Logo
    Search

    ‘Rankly Unfit’: The View From a Republican Who Voted to Impeach

    enJanuary 15, 2021

    Podcast Summary

    • Michigan Representative Peter Meyer's Hopeful Start in CongressDespite a chaotic start, Rep. Peter Meyer entered Congress with a hopeful, bipartisan mindset, but the attack on the Capitol tested his ability to work in a divided Congress.

      Despite the chaotic start to his congressional career, Representative Peter Meyer of Michigan entered the House with a hopeful and bipartisan mindset. During his swearing-in on January 3rd, he felt optimistic about the diverse freshman class and the potential for collaboration on issues like winding down conflicts and combating climate change. He believed in building bridges across the aisle and working on substantive policy issues. However, the unexpected events of the following week, including the attack on the Capitol, drastically changed the political landscape and tested his ability to work in a divided Congress.

    • Disconnect between public sphere and Congress during election certificationDuring the 2021 presidential election certification process, some Republicans raised objections based on constitutional interpretations, while others were influenced by conspiracy theories and political pressure. This disconnect underscores the need for accurate information and nuanced discussions in politics.

      During the presidential election certification process on January 6, 2021, there existed a significant disconnect between the discourse in the public sphere and the more nuanced discussions taking place in Congress. While some Republicans raised objections based on constitutional interpretations, many of their constituents and the president himself promoted conspiracy theories claiming widespread electoral fraud. Some Republicans may have held these objections genuinely, but there was also significant political pressure to do so. This disconnect highlights the importance of factual information and nuanced understanding in political discourse.

    • Political Pressure and Election Fraud ClaimsThe 2020 election process faced intense political pressure due to mail-in voting concerns and widespread fraud claims, which put immense pressure on some politicians to object to electoral college certification, fearing backlash from constituents.

      The events leading up to January 6th, 2021, were marked by intense political pressure and widespread claims of election fraud. Many Republicans in Congress were concerned about the process of mail-in voting during the pandemic, but their concerns were often interpreted by their constituents as evidence of a massive fraud. These claims, fueled by then-President Trump, put immense pressure on these politicians to object to the certification of the electoral college results. Some feared primaries or even physical harm if they didn't align with the president's position. The speaker expresses their belief that many of these colleagues knew their stance would be perceived as endorsing a stolen election. This complex web of pressure and perception ultimately contributed to the tense atmosphere that culminated in the Capitol insurrection.

    • Congressman X's Unexpected Day of Certifying Electoral VotesOn January 6, 2021, Congressman X expected a long day of certifying electoral votes, but the day took an unexpected turn when the Capitol was attacked, forcing him to evacuate and reflect on the significance of his vote for Joe Biden's certification.

      On January 6, 2021, Congressman X was prepared for a long day of certifying electoral college votes, unaware of the impending violence at the Capitol. He spent the morning reassuring constituents and preparing for a potential all-nighter in his office. However, the situation quickly escalated as challenges to the electoral college results began, and the Congressman received word that the Capitol was under siege. He and his colleague were ordered to evacuate, escaping through an elevator to safety. Despite the uncertainty and danger of the day, the Congressman had initially believed his vote for Joe Biden's certification could end his career, but the events of January 6th proved to be far more significant and unpredictable.

    • Lawmakers Faced Danger Amid Capitol AttackAmidst the Capitol attack, lawmakers remained calm, stayed together, and showed leadership despite facing threats and uncertainty.

      During the Capitol attack, a group of lawmakers found themselves in a dangerous and uncertain situation, with no weapons and facing the possibility of encountering an angry mob. They stayed calm, reassured each other, and stuck together. The fear of violence was heightened due to death threats and harassment some lawmakers had already received due to their votes to certify the election results. The question of the President's role in the attack was starting to be considered, with some already drafting articles of impeachment. The President's speech and subsequent video message during the attack were seen as encouraging the protesters and failing to provide visible leadership.

    • The president's response during the certification of the 2020 election results left a deep impact on those present.The president's failure to assert law and order during the Capitol chaos left a lasting negative impact on his legacy.

      During the certification of the 2020 presidential election results, the events at the Capitol on January 6, 2021, left a deep impact on those present. In that chaotic moment when the country was glued to their screens watching the violence unfold, the president's response was seen as a missed opportunity to assert law and order and put an end to the chaos. The images from that day erased any favorable comments the president could have made in history books. Some Republican colleagues did change their minds, but not many did. The dissonance between giving the same speech while a crime scene was ongoing was staggering. Despite the disappointment and anger felt, there was a sense of pride that the constitutional process was not disrupted.

    • Congressman Tom Malinowski's Experience on January 6, 2021Despite initial hesitation, Congressman Tom Malinowski felt compelled to support impeachment after witnessing the chaos at the Capitol and feeling a strong sense of anger towards the President's actions.

      During the events of January 6, 2021, Congressman Tom Malinowski found himself in the midst of a chaotic situation at the Capitol. He witnessed broken windows and an active crime scene, and was unable to take the elevator due to the ongoing investigation. As the day wore on, the focus shifted to the question of impeachment, and Malinowski shared his feelings of being "fucking livid" about the President's actions. Despite his strong stance, he waited for leadership to take accountability and initiate the impeachment process. The process was unprecedented, and Malinowski, along with other colleagues, worked to understand the implications and consider all angles. The lack of sleep and food, and the sickening feeling of the situation, ultimately led him to the decision that he couldn't convince himself to wait any longer.

    • Accountability paves way for unityAccountability for unconscionable actions is crucial for achieving unity, as it addresses divisive issues and allows for healing and moving forward.

      Accountability and unity are interconnected. The speaker, a congressperson, shares their struggle with deciding whether to vote for impeachment or not. They respected their colleagues' viewpoints but ultimately believed that accountability for unconscionable actions was necessary before unity could be achieved. The congressperson also reflected on historical precedents, such as Gerald Ford's pardon of Richard Nixon, and how accountability paved the way for healing and moving forward. They emphasized the importance of addressing divisive issues head-on and acknowledged the pain that comes with introspection. In essence, the speaker believed that accountability was a crucial step towards unity and preventing deeper issues from festering in the future.

    • Reflecting on our role in the current political climateLeaders must reflect honestly on their actions, acknowledge potential contributions to division, and work towards unity by reaching out to those feeling alienated and sharing facts.

      It's essential for individuals, especially those in positions of power, to reflect on their role in the current political climate and acknowledge any potential contributions to the division and distrust in American democracy. The speaker emphasizes the importance of honest self-reflection, particularly regarding the election results, and expresses concern for those who have been misled by leaders who have betrayed their trust. He believes that reaching out to those who feel alienated and working towards a shared set of facts is crucial for unity and healing. The speaker also highlights the issue of misleading fundraising and legal challenges, but ultimately, his focus is on the responsibility of leaders to avoid deceiving their followers.

    • Political Climate Puts Politicians and Families at RiskDeep-seated divisions and cynicism have led to threats and calls for violence against politicians, putting their safety and their families at risk. True patriotism lies in standing firm for the constitution and oath of office, despite the risks.

      The current political climate in the United States has reached a critical point where the safety and security of politicians and their families are at risk due to deep-seated divisions and cynicism. This was highlighted during the certification of the presidential election results, with some politicians receiving threats and even calls for violence. The consequences of these divisions are severe, as the FBI has identified the homes of congresspeople as potential targets. This situation is alarming, and it underscores the importance of fostering unity and trust in institutions. The small number of politicians who have stood firm in their commitment to the constitution and their oath of office, despite the risks, serve as examples of true patriotism. It's crucial that we recognize the value of these individuals and work towards healing the deep-rooted divisions within our society.

    • Republican Party: Accountability, Trust, and Foundational PrinciplesCongressman Guest calls for the GOP to prioritize accountability, rebuild trust, and uphold principles to sustain the party, addressing internal challenges and external crises.

      Congressman Michael Guest expressed his desire for the Republican Party to prioritize accountability, rebuild trust with its supporters, and uphold foundational principles to ensure long-term sustainability. The party faces internal challenges, including holding those responsible for the Capitol attack accountable and addressing crises in areas like the economy and public health. The US Capitol Police are under investigation for their conduct during the riot, and the Biden administration has proposed a $1.9 trillion relief package to combat the ongoing economic and health crises. Guest emphasized his commitment to fighting for the party's improvement and ensuring it remains relevant for the future.

    Recent Episodes from The Daily

    The Lingering Questions about the Attempt to Kill Trump

    The Lingering Questions about the Attempt to Kill Trump

    In the week since the assassination attempt on Donald Trump, the security mistakes that led to the shooting have come into sharp focus, prompting Kimberly Cheatle, the head of the Secret Service, to resign.

    Glenn Thrush, who reports on the Justice Department for The Times, discusses what we now know about the service’s lapses that day.

    Guest: Glenn Thrush, a reporter on the Justice Department for The New York Times.

    Background reading: 

    For more information on today’s episode, visit nytimes.com/thedaily. Transcripts of each episode will be made available by the next workday.

    The Daily
    enJuly 24, 2024

    The New Hope, and New Worry, of Kamala Harris

    The New Hope, and New Worry, of Kamala Harris

    As Democrat after Democrat races to anoint Vice President Kamala Harris as their party’s presidential candidate, it has become clear that she will face no real challenge for the nomination.

    Nate Cohn, chief political analyst for The Times, and Reid J. Epstein, a Times reporter covering politics, discuss what that smooth path for Ms. Harris could mean for her broader campaign.

    Guest: 

    • Nate Cohn, the chief political analyst for The New York Times.
    • Reid J. Epstein, who covers politics for The New York Times.

    Background reading: 

    For more information on today’s episode, visit nytimes.com/thedaily. Transcripts of each episode will be made available by the next workday.

    The Daily
    enJuly 23, 2024

    Joe Biden Drops Out

    Joe Biden Drops Out

    President Biden has dropped out of the 2024 presidential race and endorsed his vice president, Kamala Harris, as his replacement.

    Peter Baker, the chief White House correspondent for The New York Times, discusses how the race for the White House has suddenly been turned upside down.

    Guest: Peter Baker, the chief White House correspondent for The New York Times.

    Background reading: 

    For more information on today’s episode, visit nytimes.com/thedaily. Transcripts of each episode will be made available by the next workday.

    The Daily
    enJuly 22, 2024

    Sunday Special: The 100 Best Books of the Century (So Far)

    Sunday Special: The 100 Best Books of the Century (So Far)

    Earlier this month, the New York Times Book Review rolled out the results of an ambitious survey it conducted to determine the best books of the 21st century so far. On this special episode of the Book Review Podcast, host Gilbert Cruz chats with some fellow Book Review editors about the results of that survey and about the project itself.

    To read the full list, please visit: https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2024/books/best-books-21st-century.html

    For more episodes, search “Book Review podcast” wherever you get your podcasts, and follow the show.

    At the Republican Convention, Trump Achieves Mythical Status

    At the Republican Convention, Trump Achieves Mythical Status

    Donald J. Trump’s acceptance of his party’s nomination put an exclamation point on a triumphant week for a Republican Party that emerged from its convention confident and unified. At the same time, the Democratic Party is moving closer and closer to replacing President Biden on the ticket.

    Jonathan Swan, who covers Mr. Trump’s presidential campaign, gives a behind-the-scenes look at the Republican National Convention, and Reid J. Epstein, who covers Mr. Biden’s re-election campaign, discusses where it stands as expectations are rising among Democrats that the president will reconsider his decision to stay in the race.

    Guest: 

    • Reid J. Epstein, a reporter covering politics for The New York Times.
    • Jonathan Swan, a reporter covering politics and Donald Trump’s presidential campaign for The New York Times.

    Background reading: 

    For more information on today’s episode, visit nytimes.com/thedaily. Transcripts of each episode will be made available by the next workday. 

    The Daily
    enJuly 19, 2024

    Trump 2.0: He’s Never Sounded Like This Before

    Trump 2.0: He’s Never Sounded Like This Before

    In a special series leading up to Election Day, “The Daily” will explore what a second Trump presidency would look like, and what it could mean for American democracy.

    Since he began his latest campaign, former President Donald J. Trump’s message has changed, becoming darker, angrier and more focused on those out to get him than it ever was before.

    Charles Homans, who covers national politics for The Times, has been studying the evolution of Mr. Trump’s message, and what exactly it means to his supporters and for the country.

    Guest: Charles Homans, who covers national politics for The New York Times.

    Background reading: 

    For more information on today’s episode, visit nytimes.com/thedaily. Transcripts of each episode will be made available by the next workday.

    The Daily
    enJuly 18, 2024

    The Surprise Ending to the Mar-a-Lago Documents Case

    The Surprise Ending to the Mar-a-Lago Documents Case

    As the Republican National Convention entered its second day, former President Donald J. Trump and his allies absorbed the stunning new reality that the most formidable legal case against him had been thrown out by a federal judge, who ruled that the appointment of the special counsel who brought the case, Jack Smith, had violated the Constitution. 

    Alan Feuer, who has been covering the classified documents case for The Times, explains what it means that the case could now be dead.

    Guest: Alan Feuer, a reporter covering extremism and political violence for The New York Times.

    Background reading: 

    For more information on today’s episode, visit nytimes.com/thedaily. Transcripts of each episode will be made available by the next workday. 

    The Daily
    enJuly 17, 2024

    Trump Picks His Running Mate — and Political Heir

    Trump Picks His Running Mate — and Political Heir

    On the first day of the Republican National Convention, Donald J. Trump chose his running mate: Senator J.D. Vance of Ohio.

    We watched the process unfold in real time in Milwaukee.

    Michael C. Bender, who covers Mr. Trump and his movement for The Times, takes us through the day.

    Guest: Michael C. Bender, a political correspondent covering Donald J. Trump and his Make America Great Again movement for The New York Times.

    Background reading: 

    For more information on today’s episode, visit nytimes.com/thedaily. Transcripts of each episode will be made available by the next workday. 

    The Daily
    enJuly 16, 2024

    The Attempted Assassination of Donald Trump

    The Attempted Assassination of Donald Trump

    Today’s episode sets out what we know about the attempted assassination of former President Donald J. Trump at a rally in Pennsylvania on Saturday evening.

    Doug Mills, a photographer for The Times, recounts what it was like to witness the shooting, and Glenn Thrush, who covers gun violence for The Times, discusses the state of the investigation into the man who did it.

    Guest: 

    • Doug Mills, a photographer in the Washington bureau of The New York Times.
    • Glenn Thrush, who reports on the Justice Department for The New York Times.

    Background reading: 

    For more information on today’s episode, visit nytimes.com/thedaily. Transcripts of each episode will be made available by the next workday.

    The Daily
    enJuly 15, 2024

    Related Episodes

    A Braver Story: The Braver Angels Story of American Citizenship

    A Braver Story: The Braver Angels Story of American Citizenship

    The occasion is piled high with difficulty, and we must rise with the occasion. —Abraham Lincoln.

    This episodes tells the story of one group of people who have risen.

    Built by patriotic volunteers, Braver Angels is a national movement to bridge the partisan divide, equally balanced between conservatives and progressives at every level of leadership. They work in communities, on college campuses, in the media, and in the halls of political power. We’ll offer up a behind the scenes view of this extraordinary group of Americans—how they formed, what they’ve learned and what’s next.

    Find bios for our participants and a full program description online here.

    We hope you’ll join us as we explore what happens when people of goodwill who might not agree cross each others’ thresholds and break a little bread together. Whoever you are, whatever your beliefs, bring an open mind, an open heart (and an empty stomach) for a continuing conversation on the two topics your mother taught you to never broach in polite company: politics and religion. We can’t wait.

    Funding for this program was provided through a grant from Florida Humanities with funds from the National Endowment for the Humanities.

    The Village Square is a proud member of The Democracy Group, a network of podcasts that examines what's broken in our democracy and how we can work together to fix it.

     

    TP&R Feed Drop | Tim Keller and Michael Gerson, A Tribute with Pete Wehner and Jonathan Rauch

    TP&R Feed Drop | Tim Keller and Michael Gerson, A Tribute with Pete Wehner and Jonathan Rauch

    The Village Square is truly delighted to offer you a feed drop episode of Talkin' Politics & Religion Without Killin' Each Other—a podcast we loved so much, we convinced its host to also be our host (that's fandom). Along with Village SquareCast, TP&R is also a proud member of The Democracy Group, a network of podcasts that examines what's broken in our democracy and how we can work together to fix it.

    Listen to TP&R Here.  

    This episode, Tim Keller and Michael Gerson, A Tribute with Pete Wehner and Jonathan Rauch, is the most beautiful hour in the history of podcasting, in our highly informed opinion (culled from zero statistics and study... we just know). Please, whatever you do, listen—and share. Along with host Corey Nathan, Jon and Pete (both former Village Square in-person guests) zero in on the generosity of spirit that could—and should—transform everything about the world today. If we can only let it. Here's Pete, toward the end, about Tim and Michael, the gentlemen they give tribute to:

    "it's whether in discourse and conversations we can together refine each others' views, calibrate each others' views... and come closer to the true reality of things than we would without each other."

    We beseech you, please listen, and then subscribe to Corey's beautiful podcast, Talkin' Politics & Religion Without Killin' Each Other. You're going to thank yourself for doing something so very smart.

    Village SquareCast will be back with brand new episodes of Village SquareCast this fall. Like crazy soon.  

    “Go Big or Lose Small.”

    “Go Big or Lose Small.”

    Senate Republicans seem likely to exonerate the man who incited a mob that almost killed them, and our new Crooked Media/Change Research Pollercoaster series shows that Joe Biden’s agenda is extremely popular and MAGA media continues to radicalize its audience. Then Ezra Klein of The New York Times talks to Jon about ending the filibuster and the future of democracy.

    Let's Gossip! S02 E04

    Let's Gossip! S02 E04

    Gossip is not just a guilty pleasure it is much more dangerous than that. Gossip is extremely harmful and destructive. So in today's episode, we are going to talk about what gossip is, why we enjoy gossip, what are the effects of gossip, and how do you handle gossip in a healthy way.

    Follow me on Instagram, FB, or Twitter @michaelscarlton https://solo.to/michaelscarlton

    Let's Gossip! S02 E04

    Let's Gossip! S02 E04

    Gossip is not just a guilty pleasure it is much more dangerous than that. Gossip is extremely harmful and destructive. So in today's episode, we are going to talk about what gossip is, why we enjoy gossip, what are the effects of gossip, and how do you handle gossip in a healthy way.

    Follow me on Instagram, FB, or Twitter @michaelscarlton https://solo.to/michaelscarlton