Logo

    Ex-Jehovah's Witnesses-Critical Thinkers » Critical Thought Podcast

    The "Critical Thought" presents topics that will challenge you to use critical thinking as you examine the teachings of Jehovah's Witnesses. As former teachers and members of Watchtower theology, the group known as JW.org, we have insider information to raise public awareness. Most important, we know the psychological tactics the organization uses to lure unsuspecting converts into believing its deceptive teachings.Our intent is not to bash the organization’s religious practices. We are merely conduits, sharing information about the group’s motives and operation. We are dedicated to dispelling the group’s false teachings that they plant in the minds of “the fallen.”As former members of this group, we understand how an enormous burden befalls those members who cannot maintain the pace—a burden of shame, fear, obligation and guilt, judgment and condemnation; accusations of unappreciativeness, spiritual weakness, and the inability to truly love God. Carrying this burden eventually takes its toll. We know many members who expressed a desire to leave the group. But they stayed because they feared losing close relationships with family and longtime friends. So, they put up a front, feigning their zealous commitment as faithful members of the organization. Many struggled—and continue to struggle— to maintain this charade, denying their true feelings. Their friendships are conditional, based on whether they continue as members in the organization. All the while, the leaders pretend that they are part of a big, happy family and convince members to stay the course because the end to our terrible world conditions is around the corner. If through our platform, we help a single person in anguish over his or her inability to live up to the group’s standards—unattainable standards that have nothing whatsoever to do with the Bible or loving God— or prevent unsuspecting victims from joining the group, or assist public educators to better understand their pupils, or help to mend broken family relationships, or motivate individuals to see the need to further their education – we will have succeeded.
    en155 Episodes

    People also ask

    What is the main theme of the podcast?
    Who are some of the popular guests the podcast?
    Were there any controversial topics discussed in the podcast?
    Were any current trending topics addressed in the podcast?
    What popular books were mentioned in the podcast?

    Episodes (155)

    Recovery From Our Accident - Navigating Healthcare as Ex-JWs

    Recovery From Our Accident - Navigating Healthcare as Ex-JWs

    In this heartfelt episode of "A Critical Thought," Lady Cee and JT open up about their recent journey of recovery following a car accident. They extend their deepest gratitude for the overwhelming support from the community, including well-wishes, emails, and care packages that have been a source of strength during this challenging time.

    As they navigate the path to healing, Lady Cee and JT share insightful reflections on their experiences within the healthcare system, touching on the complexities of being former Jehovah's Witnesses and the unexpected conversations that arose with medical professionals. From discussions about the Hospital Liaison Committee to the personal revelations in hospital records, this episode delves into the importance of critical thinking and the power of personal advocacy in medical settings.

    Moreover, they explore the broader implications of identity and belief systems on healthcare interactions and the significance of ensuring personal records accurately reflect one's current beliefs. This episode is not just a story of physical recovery but a testament to the resilience of the human spirit and the continuous journey of self-discovery and advocacy.

    Join Lady Cee and JT as they share their thoughts, experiences, and the lessons learned along the way. Whether you're navigating your own challenges or seeking to understand the intricate dance between personal beliefs and professional healthcare, this episode offers a compelling blend of personal stories, critical insights, and heartfelt advice.

    Support the show

    Interview with Efrain: Why I Left the Jehovah's Witness Faith

    Interview with Efrain: Why I Left the Jehovah's Witness Faith

    La Verdad al Descubierto: Efrain Revela Por Qué Dejó los Testigos de Jehová - Charla Íntima con JT y Lady Cee

    English Only Version - However be sure to visit Efrain's show on six screens of Watchtower - see details below:

    🔹 Video Description:

    In this eye-opening episode of EXJW Critical Thinker, join your host, Lady Cee, as she delves into the captivating and courageous story of Efrain. Once a devout Jehovah's Witness, Efrain embarked on a daring quest for personal freedom, challenging the beliefs he was raised with and facing the daunting task of starting anew.

    🔹 About This Episode:
    Efrain shares his deeply personal experiences - from his initial faith in the Jehovah's Witnesses to the pivotal moments that led him to seek a life beyond the religion. His story is not just about leaving a faith; it's about the resilience and strength it takes to redefine one's identity and purpose.

    🔹 Efrain's Activism:
    Beyond his personal journey, Efrain is a beacon of hope and support for others navigating similar paths. His activism work is a source of inspiration and guidance for many who find themselves in the crossroads of faith and personal freedom.

    🔹 Connect with Efrain:
    Discover more about Efrain's inspiring journey and his impactful activism by visiting his YouTube channel, OASIS Ex Testigos, at [https://www.youtube.com/@araretreat](https://www.youtube.com/@araretreat). On his channel, Efrain not only shares his personal insights and stories but also features interviews with members of the Spanish-speaking community. These interviews shed light on the diverse experiences of those who have been part of or have left the Jehovah's Witness community. Efrain's channel is a rich resource for understanding, support, and solidarity, especially for Spanish-speaking individuals navigating similar paths.

    Streaming Live
    2 Saturday's/Month @ 4:00 P.M. Central Daylight Time

    🔹 Stay Engaged:
    If Efrain's story resonates with you, or if you're seeking support and community, don't hesitate to reach out and connect with him. Remember, you're not alone in this journey.

    🔹 Support Our Channel:
    If you found this episode enlightening and empowering, please like, share, and subscribe to EXJW Critical Thinker. Your support helps us continue to bring these important stories and voices to the forefront.

    Thank you for watching, and remember, keep thinking critically and stay strong.

    Join us behind the scenes on Patreon - https://www.patreon.com/exjwcriticalthinker
     
     
    Visit us on the Web at http://www.exjwcriticalthinker.com

    SUBSCRIBE to us on YouTube http://bit.ly/2p9RTSC 
     
    Subscribe to Our Podcast: https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/ex-jehovahs-witnesses-critical-thinkers-critical-thought/id967813520
     
    Follow us on:
         Twitter https://twitter.com/ExJWsThink
         Instagram https://www.instagram.com/exjwcriticalthinker/
         Facebook https://www.facebook.com/Ex-Jehovahs-Witnesses-Critical-Thinkers-529293183758131/ 
     
    Check out our t-shirt designs: https://exjwcriticalthinker.myspreadshop.com/all 
     
    How to Contact Us
    We appreciate hearing from our viewers; however, we do not have enough staff or resources to communicate with everyone. We rarely check messages in our social media platforms (i.e., Facebook, Twitter, Instagram, etc.), therefore, if you want to reach us, email us directly at the email address listed below:
     
    ✰✰ EMAIL: 
    jtladycee@gmail.com

    Support the show

    Jehovah's Witnesses: No More Counting Field Service Hours & Placements

    Jehovah's Witnesses: No More Counting Field Service Hours & Placements

    Lady Cee and JT are back to unpack a major announcement from the Jehovah's Witness Headquarters! 🚨 "Are Jehovah's Witnesses Cancelling their Door-to-Door Proselytizing for the Rank & File?" 🚪🛑

    For countless years, knocking on doors and sharing the message has been at the heart of the Jehovah's Witnesses' outreach. But now, a significant change in reporting practices suggests a potential shift in how the rank & file engage in proselytizing. Could this be a hint at a more substantial transformation within the organization? Or is it just a modern adaptation to the changing times?

    Join us as we dive deep into the implications and motivations behind this move, explore how it may impact the perception of Jehovah's Witnesses, and discuss the broader landscape of faith outreach in today's world. 🌍💬

    Your insights and perspectives are valued! Be part of this enlightening conversation, and together, let's uncover the layers behind this development. 🧐🔍

    Want to create live streams like this? Check out StreamYard:

    Previous videos produced by EXJW Critical Thinker on the topic of counting time:

    Part 1 - Counting Time - Why Are Jehovah's Witnesses Always on the Clock?

    Part 2 - Counting Time - Why Are Jehovah's Witnesses Required to Turn in Timesheets?

    Part 3 - Counting Time - Required to Turn in Timesheets

    Part 4 – Counting Time - Jehovah's Witnesses and the Publisher Record Card

    Support the show

    Jehovah's Witnesses, We Have a Deficit - Where's My Money?

    Jehovah's Witnesses, We Have a Deficit - Where's My Money?

    In this video JT focuses on his personal experience with the the financial aspects of Jehovah's Witnesses' circuit assemblies and regional conventions. JT also discusses the lack of transparency in the organization's financial dealings, particularly at higher levels.

    Key Points:
    1. **Always in the Red**: JT mentions that circuit assemblies always seem to be running a deficit, something he questioned even as a child. He didn't understand why until he became an elder and was responsible for circuit assembly accounts.

    2. **Per Publisher Rate**: The organization charges a "per publisher rate" for every circuit assembly, guaranteeing a certain amount of money will be generated. For example, if the rate is $10 per publisher and there are 1,000 publishers, the assembly starts $10,000 in the red.

    3. **Lack of Transparency**: While local Kingdom Halls and circuit assemblies provide detailed accounts of their finances, this transparency is not extended to district or regional conventions. The organization has never disclosed how much money is collected at these larger events.

    4. **Accounting Practices**: At the local level, two people are required to count and sign off on the money collected, adhering to good accounting practices. However, this level of scrutiny is not applied at higher organizational levels.

    5. **Money Makers**: JT points out that these assemblies and conventions are significant moneymakers for the organization. Despite this, there's no clear accounting provided to the general membership about where this money goes or how it's used.

    6. **Personal Experience**: JT shares anecdotes from his time as an elder, including the pressure to meet financial targets and the lack of questioning among the elders about keeping some money in the account for future needs.

    7. **Change in Policy**: Due to instances of "borrowing" (essentially stealing), the organization changed its policy to require two people to count and sign off on any money collected, even at the smaller book study level.

    The video aims to encourage critical thinking about the financial aspects of being a Jehovah's Witness, questioning the lack of transparency and accountability in the organization's handling of funds.

    Join us behind the scenes on Patreon 

    Support the show

    Why Former Bethelite Elder Leaves the Jehovah's Witness Faith

    Why Former Bethelite Elder Leaves the Jehovah's Witness Faith

    00:00 Introduction
    06:28 1914 Generation Changes
    12:17 Separating the Sheep & the Goats (changed)
    13:04 Alternative Military Service EXJW Critical Thinker Classics


    August 15, 1998 Watchtower
    Article: Strengthening Our Confidence in God’s Righteousness
    https://wol.jw.org/en/wol/d/r1/lp-e/1998604

    Located under the subheading - Feelings of Having Suffered Needlessly


    Join us behind the scenes on Patreon

    Visit us on the Web 

    SUBSCRIBE to us on YouTube

    Subscribe to Our Podcast

    Support the show

    From Faith to Freedom: Meet Phylice, She's Totally Awake

    From Faith to Freedom: Meet Phylice, She's Totally Awake

    Join us in this heartfelt and eye-opening episode of the Critical Thought Podcast, as we sit down with Phylice (https://www.youtube.com/@totallyawakeexjw), who courageously shares her journey 'From Faith to Freedom.' Phylice takes us through her awakening from the Jehovah's Witnesses, a journey fraught with personal challenges, probing questions, and intimate revelations.

    She recounts the painful experience of being disfellowshipped, privately reproved, and subjected to judicial meetings, where elders demanded personal details about the sins she confessed. But Phylice's story is not just one of struggle; it's one of triumph and love as well.

    During a life-changing visit to her cousin in Colorado, Phylice met her future husband, a dedicated Military man who became the catalyst for her ultimate liberation from the faith. Together, they navigated the complex and painful process of cutting ties with the Jehovah's Witness community.

    But Phylice's journey didn't end there. She opens up about the struggles of being shunned by her family, the painful decision to write a letter of disassociation, and the emotional toll it took on her. Yet, through it all, she found strength, resilience, and a new life of authenticity and joy.

    Tune in to hear Phylice's inspiring story, filled with lessons of courage, self-discovery, and the pursuit of true freedom. Whether you're familiar with the Jehovah's Witness faith or just intrigued by tales of personal transformation, Phylice's story will touch your heart and inspire your spirit.

    Support the show

    Meet Daria! Your Best Free Therapy Session After Leaving the Jehovah's Witnesses

    Meet Daria! Your Best Free Therapy Session After Leaving the Jehovah's Witnesses

    👋 Welcome to another eye-opening episode that you simply can't afford to miss. Today, we have a special guest who embodies the spirit of resilience and healing—meet Daria.

    🛑 Stop whatever you're doing and listen up. Daria's not just any guest; she's your best *free therapy session* after leaving Jehovah's Witnesses. 

    🌱 **About Daria:**  
    She's brave and candid, opening up about the tough choices she had to make—leaving, fading, and doing whatever it took to reclaim her life. Despite walking away from the organization, she hasn't lost her faith.

    🤔 **Know Thyself:**  
    Daria emphasizes the importance of self-discovery after leaving. According to her, healing is a journey, not a destination. Take your time to get to know the *real you* outside the confines of your past life.

    💔 **Life Happens:**  
    It wasn't all smooth sailing. Daria overcame toxic relationships and even battled cancer. Her experiences have given her the kind of therapeutic wisdom that's far more valuable than any textbook can offer.

    🙌 **Why You Must Watch:**  
    Whether you're just thinking about leaving, in the process, or years into your new life, Daria's insights will resonate. Get ready for a transformative talk that might just be the therapy session you didn't know you needed.

    👇 Hit that 'Subscribe' button to stay updated on more therapeutic conversations and healing stories. Your new life starts here!

    Support the show

    Jehovah's Witness Elder Facing Mortality: Regrets After 40 Years of Shunning His Daughter

    Jehovah's Witness Elder Facing Mortality: Regrets After 40 Years of Shunning His Daughter

    In this deeply moving and revealing episode, Gail shares her heart-wrenching story of being shunned by her father, an Elder in the Jehovah's Witness congregation, for 40 long years. Facing his mortality, her father calls her to his side, where he opens up about his regrets and the choices that kept them apart for so long.

    Through Gail's powerful narration and a candid exploration of belief, family, and forgiveness, viewers will journey with her as she uncovers the painful truths hidden beneath years of silence. But just when you think you've heard it all, a shocking twist awaits. You'll want to watch until the very end to discover the full impact of this emotional tale.

    This episode is not just about a father and daughter's reunion; it's a universal story about the complexity of faith, the consequences of our choices, and the healing power of reconciliation. Join us as we delve into Gail's story, offering a unique glimpse into the often-misunderstood world of the Jehovah's Witnesses, and learn about the profound impact that shunning can have on individuals and families.

    This is a story of loss, love, regret, and redemption that you won't want to miss. Make sure to watch until the end for a revelation that will leave you speechless.

    Support the show

    Jehovah's Witnesses - How Much Do You Care About Children? Hear Lucille's Account of Reporting Child CSA

    Jehovah's Witnesses - How Much Do You Care About Children? Hear Lucille's Account of Reporting Child CSA

    In this powerful video, we share the compelling story of Lucille, a brave individual who took decisive steps to report a case of Child CSA (Child Sexual Abuse). As a former Jehovah's Witness, Lucille faced an incredibly challenging situation but demonstrated unwavering determination to protect the innocent and advocate for justice. 

    With immense courage, Lucille first contacted Child Protective Services, knowing the gravity of her responsibility in safeguarding the vulnerable child involved. Recognizing the urgency of the situation, she sought professional intervention to ensure the safety and well-being of the young victim. 

    Additionally, Lucille also felt compelled to address the matter and decided to approach the Elders at the local Kingdom Hall to raise awareness and demand appropriate action. This decision was a significant step in holding those responsible accountable and reinforcing the importance of protecting children within the congregation. 

    Furthermore, Lucille's journey did not end there. She realized the necessity of reporting the incident to the higher authorities within the Jehovah's Witnesses organization. Understanding the significance of collective efforts in combating such issues, she reached out to The Watchtower Bible & Tract Society, seeking transparency, accountability, and changes to prevent future occurrences. 

    Lucille's experience serves as an inspiring example of how individuals can take proactive measures to protect children from the horrors of abuse, even within complex institutional structures. Her unwavering commitment to justice and child protection resonates as a beacon of hope and encouragement for others who may find themselves in similar circumstances. 

    Join us in watching this empowering video as Lucille recounts her journey of courage, resilience, and advocacy, inspiring viewers to be part of the solution and work towards a safer environment for all children. Let us stand united in the fight against Child CSA and create a world where every child's innocence is safeguarded.

    Support the show

    Jehovah's Witnesses: The Special Treatment of Anthony Morris!

    Jehovah's Witnesses: The Special Treatment of Anthony Morris!


    In this episode, we uncover a significant revelation surrounding the Watchtower Bible and Tract Society's recent housing acquisition for former Governing Body member, Anthony Morris, and his wife. Public records have brought to light the organization's purchase of a brand new home for the couple, with a unique arrangement allowing them to reside there for their lifetime before ownership reverts back to the Watchtower.

    We delve into the concerning disparities between this treatment and the experiences of rank and file Bethelites. While Anthony Morris received this apparent generosity, many others were asked to leave without any monetary support, raising questions about fairness within the organization.

    Join us as we discuss this sensitive topic and examine the implications of such actions. The episode offers an insightful exploration of the perceived double standard within the Watchtower, providing a platform for viewers to reflect on the situation and share their perspectives.

    Remember to like and subscribe to stay informed about the Jehovah's Witnesses community and other thought-provoking content. Your engagement helps foster open discussions and awareness. Let's explore these complex issues together, shedding light on the matters that deserve our attention.

    Reference

    Originating Video - Blue Envelope https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GW4IDrB0xG4&t=285s

    Support the show

    New Charges Unveiled: Five Additional Jehovah's Witnesses Indicted for CSA in Pennsylvania

    New Charges Unveiled: Five Additional Jehovah's Witnesses Indicted for CSA in Pennsylvania

    In this episode, we discuss the recent indictments within the Jehovah's Witnesses organization involving child sexual abuse. We provide a summary of the charges and the individuals involved, emphasizing the disturbing nature of the cases. We highlight the role of an investigative grand jury in reviewing the evidence and recommending the charges. Additionally, we address the challenges survivors face within the organization due to its policies and secrecy surrounding judicial matters. 

    The episode covers the announcement and the hosts' commentary on the recent indictments within the Jehovah's Witnesses organization. It aims to shed light on the gravity of the situation and the difficulties survivors may encounter within the organization.

    Resources:

    1. MSN: "Five Men from Jehovah's Witnesses Charged with Child Sexual Abuse: Attorney General" - In this video report, learn about the indictments and charges brought against five individuals associated with Jehovah's Witnesses in Pennsylvania.
      Link: Watch the video
    2. NBC Philadelphia: "Charges Probe Child Sexual Abuse Among Jehovah's Witnesses in Pennsylvania" - Read this article for a comprehensive overview of the ongoing investigation and charges related to child sexual abuse within the Jehovah's Witnesses organization.
      Link: Read the article
    Support the show

    Why Jehovah's Witnesses Don't Celebrate Mother's Day

    Why Jehovah's Witnesses Don't Celebrate Mother's Day

    Links to References

    Gregorian Calendar

    https://www.thecenterforruleoflaw.org/rule-of-law-blog/october-4-1582-the-gregorian-calendar-is-introduced-by-pope-gregory-xiii

    Golden Age (aka Awake! Magazine)
    March 13, 1935 
    March 27, 1935
    April 10, 1935

    calendar [photo]

    1935 yearbook page 168

    Calendar - Tool of Satan  March 1st 1935 page 80

    https://www.jw.org/en/library/magazines/g20030922/The-Pi%C3%B1ata-An-Ancient-Tradition/




    Support the show

    Struggles of Jehovah's Witness Youths - Should I Regular Pioneer After High School

    Struggles of Jehovah's Witness Youths - Should I Regular Pioneer After High School

    In this podcast, Ryan shares his experience on what it was like making choices as a young person graduating from high school. Unfortunately, the advice given by the elders in the congregation left him feeling helpless and hopeless when they begin encouraging him to regular pioneer.

    After taking the advice of the elders, Ryan chose to regular pioneer but quickly realized that he was unable to pay his bills. He was just struggling to survive.  Fortunately, Ryan woke up and began to reexamine his situation. 

    Perhaps you have had a similar experience where you gave up dreams, goals and aspirations to please the brothers in your local congregation. This happens all too many times where young people make decisions that drastically affect their ability to take care of their material needs much later in life. And, as Ryan discusses in this video, he was struggling to make ends meet every day.

    We hope this presentation will help you to think about your own career choices as you begin to navigate the waters in the "real world".

    Support the show

    Navigating the Watchtower Judicial Process: Six Reporting Guidelines for Elders

    Navigating the Watchtower Judicial Process: Six Reporting Guidelines for Elders

    In this episode, we explore six important instructions given to elders during the Kingdom Ministry Schools regarding the Watchtower judicial process. These guidelines aim to maintain confidentiality and uphold the authority of the organization. We delve into each instruction, discussing its significance and potential impact on the judicial proceedings. Join us as we examine the reasons behind these reporting restrictions and their implications for the decision-making process within the congregation. Whether you're a current or former Jehovah's Witness or simply interested in understanding the inner workings of religious organizations, this episode offers valuable insights into the Watchtower judicial system.

    Join us behind the scenes on Patreon - https://www.patreon.com/exjwcriticalthinker 

    Support the show

    Eva's Story - My Family Survived the Holocaust

    Eva's Story - My Family Survived the Holocaust

    Eva is from upstate New York and one of eight siblings. She was a fifth generation Jehovah's Witness and her parents and grand parents her Holocaust survivors. All her siblings are still active in the organization. Eva has over twenty years’ experience in accounting and has decades of experience in investigating retail financial fraud and management. Eva is an advocate for individuals struggling with leaving high control religions and supporting their efforts to rejoin society. Eva has a commitment in life to be a compassionate Christian and have love for all individuals.

    WITNESSING FREEDOM
    https://witnessingfreedom.org/

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kindertransport_%E2%80%93_The_Arrival
    https://kindertransport-memorial.org/
    https://www.hmd.org.uk/learn-about-the-holocaust-and-genocides/the-holocaust/kindertransport-refugees/

    RECOVERING FROM SPIRITUAL ABUSE
    David Henke
    https://www.amazon.com/Spiritual-Abuse-Recovery-Workbook-educational-ebook/dp/B09CF1FK4R

    Nicky & Vera: A Quiet Hero of the Holocaust and the Children He Rescued
    https://www.amazon.com/Nicky-Vera-Holocaust-Children-Rescued/dp/1324015748


    Join us behind the scenes on Patreon - https://www.patreon.com/exjwcriticalthinker

    Check out our videos on why we left the Why We Left the Jehovah's Witnesses

    https://youtu.be/rqYUCV4FHI4
    https://youtu.be/bLaSB9P2MEE

    Visit us on the Web at http://www.exjwcriticalthinker.com

    SUBSCRIBE to us on YouTube http://bit.ly/2p9RTSC

    Subscribe to Our Podcast: https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/ex-jehovahs-witnesses-critical-thinkers-critical-thought/id967813520

    Follow us on:
         Twitter https://twitter.com/ExJWsThink
         Instagram https://www.instagram.com/exjwcriticalthinker/
         Facebook https://www.facebook.com/Ex-Jehovahs-Witnesses-Critical-Thinkers-529293183758131/

    Check out our t-shirt designs: https://exjwcriticalthinker.myspreadshop.com/all 
     
    How to Contact Us
    We appreciate hearing from our viewers; however, we do not have enough staff or resources to communicate with everyone. We rarely check messages in our social media platforms (i.e., Facebook, Twitter, Instagram, etc.), therefore, if you want to reach us, email us directly at the email address listed below:
     
    ✰✰ EMAIL: 
    jtladycee@gmail.com

    Support the show

    Meet June & Jared and Learn how their family faded from the Jehovah's Witness Faith

    Meet June & Jared and Learn how their family faded from the Jehovah's Witness Faith

    #exjw #JehovahWitness #exjwcriticalthinker

    In this episode, you will meet June and Jared from the YouTube channel JUST JUNE:
    https://www.youtube.com/@justjune9517

    Learn how Jared and his children allow themselves to speak freely about how they feel about being one of Jehovah's Witnesses. They make changes to their dress & grooming and something even more profound, their attitude about the religion as a whole. All of this is taking place and unfolding during the time June is in a rehab for 30 days. 

    In fact, June begins to take notice of the subtle changes during their weekly visits with her at her facility.

    Find out what happens and how they are able to finally get June, to wake up and see the fallacies of the Watchtower, Bible & Tract Society.

    Support the show