomalous given the high volume of traffic through the region.

    Patreon: Support Believing the Bizarre and get tons of extra content by joining our Patreon.

    For updates, news, and extra content, follow Believing the Bizarre on social media:
    Instagram
    Facebook
    Twitter
    Discord

    Want to discuss the episode on the day it drops with Tyler and Charlie? Follow on Twitch and check out the extended Twitch streams every Tuesday.

    Shop Merch: You can rep Believing the Bizarre and buy some unique merch

    Related Podcasts