Logo
    Search

    The great private school con | Audio Long Reads

    enNovember 11, 2023

    Podcast Summary

    • Companies Prioritizing Quality and Customer Experience: Blue Nile and BurrowBlue Nile offers high-quality lab-grown diamonds and excellent customer service, while Burrow creates modular furniture that lasts and offers convenient shipping and discounts.

      Both Blue Nile and Burrow are companies focused on providing high-quality products and excellent customer experiences. Blue Nile offers beautiful lab-grown diamonds that are identical to natural diamonds, while Burrow creates modular furniture designed to last and grow with you. Both companies prioritize their customers, offering convenient shipping options and discounts. The New Statesman's Audio Long Reads is coming to an end, but listeners can look forward to new projects, including the fourth series of Westminster Reimagined. In The Great Private School Con, Melissa Deems explores the tradition of private schools selling the promise of privilege being passed down through generations. However, changes such as a potential Labour government and shifting university admissions trends may challenge this long-standing tradition.

    • Private schools in England adapt to challengesPrivate schools remain dedicated to providing quality education, exploring ways to cope with rising costs, and focusing on producing well-rounded individuals to maintain their appeal and relevance in a changing educational landscape.

      Despite the challenges posed by changes in education policies and societal shifts towards greater equality, England's exclusive private schools remain committed to their core promise: investing in a child's education leads to success. These schools are exploring various ways to cope with increased costs, such as passing the burden onto parents, selling off assets, or expanding overseas. However, their ultimate goal is to convince parents that they can still buy a privileged future for their children, despite growing competition from state schools and increasing financial barriers for many families. Schools are also focusing on producing well-rounded individuals who will make a positive impact on society, rather than just securing top university placements or high-paying jobs. The biggest concern for private schools is losing the middle tier of parents, who are crucial for maintaining a diverse student body. The schools are aware of the potential cultural shift and the possibility of a labor government with fewer privately educated ministers, and they are working to remain an aspirational choice for families.

    • The Future of Private Schools in the UK: Controversy and DebateDespite criticisms, private schools continue to thrive, with calls for reform giving way to less radical proposals. Critics argue from ideology and envy, while larger issues like teacher shortages and technology integration remain pressing concerns. A clear, consistent education policy prioritizing student needs is needed.

      The debate surrounding the role and future of private schools in the UK education system continues to be a contentious issue. Despite criticisms and calls for reform or abolition, private schools have endured, with public opinion generally favoring their preservation. The left's belief in the irrelevance of private schools gave way to less radical proposals, such as state assistance. Critics argue that the opposition to private schools stems from ideology and envy, rather than a genuine commitment to improving social mobility. Recent discussions have centered around the charitable status, tax exemptions, and the need for a coherent, long-term education policy. However, larger issues, such as teacher shortages and the lack of integration with technology, may be more pressing concerns. Regardless of political leanings, there is a need for a clear, consistent approach to education policy that prioritizes the needs of students over political agendas.

    • Private schools' tax benefits and their impact on educational equityPrivate schools receive substantial tax exemptions, costing the government £3 billion a year, which could be used to increase funding for state schools and other public services, reducing the educational divide between private and state schools.

      The existence and tax benefits of private schools in the UK raise significant questions about educational equity and the use of public funds. The Institute of Fiscal Studies reported that the gap between private school fees and state school spending per pupil has widened, with private school fees being 90% higher than state school spending in 2020. While some argue that private schools provide a social good by reducing pressure on the state system and partnering with less fortunate schools, they also receive substantial tax exemptions, costing the government an estimated £3 billion a year. This money could be used to significantly increase funding for state schools and other public services. The taxpayer effectively subsidizes private school education through these exemptions. The issue of private schools' charitable status and their place in the culture is becoming increasingly debated, with a majority of respondents in a poll supporting the end of charitable status for private schools. The educational opportunities and resources available to students in private schools are vastly different from those in state schools, creating a significant divide, especially at the elite level.

    • Private schools prioritize diversity and inclusionPrivate schools are adapting to societal changes by promoting diversity, preparing students for the real world, and prioritizing mental health support.

      Private schools, once known for their exclusivity, are now embracing diversity and inclusion in response to societal changes. This shift was evident at a conference attended by 22 schools last October, where they discussed creating inclusive communities and civil discourse. However, some critics argue that social justice and privilege don't mix. Schools are now focusing on preparing students for the real world by involving them in community projects and mentoring state school children. Mental health support is also becoming a priority, with some elite schools offering on-site counselors and well-being centers. Despite these efforts, concerns remain about the potential for creating a bubble that isolates students from the wider community. The debate continues on whether private schools can truly balance their privileged status with the need for social justice and compassion.

    • The issue of accessibility and affordability for less privileged families in private schoolsPrivate schools offer means-tested bursaries but eligibility criteria and financial thresholds can be exclusive, leaving less privileged families behind. The closure of smaller, underserved schools could have unintended consequences for educational equality.

      While diversity and inclusion may not be the top priority for some parents in expensive private schools due to their focus on smaller class sizes, well-equipped facilities, and academic advantages, the issue of accessibility and affordability for less privileged families remains a significant concern. Private schools often justify their charitable status by offering means-tested bursaries, but the eligibility criteria and financial thresholds can be exclusive. The closure of smaller, underserved schools could lead to a generational opportunity to rebalance inequality or a miscalculation, as there is little evidence that higher fees will cause a mass exodus to the state sector. The education system's divide between private and state schools raises questions about equity and fairness, with the benefits of private education often coming at a steep cost.

    • The Debate Over Private Education and Tax Breaks in the UKLabour's proposal to change private schools' tax status faces opposition, while some call for a more radical reimagining of education for all.

      The debate surrounding private education in the UK, particularly the charitable status and funding of private schools, continues to be a contentious issue. The Institute of Financial Studies estimates that up to 37% of students attend private schools at a cost of over £100 billion, which could be used to improve state schools instead. Labour's Shadow Education Secretary, Bridget Phillipson, has criticized the continued tax breaks for private schools, earning her disdain from the Independent Schools Council. Private schools, facing potential tax changes, are adapting by exploring new charitable foundations and expanding internationally. Some argue that Labour's approach lacks vision, with a focus on lifting tax exemptions rather than integrating state and private schools or promoting more vocational education. The Dutch principal of Liverpool College, Hans Broekman, calls for a more radical reimagining of education for everyone. Ultimately, the issue raises questions about the role of privilege and social segregation in education and the responsibility of the government to ensure equitable access to quality education for all.

    • Private schools sell a timeless imagePrivate schools market consistency as a valuable asset, while companies like UnitedHealthcare and 1800flowers.com offer essential services and care in changing times

      Private schools sell a sense of timelessness and insulation from change. During their autumn open days, they showcase old footage and traditions, emphasizing their love for their school motto and values. This reassuring sense of consistency is marketed as a golden ticket to the future, despite being rooted in an unequal past that many would prefer to leave behind. Meanwhile, companies like UnitedHealthcare offer supplementary health insurance plans to help individuals manage out-of-pocket costs, providing an essential service in the face of increasing healthcare expenses. Similarly, 1800flowers.com goes above and beyond in helping people celebrate life's special occasions, putting heart and care into every product and service they offer.

    Recent Episodes from The New Statesman Podcast

    The race to cervical cancer elimination | Sponsored

    The race to cervical cancer elimination | Sponsored

    Cervical cancer is the fourth most common cancer in women globally. It causes more than 800 deaths in the UK each year.

     

    Yet 99.8% of cervical cancer cases are entirely preventable. Regular screening and the introduction of the Human Papillomavirus (HPV) vaccination are helping to reduce the number of deaths. With smart policy and public health interventions NHS England have set 2040 as the target date for total elimination of cervical cancer.

     

    If that goal is to be met the issue of health inequality needs to be addressed; currently screening and vaccination rates vary between different regions, communities and socio-economic groups.

     

    So what needs to be done to share best practice and narrow these inequalities?

     

    In this episode of Spotlight on Policy, host Zoe Grunwald is joined by Emma Cerrone, Business Unit Director for Public Health & Vaccines at MSD; Dr Adeola Olaitan, Honorary Associate Professor at University College London and Honorary Consultant Gynaecological Oncologist at UCLH; and Gayathri Kumar, Senior Economist at OHE, the Office for Health Economics.

     

    This episode has been fully funded by MSD who, as sponsors, have reviewed and inputted to the final content. The report referenced by Office for Health Economics throughout this episode was fully funded by MSD. Ultimate editorial control for this episode and the OHE report rests solely with the New Statesman and the Office for Health Economics, respectively. MSD is one of the world’s leading pharmaceutical companies active in several key areas of global health, including immunisation and oncology.



    Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

    What's happening in Northern Ireland? and should polling be banned?

    What's happening in Northern Ireland? and should polling be banned?

    It's listener question time! Freddie Hayward, political correspondent, is joined by Finn McRedmond, junior commissioning editor and writer, to answer questions on Northern Ireland, personal approval ratings, presidential debates, and polling influence.


    Sign up to the New Statesman's daily politics newsletter: Morning Call

     

    Submit a question for a future episode: You Ask Us



    Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.


    On the road with Corbyn, Farage, and Lammy

    On the road with Corbyn, Farage, and Lammy

    Today New Statesman is publishing an election special issue of the magazine which includes our election endorsement as well as in-depth political interviews with Jeremy Corbyn, Nigel Farage, and David Lammy.


    Rachel Cunliffe, associate political editor, is joined in the studio by George Eaton, senior editor, and editor-in-chief Jason Cowley.


    Sign up to the New Statesman's daily politics newsletter: Morning Call

     

    Submit a question for a future episode: You Ask Us



    Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.


    Up all night to Bet Lucky

    Up all night to Bet Lucky

    Another day, another flurry of betting allegations. More and more parties are now being dragged into the gambling scandal, but should we discern some distinction between the nature of these bets and their repercussions?


    Hannah Barnes, associate editor, is joined by Freddie Hayward, political correspondent, and Ben Walker, senior data journalist.


    Sign up to the New Statesman's daily politics newsletter: Morning Call

     

    Submit a question for a future episode: You Ask Us



    Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.


    Andrew Marr: "If I were Sunak, I'd be wailing under the table"

    Andrew Marr: "If I were Sunak, I'd be wailing under the table"

    Everything's been going so badly for the prime minister, one can't help but admire the fact that he's carrying on.


    Hannah Barnes, associate editor, is joined by Andrew Marr, political editor, to discuss the developments in the betting scandal, how Nigel Reform lost the right, and why Labour failed to win over the Murdoch empire.


    Sign up to the New Statesman's daily politics newsletter: Morning Call

     

    Submit a question for a future episode: You Ask Us



    Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.


    Is GamblingGate the new PartyGate?

    Is GamblingGate the new PartyGate?

    We’re in the penultimate week of campaigning, which may come as a relief to those suffering from election fatigue - maybe no one more so than Rishi Sunak. The prime minister has not had a particularly smooth weekend as the Tory betting scandal continues to rumble on …


    Hannah Barnes, associate editor, is joined by George Eaton, senior editor, to discuss the latest developments in the gambling scandal, Labour's positions gender recognition and their plans for the House of Lords.


    Sign up to the New Statesman's daily politics newsletter: Morning Call

     

    Submit a question for a future episode: You Ask Us



    Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.


    Rishi Sunak is campaigning through gritted teeth

    Rishi Sunak is campaigning through gritted teeth

    We were bestowed yet another leadership TV special last night, Ed Davey said sorry for tuition fees, Rishi Sunak said sorry for Liz Truss, and Keir Starmer said sorry for Jeremy Corbyn. But one unmissable feature of the night was the grimace on the prime ministers face as the impassioned audience put their questions to him.


    Rachel Cunliffe, associate political editor, is joined by Freddie Hayward, political correspondent to discuss the TV special and to answer listener questions.


    Sign up to the New Statesman's daily politics newsletter: Morning Call

     

    Submit a question for a future episode: You Ask Us




    Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.


    Stop The Bets!

    Stop The Bets!

    The Tory gambling scandal respawned last night when it was revealed that a met officer working in Rishi Sunak's protection team had been arrested over alleged bets, and also being looked into by the Gambling Commission is Laura Saunders - a Conservative candidate who happens to be married to the director of campaigns in CCHQ.


    The team also discuss the three polls published last night; while the predictions may differ, all roads lead to disaster for the Conservatives.


    Hannah Barnes, associate editor, is joined by Rachel Cunliffe, associate political editor, and Freddie Hayward, political correspondent.


    Sign up to the New Statesman's daily politics newsletter: Morning Call

     

    Submit a question for a future episode: You Ask Us




    Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.


    Is there still momentum for Scottish independence?

    Is there still momentum for Scottish independence?

    "Vote SNP for Scotland to become an independent country" - bold letters shout from the first page of the SNP manifesto. But is there still momentum for independence in Scotland? And what else is John Swinney pledging in his fight to retain seats from the hands of Scottish Labour.


    Hannah Barnes, associate editor, is joined by Chris Deerin, Scotland editor, and Ben Walker, senior data journalist.


    Sign up to the New Statesman's daily politics newsletter: Morning Call

     

    Submit a question for a future episode: You Ask Us



    Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.


    Andrew Marr: Labour must prepare for the turning tide

    Andrew Marr: Labour must prepare for the turning tide

    Labour are set to win a majority, if not a supermajority, but in these politically fragmented times will people who vote for the party necessarily stay loyal in their support after July the fifth?

     

    Hannah Barnes, associate editor, is joined by political editor Andrew Marr to discuss the changing political tides, Starmer's continued struggle with tax and Corbyn, and the potential return of Boris Johnson.

     

    Register to vote: https://www.gov.uk/register-to-vote

     

    Sign up to the New Statesman's daily politics newsletter: Morning Call

     

    Submit a question for a future episode: You Ask Us



    Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

    Related Episodes

    #602 - BERT KREISCHER + WHITNEY CUMMINGS + JIM NORTON

    #602 - BERT KREISCHER + WHITNEY CUMMINGS + JIM NORTON
    Bert Kreischer, Whitney Cummings, Jim Norton, Paul Deemer, D Madness, Michael A. Gonzales, Hans Kim, David Lucas, William Montgomery, John Deas, Jules Durel, Joe White, Kristie Nova, Yoni, Tony Hinchcliffe, Brian Redban – 03/13/2023 Follow Tony: @TonyHinchcliffe Follow Yoni: @BestBarbecue To watch the podcast on YouTube: https://bit.ly/KILLTONYYouTube Don’t forget to follow the podcast for free wherever you're listening or by using this link: https://bit.ly/KILLTONY If you like the show, tell people about it! You can text, email, post, or send this link:  https://bit.ly/KILLTONY To check out the show live in Austin, TX, go to: https://killtonylive.com Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

    America's Water Infrastructure Is Collapsing | Yvonne Orji

    America's Water Infrastructure Is Collapsing | Yvonne Orji

    Trevor examines America's crumbling water infrastructure, Michael Kosta and Roy Wood Jr. cover summer sports news, and comedian Yvonne Orji discusses "Bamboozled by Jesus" and "Insecure."

    Donate at dailyshow.com/BraveSpaceAlliance to help provide life-saving resources like support groups, HIV prevention options, and housing and food services for Chicago's LGBTQ+ community.

    Learn more about your ad-choices at https://www.iheartpodcastnetwork.com

    See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

    How top-tier corporate firms can better address wellness issues

    How top-tier corporate firms can better address wellness issues

    According to Herbert Smith Freehills' Danielle Kelly, health and wellbeing strategies in the professional services sector need to shift from a reactionary, first-aid response to more proactively tackling systemic issues.

    In this episode of The Wellness Daily Show, host Jerome Doraisamy is joined by the head of diversity and inclusion at Herbert Smith Freehills to discuss how her firm's attitude towards wellness strategies has evolved over the last decade.

    Danielle elaborates on the positive impact of HSF's mental health champions for workplace culture, how the implementation of a global mental health strategy addresses diversity and inclusion, and suggests further actions for facilitating optimal wellness in big corporate.

    The Role of General Counsel in Times of Crisis with Maria Feeley, Chief Legal Officer of Washington and Lee University

    The Role of General Counsel in Times of Crisis with Maria Feeley, Chief Legal Officer of Washington and Lee University

    Gina Rubel goes on record with Maria Feeley, the Chief Legal Officer of Washington and Lee University, to discuss the important role of the general counsel in times of crisis and GC’s expectations of outside counsel.

    Learn More

    Maria Feeley is the Chief Legal Officer of Washington and Lee University, a nationally ranked private liberal arts university established in 1749 with an endowment valued at over $2 billion. She is also Chair of the Board of Trustees of Rosemont College, a private college celebrating its 100th anniversary, ranked #7 as a Top Performer in Social Mobility in this year’s U.S. News & World Report’s Best Colleges Rankings in the Regional Universities North category, up from #15 last year. Rosemont is the only college in the Philadelphia region in the Top 10.

    Prior to joining Washington and Lee, Maria served as Vice President, General Counsel, Secretary, and - for two years - as Interim Athletics Director of the University of Hartford, an institution with seven colleges offering over 100-degree programs, students from 48 states, 63 countries, and a robust Division I Athletics program. There she was responsible for oversight of the Office of General Counsel, Office of Equal Opportunity Programs and Title IX Compliance, Athletics Department, Office of the Secretary, Compliance and ERM Programs. As Athletics Director, she oversaw a budget of over $22 million, managed over 75 full time employees and 17 Division I Athletics Programs, launched new Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion initiatives and a new Varsity Esports Program, funded and built a new Esports arena, and celebrated the men’s basketball team’s first ever NCAA Tournament appearance and America East Championship win.

    Prior to joining Hartford, she served as the Chief Legal Officer of Florida A&M University, one of the largest HBCUs in the country.

    From 2007 through 2017, Maria was a partner in the Am Law 100 law firm Pepper Hamilton, where she chaired the Women’s Initiative, was vice chair of the Diversity Committee, and was on the Hiring and Contributions Committees. She was a senior legal consultant for FGIS, a risk management company former FBI Director Louis Freeh founded, and Pepper acquired. With FGIS, she served as a senior consultant for the Deepwater Horizon Economic Claims Center in connection with the largest court-supervised settlement program in U.S. history following the BP oil spill.

    In 2014, the Pennsylvania Governor appointed her to the State Ethics Commission, an independent agency which enforces the Ethics Act, and certain provisions of the Lobbying Disclosure Law, Gaming Act, and Medical Marijuana Act.

    Philly Biz named her a “Top Business Attorney;” Profiles in Diversity Journal honored her in its 10th Annual WomenWorthWatching® issue; The Legal Intelligencer and Pennsylvania Law Weekly named her one of Pennsylvania’s 25 Women of the Year in 2008; she received the Philadelphia Bar Association’s Peretta Award, was appointed Philadelphia liaison to the ABA’s Commission on Women, co-chair of the 2010 ABA Women in Law Leadership Academy Programming Committee, Zone 1 Delegate to the Pennsylvania Bar Association House of Delegates; she was elected to the Board of Governors of the 13,000 member Philadelphia Bar Association, appointed to the Committee on Judicial Selection and Retention, and chaired the Association’s Women in the Profession Committee, Annual Bench Bar Conference, Women’s Rights Committee, Sandra Day O’Connor Award Committee, and Drafting Committee for the Development of a Call to Action and Best Practices for the Retention and Promotion of Women Lawyers.

    Maria obtained her JD from Washington and Lee University where she served as senior articles editor for the Washington and Lee Journal of Civil Rights and Social Justice f/k/a Race and Ethnic Ancestry Law Digest. She obtained her BA, cum laude, in Mathematics and History from Rosemont College, where she received a full-tuition academic scholarship, was inducted into the Delta Epsilon Sigma national honor society and was an adjunct business law professor from 2006 through 2015.

    Goodbye Discriminatory Electoral Map and The Mental Health Benefits of Horror

    Goodbye Discriminatory Electoral Map and The Mental Health Benefits of Horror

    This week's good news:

    Karissa is happy to share how a federal judge decided to overturn Galveston’s discriminatory electoral map in a voting rights victory. Then, Arielle reveals the surprising mental health benefits of watching horror films.

    The Optimist Daily is a project of The World Business Academy.

    Donate link: https://www.optimistdaily.com/donate-to-support-the-optimist-daily/?gift=Y%20http://