Logo

    The loose, undefined guardrails of X’s AI image generator

    enAugust 26, 2024
    What is Grock 2's approach to content moderation?
    How does Grock 2 differ from other AI image generators?
    What concerns are raised regarding the use of Grog?
    What types of content can Grock 2 generate?
    Why does Rob from Ontario support Marketplace?

    Podcast Summary

    • AI image generator content moderationGrock 2, X's new AI image generator, offers fewer content moderation guardrails compared to other tools, generating images of real people, extreme violence, and copyrighted material while avoiding pornography, excessive violence, and deceitfulness.

      X's new AI image generator, Grock 2, offers less censored outputs compared to other similar tools. This chatbot can generate images based on text prompts and has fewer guardrails, aligning with owner Elon Musk's approach to content moderation. Unlike most image generators, Grock has fewer limitations on content, allowing for the generation of images of real people, extreme violence, and copyrighted material. However, it still avoids generating pornographic, excessively violent, or deceitful content. Users have experimented with generating images of political figures, cartoon characters, and even disturbing tableaus. The lack of strict limitations makes for an intriguing and sometimes unpleasant exploration of the tool's capabilities. While some may find the freedom appealing, others may raise concerns about potential misuse or the blurring of boundaries in content generation.

    • AI copyright and creativityAI model X pushes boundaries of copyright law by generating copyrighted material, integrated with a news platform, despite legal uncertainties.

      X, an AI text and image generation model, stands out for its willingness to push boundaries in generating copyrighted material, despite the legal uncertainties surrounding AI copyright. Unlike some other major image generators, X has a lower barrier to entry and is integrated with a widely-used news platform, even if it's only accessible to premium subscribers. While its availability is more limited than some other text and image generators, its integration with a prominent news platform gives it a unique reach. The copyright law surrounding AI is still unsettled, and X's approach to generating copyrighted material raises interesting questions about the boundaries of AI creativity and the evolving nature of copyright law. Additionally, the discussion highlighted the existence of various AI image generators, some with more restrictions than others, and the ongoing evolution of the information ecosystem.

    • AI ethics and financial burdenThe intersection of financial pressure and AI adoption can lead to ethical dilemmas, as seen in the case of X and XAI's use of a licensable AI system, Grog, which has the potential to generate harmful content

      Money and difficult life situations can create significant financial dilemmas, leaving individuals feeling burdened. Meanwhile, in the tech world, X and XAI's adoption of a licensable AI system from Black Forest Labs, known as Grog, has raised concerns. Although X and XAI have stated they're working on their own solution, Grog is currently being used as a stopgap. The main worry regarding Grog lies in its potential to generate harmful or offensive content, such as sexualized images, which have been observed in other AI systems. While some may view this as just a bit of fun, the potential for real-world harm cannot be ignored. The intersection of money, difficult life situations, and AI raises important questions about ethics, responsibility, and the impact of technology on our lives.

    • Deepfakes and credibilityDeepfakes pose a significant challenge in the digital age, but increasing awareness, scrutiny, and credibility of sources can help distinguish real images from manipulated ones. Users can also flood platforms with real content to bury deepfakes and reduce their visibility.

      The proliferation of deepfake technology, as demonstrated by the case of Grock and the spread of non-consensual, sexually explicit images of Taylor Swift on X, highlights the importance of context and credibility in the digital age. While it may be impossible to completely eliminate the creation and dissemination of deepfakes, platforms and users can take steps to increase awareness and scrutiny. The reputation and credibility of sources, such as reputable news outlets, can help distinguish real images from deepfakes. Additionally, users can flood platforms with real content to bury deepfakes and reduce their visibility. Ultimately, the challenge lies in encouraging a culture of critical thinking and skepticism in the face of potentially manipulated media. As Addie Robertson, senior tech and policy editor at The Verge, noted, "This could encourage people to look more at the things around them."

    • Marketplace importanceMarketplace is a trusted source of intelligent, engaging, and valuable news that enhances daily life. Support it through donations to ensure quality journalism continues.

      Marketplace, as described by Rob from London, Ontario, is an essential part of his daily routine. He values the highly credible, intelligent, interesting, and at times humorous information it provides. Rob emphasizes the importance of Marketplace in making his day more engaging and lessened without it. He encourages others to support Marketplace by donating, as it delivers valuable content that enhances their day as well. Marketplace is more than just a news source, it's a trusted companion for those seeking knowledge and understanding of the world around them. By supporting Marketplace, you're investing in quality journalism and ensuring its continued presence in our lives. Donate today at marketplace.org/donate.

    Recent Episodes from Marketplace Tech

    Bytes: Week in Review — Google on trial, underwater data centers and how AI spurred a celebrity endorsement

    Bytes: Week in Review — Google on trial, underwater data centers and how AI spurred a celebrity endorsement

    It’s Friday, which means it’s time for our weekly review of some of the big stories making headlines in tech. First: No, you’re not having déjà vu all over again. Google really is back in court this week for its second antitrust trial of the year. Plus, a startup in Silicon Valley wants to make AI data centers more sustainable by putting them underwater in the San Francisco Bay, but regulators have questions. And Taylor Swift announced she is endorsing Vice President Kamala Harris in this year’s presidential election. She took to Instagram on Tuesday night to publish her stance, citing artificial intelligence-enabled misinformation as a driving force. Marketplace’s Meghan McCarty Carino spoke with Paresh Dave, senior writer at Wired, for his take on this week’s tech news.

    Marketplace Tech
    enSeptember 13, 2024

    Crypto emerges as a funding powerhouse in the election

    Crypto emerges as a funding powerhouse in the election

    The cryptocurrency industry has been fairly quiet recently, with the scandals around the bankruptcy of crypto exchange FTX and its former chief executive, Sam Bankman-Fried, fading from the headlines. But behind the scenes, the industry has become a bit of a power player in the 2024 elections — funding political ads, endorsing House and Senate candidates and raising millions of dollars, according to a recent report from the nonprofit group Public Citizen. Marketplace’s Meghan McCarty Carino spoke to Axios reporter Brady Dale, author of the Axios Crypto newsletter, to learn more.

     

    Marketplace Tech
    enSeptember 12, 2024

    Big Tech’s pivot away from diversity efforts

    Big Tech’s pivot away from diversity efforts

    Over the last couple of years, the tech industry has slashed hundreds of thousands of jobs, many of them in recruiting and other departments working to improve diversity. Companies like Meta and Google, which earlier set ambitious hiring and investment goals, have pulled resources from those efforts. As a result, many nonprofit groups set up to train and recruit underrepresented workers are struggling to stay afloat. One prominent person in the field is Lisa Mae Brunson, founder of the nonprofit Wonder Women Tech. Marketplace’s Meghan McCarty Carino asked her how things have changed.

    Marketplace Tech
    enSeptember 11, 2024

    The threat posed by rumors of noncitizen voting

    The threat posed by rumors of noncitizen voting

    Among the trends of mis- and disinformation spreading ahead of the 2024 election is the narrative that large groups of noncitizens are illegally voting. Marketplace’s Kimberly Adams recently spoke with Danielle Lee Tomson, a research manager with the University of Washington’s Center for an Informed Public, about how this narrative is affecting the November election.

    This conversation is part of “Marketplace Tech’s” limited series “Decoding Democracy.” Watch the full episode on our YouTube channel.

    Marketplace Tech
    enSeptember 10, 2024

    SpaceX comes to NASA’s rescue

    SpaceX comes to NASA’s rescue

    On Friday, a Boeing Starliner spacecraft undocked from the International Space Station to return to Earth without its crew. NASA astronauts Suni Williams and Butch Wilmore stayed behind due to uncertainty about the safety of the Boeing craft. The duo will instead hitch a ride back on a SpaceX mission set to arrive at the ISS in February. It’s another win for the Elon Musk-owned company, which has come to dominate rocket launches in the U.S. But NASA’s reliance on SpaceX now is a bit of a reversal, according to Steven Feldstein, senior fellow at the Carnegie Endowment’s Democracy, Conflict and Governance program.

    Marketplace Tech
    enSeptember 09, 2024

    Bytes: Week in Review —  the X ban, Apple’s AI and airplane Wi-Fi gets upgraded

    Bytes: Week in Review —  the X ban, Apple’s AI and airplane Wi-Fi gets upgraded

    If you’re an Apple fan, you probably didn’t miss the speculation surrounding the upcoming iPhone 16 launch event next week. Many expect the tech giant to reveal more about how its artificial intelligence will be integrated into its new hardware. We’ll be digging into that on this week’s Tech Bytes: Week in Review. Plus, airlines are upgrading their Wi-Fi, so you might be able to take a Zoom meeting on your six-hour flight. But first, Elon Musk’s satellite internet provider has agreed to block Elon Musk’s social media platform in Brazil. X has been banned in the country since last weekend, and now Starlink has agreed to enforce that ban for its roughly quarter-million internet subscribers in the country. Marketplace’s Meghan McCarty Carino spoke with Wall Street Journal senior personal technology columnist Joanna Stern or her take on this week’s tech news.

    Marketplace Tech
    enSeptember 06, 2024

    A mother’s quest for social media reform

    A mother’s quest for social media reform

    Warning: This episode mentions suicide. If you are in crisis, please call the National Suicide Prevention Lifeline at 1-800-273-TALK (8255).

    There seems to be growing momentum for efforts to protect kids from online harm. In June, the Surgeon General Vivek Murthy called for a warning label on social media for children, and more recently the Senate passed the Kids Online Safety Act with bipartisan support. On the show we’ve heard from lobbyists and advocates on different sides of the issue. Today we speak with Kristin Bride, for whom the debate is personal. In 2020, Bride’s 16-year-old son, Carson, died by suicide after being cyberbullied on the social media platform Snapchat. Since then, Bride has become a vocal advocate for social media reform because, she says, even the most vigilant parents can’t always protect their kids.

    Marketplace Tech
    enSeptember 05, 2024

    The AI safety bill dividing Silicon Valley

    The AI safety bill dividing Silicon Valley

    Depending on whom you ask, a bill passed by California lawmakers last week could either save us from imminent AI doom or strangle innovation in Silicon Valley. The bill, SB 1047, is one of the first significant attempts to regulate artificial intelligence in the U.S. It’s supported by some high-profile voices in tech like Elon Musk. But critics say the regulation could stifle growth in Silicon Valley. On the show today, Marketplace’s Meghan McCarty Carino is taking a closer look at the arguments for and against SB 1047 with Chase DiFeliciantonio, a reporter at The San Francisco Chronicle, who has been following the bill’s journey through the Legislature.

    Marketplace Tech
    enSeptember 04, 2024

    Teenagers could be more susceptible to online “dark patterns”

    Teenagers could be more susceptible to online “dark patterns”

    Dark patterns are everywhere on the web. These are design tricks that manipulate users in some way and prompt them to give up information, money or just more of their time. A recent study from the Federal Trade Commission found three-quarters of all subscription apps and websites use at least one dark pattern, and a majority use multiple such tricks. Marketplace’s Meghan McCarty Carino spoke with Yanely Espinal, who covered the topic in this week’s episode of “Financially Inclined.” She said some common dark patterns include advertising that doesn’t look like advertising, online forms that come with check boxes pre-selected and something called confirm shaming.

    Marketplace Tech
    enSeptember 03, 2024