Logo

    Part 2: The Racist Roots of NonProfits & Philanthropy w Christina Shimizu LIVE

    enJune 09, 2021
    What was the main topic of the podcast episode?
    Summarise the key points discussed in the episode?
    Were there any notable quotes or insights from the speakers?
    Which popular books were mentioned in this episode?
    Were there any points particularly controversial or thought-provoking discussed in the episode?
    Were any current events or trending topics addressed in the episode?

    About this Episode

    Episode Notes

    PLEASE listen to Part 1, which is S1:E7 which also has really great content! Part 2 is a continuation and includes great citations…here are some links...(and sign up for our mailing list for future updates):

    • Michelle talks with Christina Shimizu one of the co-founders of community centric fundraising
    • Chrissy work includes Seattle-based organizations like the Wing Luke Museum, Asian Pacific Americans for Civic Empowerment Votes, Chinatown International District Coalition, and she's been working with the Decriminalize Seattle Movement, the Afro-Socialist Defund Seattle Police Campaign. And she's now housed at Puget Sound Sage

    References: 

    "But whether the law be benign or not, we must say of it, as we say of the change in the conditions of men to which we have referred: It is here; we cannot evade it; no substitutes for it have been found; and while the law may be sometimes hard for the individual, it is best for the race because it insures the survival of the fittest in every department. We accept and welcome therefore, as conditions to which we must accommodate ourselves, great inequality of environment, the concentration of business, industrial and commercial in the hands of a few, and the law of competition between these as being not only beneficial, but essential for the future progress of the race."

    Okay and here is the old school definition for philanthropy in the same context:

    "It is a law, as certain as any of the others named, that men possessed of this peculiar talent for affair, under the free play of economic forces, must, of necessity, soon be in receipt of more revenue than can be judiciously expended upon themselves; and this law is as beneficial for the race as the others."

    • She talks about the rise in power of organized labor and mutual aid networks (1870s/1880s) and cites the Haymarket bombing (also called “affair” or “riot”)during the fight for the 10 hour workday

       
    • Fair Labor Standards Act of (she was right) 1938

       
    • Berkeley students help us wrap our monkey brains around the concept of a Billion

       
    • Consider: Philanthropy and nonprofits as: a political system, an economic system, a culturally informed system.

       
    • We discuss Amazon’s policy to penalize workers if they don’t work fast enough, and connect it to TER’s recent episode feat. Teddy Schleifer and how MacKenzie Scott (was Bezos) can’t give money away fast enough because of her investments (in Amazon and these extractive practices for ex) 

       
    • Donor Advised Funds. One day I’ll write an article about it but we discuss it here and in S2:E6 with Teddy Schleifer. Very important to learn about if you dunno…

       
    • Heather Infantry, and the TER episode Disrupting Your Community Foundation was named. She’s a badass and we are so appreciative of her work!

       
    • "We live in capitalism. Its power seems inescapable, but then so did the divine right of kings. Any human power can be resisted and changed by human beings. Resistance and change often begin in art. Very often in our art, the art of words." - Ursula LeGuin

       
    • Consider: Within our work, who are we investing in? “...when we dig into the actual complexities our communities, our networks will fall apart unless we trust and have genuine relationships with each other outside of work. So, are we investing in that?”

       
    • Things get heavy here, as we talk about the murder of Seattle resident Charleena Lyles, who was murdered, while pregnant, with three of her children home, by police. What is not covered in reports is the relationship to the nonprofit housing she was living in. 

    References from the Q&A:

    Need to know:

    NOTE: So we’re learning that this podcast is becoming part of university curriculum across the US and Canada! If you happen to be studying this episode, and want to either tell us about it (plz) or add more links related to this episode...email us! hello@theethicalrainmaker.com because if you are doing the research anyway… ;)

    We are self-funded. So. If you’d like to inspire this beautiful series through your financial contribution - we’ll take it on Patreon! 

    Subscribe to this podcast to get the best of what we have to offer. I promise there are more incredible episodes on their way - every other Wednesday.

    The Ethical Rainmaker is produced in Seattle, Washington by Isaac Kaplan-Woolner and Kasmira Hall, with socials by Rachelle Pierce. Michelle Shireen Muri is the executive producer and this pod is sponsored by 

    Freedom Conspiracy

    .

    Recent Episodes from The Ethical Rainmaker

    The Hidden Danger of Purity Culture, ft. Lorraine Nibut

    The Hidden Danger of Purity Culture, ft. Lorraine Nibut

    Juicy episode alert! Michelle and Lorraine break down many aspects of purity culture and how this form of supremacy and oppression — controls and dictates how we express ourselves, causing anguish and keeping us from our best work. From large breasts, to Honey Boo Boo, the Atlanta spa shooting and fetishization, the Fyre Festival  and consent violation ... Michelle and Lorraine explore the many ways purity culture holds us down — and what we can do to fight back against it! 

    Links:

    Check out Michelle's workshop collabs here: https://www.freedom-conspiracy.com/workshops--trainings.html

    Reach Lorraine Nibut here! https://www.linkedin.com/in/lorrainenibut/

    The Game defends his 12yo, cite 1 and cite 2

    Fyre Festival article and documentary

    Purity culture as motive for Atlanta spa shootings

    Here Comes Honey Boo Boo

    Lorraine's recommends: 

    + Present how you are most comfortable, unapologetically

    + Embrace your identities - own it and rise above the shamers

    + Speak your needs choose courage over comfort as courage can bring comfort

    + Express when something is uncomfortable for you

    + Face when your own discomfort is preventing you from your own success

    Why White People Have A Hard Time Being Real ft Fleur Larsen

    Why White People Have A Hard Time Being Real ft Fleur Larsen

    Fleur drops some knowledge especially for our white colleagues - for example "we can't move forward until  we've tended to what's occurred - most orgs need to do repair...not pretend that we can just move forward like nothing happened, you gotta try and see what happens." 

    Check out our new workshops just for you!

    Here are some of the resources she loves on this topic:
    + Generational Differences in Racial Equity Work by Dax-Devlon Ross
    + How to plan a White Caucus Agenda by Pippi Kessler
    + Racial Identity Caucusing: A Strategy for Building Anti-Racist Collectives by Crossroads
    + Why We're All Suffering from Racial Trauma (Even White People) -- and How to Handle It by Resmaa Menakem via Ten Percent Happier
    + A Call to White People: It's Time To Live In The Answer by Melia LaCour

    Oh and Doctors Without Borders recently set this example of truth telling!

    Patagonia did WHAT? ft Andy King

    Patagonia did WHAT? ft Andy King

    "If you're giving back, maybe you should just stop taking." Wow, so much to say about current events in the world of nonprofits and philanthropy including ridiculous claims and unethical, dishonest behavior from UK's famous BrewDog, dishonest partnership and tokenization at Forterra in Seattle, the relationship between extractive practices, power hoarding and Patagonia, and beloved Captain Tom and his daughter, mourning through greed! Show notes can be found at theethicalrainmaker.com

    Learn about upcoming collaborations between Michelle and guests like Andy King, Mallory Mitchell, Fleur Larsen, Rachel D'Souza-Siebert and more - at http://www.theethicalrainmaker.com/

     

     

    Are We Even Evaluating What Matters? ft Dr Marcia Coné

    Are We Even Evaluating What Matters? ft Dr Marcia Coné
    Traditional philanthropy has been asking nonprofits to jump through ridiculous and paternalistic hoops since its inception. But as movements like CCF require institutions to rethink how we do our work, we are not questioning our evaluation and metrics practices! In a world where tech money wants us to quantify our work, what is truly meaningful and how do we change!? Michelle talks with Marcia about Equitable Evaluation Framework and how our practices are so wrong and how to do better.