Gank That Drank: A Supernatural Drinking Game Podcast

Grab your robe and slippers, night owls, because tonight we're dishing all the deets on the recent Supernatural episode that had more twists than a pretzel factory! Leave your disbelief at the door, because this week the Winchester bros battled freaky fairies masquerading as little green men. Cue the alien autopsy gags! But the real star of this show was Soulless Sam, whose sassy comebacks and snarky attitude delivered more laughs than a stand-up special. Watching Dean try to teach morality to his soulless sibling? Comedy gold! The creepy leprechaun trying to tempt Sam with getting his soul back provided spooky thrills, but the real horror came when Dean nuked a fairy with the microwave! Yikes. At least they stopped the nasty creatures by spilling salt and forcing them to count each tiny grain. As always, thanks for listening faithful fans! Until next time, remember – the truth is out there, but sometimes it's wearing green tights and pointy shoes!

This Week, Nate and Chrissy drink and discuss the comedic adventure where cartoon physics invades a small town.

We're diving into a world where the Grim Reaper meets the Giggle Factory. Imagine Sam, Dean, and Castiel tiptoeing through a landscape of cartoonish calamities, complete with anvils and improbable escapes—yep, we're talking about that kind of episode! We're gonna appreciate the masterful mix of edge-of-your-seat drama and laugh-out-loud absurdity.

Hold onto your hats because "Detective Cass" is on the case! Castiel’s side-splitting transformation into a gumshoe is nothing short of a comedic gem, and we're here for it. We'll also tiptoe down memory lane with Sam as he gets flashbacks to a slice of normality with Amelia, giving us a peek into the life that could have been.

As we explore the whimsical world of escapism and alternate realities, we'll chat about how sometimes, we all just need to press pause on the real world and play in a cartoon for a while. 

And of course, we can't gloss over the belly laughs delivered by the dynamic duo, Misha Collins and Jensen Ackles, whose comedic timing is as spot-on as a Road Runner escape. We'll dissect our favorite cartoon antics, the visual gags that had us in stitches, and the hilariously bizarre rules that govern this animated universe. 

Sure, we'll scratch our heads together at the villain’s motivations—which make about as much sense as a talking sponge—but it's all in good fun. 

So, as we wrap up, let's just say this episode achieved the impossible: blending the tones of suspense and silliness into a deliciously entertaining diversion that had us both on the edge of our seats and falling off them with laughter. Tune in, and let's get animated!

In this episode, hosts Nate and Krissy drink and discuss the flashback-heavy story showing Sam and Dean undercover at their old high school in Season 4, Episode 13: After School Special.

That’s right, young Sam and Dean investigate ghostly happenings at Truman High this week!

Appreciate the rules playing off the many flashbacks to the brothers' school days!

Note inappropriate behavior and outdated mindsets now seen as problematic!

Ok, so there are some complex themes around bullying, violence, guilt and the cycle of hurt people hurting people. We have to question some moral implications in the brothers' actions and the tone of this episode. Does it hold up?

We have a blast highlighting the fun moments like Dean teaching dodgeball in tiny shorts but the  main ghost plot unexpectedly dark for a lighthearted framing. Character motivations and the ending's emotional impact are worth a healthy debate but the bottom line: We love the rules and the flashbacks! It’s a monster-of-the-week story structured around looking into the Winchesters' early days and it still plays!

Get ready to feel the festive spirit in the latest episode of Gank That Drank! This time, Krissy and Nate have brought out all the stops to celebrate a Very Supernatural Christmas. 

The episode takes us back to 2007 as Sam and Dean exchange gifts, a magical amulet, and a broken Barbie doll, and we get all the feels. In the present day, Dean grapples with this being his last Christmas ever while Sam tries to make it bright and cheerful. 

But what's a Christmas episode without a holiday drinking game? Get ready for some festive hammering with rules for flashing back, sentimental scenes, meadowsweet wreaths, jingling tunes, and doorbells. According to Krissy, this super robust game conjures up some 46 drinks! So, drink ye merry people, while there's still time!

The episode also covers some jolly topics, including the sweet yet sinister pagan gods, Edward and Madge, the perpetual grayness of Ypsilanti, Michigan, Dean's lack of knowledge about Dick Van Dyke, Christmas porn, drug paraphernalia, impaling gods with Christmas tree branches, and the real meaning of Christmas: family.

So, get yourself some eggnog or peppermint schnapps and have a merry little drinking game with Gank That Drank!

In this episode, Nate and Krissy enjoy some drinks while recapping the story of Mrs. Butters, a wood nymph who takes care of the bunker. It's a unique bottle episode where a new character joins Team Free Will for some holiday hijinks in Supernatural Season 15, Episode 14: Last Holiday.

They appreciate the humor and levity that Mrs. Butters brings, including exotic smoothies and decorated bunkers. However, her swift changes in opinion about Jack highlight her unstable nature. The hosts analyze her motivations, backstory reveal, and inconsistencies. They also touch on the episode’s themes of enjoying life while fighting the good fight.

Jensen Ackles as Dean brings great comedic moments to the episode as he fully embraces the festivities. They note the Men of Letters’ poor treatment of Mrs. Butters in the past and question some plot holes in the group’s strategy with her. They also recall other instances of the show’s holiday episodes, discuss their favorite rules, and count their occurrence.

Overall, it's a delightful one-off story that provides some laughter before the season finale stretch. The hosts also look ahead to the classic season three Christmas episode “A Very Supernatural Christmas.”

Let's do the time warp again with Gank That Drank's tubular recap of Supernatural's radical time travel episode "Time After Time." Our bodacious hosts Nate and Krissy hop in the DeLorean to recap this totally gnarly episode where Dean goes back to 1944. Righteous!

The hosts give us the 411 on this freaky episodio where Sam and Sheriff Jody "McFly" Mills have to help Dean get back from the past. Heavy!

Majorly Important Points:

• Dean teaming up with the swingin' Eliot Ness in 1944 is most triumphant!
• They use some primo time jumping between the years - it's wild!
• Jody and Sam's research sesh in 2012 is a party on, dudes.
• There's some seriously funny time travel and pop culture references all over this episode. We dig it.
• They lay down some themes about fate vs free will - deep stuff, man.

Other Tubular Topics:

• We get stoked on the bodacious guest stars like Nicholas Lea as Ness.
• There's some kooky plot holes but we don't harsh our mellow.
• Dean's snazzy vintage garb makes him look most excellent.
• Seeing awesome recurring chars like Jody is always a thrillsville choice.

Like, this episode is a wicked fun bottle episode, dudes. Up next is "The Last Holiday" - the first rad Jack drinking ep! Hang loose!

In this fun episode, Nate and Krissy discuss the Season 4 episode of Supernatural called "It's a Terrible Life" where Sam and Dean find themselves in an alternate corporate reality. It’s a unique "bottle episode" where the Winchesters work normal office jobs. 

The highlight of the episode is Dean's portrayal as a well-respected executive, complete with NPR and golf. We also see Sam's dreams and Dean's skepticism about ghosts and hunting. After some coworkers meet grizzly deaths, the brothers investigate the supernatural happenings, taking a trip to the ominous Room 1444, taking on a ghost, and doing research with a familiar group's videos. They later discover that Zachariah put them in this scenario to teach them a lesson.

Nate and Krissy also provide enjoyable commentary on creative death scenes, the horror elements around Halloween time, and some entertaining plot holes and logistics questions. They also note the outdated use of "walkie-talkie mode" on a cell phone. Additionally, they share their general impressions, favorite moments, and ratings of the episode.

Overall, this is a great bottle episode that plays with the themes of fate and identity in an amusing way. Nate and Krissy look forward to the next drinking episode "Time After Time."

Get ready for your close-up, we're making a movie on this week's Gank That Drank: A Supernatural Drinking Game Podcast. Nate and Krissy create and play along with drinking game rules while recapping this favorite episode of our favorite show, Supernatural! It's season 8, episode 4: "Bitten", a "Boys Light" Halloween episode.

IMDB Says: Sam and Dean come across a home made video of three friends whose lives are turned upside down by a werewolf.

DRINKING GAME RULES FOR SEASON 8 EPISODE 4 "BITTEN"

• TAKE A DRINK ANYTIME THERE IS TOXIC MASCULINITY
• LOOK, ITS THE BOYS!
• TAKE A DRINK WHEN THE BOYS APPEAR
• THERE IS A SHOT IN A MIRROR
• THERE IS KISSING
• SOMEONE REFERENCES THE MOVIE THEY ARE MAKING
• BROKEN FURNITURE
• SOMEONE DIES
• FINISH YOUR DRINK AS THE OPENING CREDITS PLAY AT THE END OF THE EPISODE

It's time to slice and dice on Gank That Drank: A Supernatural Drinking Game Podcast! Nate and Krissy create and play along with drinking game rules while recapping this favorite episode of our favorite show, Supernatural! It's season 14, episode 4: "Mint Condition"

IMDB Says: Dean continues to struggle, and then Sam has to think when action figures come to life and Dean finds himself inside a real-life horror movie. Starring Jared Padalecki & Jensen Ackles

DRINKING GAME RULES FOR SEASON 14 EPISODE 4 "MINT CONDITION"

• TAKE A DRINK ANYTIME SOMEONE SAYS
• "TIME TO SLICE AND DICE"
• PANTHRO GOES PSYCHO SOMEONE SAYS "HALLOWEEN"
• SOMEONE SAYS "TRICK OR TREAT"
• THERE IS A "BM" (BOY MELODRAMA) SCENE
• TAKE A SHOT OR DOUBLE DRINK WHEN DEAN SAYS "IT'S LIKE A DOLPHIN'S BELLY"

Welcome to Gank That Drank: A Supernatural Drinking Game Podcast! Be careful what you wish for in today's episode because nothing is what you expect. Nate and Krissy create and play along with drinking game rules while recapping this favorite episode of our favorite show, Supernatural! It’s season 4, episode 8: "Wishful Thinking." 

IMDB Says: Sam and Dean investigate when a small town's wishing well actually starts to grant the people's wishes. Starring Jared Padalecki & Jensen Ackles

DRINKING GAME RULES FOR S4E8 "WISHFUL THINKING"

THE THEMED MOTEL ROOM RULE- ALL RULES ARE DOUBLED FOR THIS GAME

TAKE A DRINK ANYTIME...

• THERE IS A POP CULTURE REFERENCE
• SOMEONE SAYS "SON OF A BITCH"
• SOMEONE SAYS "WHAT THE HELL IS GOING ON IN THIS TOWN"
• SOMEONE SAYS "I LOVE YOU MORE THAN ANYTHING"
• A COIN GOES INTO OR OUT OF THE FOUNTAIN
• DEAN EATS OR DRINKS
• SOMEONE SAYS "BE CAREFUL WHAT YOU WISH FOR"
• DEAN DREAMS
• DEAN CALLS SAM "SAMMY"
• DOUBLE DRINK OR TAKE A SHOT WHEN SOMEONE SAYS "KNEEL BEFORE TODD!"

Oh no, we're stuck in a time loop! Nate and Krissy create and play along with drinking game rules while recapping this favorite episode of our favorite show, Supernatural! It's season 3, episode 11: Mystery Spot.

IMDB Says: Sam relives the same day over and over, continually having to deal with Dean's death, starring Jared Padalecki & Jensen Ackles & Richard Speight Jr. & Jim Beaver

First, the rules:

TAKE A DRINK ANYTIME

• "HEAT OF THE MOMENT"
• WATERFALL AS DEAN GARGLES
• SAMMY CATCHES THE HOT SAUCE
• AN X-FILES REFERENCE
• SYRUP SWAP
• REVEAL THE TRICKSTER
• YOU HEAR HUEY LEWIS AND THE NEWS
• BOBBY CALLS

It's an episode of Gank That Drank: A Supernatural Drinking Game Podcast where the imaginary is real and really really in danger! Nate and Krissy create and play along with drinking game rules while recapping this favorite episode of our favorite show, Supernatural! It’s season 11, episode 8: "Just My Imagination."

IMDB Says: “Sam is shocked when his imaginary childhood friend, Sully, makes an unexpected appearance. Sam tries to understand why he is seeing Sully now. Even more surprising, Dean can see him too.”

Starring Jared Padalecki & Jensen Ackles

DRINKING GAME RULES FOR S11 E8 "JUST MY IMAGINATION"

• THERE IS A "ZANNA"CIDAL ATTACK
• THERE IS A FLASHBACK
• DEAN IS INDIGNANT
• CAGE TALK
• POP CULTURE REFERENCES BY DEAN
• CHUG DURING THE AIR GUITAR SOLO

Are we all monsters, deep down? Get ready for an episode of Gank That Drank: A Supernatural Drinking Game Podcast where things are black and white! Nate and Krissy create and play along with drinking game rules while recapping this favorite episode of our favorite show, Supernatural! its S4E5 "Monster Movie"

IMBD says: “It's Halloween time, and the Winchesters face off against a shapeshifter with a penchant for impersonating classic movie monsters like Dracula, the Wolfman, and the Mummy.”

Starring Jared Padalecki & Jensen Ackles

DRINKING GAME RULES FOR S4 E5 MONSTER MOVIE

• TAKE A DRINK ANYTIME...
• SOMEONE SAYS "MONSTER"
• THERE'S A SMOOCHY NAPKIN
• THE BOYS GIVE THEIR AGENT NAMES
• SOMEONE SAYS "VAMPIRE"
• A BIG PRETZEL
• COMICALLY LARGE CUPS
• DEAN DISCUSSES BEING "RE-HYMENATED"
• A MONSTER KILLS
• A TINY BUCKET
• DRAC ON A SCOOTER
• WATERFALL DURING INTERMISSION
• THE VILLAIN MONOLOGUES
• SOMEONE SAYS, "GANK"

Dust off your creepiest haunted mask for this episode of Gank That Drank: A Supernatural Drinking Game Podcast! Nate and Krissy create and play along with drinking game rules while recapping this favorite episode of our favorite show, Supernatural! It’s season 11, episode 7: "Plush"

IMDB Says: Sheriff Donna calls Sam and Dean for help after a horrific murder with supernatural elements happens in her town. Sam continues to have visions and asks God for help, which frustrates Dean

Starring Jared Padalecki & Jensen Ackles & Briana Buckmaster

DRINKING GAME RULES

TAKE A DRINK ANYTIME...

• THERE IS A MASK ATTACK
• DONNA DOES DONNA-ISMS
• DONNA DOES DOUG DIGS
• SOMEONE HAS TO STAY IN A SALT CIRCLE
• RABBIT PUNS
• PRAYER TALK

Get your LARP gear together for this episode of Gank That Drank: A Supernatural Drinking Game Podcast!  Nate and Krissy create and play along with drinking game rules while recapping this favorite episode of our favorite show, Supernatural! It’s season 5, episode 9: "The Real Ghostbusters"

IMDB Says: Dean and Sam are at a Supernatural convention where they meet lots of fans of the Supernatural Books. After a while, they get the impression that something is not right at the location of the convention.

Starring Jared Padalecki & Jensen Ackles & Rob Benedict featuring Devin Ratray, Ernie Grunwald, and Emily Perkins.

DRINKING GAME RULES

TAKE A DRINK 

• WHEN THE PANELS ARE ANNOUNCED
• WHEN WE SEE A "YELLOW EYE COOLER"
• WHEN SOMEONE SAYS "LARP" OR "LARPING"
• ANYONE GIVES AGENT NAMES, DOUBLE IT IF YOU KNOW THE BAND REFERENCE
• "NAUGHTY, NAUGHTY, NAUGHTY!"
• A GHOST SIGHTING
• "CHUCKLES"
• ANYONE SALT AND BURNS BONES

TAKE A SHOT OR DOUBLE DRINK 

• WHEN SOMEONE SAYS "THATS WHAT SAM AND DEAN WOULD DO"

Time travel is suddenly on the menu at Gank That Drank: A Supernatural Drinking Game Podcast! Square up at high noon with Nate and Krissy as they create and play along with drinking game rules while recapping this favorite episode of our favorite show, Supernatural! It's Season 6, Episode 18: "Frontierland."

IMDB says: Castiel sends Sam and Dean back in time to 1861 to collect the ashes of a phoenix. Starring Jared Padalecki & Jensen Ackles

DRINKING GAME RULES FOR SEASON S6E18 "Frontierland"

• TAKE A DRINK
• WHEN THERE IS A RESEARCH MUSIC MONTAGE
• ANYTIME DEAN GEEKS OUT OR IS DISSAPOINTED IN THE OLD WEST
• TAKE A DRINK ANYTIME THERE IS A HAT TIP
• SOMEONE DIES
• SWINGING DOORS SWING
• SOMEONE SAYS "GANK"
• TAKE A SHOT OR DOUBLE DRINK ANYTIME SOMEONE MENTIONS WALKER, TEXAS RANGER
• TAKE A SIP FOR A POP CULTURE REFERENCE

It's time for a wedding on Gank That Drank: A Supernatural Drinking Game Podcast! Take a walk down the aisle with Nate and Krissy as they create and play along with drinking game rules while recapping this favorite episode of our favorite show, Supernatural! It's season seven, episode eight: Time for a Wedding!

Play along with Krissy Lenz and Nate McWhortor of the Neighborhood Comedy Theatre as they create drinking game rules and recap one of the oddest and most out-of-body episodes of Supernatural.

IMDB Says: Sam runs into Becky and they end up getting married. Dean finds it suspicious that Sam is falling for her and decides to investigate.

Starring Jared Padalecki & Jensen Ackles, featuring guest stars Emily Perkins, Leslie Odom Jr & DJ Qualls.

DRINKING GAME RULES

• TAKE 1 DRINK ANYTIME....
• SOMEONE CALLS SAM "BABY BRO"
• CAKESPLOSION
• SAM GETS SPELLY
• SOMEONE DIES (DOUBLE IT IF YOU DONT KNOW THEIR NAME)
• AN OZ REFERENCE
• DEMON EYES
• A CAR THATS NOT BABY APPEARS
• GARTH DOES GARTH
• CROWLEY MONOLOGUE
• ANYTIME SOMEONE SAYS "GANK"
• A BM ( BOY MELODRAMA ) SCENE

Play along with Krissy Lenz and Nate McWhorter of the Neighborhood Comedy Theatre as they create drinking game rules and recap one of the oddest and most out-of-body episodes of Supernatural: It's season nine, episode nine: Dog Dean Afternoon.

IMDB says: When the only witness to a couple of mysterious murders is a dog, Dean performs a risky spell to help him communicate with canines.

Starring Jared Padalecki & Jensen Ackles.

Drinking Game Rules

• DRINKING GAME RULES FOR DOG DEAN AFTERNOON S9E5
• TAKE A DRINK ANYTIME
• SOMEONE OR SOMETHING DIES
• THE BOYS MAKE A WRONG GUESS OF WHAT THE BAD GUY IS
• SOMEONE USES THE ACRONYM S.N.A.R.T.
• "DOUCHE" IS SAID IN COMBINATION WITH ANY OTHER WORD
• VAGUE ZEKE TALK
• DEAN DOES DOG THINGS
• PUNS!
• TAKE A SHOT/ FINISH YOUR DRINK
• FREEDOM!
• ZEKE APPEARS

Krissy and Nate of the Neighborhood Comedy Theatre explore one of the most awesomely meta and referential monster of the week episodes of the show Supernatural. IMDB Says: Sam and Dean hit the road to help an old friend, but it appears that their luck may have finally run out, and they are the ones who may be in need of rescue.

Starring Jared Padalecki & Jensen Ackles & DJ Qualls.

Drinking Game Rules

• TAKE A DRINK ANYTIME
• GARTH WOLFS OUT
• SOMEONE SAYS "NORMAL"
• SAMMY SNEEZES
• DEAN SAYS "SERIOUSLY"
• BABY BREAKS DOWN
• "MOMMY, THE GIANT IS CRYING"
• "YOU NEED A COLONOSCOPY, STAT!"
• YOU SEE THE FAMOUS MUGSHOT
• BM (BOY MELODRAMA) SCENE
• FINISH YOUR DRINK DURING A DANCE NUMBER

We're not in Kansas anymore, but Gank That Drank: A Supernatural Drinking Game Podcast will still have you feeling like there is no place like home. Let’s take a walk down the yellow brick path with Nate and Krissy of the Neighborhood Comedy Theater as they create and play along with drinking game rules while recapping one of the most awesomely meta and self-referential monster-of-the-week episodes of the show Supernatural. It’s S9 E4: "Slumber Party."

IMDB Says: “Sam and Dean accidentally free Dorothy, who has been trapped in the bunker for years, who seeks their help in killing the wicked witch.”

Starring Jared Padalecki & Jensen Ackles & Felicia Day

"SLUMBER PARTY" DRINKING GAME RULES 

• LIGHTS ON - Take 1 drink anytime someone turns the lights on
• SAMMY - Take 1 drink anytime Dean calls Sam Sammy or Sam corrects his name
• SOMEONE DIES - Take 1 drink anytime a character dies, double it if you know their name
• OZ REFERENCE - Take 1 drink anytime there is a pop culture reference to OZ, Wicked, etc
• POPPY BULLET- Take 1 drink anytime a poppy bullet is shot
• BM SCENE / MOMENT - Take 1 drink during any "Boy Melodrama" Scene or Moment (include Charlie & Dorothy)
• THE WITCH IS BEHIND YOU - Take 1 shot for a jump scare
• SHOTS / 2 Drinks
  • ZEKE APPEARS
  • WE SALUTE YOU