Logo

    The Criterinot Podcast

    The Criterinot Podcast is a comedic podcast about films that are not in The Criterion Collection. Host Graydon Sheppard is joined in each episode by a filmmaker, actor, producer, comedian, etc., to get into the mainstream movies they love that don't get enough cred.
    en-us35 Episodes

    People also ask

    What is the main theme of the podcast?
    Who are some of the popular guests the podcast?
    Were there any controversial topics discussed in the podcast?
    Were any current trending topics addressed in the podcast?
    What popular books were mentioned in the podcast?

    Episodes (35)

    Requiem for a Dream with Matt Hannam

    Requiem for a Dream with Matt Hannam

    In the Season Two finale I am joined by superstar editor Matt Hannam (Enemy, Swiss Army Man, The OA, White Noise) to talk about the ultra-depressing and incredibly innovative Requiem for a Dream. Did Miranda July get "pooping back and forth" from watching the ass-to-ass scene in this film? Yes. Well, I don't know for sure, but...yes.

    Thank you for listening. If you enjoyed the season let me know by leaving a review on Apple Podcasts! xoxo

    The Criterinot Podcast
    en-usMarch 17, 2022

    Marie Antoinette with Magali Simard

    Marie Antoinette with Magali Simard

    "Dear God, guide us and protect us. We are too young to reign." On this week's episode I'm joined by a French-Canadian queen to talk about THE French queen and the injustices that both she and director Sofia Coppola have suffered. Magali Simard (TIFF Programmer, Toronto Film Development Manager) and I are quietly outraged about the way this film was received. It is a movie that was truly ahead of its time. Long Live Marie Antoinette.

    The Criterinot Podcast
    en-usMarch 03, 2022

    Crossroads with Jacki Calleiro

    Crossroads with Jacki Calleiro

    This motion picture is a grim foreshadowing of Britney's real life. It's uncanny how many things in the story wound up playing out in Brit Brit's IRL timeline. Producer and Southern belle Jacki Calleiro gets into this Shonda Rimes/Tamra Davis spectacle of teen suffering with me. We also talk about Frances Farmer, Kim Cattrall's day-play, felons crossing state lines with minors, and much more. 

    The Criterinot Podcast
    en-usFebruary 10, 2022

    Good Will Hunting with Carlo Guillermo Proto

    Good Will Hunting with Carlo Guillermo Proto

    It's the movie that dares to ask "Fellas, is it gay to hug?"

    Filmmaker and hunk Carlo Guillermo Proto (El Huaso, Resurrecting Hassan) joins me to talk about the shockingly f-slurless Good Will Hunting. Directed by queer auteur Gus Van Sant, this extremely straight movie will have you in tears simply because a couple bros open up about their feelings. If you love this movie as much as we do, "It's not your fault."

    The Criterinot Podcast
    en-usFebruary 03, 2022

    The Hand That Rocks the Cradle with Jamie Travis

    The Hand That Rocks the Cradle with Jamie Travis

    Yellowjackets director and producer Jamie Travis joins me to talk about the 1992 "lady thriller" The Hand That Rocks the Cradle. Annabella Sciorra, Rebecca De Mornay, Ernie Hudson, Matt McCoy, and Julianne Moore star in this wild, upsetting, and incredibly entertaining movie about a psychotic usurping nanny.

    The Criterinot Podcast
    en-usJanuary 27, 2022

    The First Wives Club with Katie Silberman

    The First Wives Club with Katie Silberman

    Writer Katie Silberman (Don't Worry Darling, Booksmart, Set It Up, and a super secret upcoming Marvel movie) is a master of storytelling and a MAJOR fan of The First Wives Club. This 1996 adaptation of the Olivia Goldsmith novel stars absolutely everyone, but mostly Goldie Hawn, Diane Keaton, Bette Midler, Stockard Channing, Maggie Smith, Elizabeth Berkley, and Sarah Jessica Parker.

    The Criterinot Podcast
    en-usJanuary 20, 2022

    Mask with Darren Stein

    Mask with Darren Stein

    Darren Stein - writer and director of Jawbreaker, Sparkler, and Put the Camera on Me - joins me to talk about Peter Bogdanovich's 1985 tearjerker Mask*. Cher, Eric Stoltz, Laura Dern, and Sam Elliott star in the biopic about Rocky Dennis, a teenager with a big ole face.

    *Not to be confused with THE Mask starring Jim Carrey.

    The Criterinot Podcast
    en-usJanuary 13, 2022

    The Holiday with Jennifer Shin

    The Holiday with Jennifer Shin

    The Holiday is a delightfully boring movie. At Criterinot, we're fans not critics, but we do shit-talk this movie quite a bit and still come out the other end loving it. Other topics this episode include Jerry Seinfeld's bee fetish, why moms love pan flute music, people being "90s hot", and Amanda Knox. My guest this week, Jennifer Shin, is Director of Development for Comedy at The CBC. 

    The Criterinot Podcast
    en-usDecember 16, 2021

    Romancing the Stone with Jordan Canning

    Romancing the Stone with Jordan Canning

    Writer/director Jordan Canning (Schitt's Creek, Fraggle Rock, Baroness von Sketch, We Were Wolves) joins me this week to talk about Robert Zemeckis and Diane Thomas's 1984 adventure comedy Romancing the Stone. Kathleen Turner stars as the romance novelist turned reluctant adventurer Joan Wilder. Along with the pits and pratfalls that Joan deals with while trying to save her sister in Cartagena, Colombia, we get into the pits and pratfalls of filmmaking itself. 

    The Criterinot Podcast
    en-usDecember 09, 2021

    Romy and Michele's High School Reunion with Tranna Wintour

    Romy and Michele's High School Reunion with Tranna Wintour

    Look out Tucson, here we come! The inimitable comedian and elusive chantuese Tranna Wintour is here to talk about 1997’s Romy and Michele’s High School Reunion, written by Robin Schiff and directed by David Mirkin. We go deep on this 90s classic featuring an incredible cast that includes Mira Sorvino (hot on the heels of her Oscar win), Lisa Kudrow, Janeane Garofalo, Alan Cumming, Justin Theroux and Camryn Manheim. 

    The Criterinot Podcast
    en-usDecember 02, 2021

    Adventures in Babysitting with Naomi Fry

    Adventures in Babysitting with Naomi Fry

    New Yorker staff writer and prolific Twitter user Naomi Fry is here to talk about Adventures in Babysitting, Elvis crapping to death, Beverly Hills 90210, Melrose Place, Matthew Modine, and why young people looked so old in the 80s.

    The Criterinot Podcast
    en-usNovember 25, 2021

    To Die For with Bayne Gibby

    To Die For with Bayne Gibby

    To Die For (1995) is not just this week’s movie, it’s how I’d describe my guest. The wonderful Bayne Gibby (The Comeback, Enlightened, Ladybird) is on the podcast this week to gush with me about Nicole Kidman in Gus Van Sant’s "black comedy-drama crime film.” 

    The Criterinot Podcast
    en-usNovember 18, 2021

    White Chicks with Hubert Davis

    White Chicks with Hubert Davis

    White Chicks is a fever dream of a movie and I'm a huge fan. My guest, Oscar and Emmy-nominated director Hubert Davis is also a fan. Directed, written, and produced by Keenen Ivory Wayans, this perfect movie stars the incredible Shawn and Marlon Wayans, B*sy Ph*l*pps, Dexter's Sister, Terry Crews, Jaime King, Frankie Faison, and my high school crush Lochlyn Munro. Thanks.

    The Criterinot Podcast
    en-usNovember 11, 2021

    Strangers in Good Company with John Early

    Strangers in Good Company with John Early

    Strangers in Good Company is my favourite Canadian film (full disclosure, I haven't seen the unauthorized Céline Dion biopic  yet...so, that could change). I'm joined by actor, comedian, and fellow Stranger-head John Early (Search Party, I Think You Should Leave, and an IMDb STARmeter score of 13,959) to laugh and cry together about this fabulous gang of eight women who get stranded in the middle of nowhere in Québec. 

    Watch the movie in Canada for FREE on the NFB YouTube Channel: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VKGw1wCWP1g

    Watch the movie on Amazon Prime in America here: https://www.amazon.com/Strangers-Good-Company-Alice-Diabo/dp/B002YV5LMU

    The Criterinot Podcast
    en-usNovember 04, 2021

    Misery with Craig Johnson

    Misery with Craig Johnson

    Director and writer Craig Johnson (The Skeleton Twins, Special, Gossip Girl) joins me to talk about Kathy Bates's introduction to the wider world in Rob Reiner and William Goldman's adaptation of Stephen King's Misery (1990).

    The Criterinot Podcast
    en-usOctober 28, 2021

    Se7en with Lara Marie Schoenhals

    Se7en with Lara Marie Schoenhals

    Don't watch this movie.

    The unmatchable Lara Marie Schoenhals joins me to talk about this huge bummer of a movie that we both love and hate.  David Fincher. Gwyneth Paltrow. Morgan Freeman. Brad Pitt. Kevin Spacey.

    The Criterinot Podcast
    en-usOctober 21, 2021

    The Craft with David Wilson

    The Craft with David Wilson

    Hail to the Guardians of the Watchtowers of the Notties! It's October so I guess it's time to catch up with "The Bitches of Eastwick." Grammy nominated music video and short film director David Wilson (Lady Gaga, Arcade Fire, Arctic Monkeys, M83, Tame Impala, Metronomy) hops on the pod to talk with me about Andrew Fleming's teen witch drama The Craft. The movie was released in 1996 and stars Robin Tunney, Fairuza Balk, Neve Campbell, Rachel True, Skeet Ulrich, and Christine Taylor. 

    The Criterinot Podcast
    en-usOctober 07, 2021

    Cruel Intentions with Nancy Jo Sales

    Cruel Intentions with Nancy Jo Sales

    It was the ass that launched a thousand gays. Nancy Jo Sales (journalist, writer of The Bling Ring, director of Swiped on HBO) joins me to talk about Roger Kumble's interpretation of Dangerous Liaisons. We get into the good and the bad, the unparalleled soundtrack, the incredible performances of Reese Witherspoon, Selma Blair, Sarah Michelle Gellar, and of course...Ryan Phillippe's bu-bu-bu-butt. 

    The Criterinot Podcast
    en-usSeptember 30, 2021