Logo
    Search

    Why the NHS needs Martha’s rule

    en-gbFebruary 21, 2024

    Podcast Summary

    • A mother's campaign for change after losing her daughter in the NHSMother's fight for Martha's Rule grants patients the legal right to a second medical opinion, improving patient safety and preventing similar tragedies.

      A mother's love for her daughter, lost too soon, led to a campaign for change in the NHS. Martha, a kind, bright, and original teenager, was taken from her family due to shocking mistakes in an NHS hospital. Her mother, Merope, shares her grief and longing for what could have been, as Martha was frozen in a moment, leaving her family to imagine how she would have grown. In response, Merope has fought for Martha's Rule, which grants patients the legal right to a second medical opinion if they feel their hospital treatment is not going well. This rule, backed by the government, will be implemented in English hospitals in April 2023, aiming to improve patient safety and prevent similar tragedies from occurring. The loss of Martha serves as a reminder of the importance of advocating for healthcare rights and cherishing the precious moments in life.

    • A family's unexpected journey through the UK's healthcare systemThe UK's National Health Service (NHS) proved invaluable during a family's medical crisis, demonstrating its vast resources and capabilities.

      A family's idyllic vacation took an unexpected turn when their daughter sustained a serious injury from a bike accident. Despite initial uncertainty about the severity of her injuries, they received timely care from various hospitals, ultimately ending up at a specialized unit in London. The experience highlighted the importance and significance of the UK's National Health Service (NHS), providing them with a deep appreciation for its resources and capabilities during their time of need. At the heart of the story is the family's resilience and gratitude for the care they received, despite the initial shock and fear.

    • Miscommunication between family and healthcare team leads to delayed sepsis treatment for MarthaEffective communication and collaboration between families and healthcare providers is crucial for accurate diagnosis and timely treatment.

      Despite raising concerns about Martha's deteriorating condition and suspected sepsis, the family was repeatedly reassured by medical staff, but not effectively listened to. Martha's care team, who were experienced in sepsis, provided incorrect information and kept concerns from the family, leading to a delay in appropriate treatment. This situation highlights the importance of open communication and collaboration between healthcare providers and families in ensuring the best possible care for patients. The family's experience underscores the need for healthcare professionals to prioritize transparency and trust in their interactions with patients and their loved ones.

    • Hierarchy and Ego in Healthcare: A Deadly CombinationHumility, open communication, and trust among healthcare professionals are crucial for optimal patient care. Delayed treatment due to ego and hierarchy can be life-threatening.

      Ego and hierarchy within the healthcare system can have life-threatening consequences. In the story shared, Martha, a patient, developed symptoms of sepsis, but her doctors on the "rays of sunshine" ward were reluctant to refer her to ICU due to their belief in their ability to handle the sickest patients. This resistance to collaboration led to a delay in proper treatment, which ultimately cost Martha her life. The incident highlights the importance of humility, open communication, and trust between healthcare professionals to ensure the best possible patient outcomes. It also underscores the need for a culture that values collaboration and prioritizes patient care over individual or team egos.

    • Failure to escalate concern leads to tragic consequencesMedical professionals must prioritize patient care, treat each case with urgency, communicate openly, and hold themselves accountable for mistakes.

      During the discussion, it was revealed that in instances where parents express concern about their child's health, it's common practice for medical professionals to escalate the situation. However, in the case of Martha's death, a consultant chose not to follow this protocol, which led to tragic consequences. Despite the hospital being well-funded and having available resources, key doctors involved in Martha's care have resisted taking responsibility and apologizing for their mistakes. The inquest revealed clear failings, and the hospital eventually admitted breach of duty of care. The lack of individual apologies from doctors involved was found to be galling by the family. The incident highlights the importance of prioritizing patient care and treating each case with the same level of urgency and attention, regardless of the patient's background or financial situation. The family's experience underscores the need for open communication, accountability, and a culture that encourages challenging the status quo when necessary.

    • Patient Empowerment through Martha's RuleMartha's Rule empowers patients to request urgent reviews from critical care teams, improving patient safety and care in under-resourced healthcare systems.

      Martha's Rule is a patient escalation system aimed at giving power back to patients and their families in hospitals. The rule, inspired by a tragic incident in Australia, allows patients to directly request an urgent review from a critical care outreach team. This team, composed of intensive care professionals, can assess and refer patients exhibiting concerning symptoms. The initiative gained immediate support from key figures in the UK healthcare sector and is now being implemented in hospitals. Despite facing initial concerns from doctors about potential overuse, the campaigners believe Martha's Rule will be beneficial in an under-resourced NHS and are working to get medical professionals on board.

    • New initiative Martha's Rule for patient-centered care in English hospitalsMartha's Rule empowers patients to request second opinions, improving care and safety, with minimal cost, but resistance is expected from clinicians.

      Martha's Rule, a new initiative aimed at improving patient care and safety in hospitals, is being introduced in English hospitals as a response to tragic incidents where families felt their concerns were not adequately addressed. This rule, which allows patients and families to request a second opinion from critical care outreach teams, is seen as a crucial step towards saving lives and changing the hospital culture to be more patient-centered. However, despite the evidence supporting its effectiveness and the success of its implementation in some hospitals, resistance is expected due to the instinctive belief that it will be overused. The rule is not yet widespread across England and requires the buy-in and support of clinicians to be successful. For patients, Martha's Rule offers a sense of agency and a means to challenge the status quo when they have concerns about their care. The cost of implementing Martha's Rule is minimal in hospitals where critical care outreach teams already exist, and there is evidence that it can make a significant difference in patient care.

    • Speak Up: Empowering Patients to Communicate with Their Healthcare TeamPatients should feel confident to voice concerns, and healthcare systems can promote open communication through hotlines, reporting systems, and cultural changes.

      While it's essential to trust and believe in the expertise of healthcare professionals, patients should also have the confidence to speak up if they feel something is not right. This can be particularly important in situations where a patient may feel hesitant to challenge their healthcare team. The implementation of a hotline or reporting system, along with a culture change that encourages open communication, can help address this issue. It's important to remember that healthcare providers are human, and while most are dedicated and competent, mistakes can happen. By empowering patients to speak up, we can help ensure that any issues are addressed promptly and effectively. This can lead to better outcomes for patients and a more positive healthcare experience overall. Practically, this can involve posters and other signage in hospitals and healthcare facilities, as well as clinician buy-in and support. It's a small but crucial step towards promoting open communication and ensuring that patients' voices are heard.

    • Speak up in healthcare situations, seek support during griefPatients and families should advocate for themselves in healthcare situations and lean on each other for support during grief, as shared in articles 'We Had Such Trust, We Feel Such Fools' and 'Can I Forgive Myself for My Daughter's Death?'

      Patients and their families should not hesitate to question medical decisions and seek information, even if it means looking up medical information online. This was emphasized by a doctor in the discussion. It's important to have a consistent point of contact within the healthcare system and to be aware of potential differences in treatment during weekends. Grief after losing a loved one, especially a child, is an indescribable and overwhelming experience. The loss leaves a deep impact on every aspect of life, causing feelings of guilt and unfairness. However, it's essential to lean on each other for support during these difficult times. Martha's story, shared in an article by The Guardian, serves as a reminder of the importance of speaking up and advocating for oneself in healthcare situations. The article, titled "We Had Such Trust, We Feel Such Fools," is a powerful read that sheds light on the consequences of hospital mistakes. Another article, "Can I Forgive Myself for My Daughter's Death?" by Paul Leite, also provides insight into the emotional journey of grieving parents.

    • Upgrade your wardrobe and financesShop ethically and affordably at Quince, and make informed financial decisions with Yahoo Finance

      You can upgrade your wardrobe with high-quality, ethical, and affordable clothing from Quince, while also making smart investments and staying informed about the financial markets using Yahoo Finance. Quince offers stylish options for shirts, polos, activewear, and leather goods at discounted prices, ensuring a luxury vibe without the luxury price tag. Plus, they prioritize safe, ethical, and responsible manufacturing. On the other hand, Yahoo Finance is the go-to platform for both seasoned investors and beginners, providing comprehensive financial news, analysis, and tools to help you make informed decisions and grow your wealth. By combining these two resources, you can enhance your personal style and financial strategy. Remember, you can shop for free and return items at any time when you order from Quince using the link quince.com/upgrade. And, for all your financial needs, visit yahoofinance.com.

    Recent Episodes from Today in Focus

    Rishi Sunak staggers on – but for how long?

    Rishi Sunak staggers on – but for how long?
    The prime minister is another MP down after Natalie Elphicke crossed the floor to join Labour. With the Conservatives trailing by 30 points after heavy local election losses, what options does Rishi Sunak now have? Guardian political correspondent Kiran Stacey tells Helen Pidd what these losses mean for the PM, and looks at what calculation Keir Starmer made in taking in a rightwing Tory. Help support our independent journalism at theguardian.com/infocus

    The London Bridge ‘hero’ who could go to prison for 99 years

    The London Bridge ‘hero’ who could go to prison for 99 years
    In 2019, ex-offender Marc Conway helped hold down a knifeman who killed two people in a terror attack. But by doing so he risked being recalled to prison. Simon Hattenstone reports Marc Conway risked his life to stop the London Bridge terror attack. Why did he fear being sent to prison for it?. Help support our independent journalism at theguardian.com/infocus

    Related Episodes

    Are Indian Drugs Safe? | Explain Like I'm 10

    Are Indian Drugs Safe? | Explain Like I'm 10

    In this episode of Explain Like I'm 10, our host Meghnad speaks with the co-authors of the book "The Truth Pill" Dinesh S Thakur & Prashant Reddy T. They are joined by comedian & writer Hoshang Maini who is our manifestation of a YouTube comment. Together, they discuss how safe Indian medicines are, how drugs are regulated in India, and how laws & policies can align to ensure public health security. Tune in for information you need to know before you swallow another pill!

    Follow Dinesh on Twitter: https://twitter.com/d_s_thakur?t=gD_ns2orin0eymrF2WyeKw&s=08

    Follow Prashant on Twitter: https://twitter.com/Preddy85?t=Fk-ux_EF4i6GL5Z9OX5pNw&s=08

    Follow Hoshang on Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/hoshangmaini/?igshid=YmMyMTA2M2Y%3D

    Subscribe to us on YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UC0sxICr-rvhR9dvBsx4uoTA

    Find our host Meghnad on his social handles

    YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@meghnerd

    Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/meghnads/?hl=en

    Twitter: https://twitter.com/Memeghnad?s=20&t=Gc1ww3EvNh-6TNEcFD76Pw

    LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/meghnad-s-83278a18b/?originalSubdomain=in

    Connect with us at: allaboutnow@pratilipi.com

    Know more about the book here: thetruthpill.in

     

    See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

    AI may soon use our voice to diagnose illness

    AI may soon use our voice to diagnose illness

    We humans are social animals, and we communicate a lot with our voices - much more than just in the words we speak. So if our voices can communicate emotion, can they also communicate health markers? Well, apparently so. Increasingly, AI research is looking at using AI voice analysis to diagnose everything from common colds to cancer, as well as mental health markers.

    It could be a huge opportunity in the healthcare space, but also in professional settings as a tool in the belt of HR and talent managers.

    This week, we're joined by Yaël Bensoussan, MD, Head of the Department of Otolaryngology at the Morsani College of Medicine, to find out more.

    We'd love to hear your one minute review of books which have changed your year! Simply record them on your smart device or computer and upload them using this Google form: https://forms.gle/pqsWwFwQtdGCKqED6

    Do you have a question for the expert? Ask it here using this Google form: https://forms.gle/8vzFNnPa94awARHMA

    About the expert, Yaël Bensoussan: https://www.linkedin.com/in/yael-bensoussan-3108a181

    This is Technology Now, a weekly show from Hewlett Packard Enterprise. Every week we look at a story that's been making headlines, take a look at the technology behind it, and explain why it matters to organisations and what we can learn from it.

    How AI is creating a digital twin of the human brain

    How AI is creating a digital twin of the human brain

    According to Alzheimer Disease International, there are 10 million new cases of dementia across the world every year. That’s the equivalent of a new case every 3 seconds.

    It’s a devastating disease which manifests differently in different patients, but a new and novel approach could revolutionize treatment. A team from University College London is developing a foundational AI model of the human brain, with the hope it can be trained to trial individualised treatment plans for dementia sufferers, as well as better understand the disease.

    Our guest this week is one of the project leaders. Parashkev Nachev is a Professor of Neurology at University College London. His team have been working in collaboration with HPE to create these AI-based digital twin, bringing together the best of AI and human medical expertise.

    This is Technology Now, a weekly show from Hewlett Packard Enterprise. Every week we look at a story that's been making headlines, take a look at the technology behind it, and explain why it matters to organizations and what we can learn from it.

    Do you have a question for the expert? Ask it here using this Google form: https://forms.gle/8vzFNnPa94awARHMA
    About the expert: https://www.ucl.ac.uk/ion/people/professor-parashkev-nachev

    Sources and statistics cited in this episode:
    AI methods for earlier Alzheimer's diagnosis: https://www.alzheimers.org.uk/blog/artificial-intelligence-ai-dementia
    Statistics on Alzheimer’s disease: https://www.alzint.org/about/dementia-facts-figures/dementia-statistics/#:~:text=There%20are%20over%2010%20million,new%20case%20every%203.2%20seconds 
    Precision medicine statistics: https://www.prnewswire.com/news-releases/precision-medicine-market-worth-50-2-billion--marketsandmarkets-301918806.html#:~:text=Precision%20Medicine%20Market%20in%20terms,new%20report%20by%20MarketsandMarkets%E2%84%A2.
    A wearable breast cancer screening device: https://news.mit.edu/2023/wearable-ultrasound-scanner-breast-cancer-0728