Logo
    Search

    The mental price of affluence (SOP18)

    enDecember 08, 2014

    Podcast Summary

    • Discovering Depression, Anxiety, and Substance Use in Affluent YouthAffluent youth face higher rates of depression, anxiety, and substance use compared to national norms, likely due to societal values promoting 'more is better' mindset, emphasizing emotional well-being and resilience in addition to success.

      Children from affluent families experience higher rates of depression, anxiety, and substance use compared to national norms. This finding, which was discovered by accident during a study comparing inner city kids to upper middle class youth, has been consistently replicated. The reasons behind these high numbers are complex and not solely attributable to parents or schools. Instead, societal values, such as the belief that "more is better," contribute to this issue. It's important to note that these findings do not imply that being affluent causes these issues, but rather that wealth does not guarantee happiness or protection from mental health challenges. Therefore, it's crucial for parents and educators in affluent communities to prioritize emotional well-being and resilience in addition to academic and professional success.

    • Pressure to Succeed and Its Impact on Mental HealthThe pressure to constantly achieve can lead to mental health issues, but focusing on being good parents and friends, and valuing effort and personal growth can help create a healthier balance.

      The cultural pressure to constantly achieve more can lead to anxiety, depression, and even substance abuse. This pressure is not just felt by individuals, but is reinforced by society, schools, and universities. Admissions values accomplishments and achievements, creating a sense of self-worth tied to success. However, this can lead to a constant state of fear and tension if achievements are not met. Instead of tying self-worth to accomplishments, parents can focus on being good parents and friends, and help their children find a healthy balance between success and mental health. Parents in affluent areas may need to be mindful of the pressure they put on their children and work to create a supportive environment that values effort and personal growth over constant achievement. Ultimately, it's important for individuals and parents to remember that they are more than their accomplishments and that their worth is not determined by external factors.

    • Parenting Challenges in Inner City and Upper Middle Class FamiliesParents in all socio-economic backgrounds should prioritize instilling kindness, compassion, and decency in their children to promote their overall well-being and strong social connections.

      Both inner city and upper middle class families face unique challenges in raising well-rounded children. While inner city parents focus on keeping their children physically safe, upper middle class parents need to ensure their children don't get swept away in a culture of self-centered ambition. Research shows that being kind, compassionate, and generous not only benefits others but also improves the giver's own well-being. However, upper middle class children also face issues like alcohol and drug use, depression, anxiety, and high levels of rule breaking, which can be comparable to those in inner city settings. It's crucial for parents in all socio-economic backgrounds to prioritize instilling values of decency, kindness, and compassion in their children to promote their overall well-being and strong social connections.

    • Complex behaviors among upper middle class kidsParents should model good behavior and be aware of their reactions to help upper middle class kids develop a balanced value system.

      The behavioral issues among upper middle class children are more complex than simple acts of delinquency. While inner city kids may engage in self-protective activities or gang involvement, upper middle class kids exhibit higher rates of rule-breaking, substance use, and envy. Parents cannot solely rely on teaching values to their children through words; they must model good behavior themselves. Additionally, parents must be mindful of their own reactions and subtle expressions of competition, as these can convey unintended messages to their children. Ultimately, it's essential for parents to be conscious of their actions and values to help their children develop a balanced value system.

    • Balancing Career and FamilyParents should encourage children's education and interests, fostering a well-rounded life, while maintaining a balance between career goals and family relationships.

      While striving for professional success is important, it should not come at the expense of neglecting other aspects of life, particularly our relationships with our children. Dr. Luther emphasized that it's natural for parents, especially those from upper middle class backgrounds, to want their children to experience the same level of gratification and success they have achieved through their careers. However, it's crucial to remember that life is not solely defined by professional accomplishments. Instead, parents should encourage their children to pursue an education and explore various interests, fostering a well-rounded and fulfilling life. Inadvertently prioritizing career success over family relationships can lead to saying and doing things we don't mean to. Overall, striking a balance between career goals and family relationships is essential for maintaining a healthy and happy life.

    Recent Episodes from Speaking of Psychology

    How noise pollution harms our health, with Arline Bronzaft, PhD

    How noise pollution harms our health, with Arline Bronzaft, PhD

    From roaring leaf blowers to screeching trains, the world is full of unwelcome noise – and researchers have found that noisy environments can take a real toll on people’s mental and physical health. Arline Bronzaft, PhD, talks about how noise affects health and well-being, how it can harm kids’ learning, why it’s not just a problem in big cities, and the most unusual noise complaints she’s heard in her five decades of advocacy combating noise pollution.

    Speaking of Psychology
    enJune 26, 2024

    Mental health in a warming world, with Kim Meidenbauer, PhD, and Amruta Nori-Sarma, PhD

    Mental health in a warming world, with Kim Meidenbauer, PhD, and Amruta Nori-Sarma, PhD

    Last year -- 2023 -- was the world’s warmest on record, and 2024 could bring another record-shattering summer. Psychologist Kim Meidenbauer, PhD, and public health researcher Amruta Nori-Sarma, PhD, discuss how heat affects people’s mental health, emotions and even cognitive abilities; the link between heat, violence and aggression; who is most vulnerable to the effects of extreme heat; and what policy makers could be doing to mitigate its effects.

    Speaking of Psychology
    enJune 19, 2024

    How to motivate yourself and others, with Wendy Grolnick, PhD, and Frank Worrell, PhD

    How to motivate yourself and others, with Wendy Grolnick, PhD, and Frank Worrell, PhD

    Why can’t I get myself to run that 5K? Why isn’t my child getting better grades? We all have things that we struggle to accomplish – or that we struggle to get someone else to accomplish. Frank Worrell, PhD, and Wendy Grolnick, PhD, co-authors of “Motivation Myth Busters: Science-based Strategies to Boost Motivation in Yourself and Others,” discuss how our misconceptions about motivation get in the way of reaching our goals, why there’s no such thing as an “unmotivated” person, and the merits and drawbacks of strategies like rewards, competition and praise.

    Speaking of Psychology
    enJune 12, 2024

    The benefits of solitude, with Thuy-vy Nguyen, PhD, and Netta Weinstein, PhD

    The benefits of solitude, with Thuy-vy Nguyen, PhD, and Netta Weinstein, PhD

    The average American adult spends up to one-third of their waking hours alone. Psychologists are exploring how those hours spent on our own affect us – including the potential benefits, as well as the challenges, of solitude. Thuy-vy Nguyen, PhD, and Netta Weinstein, PhD, discuss the difference between solitude and loneliness, how solitude affects our emotions and stress levels, why some people crave solitude more than others, and why the stigma against solitude can make us uncomfortable with being alone.

    Speaking of Psychology
    enJune 05, 2024

    Which countries are happiest and why? With Lara Aknin, PhD

    Which countries are happiest and why? With Lara Aknin, PhD

    The 2024 World Happiness Report, which ranks the happiness levels of countries around the world, found that young Americans are less happy than their peers in many other countries. Psychology professor Lara Aknin, PhD, an editor of the report, talks about how the report defines happiness, why young people’s happiness levels may have dropped in the U.S, what drives happiness, and why being generous makes people happy – even when they don’t have much to spare.

    Choosing to be child free, with Jennifer Watling Neal, PhD

    Choosing to be child free, with Jennifer Watling Neal, PhD

    A growing number of adults in the U.S. are choosing not to have children. Jenna Watling Neal, PhD, of Michigan State University, talks about her research that’s found 1 in 5 adults are child free, why people are choosing not to have kids, the stigma child-free adults face, whether people who decide not to have kids early in life usually stick with that choice, and how the prevalence of child-free adults in the U.S. compares with other countries.

    How to cope with political stress this election season, with Brett Q. Ford, PhD, and Kevin Smith, PhD

    How to cope with political stress this election season, with Brett Q. Ford, PhD, and Kevin Smith, PhD

    If the thought of the upcoming election sends your stress level through the roof, you’re not alone. Psychologist Brett Q. Ford, PhD, and political scientist Kevin Smith, PhD, talk about how political stress affects people’s well-being; what high levels of political stress mean for people’s lives, for the U.S. and for democracy; and how to stay politically engaged while still maintaining your mental health.

    For transcripts, links and more information, please visit the Speaking of Psychology Homepage.

    How Sesame Street teaches kids about emotional well-being, with Rosemarie Truglio, PhD

    How Sesame Street teaches kids about emotional well-being, with Rosemarie Truglio, PhD

    Sesame Street has entertained and educated generations of children. Developmental psychologist Rosemarie Truglio, PhD, Sesame Workshop’s senior vice president of curriculum and content, talks about why the show has a new focus on young children’s emotional well-being; how Sesame Street translates complicated concepts into stories that young kids can connect with; the research that underpins all of the content on Sesame Street; and why the Sesame Street characters still resonate with so many adults.

    For transcripts, links and more information, please visit the Speaking of Psychology Homepage.

    What déjà vu can teach us about memory, with Chris Moulin, PhD

    What déjà vu can teach us about memory, with Chris Moulin, PhD

    The eerie sensation of “déjà vu” -- feeling a strong sense of familiarity in a new place or situation -- is one of memory’s strangest tricks. Researcher Chris Moulin, PhD, of Grenoble Alpes University, talks about why déjà vu happens; why both déjà vu and its lesser-known opposite, jamais vu, may actually be signs of a healthy memory at work; why young people are more prone to déjà vu; how he and others study déjà vu and jamais vu in the lab; and what these experiences can teach us about memory more broadly.

    For transcripts, links and more information, please visit the Speaking of Psychology Homepage.

    The psychology of sports fans, with Daniel Wann, PhD

    The psychology of sports fans, with Daniel Wann, PhD

    Are you a sports “superfan”? Or do you wonder what’s driving the superfans in your life? Daniel Wann, PhD, of Murray State University, talks about why being a fan is usually good for people’s mental health, how they choose the teams they root for, why some are fair-weather fans while others love to cheer for the underdog, how fandom is changing among younger people, and whether a crowd of supportive fans can affect the outcome of a game.

    For transcripts, links and more information, please visit the Speaking of Psychology Homepage.

    Related Episodes

    Ep. 013: PTSD and Suicide, Part II- Why Are They Linked?

    Ep. 013: PTSD and Suicide, Part II- Why Are They Linked?

    In Part II of our series on PTSD and its relationship to suicide we’ll explore why those who suffer from PTSD are at risk of death by suicide. Additionally, we’ll cover important info for groups more vulnerable to thoughts of suicide and the critically important progress that has been made in treating PTSD and ending its symptoms.

    Ep. 039 : Why Won’t Therapy Work? Part II- Opening Up

    Ep. 039 :  Why Won’t Therapy Work? Part II- Opening Up

    Why do some people claim, "Therapy didn't work for me"? In part two of our series, we discuss some of the issues that stand in the way of success in therapy. Some quit before they've really given the process a chance or are inconsistent about therapy. Additionally, people are often reluctant to seek help, believing they can relying on friends and family for support. If you are suicidal, it is highly unlikely that your loved ones know enough about mental health to provide the exact support you need. If you want to benefit from therapy, be consistent, be honest, and be willing to do your homework. Spend some time researching therapists in your area. Not every therapist is perfect for every person. Sometimes we are put off from seeking therapy because the thought of sharing can feel unbearable. Finding the right counselor will involve opening up. 

    Ep. 024: First Responders & Suicide, Part II

    Ep. 024: First Responders & Suicide, Part II

    In Part II of our conversation, we explore the substantial difference in suicide rates between First Responders and the general population. Research suggests that police officers may be 50% more suicidal than the average citizen and that risk is even higher for firefighters. In fact, more firefighters die by suicide than in the line of duty. Why do we spend so much money on physically protecting our First Responders but so little on protecting their mental health? 

    May 2021: Quality of Depression Care for Patients With Comorbid Substance Use Disorder

    May 2021: Quality of Depression Care for Patients With Comorbid Substance Use Disorder

    Executive Editor Michael Roy speaks with Lara N. Coughlin, Ph.D., and Lewei Allison Lin, M.D., M.S., about their article on the provision of guideline-concordant depression treatment to patients with and without substance use disorders.

    Dr. Lara Coughlin is an assistant professor in the Department of Psychiatry and an adjunct assistant professor of psychology at the University of Michigan. She is also a licensed clinical psychologist. Her research aims to find new ways to use behavioral economic frameworks to improve outcomes among individuals with substance use disorders. In particular, she is interested in decision making around health behaviors, such as choosing between sooner and smaller rewards, like substance use, and delayed and larger rewards, like overall health or career development. Her current work looks at the delivery and evaluation of care for underserved and rural populations.

    Dr. Allison Lin is an addiction psychiatrist, an assistant professor in the Department of Psychiatry at the University of Michigan, and a research scientist in the Department of Veterans Affairs Ann Arbor Healthcare System.

    • How the authors became interested in their areas of research [2:28]
    • How often does depression co-occur with other disorders? [5:05]
    • Current recommendations or best practices for the treatment of these conditions [5:33]
    • Objective of the study [6:55]
    • Description of study participants [7:27]
    • Measures used to collect and analyze data [9:15]
    • Main results of the study [11:20]
    • Were there significant differences between disorders with respect to receipt of appropriate treatment? [12:10]
    • Did any demographic characteristics, medical comorbidities, or other variables affect the findings? [13:25]
    • Other notable or surprising results [14:03]
    • Do the findings of the study extend to patients in the general population? [14:50]
    • Study limitations [15:28]
    • Patient or structural factors that may contribute to inequity in guideline-concordant care [16:13]
    • How can we improve depression care for patients with comorbid substance use disorders? [19:01]
    • Key points that researchers, clinicians, and other mental health professionals should take away from the article [22:12]
    • Recommendations for further research in this area [23:32]

    Be sure to let your colleagues know about the podcast, and please rate and review it on Apple Podcasts, Google Podcasts, Stitcher, Spotify, or wherever you listen to it.

    Subscribe to the podcast here.

    Listen to other podcasts produced by the American Psychiatric Association.

    Browse articles online.

    Watch Deputy Editor Daniel S. Pine, M.D., present highlights from the May 2021 issue.

    How authors may submit their work.

    Follow the journals of APA Publishing on Twitter.

    E-mail us at ajp@psych.org

    Ep. 016 : What Parents Should Know About Suicide Part I: Why Kids Become Suicidal

    Ep. 016 : What Parents Should Know About Suicide Part I: Why Kids Become Suicidal

    Young people are amongst the most vulnerable to thoughts of suicide. Suicide is the number two leading cause of death for people ages 10-34. However, parents often fail to recognize the danger their children may be in until it is too late. In this episode, we’ll explore what might cause a young person to become suicidal. We’ll discuss how violence and sadness are pretty typical experiences for young people. We’ll also look at how the internet, social media, and cyberbullying may add to the stresses of childhood. Lastly, we’ll discuss how a lack of emotional tools and impulsivity may contribute to thoughts of suicide in young people.