Logo
    Search

    Why our attention spans are shrinking, with Gloria Mark, PhD

    enFebruary 08, 2023

    Podcast Summary

    • Understanding Different Types of AttentionFocused attention occurs during challenging tasks while rote activities can occur throughout the day, but constant technology use blurs the lines leading to distraction and decreased productivity.

      Our constant engagement with technology is making it harder for us to focus and pay attention, leading to shrinking attention spans. According to Gloria Mark, a psychologist and professor at the University of California, Irvine, there are different kinds of attention: focused attention, when we're engaged and challenged, and rote activity, when we're engaged but not challenged. Mark's research shows that focused attention tends to occur in late morning and mid to late afternoon, while rote activities, such as browsing the web or playing simple games, can happen throughout the day. The rise of the Internet and digital devices has made it harder to distinguish between these two types of attention, leading to a constant state of distraction and decreased productivity. Understanding the science of attention can help us regain focus and improve both productivity and happiness.

    • Human attention span decreased significantly over the past few decadesDecreased attention span due to multitasking leads to increased stress and errors, negatively impacting mental and physical well-being

      The average human attention span has decreased significantly over the past few decades, from an average of 2.5 minutes in 2004 to approximately 47 seconds in the present day. This trend, which is reflected in both averages and medians, raises concerns due to its correlation with increased stress levels and error rates. Research indicates that frequent attention switching, a result of multitasking, leads to heightened stress as measured by heart rate monitors and self-reported perception. Furthermore, errors and decreased performance are common when individuals switch their attention rapidly between tasks. Despite this trend seemingly becoming the norm, it is not a desirable outcome due to its negative impact on mental and physical well-being.

    • Managing Attention and Taking Meaningful BreaksTaking intentional breaks at natural stopping points and understanding self-regulation skills can help optimize productivity and avoid burnout.

      Our ability to focus and be productive is significantly impacted by the number and length of attention shifts we make throughout the day. These shifts, or "switch costs," can be detrimental as they require mental effort to refocus and can lead to decreased performance. However, taking intentional breaks at natural stopping points in tasks can help replenish energy and improve overall productivity. Additionally, while tools like internet blockers can be beneficial for individuals with poor self-regulation skills, they may harm those with strong self-regulation abilities who rely on taking regular breaks to maintain focus. Ultimately, it's essential to understand the importance of managing attention and taking meaningful breaks to optimize productivity and avoid burnout.

    • Managing Attention: Listen to Your Body and Take BreaksDevelop self-awareness, use tools like Pomodoro Technique, and schedule breaks to manage attention effectively. Encourage healthy device usage habits for children.

      While tools like software blockers can help manage attention, it's crucial for individuals to develop their own self-awareness and take breaks based on their unique energy levels. The Pomodoro Technique, which involves working for 25 minutes then taking a 5-minute break, is an example of a low-tech solution. However, everyone's capacity varies, so it's essential to listen to your body and adjust accordingly. Additionally, scheduling breaks between challenging tasks is essential to maintain energy levels and productivity. Another concept related to attention is flow, a state of optimal attention where individuals are fully immersed in an activity, and time seems to stand still. This state leads to peak creativity. However, not all jobs allow for flow, and that's okay. Instead, focusing on self-awareness and scheduling breaks can help maintain productivity and focus. Regarding children and their use of devices, research on attention spans primarily focuses on adults. However, with children spending increasing time on devices, there are concerns about their ability to sustain attention. While more research is needed, it's essential to encourage healthy device usage habits and provide opportunities for physical activity and social interaction to support children's cognitive and emotional development.

    • Impact of Excessive Screen Time on Young Children's Focus and DevelopmentExcessive screen time for young children can hinder their focus and executive function development, averaging 2.5 hours a day for 2-4 year olds and 3 hours for 5-8 year olds, primarily on TV, YouTube, and gaming.

      Excessive screen time for young children can negatively impact their ability to focus and develop important mental functions. Children as young as 2 to 4 years old already average 2.5 hours of screen time a day, and by the age of 5 to 8, they average 3 hours. This screen time is primarily spent on TV, YouTube, and gaming. Young children are more susceptible to distraction than older children, and the constant exposure to distractions can hinder their development of executive function, which is responsible for decision making, setting priorities, and managing interference from peripheral stimuli. This is concerning because children need self-control to succeed in online learning environments, and their brains are not yet fully developed to handle the distractions of the digital world. To help children learn to focus, it's recommended that they engage in off-screen activities such as playing outside or reading books. Adults can also improve their focus by ensuring they get a good night's sleep, as sleep debt can lead to shorter attention spans and a greater reliance on lightweight activities like social media.

    • Adapting to Shorter Attention Spans in MediaMedia creators are responding to shorter attention spans by producing content with shorter lengths, while individuals may consume content faster to fit more into their schedules. The pandemic may worsen these trends, making focus and deep work increasingly difficult.

      Both individuals and media creators are adapting to shorter attention spans due to the abundance of content and resources. This is evident in the decreasing lengths of TV and film shots, as well as the increasing popularity of fast-paced content on platforms like YouTube. People may intentionally or unintentionally consume content at faster speeds to fit more into their schedules. However, the causality of this trend is unclear - it could be that our attention spans have been influenced by media, or that media has been created to cater to shorter attention spans. The shift to remote work during the pandemic may further exacerbate these issues, as workers are bombarded with emails and messages, making focus and deep work even more challenging. It's important to consider the potential consequences of these trends on our ability to fully engage with and understand complex information.

    • Minimizing Distractions in Remote WorkIndividuals can manage distractions by setting quiet work hours and limiting email checks. Organizations can help by establishing quiet work hours and limiting non-urgent electronic communications. Societal policies, like the 'Right to Disconnect,' can also support a more focused remote work environment.

      Remote work comes with unique distractions that can hinder focus, and individuals and organizations can take steps to mitigate these distractions. Individuals may feel pressure to constantly check emails and messages to demonstrate their productivity, but this can lead to excessive distractions. Organizations can help by establishing quiet work hours and limiting the sending of non-urgent electronic communications during these times. On a societal level, there are laws and policies, such as the "Right to Disconnect," that aim to prevent workers from being penalized for not answering electronic communications outside of work hours. Overall, a collective effort is needed to create a more focused and productive remote work environment.

    • Disconnecting from work for better productivity and well-beingThe implementation of right to disconnect policies and effective time management on the internet are crucial for optimizing attention, teamwork, and personal well-being in the digital age.

      The importance of work-life balance and the psychological benefits of disconnecting from work. The Bureau of Tourism argued for the implementation of right to disconnect policies, stating that individuals need a break from work to recharge and return to work more productive. Researcher Mark Griffiths expressed his interest in optimizing attention and teamwork in the digital age, particularly in the context of remote work. Griffiths emphasized the need to find value from the Internet and utilize time effectively to avoid exhaustion. Overall, the conversation highlighted the significance of balancing work and personal life, as well as the potential of technology to enhance productivity and well-being.

    Recent Episodes from Speaking of Psychology

    How noise pollution harms our health, with Arline Bronzaft, PhD

    How noise pollution harms our health, with Arline Bronzaft, PhD

    From roaring leaf blowers to screeching trains, the world is full of unwelcome noise – and researchers have found that noisy environments can take a real toll on people’s mental and physical health. Arline Bronzaft, PhD, talks about how noise affects health and well-being, how it can harm kids’ learning, why it’s not just a problem in big cities, and the most unusual noise complaints she’s heard in her five decades of advocacy combating noise pollution.

    Speaking of Psychology
    enJune 26, 2024

    Mental health in a warming world, with Kim Meidenbauer, PhD, and Amruta Nori-Sarma, PhD

    Mental health in a warming world, with Kim Meidenbauer, PhD, and Amruta Nori-Sarma, PhD

    Last year -- 2023 -- was the world’s warmest on record, and 2024 could bring another record-shattering summer. Psychologist Kim Meidenbauer, PhD, and public health researcher Amruta Nori-Sarma, PhD, discuss how heat affects people’s mental health, emotions and even cognitive abilities; the link between heat, violence and aggression; who is most vulnerable to the effects of extreme heat; and what policy makers could be doing to mitigate its effects.

    Speaking of Psychology
    enJune 19, 2024

    How to motivate yourself and others, with Wendy Grolnick, PhD, and Frank Worrell, PhD

    How to motivate yourself and others, with Wendy Grolnick, PhD, and Frank Worrell, PhD

    Why can’t I get myself to run that 5K? Why isn’t my child getting better grades? We all have things that we struggle to accomplish – or that we struggle to get someone else to accomplish. Frank Worrell, PhD, and Wendy Grolnick, PhD, co-authors of “Motivation Myth Busters: Science-based Strategies to Boost Motivation in Yourself and Others,” discuss how our misconceptions about motivation get in the way of reaching our goals, why there’s no such thing as an “unmotivated” person, and the merits and drawbacks of strategies like rewards, competition and praise.

    Speaking of Psychology
    enJune 12, 2024

    The benefits of solitude, with Thuy-vy Nguyen, PhD, and Netta Weinstein, PhD

    The benefits of solitude, with Thuy-vy Nguyen, PhD, and Netta Weinstein, PhD

    The average American adult spends up to one-third of their waking hours alone. Psychologists are exploring how those hours spent on our own affect us – including the potential benefits, as well as the challenges, of solitude. Thuy-vy Nguyen, PhD, and Netta Weinstein, PhD, discuss the difference between solitude and loneliness, how solitude affects our emotions and stress levels, why some people crave solitude more than others, and why the stigma against solitude can make us uncomfortable with being alone.

    Speaking of Psychology
    enJune 05, 2024

    Which countries are happiest and why? With Lara Aknin, PhD

    Which countries are happiest and why? With Lara Aknin, PhD

    The 2024 World Happiness Report, which ranks the happiness levels of countries around the world, found that young Americans are less happy than their peers in many other countries. Psychology professor Lara Aknin, PhD, an editor of the report, talks about how the report defines happiness, why young people’s happiness levels may have dropped in the U.S, what drives happiness, and why being generous makes people happy – even when they don’t have much to spare.

    Choosing to be child free, with Jennifer Watling Neal, PhD

    Choosing to be child free, with Jennifer Watling Neal, PhD

    A growing number of adults in the U.S. are choosing not to have children. Jenna Watling Neal, PhD, of Michigan State University, talks about her research that’s found 1 in 5 adults are child free, why people are choosing not to have kids, the stigma child-free adults face, whether people who decide not to have kids early in life usually stick with that choice, and how the prevalence of child-free adults in the U.S. compares with other countries.

    How to cope with political stress this election season, with Brett Q. Ford, PhD, and Kevin Smith, PhD

    How to cope with political stress this election season, with Brett Q. Ford, PhD, and Kevin Smith, PhD

    If the thought of the upcoming election sends your stress level through the roof, you’re not alone. Psychologist Brett Q. Ford, PhD, and political scientist Kevin Smith, PhD, talk about how political stress affects people’s well-being; what high levels of political stress mean for people’s lives, for the U.S. and for democracy; and how to stay politically engaged while still maintaining your mental health.

    For transcripts, links and more information, please visit the Speaking of Psychology Homepage.

    How Sesame Street teaches kids about emotional well-being, with Rosemarie Truglio, PhD

    How Sesame Street teaches kids about emotional well-being, with Rosemarie Truglio, PhD

    Sesame Street has entertained and educated generations of children. Developmental psychologist Rosemarie Truglio, PhD, Sesame Workshop’s senior vice president of curriculum and content, talks about why the show has a new focus on young children’s emotional well-being; how Sesame Street translates complicated concepts into stories that young kids can connect with; the research that underpins all of the content on Sesame Street; and why the Sesame Street characters still resonate with so many adults.

    For transcripts, links and more information, please visit the Speaking of Psychology Homepage.

    What déjà vu can teach us about memory, with Chris Moulin, PhD

    What déjà vu can teach us about memory, with Chris Moulin, PhD

    The eerie sensation of “déjà vu” -- feeling a strong sense of familiarity in a new place or situation -- is one of memory’s strangest tricks. Researcher Chris Moulin, PhD, of Grenoble Alpes University, talks about why déjà vu happens; why both déjà vu and its lesser-known opposite, jamais vu, may actually be signs of a healthy memory at work; why young people are more prone to déjà vu; how he and others study déjà vu and jamais vu in the lab; and what these experiences can teach us about memory more broadly.

    For transcripts, links and more information, please visit the Speaking of Psychology Homepage.

    Related Episodes

    #435: How to Achieve Hyperfocus

    #435: How to Achieve Hyperfocus

    We all want to be more productive. And when we buckle down to do so, we typically try to figure out ways to better manage our time. My guest today, though, argues that focusing on managing your time is only part of the productivity picture. You also need to learn how to better manage your attention.

    His name is Chris Bailey, and his latest book is Hyperfocus: How to Be More Productive in a World of Distraction. Today on the show, Chris shares research-backed advice on how to improve your powers of concentration, and why doing so is more important than ever. We delve into why you need to be intentional about directing your attention, why multitasking actually causes you to be less productive, and the surprisingly long time it takes to get refocused when you get distracted. Chris then shares tactics you can start using today to become more focused. We then shift gears and discuss the importance of having periods of time when you’re NOT focused, especially when planning for the future. Chris shares how you can organize your day to get the benefits of being both focused and unfocused.

    Get the show notes at aom.is/hyperfocus.

    HIBT Lab! Stolen Focus: Johann Hari

    HIBT Lab! Stolen Focus: Johann Hari

    Like so many of us, author Johann Hari noticed that the more time he spent looking at screens and switching from device to device, the harder it became for him to concentrate and achieve his goals. After talking to more than 200 doctors, researchers, and neuroscientists around the world, Johann came to a sobering conclusion: the human race is in the middle of an attention crisis. He examines this societal challenge in his new book, Stolen Focus: Why You Can’t Pay Attention and How to Think Deeply Again.

    This week on How I Built This Lab, Johann and Guy discuss the factors chipping away at our ability to focus, and what we can do to reclaim our attention. They also talk about flow states – how we get into them, and why everyone in the business world should be working to achieve them. 

    Check out Johann’s book here: https://amzn.to/3L3wsMC

    See Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info.

    Ep 3: "How do we build tech-healthy habits?" with Daniel Sih

    Ep 3: "How do we build tech-healthy habits?" with Daniel Sih
    Episode 3: "How do we build tech-healthy habits?"

    For this episode we shift our focus away from Christianity's place in society, and more towards a universal issue worth pondering; our relationship with technology. Many of us spend large parts of our working life navigating screens and the internet, only to come home and do the same for our leisure times. We know it's changing us day by day, but not necessarily in a good way. Are there ways we can reclaim our time and humanity? And how do we guide our kids in a rapidly changing landscape when we ourselves are only novices?

    Daniel Sih is the CEO and co-founder of Spacemakers – a leadership and productivity consulting company aiming to help busy leaders and their teams make space to think deeply, build habits and get the right things done. As a trainer, coach and keynote speaker, Daniel has worked with CEO’s, executives, and other senior professionals throughout Australia and the world. His book Spacemaker: how to unplug, unwind and think clearly in the digital age continues to scoop up awards in the business world. While his latest book Raising Tech-Healthy Humans helps families and communities navigate the joys and pitfalls of tech together.

    Other References:

    Got questions?


    You can shoot Aaron or Amy an email about anything! We'd love to hear your brutally honest or delightfully encouraging thoughts on the show and the topics that come up each week. There's a good chance we have stuff on our website at Third Space too!

    Deeper Questions is produced by Production Farm Studios

    #584 - Dr Gloria Mark - How To Take Control Of Your Attention

    #584 - Dr Gloria Mark - How To Take Control Of Your Attention
    Dr Gloria Mark is the Chancellor's professor in the Department of Informatics at the University of California and an author whose research focuses on human-computer interaction. Not being able to focus and suffering with distracted attention is one of the most common complaints amongst people in the modern world. The ability to stay focussed on a single task for a long period of time is hugely beneficial and yet has never been more difficult to achieve. Expect to learn what attention actually is and how it works, the average amount of time that people spend on a single task in the modern world, why attention is so easy to distract, whether multitasking is actually a thing, how to take back control from your distractions, how to deal with guilt around being distracted, the best way to design your daily routine for maximum focus and much more... Sponsors: Get 15% discount on Craftd London’s jewellery at https://bit.ly/cdwisdom (use code MW15) Get $100 off plus an extra 15% discount on Qualia Mind at https://neurohacker.com/modernwisdom (use code MW15) Get 10% discount on all Optimal Carnivore’s products at www.amazon.com/optimalcarnivore (use code: WISDOMSAVE10) Extra Stuff: Buy Attention Span - https://amzn.to/3HzL1ZC  Get my free Reading List of 100 books to read before you die → https://chriswillx.com/books/ To support me on Patreon (thank you): https://www.patreon.com/modernwisdom - Get in touch. Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/chriswillx Twitter: https://www.twitter.com/chriswillx YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/modernwisdompodcast Email: https://chriswillx.com/contact/  Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

    55 – How to Know When Multitasking is a Good Thing

    55 – How to Know When Multitasking is a Good Thing

    Multitasking is an ability often highlighted on resumes and celebrated in the workplace. We like to think we can juggle all the things, and do it well. We might even welcome more on our plate, label it practice. This is how we level up, enhance our performance, earn our merit. Yet before we can know when multitasking is a good thing, we must identify where it directs our focus.

    Listen in, or if you prefer to read, head on over to the blog.

    More content is available at TheUncommonNormal.com. I would also love to connect with you on social media. You may find me on Instagram, Pinterest, Facebook, and Twitter.

    If you want to live on mission but don’t know where to start, check out my brand-new devotional, Cultivating a Missional Life: A 30-Day Devotional to Gently Help You Open Your Heart, Home, and Life to Your Neighbors.

    Link mentioned:

    Around the Clock Mom by Sarah Butterfield