Logo
    Search

    Millennials: moaners or martyrs? Janan Ganesh takes on Aime Williams

    enMarch 23, 2016

    Podcast Summary

    • Appreciating Modern Conveniences and Historical ContextMillennials have it better than previous generations due to advancements in technology and lifestyle, even if economic data doesn't always reflect it. Consider the bigger picture and be grateful for modern conveniences.

      We often overlook the everyday conveniences and historical context that make our lives better than previous generations. Janang Ganesh, a political commentator, argues that millennials, despite their complaints about financial struggles, have it much better than those born in the 1960s. He points out that had we been born during the Cold War era, we could have been conscripted into total wars. We also take for granted modern technologies like the internet, motor cars, and refrigeration. These improvements in lifestyle are not always reflected in economic data. Ganesh encourages us to adopt a broader perspective when evaluating our generation's progress compared to previous ones. Instead of focusing solely on income and property prices, we should consider the bigger picture and ask ourselves if we would rather be born in the current era or in the 1960s. This Mother's Day, Blue Nile invites us to express our love and appreciation for the extraordinary women in our lives with a heartfelt gift. With a vast selection of exquisite pearls and mesmerizing gemstones, fast shipping options, and discounts of up to 50%, Blue Nile makes this Mother's Day unforgettable. Meanwhile, LinkedIn offers access to professionals like Sandra, who might be open to new opportunities despite not actively seeking a new job. LinkedIn's unique platform can help businesses hire top talent that they might miss out on by not looking there.

    • The Millennial Experience: Beyond Economic MetricsBoth Amy Williams and Janan Ganesh offer nuanced perspectives on the millennial experience, recognizing that it's not solely about economic metrics but also about the broader context of living, including technological and social advancements, and the complexities of the millennial generation's financial situation.

      While technological and social progress may be beneficial, it doesn't negate the fact that many millennials are experiencing financial struggles compared to previous generations. Millennial columnist Amy Williams argues that focusing solely on economic metrics doesn't capture the full picture of living. She also suggests that assumptions about young people's apathy towards voting may be misguided, as there could be various reasons for their absence at the polls. Janan Ganesh, the original columnist, acknowledges that he may have had a slightly worse financial deal as a millennial but emphasizes the advantages of modern technology and communication. However, Williams argues that these advantages don't offset the economic disparities between generations. Ultimately, both writers encourage a nuanced perspective on the millennial experience, recognizing that it's not all about economic metrics but also about the broader context of living.

    • Financial security's impact on political engagementFinancial insecurity among young people and income inequality within generations may influence political attitudes and behaviors more than intergenerational differences.

      Financial security plays a significant role in political engagement, and many young people may feel financially insecure, leading to lower voter turnout. Additionally, while there may be disagreements between generations on certain issues, such as pensions, the real divide may be within generations due to income inequality. Furthermore, the use of store cards and loyalty programs is widespread in the UK, with over 92% of the population having at least one, yet a significant amount of points go unused, amounting to billions of pounds. The struggle for financial stability and intragenerational income disparities may be more impactful on political attitudes and behaviors than intergenerational differences.

    • Maximizing Supermarket Loyalty Card BenefitsStay informed about offers, be strategic, and adapt to rules for optimal loyalty card usage. Some cards may offer better deals when used 'disloyally' or by sending someone else's card for shopping.

      While supermarket loyalty cards are marketed as rewards for customer loyalty, the best deals and offers can often be found by being strategic and even "disloyal" to a single store. For instance, if you don't use a card for an extended period, you may lose your points, and if you try to use them at a different branch or store, you might not be able to redeem them. However, sending someone else's card for shopping can result in better offers and discounts for you. For example, a Waitrose cardholder in the home counties might prefer their card due to the free tea and coffee and the ability to choose favorite items for a 20% discount. However, the least popular card, according to the discussion, is the Spark card from Marks and Spencer. Despite its initial success with 3.8 million users, many customers have complained about the limited food items and general merchandise discounts. Marks and Spencer, however, is trying to improve this by profiling customers better to provide more targeted offers and extending the offer duration from once a week to two weeks. Overall, to maximize the benefits of supermarket loyalty cards, it's essential to stay informed about the offers, be strategic, and adapt to the ever-changing rules and policies.

    • Political instability in democratic states and its impact on marketsInvestors should monitor political developments in democratic states for potential market impact, as instability can increase due to fragmented political processes and unstable governments, particularly in Europe where the euro's controlling policy limits policy changes based on electorate preferences.

      Political instability in democratic states can significantly impact markets, particularly in Europe, where the two major parties have been losing traction with the public, leading to more fragmented political processes and unstable governments. John Redwood, a politician, FT Money columnist, and chair of the Charles Stanley Pan Asset Investment Committee, suggests that when the polls start to dip too much for the two major parties in Europe, investors should ascribe more political risk to that particular country. With the advent of the euro, electorates in different European countries can express any economic preference they like, but it won't be reflected in policy due to the euro's controlling policy, leading to more political risk in the European space as a whole. This trend is also happening to a lesser extent in countries outside the euro area, and even in the United States, where the two major parties still dominate the political landscape, a similar process is underway. Therefore, investors should keep a close eye on political developments in democratic states and assess the potential impact on markets.

    • Rise of Populism in America and EuropeThe income gap between capital and labor is fueling a rise in populism, driving the success of protest parties and populist movements like Syriza and Trump.

      The political landscape in both America and Europe is experiencing a rise in populism due to growing resentment among working people over issues like wages, labor competition, and migration. This sentiment is fueling the rise of protest parties and populist movements, such as Syriza in Greece and Trump in America. Investors need to recognize that there's a strong feeling that the income gap between capital and labor is unfair, and there will be political expression to this. The electoral contests within the Republican and Democrat parties in the US are reflecting this trend, with Hillary Clinton being pushed to the left and both Trump and Cruz challenging the establishment. Overall, uncertainty and populism are key themes in the current political climate.

    Recent Episodes from Money Clinic with Claer Barrett

    Financial regrets? Comedian Lucy Porter’s had a few

    Financial regrets? Comedian Lucy Porter’s had a few

    It’s easy to harbour regrets about poor financial decisions, but this week’s guest has decided to do what many wouldn’t dare: air her mistakes in public on a national tour. Presenter Claer Barrett speaks with comedian Lucy Porter, best known for her appearances on QI, Have I Got News For You and EastEnders, about her biggest money regrets and more, and the many, many laughs along the way. Clip: BBC 


    Catch Lucy on her national tour of No Regrets and listen to her podcast, Fingers on Buzzers.

    For more tips on how to organise your money, sign up to Claer's email series 'Sort Your Financial Life Out With Claer Barrett' at FT.com/moneycourse

    If you would like to be a guest on a future episode of Money Clinic, email us at money@ft.com or send Claer a DM on social media — she’s @ClaerB on Twitter, Instagram and TikTok. 


    Want more?

    Check out Claer’s column, What I wish I’d known before my smartphone was snatched.

    Listen to more episodes, such as Money Clinic meets Joe Lycett, Credit Card Clinic: How to get on top of your debts in 2024, and more.

    Presented by Claer Barrett. Produced by Tamara Kormornick. Our executive producer is Manuela Saragosa. Sound design by Breen Turner, with original music from Metaphor Music. Cheryl Brumley is the FT’s global head of audio.


    Read a transcript of this episode on FT.com



    Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.


    What will the UK election mean for your money?

    What will the UK election mean for your money?

    Regardless of which political party wins the UK general election on July 4, voters fear they will have to pay more taxes. Taxes are the crucial battleground in the run-up to polling day, and experts question whether manifesto pledges can be delivered without raising them. What aspects of our personal finances could be affected - and could a change of leadership potentially be beneficial for investors in UK stocks? In this episode, host Claer Barrett discusses what could happen next with Miranda Green, the FT’s deputy opinion editor; Nimesh Shah, chief executive of advisory firm Blick Rothenberg and Moira O’Neill, an FT investing columnist. Clips: LBC, Labour Party


    Links to articles mentioned in the show:

    Blue Wall vulnerable to tactical voting as natural Conservatives turn against party

    The hunt for good-value UK stocks

    Wealthy foreigners step up plans to leave UK as taxes increase


    For more tips on how to organise your money, sign up to Claer's email series 'Sort Your Financial Life Out With Claer Barrett' at FT.com/moneycourse

    If you would like to be a guest on a future episode of Money Clinic, email us at money@ft.com or send Claer a DM on social media — she’s @ClaerB on Twitter, Instagram and TikTok. 


    Want more?

    Check out Claer’s column, What I wish I’d known before my smartphone was snatched.

    Listen to more episodes, such as Tax cuts: will they or won’t they?, The bonus secrets of Financial Times readers, and more.


    Presented by Claer Barrett. Produced by Tamara Kormornick. Our executive producer is Manuela Saragosa. Sound design by Breen Turner, with original music from Metaphor Music. Cheryl Brumley is the FT’s global head of audio.


    Read a transcript of this episode on FT.com



    Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.


    Can financial therapy change our relationship with money?

    Can financial therapy change our relationship with money?

    Prepare to take a seat on the therapist’s couch and discover what your money habits say about you. In this episode, host Claer Barrett sits down with the UK’s first financial therapist, Vicky Reynal whose new book, Money on Your Mind: The Psychology Behind Your Financial Habits, aims to help people untangle problematic aspects of their relationship with money. They discuss the symbolic nature of money, what can make one person a spender and another a saver, and how equipping yourself with this knowledge can empower you to change negative behaviours around money.


    Want more?

    Check out Claer’s column, What I wish I’d known before my smartphone was snatched.

    Listen to more episodes, such as Money and relationships: a crash course, Investment masterclass: The psychology of money, The high cost of being a wedding guest, and more.

    For more tips on how to organise your money, sign up to Claer's email series 'Sort Your Financial Life Out With Claer Barrett' at FT.com/moneycourse

    If you would like to be a guest on a future episode of Money Clinic, email us at money@ft.com or send Claer a DM on social media — she’s @ClaerB on Twitter, Instagram and TikTok. 


    Presented by Claer Barrett. Produced by Tamara Kormornick. Our executive producer is Manuela Saragosa. Sound design by Breen Turner, with original music from Metaphor Music. Cheryl Brumley is the FT’s global head of audio.


    Read a transcript of this episode on FT.com



    Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.


    The Five Minute Investor from Money Clinic: What is a PE ratio?

    The Five Minute Investor from Money Clinic: What is a PE ratio?

    When we talk about the relative value of our investments, PE ratios are never far away from the conversation - but what does this mean, and what exactly goes into this calculation? In the latest episode of our Five Minute Investor miniseries, FT consumer editor Claer Barrett challenges FT investment columnist Stuart Kirk to break down the ‘price’ and ‘earnings’ parts of the equation, and elucidate on other ways the PE ratio is used by investors to benchmark the relative value of different shares and other assets in their portfolio. 


    Tune in every Tuesday to catch the latest episode of the Five Minute Investor, and subscribe to Money Clinic wherever you get your podcasts. If you would like Claer to demystify an investment term, email the team at money@ft.com or send Claer a DM on social media — she’s @ClaerB on Instagram and TikTok.


    For more tips on how to organise your money, sign up to Claer's email series 'Sort Your Financial Life Out With Claer Barrett' at FT.com/moneycourse


    Want more?

    Check out Claer’s column, Have you got five minutes to talk about investing?

    Read Stuart Kirk’s latest Skin in the Game column for free.

    Listen to Money Clinic’s Investment Masterclasses, such as Stuart Kirk has ‘skin in the game’, ‘Money is basically a fiction’, and more.

    Disclaimer: The Money Clinic podcast is a general discussion about financial topics and does not constitute an investment recommendation or individual financial advice.


    Presented by Claer Barrett. Produced by Tamara Kormornick. Our executive producer is Manuela Saragosa. Sound design by Breen Turner, with original music from Metaphor Music. Cheryl Brumley is the FT’s global head of audio.


    Read a transcript of this episode on FT.com



    Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.


    The Five-Minute Investor from Money Clinic: What’s an IPO?

    The Five-Minute Investor from Money Clinic: What’s an IPO?

    With a string of companies preparing to launch stock market listings on both sides of the Atlantic, investors may be tempted to invest in an IPO. But when companies stage an initial public offering, what are the factors to consider? In our new miniseries, The Five-Minute Investor, consumer editor Claer Barrett challenges Rob Armstrong, co-host of FT’s Unhedged podcast and author of the Unhedged newsletter, to explain why companies go public, and the risks of getting carried away with investing on the first day of public trading.


    Tune in every Tuesday to catch the latest episode of The Five-Minute Investor, and subscribe to Money Clinic wherever you get your podcasts. If you would like Claer to demystify an investment term, email the team at money@ft.com or send Claer a DM on social media — she’s @ClaerB on Instagram and TikTok.


    For more tips on how to organise your money, sign up to Claer's email series 'Sort Your Financial Life Out With Claer Barrett' at FT.com/moneycourse


    Want more?

    Listen to Unhedged wherever you get your podcasts, read Rob Armstrong’s latest Unhedged newsletter, and sign up to a free 30-day trial of the Unhedged newsletter: https://www.ft.com/unhedgedoffer

    Check out Claer’s column, Have you got five minutes to talk about investing?

    Listen to Money Clinic’s Investment Masterclasses, such as An insider's view of the City of London, What’s one of the world’s leading investors buying?, and more.


    Disclaimer: The Money Clinic podcast is a general discussion about financial topics and does not constitute an investment recommendation or individual financial advice.


    Presented by Claer Barrett. Produced by Tamara Kormornick. Our executive producer is Manuela Saragosa. Sound design by Breen Turner, with original music from Metaphor Music. Cheryl Brumley is the FT’s global head of audio.


    Read a transcript of this episode on FT.com



    Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.


    The Five-Minute Investor from Money Clinic: What is a yield?

    The Five-Minute Investor from Money Clinic: What is a yield?

    Like an interest rate on a savings account, investment yields show us how much income different investments are able to generate. But how are yields calculated, and how can they measure the returns on different types of investments including shares, bonds and property? 

    In our new miniseries, The Five-Minute Investor, consumer editor Claer Barrett asks FT markets columnist and Unhedged co-host Katie Martin to give practical examples of how yields can be used as a benchmark for different assets, and how to interpret the story behind the numbers.


    Tune in every Tuesday to catch the latest episode of The Five-Minute Investor, and subscribe to Money Clinic wherever you get your podcasts. If you would like Claer to demystify an investment term, email the team at money@ft.com or send Claer a DM on social media — she’s @ClaerB on Instagram and TikTok.


    For more tips on how to organise your money, sign up to Claer's email series 'Sort Your Financial Life Out With Claer Barrett' at FT.com/moneycourse.


    Want more?


    Listen to Unhedged wherever you get your podcasts, and read Katie Martin’s column on the topic, How the humble dividend might rise again.


    Check out Claer’s Lunch with investor and ‘Dragon’s Den’ star Deborah Meaden.


    Listen to Money Clinic’s investment masterclasses, such as Deborah Meaden on her life in business, An insider's view of the City of London, and more.


    Presented by Claer Barrett. Produced by Tamara Kormornick. Our executive producer is Manuela Saragosa. Sound design by Breen Turner, with original music from Metaphor Music. Cheryl Brumley is the FT’s global head of audio.


    Disclaimer: The Money Clinic podcast is a general discussion about financial topics and does not constitute an investment recommendation or individual financial advice.


    Read a transcript of this episode on FT.com



    Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.


    The Five-Minute Investor from Money Clinic: What’s a bull market?

    The Five-Minute Investor from Money Clinic: What’s a bull market?

    Global stock markets are charging along breaking record after record — but what’s driving this ‘bull market’ and how much longer can it last? Plus, what could it mean for investors if a ‘bear market’ awakens from hibernation? In our new miniseries, The Five-Minute Investor, consumer editor Claer Barrett challenges Rob Armstrong, co-host of FT’s Unhedged podcast and author of the Unhedged newsletter, to explain the factors that drive bull and bear markets, and if individual investors should reconsider their strategy.


    Links:

    Free pound cost averaging calculator: https://www.hl.co.uk/tools/calculators/regular-investing-calculator


    Free dollar cost averaging calculator: https://www.buyupside.com/calculators/dollarcostave.php


    Tune in every Tuesday to catch the latest episode of The Five-Minute Investor, and subscribe to Money Clinic wherever you get your podcasts. If you would like Claer to demystify an investment term, email the team at money@ft.com or send Claer a DM on social media — she’s @ClaerB on Instagram and TikTok.


    For more tips on how to organise your money, sign up to Claer's email series 'Sort Your Financial Life Out With Claer Barrett' at FT.com/moneycourse


    Want more?


    Listen to Unhedged wherever you get your podcasts, read Rob Armstrong’s Unhedged newsletter on the topic, A better bull market?, and sign up to a free 30-day trial of the Unhedged newsletter: https://www.ft.com/unhedgedoffer


    Check out Claer’s column, Have you got five minutes to talk about investing?


    Listen to Money Clinic’s Investment Masterclasses, such as An insider's view of the City of London, What’s one of the world’s leading investors buying?, and more.


    Presented by Claer Barrett. Produced by Tamara Kormornick. Our executive producer is Manuela Saragosa. Sound design by Breen Turner, with original music from Metaphor Music. Cheryl Brumley is the FT’s global head of audio.


    Disclaimer: The Money Clinic podcast is a general discussion about financial topics and does not constitute an investment recommendation or individual financial advice.


    Read a transcript of this episode on FT.com



    Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.


    The Five-Minute Investor from Money Clinic: The power of compounding

    The Five-Minute Investor from Money Clinic: The power of compounding

    ‘The two most powerful warriors are patience and time,’ Leo Tolstoy once wrote. But how can this make you a richer investor? The answer is compounding, and in our new miniseries, The Five-Minute Investor, consumer editor Claer Barrett challenges Bobby Seagull, the TV star and mathematics teacher, to demonstrate how compounding can power up our long-term investments. 


    Tune in every Tuesday to catch the latest episode of The Five-Minute Investor, and subscribe to Money Clinic wherever you get your podcasts. If you would like Claer to demystify an investment term, email the team at money@ft.com or send Claer a DM on social media — she’s @ClaerB on Instagram and TikTok.


    Try out a compound interest calculator, and read more about INC and ACC funds.


    Take a look at MoneySavingExpert’s credit card minimum repayment calculator.


    For more tips on how to organise your money, sign up to Claer's email series 'Sort Your Financial Life Out With Claer Barrett' at FT.com/moneycourse


    Want more?


    Check out Claer’s column, Why do we think we can beat the market?


    Listen to Money Clinic’s Investment Masterclasses, such as An insider's view of the City of London, What’s one of the world’s leading investors buying?, and more.


    Presented by Claer Barrett. Produced by Tamara Kormornick. Our executive producer is Manuela Saragosa. Sound design by Breen Turner, with original music from Metaphor Music. Cheryl Brumley is the FT’s global head of audio.


    Disclaimer: The Money Clinic podcast is a general discussion about financial topics and does not constitute an investment recommendation or individual financial advice.


    Read a transcript of this episode on FT.com



    Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.


    The Five Minute Investor from Money Clinic: Are share buybacks good news for investors?

    The Five Minute Investor from Money Clinic: Are share buybacks good news for investors?

    Share buybacks have been in the news as Apple announced what would be the largest buyback in US history. But why is the US tech giant purchasing $110bn of its own shares, and cancelling them? In the latest episode of our Five Minute Investor miniseries, FT consumer editor Claer Barrett quizzes FT investment columnist Stuart Kirk on why more and more companies are doing this — and how investors can benefit. 


    Tune in every Tuesday to catch the latest episode of the Five Minute Investor, and subscribe to Money Clinic wherever you get your podcasts. If you would like Claer to demystify an investment term, email the team at money@ft.com or send Claer a DM on social media — she’s @ClaerB on Instagram and TikTok.


    For more tips on how to organise your money, sign up to Claer's email series 'Sort Your Financial Life Out With Claer Barrett' at FT.com/moneycourse


    Want more?

    Check out Claer’s column, Have you got five minutes to talk about investing?

    Read Stuart Kirk’s latest Skin in the Game column for free.

    Listen to Money Clinic’s Investment Masterclasses, such as Stuart Kirk has ‘skin in the game’, ‘Money is basically a fiction’, and more.


    Presented by Claer Barrett. Produced by Tamara Kormornick. Our executive producer is Manuela Saragosa. Sound design by Breen Turner, with original music from Metaphor Music. Cheryl Brumley is the FT’s global head of audio.


    Disclaimer: The Money Clinic podcast is a general discussion about financial topics and does not constitute an investment recommendation or individual financial advice.


    Read a transcript of this episode on FT.com



    Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.


    The Five Minute Investor from Money Clinic: Why liquidity matters for investors

    The Five Minute Investor from Money Clinic: Why liquidity matters for investors

    In the age of the smartphone, it’s never been easier to buy an investment — but how quickly can you sell one, and how might this affect the price? In our new miniseries, The Five Minute Investor, consumer editor Claer Barrett challenges investment commentator Justin Urquhart-Stewart to explain why liquidity should be at the forefront of every investor’s mind.


    Tune in every Tuesday to catch the latest episode of the Five Minute Investor, and subscribe to Money Clinic wherever you get your podcasts. If you would like Claer to demystify an investment term, email the team at money@ft.com or send Claer a DM on social media — she’s @ClaerB on Instagram and TikTok.


    For more tips on how to organise your money, sign up to Claer's email series 'Sort Your Financial Life Out With Claer Barrett' at FT.com/moneycourse


    Want more?

    Check out Claer’s column, Why do we think we can beat the market?

    Listen to Money Clinic’s Investment Masterclasses, such as An insider's view of the City of London with today’s guest Justin Urquart-Stewart, What’s one of the world’s leading investors buying?, and more.

    Presented by Claer Barrett. Produced by Tamara Kormornick. Our executive producer is Manuela Saragosa. Sound design by Breen Turner, with original music from Metaphor Music. Cheryl Brumley is the FT’s global head of audio.


    Disclaimer: The Money Clinic podcast is a general discussion about financial topics and does not constitute an investment recommendation or individual financial advice.


    Read a transcript of this episode on FT.com



    Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.


    Related Episodes

    Attracting IT talent to Ohio

    Attracting IT talent to Ohio

    Ohio is being considered for the site of a large new semiconductor factory outside Columbus and is already home to Amazon fulfillment centers and dozens of tech-based startups and organizations.

    Guest host Mike Kallmeyer speaks with Rep. Mark Fraizer (R-Newark), and other guests, to discuss technical talent attraction in Ohio and the climate that's been established to make Ohio friendly to workers in the ‘smart economy.’

    #22 - Chris Vigilante

    #22 - Chris Vigilante

    Millennial- Chris Vigilante is the owner and green coffee buyer of Vigilante Coffee Company. Chris breaks down his journey from working at a coffee shop in Hawaii, to a successful business owner. The greatest takeaway in this episode is that you may have more failures than successes, but if you're operating with passion and belief, you can ultimately achieve success and impact the world with an incredible curated coffee experience. Enjoy!

    #20 - Trey Sherman

    #20 - Trey Sherman

    Millennial- Trey Sherman is a Journalist, IG Storyteller and a YouTube Commentator. We get to the essence of how boomers and millennials think differently by virtue of the generational divide along with the technology effect. We talk about whether sexuality is determined by nature or nurture. We also talk about Trey's journey of being gay and the road that he has traveled. Funny, deep and insightful. Enjoy!

    #6 - Alicia Cameron - Parenting

    #6 - Alicia Cameron - Parenting

    Gen X- In this episode, we have Alicia Cameron in the studio. As a parent of a millennial and a Gen-Zer, Alicia brings a unique perspective of the difference in her parenting of her millennial vs her Gen-Zer. We talk about how she was raised as compared to how she raised (and raises) her kids now. We also talk about the heart-breaking trend of suicide among young people, why its happening and its relationship to social media. 
    Thought provoking and funny- Enjoy!

    #7 - Hans Colglazier - What the hell is Bitcoin and why Millennials aren't politically engaged.

    #7 - Hans Colglazier - What the hell is Bitcoin and why Millennials aren't politically engaged.

    Millennial - Hans is A cryptocurrency guru having been in the space for years. We talk about Bitcoin and blockchain technology generally and why it's worth investing. We talk about the concept of crypto and the investment opportunities on the horizon for the informed. We move to a discussion about the Millennial mindset today and their disdain for a 9-5 construct. We then end on a VERY heated discussion about climate change and why millennials don't believe the political system and the importance of voting.