Logo
    Search

    Polls, Diane Abbott and Campaigning Tales... with Allan Faulds

    enMay 29, 2024

    Podcast Summary

    • Personalization in Healthcare and DietingPersonalization is crucial in healthcare and dieting as individual needs and situations vary. Flexible plans and customized approaches can lead to better outcomes.

      Personalization matters, whether it's in choosing the right health insurance coverage or losing weight through a customized diet plan. The discussion highlighted the importance of flexibility and individual needs in various aspects of life. In healthcare, UnitedHealthcare offers a range of plans to cater to different situations and requirements. Similarly, Noom's personalized approach to weight loss has helped people like Evan, who struggled with salads, achieve their goals. The Sleep Number smart bed also allows individuals to customize their comfort for better sleep. These examples illustrate that a one-size-fits-all approach may not always be effective or suitable, and personalization can lead to better outcomes.

    • Scottish Political Landscape ShiftsLabour is poised to win a significant number of seats in Scotland due to SNP's focus on independence and Tories' inability to use 'stand up for the union' narrative effectively. Labour needs to address pro-independence voters' concerns to solidify its position as a national party in Scotland.

      The political landscape in Scotland is undergoing significant shifts, with a clear trend towards change and a decline in support for the Scottish National Party (SNP) and Scottish Conservative Party (Tories). According to recent polling, Labour is set to win a significant number of seats in Scotland, with 36% of Scottish people intending to vote for them in the Westminster election. The SNP's support has dropped to 16%, and the Tories would only get 8 MPs. This trend is due in part to the SNP's focus on independence, which is no longer a priority issue for many voters. People are looking for change in the here and now, and Labour is positioning itself as the party that can deliver that. The Tories' inability to use the "stand up for the union" narrative effectively has also contributed to their decline in support. Labour is benefiting from the disaggregation of support for independence and political party, with many pro-independence voters shifting to Labour. However, if Labour truly aspires to be a national party of Scotland in the future, it may need to offer something on the constitution to appeal to the 45% of people who support independence. Enhanced devolution may be a more popular option than the status quo or independence, and Labour needs to read the signs and adapt accordingly.

    • Effective use of devolution in ScotlandDespite the desire for enhanced devolution, the current system isn't positively impacting people's lives. The Scottish government needs to focus on maximizing the use of existing powers and avoid getting bogged down in constitutional debates.

      While people in Scotland may desire enhanced devolution, the current system is not effectively translating into positive impacts on people's lives. There is a need for the Scottish government to focus on maximizing the use of the current powers instead of being bogged down in the constitutional debate. The approval ratings of political leaders, including John Swinney, Anas Sarwar, and Rishi Sunak, are not particularly impressive, with none of them having a net positive approval rating. Tactical voting is expected to play a significant role in the Westminster election, potentially helping Labour and the Lib Dems in certain constituencies, but making it difficult for the SNP in the central belt due to the presence of conservative voters. The lack of a constitutionally aligned but politically opposed government arrangement in Scotland has made it unclear what the exact limits of devolution are, adding to the complexity of the situation.

    • Scottish Politics ShiftPeople's political allegiances in Scotland are becoming more nuanced, with some voters prioritizing their immediate concerns and potential benefits over traditional unionist or nationalist views.

      The tribal nature of politics in Scotland, while still present, may not be as rigid as it once was. People's political allegiances are not solely based on unionist or nationalist views, but rather on what they believe will benefit them the most. Some voters may be willing to give Labour a chance despite their stance on Scottish independence, as they see potential influence and gains from being in the heart of the UK government. However, it's important to note that this doesn't necessarily mean the dream of independence has waned, but rather that people are prioritizing their immediate concerns, such as opposing the conservative government. The Scottish Labour argument of being in the heart of government to influence decisions is a compelling one for many voters. Ultimately, the election results may show a shift in voter priorities and a more nuanced approach to politics in Scotland.

    • Scottish Election CampaignSNP faces criticism for internal issues and lack of clear agenda, Scottish Conservatives lost first-mover advantage, Labour shows better organization and message discipline, John Swinney's unpopularity hinders SNP, outcome uncertain, parties need to address issues and offer compelling visions for Scotland's future

      The Scottish political landscape is witnessing an uninspiring start to the election campaign, with parties struggling to gain traction and make a substantial impact. The Scottish National Party (SNP) has faced criticism for its handling of internal issues and the lack of a clear agenda, while the Scottish Conservatives have lost their first-mover advantage. The Labour Party, on the other hand, has shown better organization and message discipline, capitalizing on the missteps of their opponents. John Swinney's unpopularity as SNP leader and the lack of a clear alternative have left voters disengaged. The SNP's avoidance of a leadership contest also hindered Swinney's ability to properly introduce himself as first minister to the public. The election's outcome remains uncertain, but it's clear that parties need to address these issues and offer compelling visions for Scotland's future to win over voters.

    • SNP, Labour internal issuesBoth SNP and Labour face internal challenges that could hinder their electoral success, with the SNP's poor election performance and ongoing issues, and Labour's controversial decision to bar Diane Abbott from standing as a candidate potentially alienating some supporters

      The SNP's potential poor election performance and the ongoing internal issues within the party could hinder their ability to enact change, while the Labour Party's decision to bar Diane Abbott from standing as a candidate has sparked controversy and could potentially impact their campaign in marginal seats. The Labour Party's stance on this issue may appeal to centrist voters but could also alienate some traditional Labour supporters, and the timing of the announcement seems unnecessary given the party's focus on other issues in the campaign. Overall, both parties face internal challenges that could impact their electoral success.

    • Campaign management mistakesMissteps and misjudgments in campaign management can significantly impact public perception and ultimately, election outcomes. Preparation, avoiding embarrassing media ops, and adapting to changing circumstances are crucial.

      Effective campaign management is crucial for political success. The discussion highlighted various instances of missteps and misjudgments in political campaigns, which can significantly impact public perception and ultimately, the election outcome. Jeff and Andy shared their personal experiences of campaigning, emphasizing the importance of being prepared, avoiding embarrassing media ops, and adapting to changing circumstances. Kat added to the conversation by discussing the challenges of door-knocking and the importance of understanding voters' preferences. The conversation also touched upon the significance of context and narrative in shaping public opinion. Despite the humor and light-hearted tone of the discussion, the underlying message was clear: campaign management matters, and even the smallest mistakes can have significant consequences.

    • Election Campaigns, PerceptionPoliticians' actions during election campaigns can be perceived differently based on the context and ongoing narratives. A gaffe that was seen positively in one campaign might be perceived negatively in another. Targeted policies and appealing to specific voter demographics can also impact election outcomes.

      The context of an election campaign can significantly impact how politicians' actions are perceived by the public. Using the example of Rishi Sunak's pie incident in 2011, it was seen as a light-hearted moment that helped humanize him at the time. However, in the current election campaign, a similar gaffe could be perceived negatively due to the ongoing narrative about Sunak being part of an out-of-touch elite. Another key point raised during the discussion was the importance of appealing to specific voter demographics and the potential impact of narrowing the gap between parties through targeted policies. Additionally, the polling data mentioned suggested that Labour's 12-point lead could be reduced if Sunak successfully courts the conservative vote with policies like the triple pension lock. Overall, the conversation highlighted the complex dynamics of election campaigns and the importance of understanding the context and nuances of political messaging.

    Recent Episodes from Holyrood Sources

    To Bet Or Not To Bet

    To Bet Or Not To Bet

    Labour leader Sir Keir Starmer says “the culture of politics" needs to change in light of the investigations into allegations of gambling on the general election from both Conservative and Labour figures. Calum, Geoff, Andy and Cat Headley discuss what can be done to address the relationship between politics and gambling, and whether anything should be done at all. 


    Plus, if IndyRef2 becomes a fading prospect, what is the point of the Scottish Conservatives? Who's had a good election campaign? And who's had a bad one? All in today's episode. 


    This episode is sponsored by Port of Aberdeen. Find out more at https://www.portofaberdeen.co.uk/

    Become a member at https://plus.acast.com/s/holyroodsources.



    Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.


    Holyrood Sources
    enJune 26, 2024

    Manifestos, Scottish Tories and should polling stop?

    Manifestos, Scottish Tories and should polling stop?
    We discuss the recent launch of the SNP manifesto for the upcoming general election. We explore the purpose of a manifesto in a general election and the tactics at play. Plus, we discuss the potential impact of the polls on the outcome of the election and the future of the Scottish Conservative Party. We take your questions on the achievements of the SNP at Westminster and the possibility of a leadership contest within the Scottish Conservatives.

    Become a member at https://plus.acast.com/s/holyroodsources.



    Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

    Holyrood Sources
    enJune 20, 2024

    Growing Scotland's Economy: Holyrood Sources Live

    Growing Scotland's Economy: Holyrood Sources Live

    We're diving deep into the various economic challenges and opportunities that lie ahead for Scotland.


    With:

    Kate Forbes MSP (SNP), Deputy First Minister and Cabinet Secretary for Economy and Gaelic.

    Murdo Fraser MSP (Conservative), Shadow Cabinet Secretary for Business, Economic Growth and Tourism.

    Michael Marra MSP (Labour), Shadow Cabinet Secretary for Finance.

    Willie Rennie MSP (Liberal Democrat), Spokesperson for Education, Economy and Communities.


    We'll be discussing key concerns raised by investors regarding infrastructure projects, planning, and the general business environment. Plus, we'll address the ambiguous terminology often used in policy-making, like the phrases "wellbeing economy" and "startup," which can hinder real progress. Our discussion today will also cover persistent issues of poverty and social mobility, the critical state of Scotland's education sector, the impact of Brexit on skilled workers, and the urgent need for immigration policies that support economic growth. We delve into the energy sector, focusing on offshore wind development, the fiscal constraints facing green prosperity plans, and the importance of a just transition from oil and gas to renewables. Moreover, we'll explore the impact of tax policies on the economy and public services, highlighting the need for a reevaluation of the taxation system to foster growth and retain talent.


    Holyrood Sources is sponsored by Port of Aberdeen, find out more at https://www.portofaberdeen.co.uk/


    This special episode is brought to you with our delivery partners, Scottish Financial Enterprise and in association with EY.

    Become a member at https://plus.acast.com/s/holyroodsources.



    Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.


    Holyrood Sources
    enJune 19, 2024

    The SNP/Labour Poll Gap Closes...with Emily Gray

    The SNP/Labour Poll Gap Closes...with Emily Gray

    Ipsos’ first Scotland poll since the General Election indicates the SNP and Labour in Scotland share 36% of the country's voting intention. Managing Director of Ipsos in Scotland, Emily Gray, joins the podcast to discuss what it means. Plus, after predicting it would happen, Calum, Andy and Geoff assess what next for the Scottish Conservatives after Douglas Ross announced he would stand down as leader.


    Become a member at https://plus.acast.com/s/holyroodsources.



    Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.


    Holyrood Sources
    enJune 12, 2024

    Douglas Ross U-Turns and will run to be an MP

    Douglas Ross U-Turns and will run to be an MP
    Douglas Ross has U-turned on a pledge to quit Westminster to focus on leading the Scottish Conservatives at Holyrood and will once again stand as a candidate at the general election. He will replace David Duguid, who was sacked last night as the candidate for Aberdeenshire North & Moray East because he suffered a serious spinal injury.

    Become a member at https://plus.acast.com/s/holyroodsources.



    Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

    Holyrood Sources
    enJune 06, 2024

    The Leaders Debate... We Discuss

    The Leaders Debate... We Discuss
    Calum, Geoff and Andy are joined by former Labour candidate Cat Headley to pick apart the key moments from last night's first television debate between Rishi Sunak and Keir Starmer. There was a lot of back and forth, and interrupting, but what cut through? Plus, Nigel Farage is back - so what does that mean for the Conservatives, or for the future of the of the Right of politics?

    Become a member at https://plus.acast.com/s/holyroodsources.



    Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

    Holyrood Sources
    enJune 05, 2024

    Deputy Leaders analyse the debates and campaign

    Deputy Leaders analyse the debates and campaign

    The podcast episode features post-debate analysis with the deputy leaders of Scottish political parties.


    Chapters

    5:05 - Jackie Baillie (Labour)

    The discussion covers the recent debate, party strategies, and key messages. It also delves into the topic of GB Energy and its potential impact on the energy sector. The conversation concludes with a discussion on Keir Starmer's U-turn on Diane Abbott's candidacy.


    23:02 - Kate Forbes (Deputy First Minister, SNP)

    The conversation covers party positioning, funding, oil and gas, campaign strategies, the SNP's election prospects, and EU funding. The discussion also delves into the SNP's economic policies, alliances with other parties, and the implications of Michael Matheson MSP maintaining the support of the party.


    49:55 - Meghan Gallacher (Conservative)

    The discussion delves into the performance of Douglas Ross, the Scottish Conservative Party's approach to campaign issues, and the impact of UK politics on the Scottish election. The conversation also explores the role of Rishi Sunak and the timing of the general election.


    1:05:17 - Wendy Chamberlain (Liberal Democrat)

    Wendy Chamberlain from the Liberal Democrats discusses the recent TV debate, the party's stance on Brexit, and their strategy for the upcoming election. The conversation also delves into the relevance of the Liberal Democrats in the current political landscape and their approach to environmental issues.

    Become a member at https://plus.acast.com/s/holyroodsources.



    Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.


    Holyrood Sources
    enJune 04, 2024

    Election Bulletin 1: What You Might Have Missed

    Election Bulletin 1: What You Might Have Missed
    Our first (maybe last, if you don't like it) Election Bulletin to catch you up on events from the week including: Michael Matheson, Diane Abbott, policy announcements and TikToks. Plus, Tales from the Campaign Trail where some of our journalist friends drop in to let us know how they're getting on. And we tell you what's on the agenda today.

    Become a member at https://plus.acast.com/s/holyroodsources.



    Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

    Holyrood Sources
    enMay 31, 2024

    Polls, Diane Abbott and Campaigning Tales... with Allan Faulds

    Polls, Diane Abbott and Campaigning Tales... with Allan Faulds
    Ballot Box's Allan Faulds and former Labour Scottish Parliamentary candidate Cat Headley join Calum, Geoff and Andy to pick apart what new polling, the treatment of Dianne Abbott by the Labour party and also reflect on some of their favourite (or not-so-favourite) memories of being on the campaign trail.

    Become a member at https://plus.acast.com/s/holyroodsources.



    Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

    Holyrood Sources
    enMay 29, 2024