Logo

    Magical Mystery Hour

    Mysterious real-life stories and the music it inspires. Hosts Amanda Benjamin and Paul Carganilla welcome you a show in which we explore mysteries of the unknown. In this live-stream-and-podcast, we tell tales of the paranormal and unsolved… while mixing in a little fun and live music, as well. Join us as we discuss ghosts, aliens, conspiracies, true crime, and more! This bi-weekly podcast mixes great tales and tunes. We hope you enjoy the Magical Mystery Hour!
    en-us27 Episodes

    People also ask

    What is the main theme of the podcast?
    Who are some of the popular guests the podcast?
    Were there any controversial topics discussed in the podcast?
    Were any current trending topics addressed in the podcast?
    What popular books were mentioned in the podcast?

    Episodes (27)

    Time Slips - The Queen Mary & Abandoned House

    Time Slips - The Queen Mary & Abandoned House

    Join us for Part 3 (of 3) of our Season One Finale episode of The Magical Mystery Hour Podcast. Special Guest Host L.A. Beadles ("Unsinkable: a Titanic Podcast") joins MMH Hosts Paul Carganilla and Amanda Benjamin to dive into the mysterious time slips. In this episode, Paul shares time slip stories from The Queen Mary & an abandoned house. Featuring: a special guest appearance from singer/musician Dan Franklin.

    Inspired by the subject matter, Paul & Amanda perform an acoustic duet cover of  "Clocks", by Coldplay.

    UNSINKABLE: THE TITANIC PODCAST: www.unsinkablepod.com

    Support the show

    Support the show

    Thanks for listening! If you love true crime, ghost stories, and the paranormal, you’ll love our show! If you want to see our faces, find us on the Vaudacity Network on YouTube!

    Support us on Patreon!
    https://www.patreon.com/TheMagicalMysteryHour

    Magical Mystery Hour
    en-usJanuary 25, 2024

    Time Slips - Bold Street, London | Special Guest Co-Host L.A. Beadles

    Time Slips - Bold Street, London | Special Guest Co-Host L.A. Beadles

    Join us for Part 2 (of 3) of our Season One Finale episode of The Magical Mystery Hour Podcast. Special Guest Host L.A. Beadles ("Unsinkable: a Titanic Podcast") joins MMH Hosts Paul Carganilla and Amanda Benjamin to dive into the mysterious time slips reported on Bold Street in London.

    Inspired by the subject matter, Amanda performs a cover "Gravity", by John Mayer.

    UNSINKABLE: THE TITANIC PODCAST: www.unsinkablepod.com

    Support the show

    Thanks for listening! If you love true crime, ghost stories, and the paranormal, you’ll love our show! If you want to see our faces, find us on the Vaudacity Network on YouTube!

    Support us on Patreon!
    https://www.patreon.com/TheMagicalMysteryHour

    Support the show

    Thanks for listening! If you love true crime, ghost stories, and the paranormal, you’ll love our show! If you want to see our faces, find us on the Vaudacity Network on YouTube!

    Support us on Patreon!
    https://www.patreon.com/TheMagicalMysteryHour

    Magical Mystery Hour
    en-usJanuary 11, 2024

    Mad Man Mike Marcum: Lost in Time

    Mad Man Mike Marcum: Lost in Time

    Embark on an extraordinary journey through the fabric of time in our Season 1 finale of the 'Magical Mystery Hour.' Join hosts Amanda Benjamin and Paul Carganilla, along with special guest co-host LA Beadles from the podcast 'Unsinkable,' as we unravel the enigma of time slips with a spotlight on the tale of Mike Marcum.

    In this episode, we delve into the world of time travel, exploring the life and experiences of Mike Marcum, a man who claims to have traveled through time and space. LA Beadles joins us to dissect the complexities of Marcum's journey.

    As a musical interlude, Paul Carganilla serenades us with  'Lost in the Woods."

    Get ready for a mind-bending season finale that blurs the lines between reality and the unknown. Tune in for part one of our exploration into the 'Magical Mystery Hour."

    Support the show

    Thanks for listening! If you love true crime, ghost stories, and the paranormal, you’ll love our show! If you want to see our faces, find us on the Vaudacity Network on YouTube!

    Support us on Patreon!
    https://www.patreon.com/TheMagicalMysteryHour

    Beyond the Veil: Conversations with a Psychic Medium

    Beyond the Veil: Conversations with a Psychic Medium

    Join hosts Amanda Benjamin and Paul Carganilla in another episode of "The Magical Mystery Hour" as they delve into the mystical world with psychic medium Jacque. Uncover the secrets beyond the veil as Jacque shares her extraordinary experiences and offers profound insights into the unseen realms. From communicating with spirits to unraveling the mysteries of the metaphysical, this episode is a journey into the unknown, exploring the magical tapestry of Jacque's encounters. Tune in for a spellbinding hour of revelations and enchanting stories.

    *UPDATE*
    Just replaced the audio, it should update within the next 24 hours. You don't need to hear just how bad we are at intros! *nervous laughter*

    Support the show

    Thanks for listening! If you love true crime, ghost stories, and the paranormal, you’ll love our show! If you want to see our faces, find us on the Vaudacity Network on YouTube!

    Support us on Patreon!
    https://www.patreon.com/TheMagicalMysteryHour

    Haunted Places - The RMS Queen Mary, The Glen Tavern Inn, & The Carriage House Inn

    Haunted Places - The RMS Queen Mary, The Glen Tavern Inn, & The Carriage House Inn

    Join us on another haunting episode of The Magical Mystery Hour Podcast as hosts Paul Carganilla and Amanda Benjamin dive into three reportedly haunted locations. First, we recount tales from Paul's Grandparents' home - one of the oldest homes in King City, California, reportedly built by John Steinbeck's uncle. Next, we explore several of the most commonly-known haunts of the RMS Queen Mary docked in Long Beach, California. Last, we will check in to the Glen Tavern Inn, located in Santa Paula, California. Paul tells stories from the hotel's history and his experience filming his original feature film, "The Haunted Man".

    Inspired by the subject matter, Amanda performs a cover "My Immortal", by Evanescence. 

    Support the show

    Thanks for listening! If you love true crime, ghost stories, and the paranormal, you’ll love our show! If you want to see our faces, find us on the Vaudacity Network on YouTube!

    Support us on Patreon!
    https://www.patreon.com/TheMagicalMysteryHour

    Magical Mystery Hour
    en-usDecember 01, 2023

    Spirits and Staircases: The Untold Story of Sarah Winchester

    Spirits and Staircases: The Untold Story of Sarah Winchester

    Step into the shadows of history this episode of The Magical Mystery Hour, 'Spirits and Staircases: The Untold Story of Sarah Winchester.' Join us on a mysterious journey through the life of Sarah Winchester and her architectural wonder, the Winchester Mystery House. Unveil the secrets of a mansion veiled in labyrinthine corridors, staircases to nowhere, and the echoes of ghostly legends. Delve into the life of Mrs. Winchester, the widow with a haunting past, and explore the theories behind her ceaseless construction. From the mystical number 13 to the spirits that may linger within its walls, our podcast takes you beyond the surface, into the heart of a mystery that has fascinated generations. Welcome to a realm where history, architecture, and the supernatural converge, leaving you captivated by the enduring enigma of the Winchester Mystery House.

    Support the show

    Thanks for listening! If you love true crime, ghost stories, and the paranormal, you’ll love our show! If you want to see our faces, find us on the Vaudacity Network on YouTube!

    Support us on Patreon!
    https://www.patreon.com/TheMagicalMysteryHour

    True Crime: Dan Wozniak and Rachel Buffett - The Murder of Julie Kibuishi and Sam Herr

    True Crime: Dan Wozniak and Rachel Buffett - The Murder of Julie Kibuishi and Sam Herr

    Join us on another spellbinding episode of The Magical Mystery Hour Podcast as hosts Paul Carganilla and Amanda Benjamin dive into the gruesome murders of Julie Kibuishi and Sam Herr. Join us as we unravel the sinister web of deception, betrayal, and violence that led to this heinous crime. Learn about the intricate details of the case, the motives behind the murder, and the shocking twists and turns that kept investigators and the public on the edge of their seats. Tune in to explore the dark psychology of the perpetrator and the relentless pursuit of justice in a case that shocked the nation.

    Inspired by the subject matter, Amanda performs a cover of Wings's  "Band on the Run." Paul and Amanda close the episode with an acoustic guitar cover of Michael Jackson's "Smooth Criminal".

    Be sure to subscribe so you don't miss the next episode - Subscribe today!

    Support the show

    Thanks for listening! If you love true crime, ghost stories, and the paranormal, you’ll love our show! If you want to see our faces, find us on the Vaudacity Network on YouTube!

    Support us on Patreon!
    https://www.patreon.com/TheMagicalMysteryHour

    Magical Mystery Hour
    en-usNovember 02, 2023

    True Crime - OJ Simpson: How the Glove Fits

    True Crime - OJ Simpson: How the Glove Fits

    Get ready for an in-depth exploration of one of the most infamous cases in history on this episode of "The Magical Mystery Hour"! 

    Join Amanda as she unravels the chilling story of O.J. Simpson and the tragic murders of Nicole Brown Simpson and Ronald Goldman for you and co-host Paul Carganilla. She leaves no stone unturned, delving into the lives of the victims, the sensational trial that gripped the nation, and the key players involved. But here's the twist – Amanda unveils her favorite theory that challenges conventional wisdom: O.J. might not be the real murderer!

    Tune in to discover the compelling alternative theory and the reasons behind it. This is a true crime podcast episode you won't want to miss. Uncover the mystery, challenge your assumptions, and find out who she believes is the true culprit. 
     #TrueCrime #OJSimpson #MysteryHour #PodcastEpisode

    Support the show

    Thanks for listening! If you love true crime, ghost stories, and the paranormal, you’ll love our show! If you want to see our faces, find us on the Vaudacity Network on YouTube!

    Support us on Patreon!
    https://www.patreon.com/TheMagicalMysteryHour

    Reincarnation: Interview with Rosa Hope

    Reincarnation: Interview with Rosa Hope

    Join us on our first ever interview episode of The Magical Mystery Hour Podcast! Paul and Amanda discuss past lives and reincarnation with past lives regression therapist and astrophysicist Rosa Hope. Rosa's expertise on past lives insights on the human experience will leave you wondering what secrets may lie just beneath the surface of your own memories. If you've ever been curious about the idea of reincarnation this interview will both answer so many of your questions and leave you wanting more.  

    Tune in, open your mind, and prepare to embark on a journey through the ages with The Magical Mystery Hour Podcast. 

    Inspired by the topic, Amanda and Paul perform a cover of the Lorenz and Hart standard  "Where or When."

    Be sure to subscribe so you don't miss the 20th episode - Subscribe today!

    [How the Glove Fits: The Murders of Nicole Brown Smith, Ron Goldman, and the Trial of OJ Simpson- estimated release date: 10/19/23] 

    Support the show

    Thanks for listening! If you love true crime, ghost stories, and the paranormal, you’ll love our show! If you want to see our faces, find us on the Vaudacity Network on YouTube!

    Support us on Patreon!
    https://www.patreon.com/TheMagicalMysteryHour

    Reincarnation: Echoes of the Past, Part 2

    Reincarnation: Echoes of the Past, Part 2

    Join us on another spellbinding episode of The Magical Mystery Hour Podcast as we continue our dive into the mysticism of past lives. If you've ever been curious about the idea of reincarnation or the enduring threads that link our past lives to our present, this episode is an absolute must-listen.  

    Prepare to be transported as we unravel the mysteries of reincarnation through the captivating stories of Jamey, a young boy with Titanic memories, and James, who recalls specific details of fighting in World War II. Tune in, open your mind, and prepare to embark on a journey through the ages with The Magical Mystery Hour Podcast. 

    Inspired by the subject matter, Amanda performs a cover of Nick Drake's  "One of These Things First."

    Be sure to subscribe so you don't miss the Nineteenth episode - Subscribe today!

    [Past Lives - Part 3 - release date: 10/05/23]

    Support the show

    Support the show

    Thanks for listening! If you love true crime, ghost stories, and the paranormal, you’ll love our show! If you want to see our faces, find us on the Vaudacity Network on YouTube!

    Support us on Patreon!
    https://www.patreon.com/TheMagicalMysteryHour

    Magical Mystery Hour
    en-usSeptember 21, 2023

    Reincarnation: Echos of the Past

    Reincarnation: Echos of the Past

    Join us on this spellbinding episode of The Magical Mystery Hour Podcast as we dive headfirst into the mysticism of past lives. Amanda Benjamin's captivating storytelling and insightful analysis will leave you mesmerized and questioning the boundaries of time, memory, and the profound interconnectedness of our souls. If you've ever been curious about the idea of reincarnation or the enduring threads that link our past lives to our present, this episode is an absolute must-listen.  

    Prepare to be transported as we unravel the mysteries of reincarnation through the captivating stories of The Pollock Twins, Ryan Hammond, and Dorothy Eady. Tune in, open your mind, and prepare to embark on a journey through the ages with The Magical Mystery Hour Podcast. 

    Inspired by the story, Paul performs a cover of Sarah McLachlan's  "I Will Remember You."

    Be sure to subscribe so you don't miss the Eighteenth episode - Subscribe today!

    [Past Lives - Part 2 - release date: 09/21/23]

    Support the show



    Support the show

    Thanks for listening! If you love true crime, ghost stories, and the paranormal, you’ll love our show! If you want to see our faces, find us on the Vaudacity Network on YouTube!

    Support us on Patreon!
    https://www.patreon.com/TheMagicalMysteryHour

    The Disappearance of Brian Shaffer

    The Disappearance of Brian Shaffer

    Hosts Amanda Benjamin and Paul Carganilla discuss a the mystery of a man who seemingly vanished into thin air. In this episode, Paul tells the true story of Brian Shaffer.

    Inspired by the theme, Amanda performs an electric guitar cover of Bill Withers', "Ain't No Sunshine". The two hosts close the episode with an acoustic cover duet of "Come Away With Me", by Norah Jones.

    Support the show

    Thanks for listening! If you love true crime, ghost stories, and the paranormal, you’ll love our show! If you want to see our faces, find us on the Vaudacity Network on YouTube!

    Support us on Patreon!
    https://www.patreon.com/TheMagicalMysteryHour

    Magical Mystery Hour
    en-usAugust 24, 2023

    Whispers of Roanoke - America's Oldest Unsolved Mystery

    Whispers of Roanoke - America's Oldest Unsolved Mystery

    Step into the shadows of history as we embark on a riveting journey through one of the most confounding mysteries of all time. Join us on "The Magical Mystery Hour,"  as we delve deep into the enigma surrounding the disappearance of the Roanoke Colony.

    Intrigue and uncertainty surround the story of the Roanoke Colony, a 16th-century English settlement that vanished without a trace, leaving behind only cryptic clues and unanswered questions. In this episode, we'll unravel layers of history as we attempt to shed light on this centuries-old puzzle.

    Amanda Benjamin will guide you through the labyrinthine corridors of the past, connecting the dots and presenting compelling theories that may finally bring us closer to the truth with help from her co-host Paul Carganilla. From examining the lives of the colonists to scrutinizing the prevailing theories and captivating legends, "The Magical Mystery Hour" aims to explore every facet of this enduring mystery.

    Get ready to immerse yourself in a world of intrigue, suspense, and intellectual adventure as we attempt to unlock the secrets of the Roanoke Colony's disappearance. Subscribe now and join us on this captivating quest to decipher history's most perplexing riddle.

    Inspired by the story, Paul performs a cover of Three Doors Down's "Without You."

    Be sure to subscribe so you don't miss the fifteenth episode - Subscribe today!

    [Vanishing - Part 2 - The Vanishing of Brian Schaffer - release date: 08/24/23]

    Thanks for listening! If you love true crime, ghost stories, and the paranormal, you’ll love our show! If you want to see our faces, find us on the Vaudacity Network on YouTube!

    Support the show

    Thanks for listening! If you love true crime, ghost stories, and the paranormal, you’ll love our show! If you want to see our faces, find us on the Vaudacity Network on YouTube!

    Support us on Patreon!
    https://www.patreon.com/TheMagicalMysteryHour

    Bermuda Triangle Flights - Bruce Gernon's Electric Fog & Naval Flight 19

    Bermuda Triangle Flights - Bruce Gernon's Electric Fog & Naval Flight 19

    Hosts Amanda Benjamin and Paul Carganilla discuss aerial mysteries, or "mysteries of flight". In this episode, Paul tells the true stories of two Bermuda Triangle : a time-traveling private flight and a Naval training mission that went mysteriously haywire.

    Inspired by the theme, Amanda performs a cover of John Lennon / The Bealtes, "Free As a Bird", accompanied by her husband, David Benjamin, on piano. The two hosts close the episode with an acoustic cover duet of "Fly Me to the Moon".

    Support the show

    Thanks for listening! If you love true crime, ghost stories, and the paranormal, you’ll love our show! If you want to see our faces, find us on the Vaudacity Network on YouTube!

    Support us on Patreon!
    https://www.patreon.com/TheMagicalMysteryHour

    Magical Mystery Hour
    en-usJuly 28, 2023

    Into Thin Air: MH370's Mysterious Journey - Aerial Mysteries Part 1

    Into Thin Air: MH370's Mysterious Journey - Aerial Mysteries Part 1

    Hosts Amanda Benjamin and Paul Carganilla discuss aerial mysteries. In this episode, Amanda tells the tale of the disappearance of MH370

    Inspired by the theme, Paul performs John Denver's classic, "Leaving on a Jet Plane".

    Don't miss the next episode - Subscribe today!
    [Aerial Mysteries - Part 2 - Bermuda Triangle mysteries and the Story of  - projected release date: 07/27/2023]

    Thanks for listening! If you love true crime, ghost stories, and the paranormal, you’ll love our show! If you want to see our faces, find us on the Vaudacity Network on YouTube!

    Thanks for listening! If you love true crime, ghost stories, and the paranormal, you’ll love our show! If you want to see our faces, find us on the Vaudacity Network on YouTube!

    Support the show

    Thanks for listening! If you love true crime, ghost stories, and the paranormal, you’ll love our show! If you want to see our faces, find us on the Vaudacity Network on YouTube!

    Support us on Patreon!
    https://www.patreon.com/TheMagicalMysteryHour

    Alien Abductions - Travis Walton

    Alien Abductions - Travis Walton

    Hosts Amanda Benjamin and Paul Carganilla discuss alien abductions. In this episode, Paul tells the abduction tale of Travis Walton.

    Inspired by the theme, Amanda performs an Amanda Benjamin original song, "Taken", which she wrote and recorded in a single day. The two hosts close the episode with an acoustic cover duet of Train's "Drops of Jupiter".

    Be sure you don't miss the next episode, featuring the disappearance of Malaysia Airlines Flight 370!

    Support the show

    Thanks for listening! If you love true crime, ghost stories, and the paranormal, you’ll love our show! If you want to see our faces, find us on the Vaudacity Network on YouTube!

    Support us on Patreon!
    https://www.patreon.com/TheMagicalMysteryHour

    Magical Mystery Hour
    en-usJune 30, 2023

    The Hill Abduction Files: Unraveling the Extraterrestrial Mystery - Alien Abductions

    The Hill Abduction Files: Unraveling the Extraterrestrial Mystery - Alien Abductions

    Hosts Amanda Benjamin and Paul Carganilla discuss alien abductions. In this episode, Amanda tells the abduction tale of Barney and Betty Hill.

    Inspired by the theme, Paul performs The Beatles' classic, "Across the Universe".

    Don't miss the next episode - Subscribe today!
    [Alien Abductions - Part 2 - TheTravis Walton Story - projected release date: 06/29/23]

    Thanks for listening! If you love true crime, ghost stories, and the paranormal, you’ll love our show! If you want to see our faces, find us on the Vaudacity Network on YouTube!

    Support the show

    Thanks for listening! If you love true crime, ghost stories, and the paranormal, you’ll love our show! If you want to see our faces, find us on the Vaudacity Network on YouTube!

    Support us on Patreon!
    https://www.patreon.com/TheMagicalMysteryHour

    Mysteries of the Sea - Bermuda Triangle & Flannan Isles Lighthouse

    Mysteries of the Sea - Bermuda Triangle & Flannan Isles Lighthouse

    Hosts Amanda Benjamin and Paul Carganilla discuss nautical mysteries. In this episode, Paul tells a few Bermuda Triangle stories, and also discusses the Flannan Isles Lighthouse mystery.

    Inspired by the mysteries, Amanda performs a cover of "Come Sail Away", by STYX. The two hosts close the episode with an acoustic cover duet of Helen Reddy's "Candle on the Water".

    Be sure you don't miss the eleventh episode, featuring the alien abduction of Barney and Betty Hill - SUBSCRIBE TODAY!

    Support the show

    Thanks for listening! If you love true crime, ghost stories, and the paranormal, you’ll love our show! If you want to see our faces, find us on the Vaudacity Network on YouTube!

    Support us on Patreon!
    https://www.patreon.com/TheMagicalMysteryHour

    Magical Mystery Hour
    en-usJune 01, 2023

    Ghost Ship Chronicles: The Enigma of the Mary Celeste- Mysteries of the Sea

    Ghost Ship Chronicles: The Enigma of the Mary Celeste- Mysteries of the Sea

    Hosts Amanda Benjamin and Paul Carganilla discuss nautical mysteries. In this episode, Amanda tells the tale of the cursed ghost ship Mary Celeste.

    Inspired by the theme, Paul performs a traditional sea shanty, "Rolling Down to Old Maui".

    Don't miss the tenth episode - Subscribe today!
    [Mysteries of the Sea - Part 2 - The Bermuda Triangle & The Flannan Isles Lighthouse - projected release date: 03/09/23]

    Support the show

    Thanks for listening! If you love true crime, ghost stories, and the paranormal, you’ll love our show! If you want to see our faces, find us on the Vaudacity Network on YouTube!

    Support us on Patreon!
    https://www.patreon.com/TheMagicalMysteryHour

    Mysterious Creatures - Saola, Sasquatch, & the Giant of Kandahar

    Mysterious Creatures - Saola, Sasquatch, & the Giant of Kandahar

    Hosts Amanda Benjamin and Paul Carganilla discuss mysterious creatures. In this episode, Paul tells stories about several mysterious creatures, including: Saola, Sasquatch, the Rock Apes of Vietnam, and the Giant of Kandahar

    Inspired by the mysteries, Amanda performs a cover of Creedence Clearwater Revival's "Bad Moon Rising". The two hosts close the episode with an acoustic cover duet of "Into the Unknown", from Frozen 2.

    Be sure you don't miss the ninth episode, featuring the mystery of The Cursed Mary Celeste - SUBSCRIBE TODAY!

    Support the show

    Thanks for listening! If you love true crime, ghost stories, and the paranormal, you’ll love our show! If you want to see our faces, find us on the Vaudacity Network on YouTube!

    Support us on Patreon!
    https://www.patreon.com/TheMagicalMysteryHour

    Magical Mystery Hour
    en-usFebruary 09, 2023
    Logo

    © 2024 Podcastworld. All rights reserved

    Stay up to date

    For any inquiries, please email us at hello@podcastworld.io