Logo

    Troubled Waters

    Troubled Waters is the pop culture quiz show where comedians disagree to disagree. Twice a month, Dave will stoke pointless arguments between two teams of comedians and make them compete against each other in order to settle their meaningless debates once and for all. Winner takes home the right to be right.
    en264 Episodes

    People also ask

    What is the main theme of the podcast?
    Who are some of the popular guests the podcast?
    Were there any controversial topics discussed in the podcast?
    Were any current trending topics addressed in the podcast?
    What popular books were mentioned in the podcast?

    Episodes (264)

    HGTV vs Peacock

    HGTV vs Peacock

    This week, our friends Cailin Peluffo and Ashley Ray learn about the weird world of Dune and Doonesbury, box office flops, and give strange acceptance speeches.

    Caitlin Peluffo would like to plug her album Dirty Bird and recommends Nobody Presents Greg Stone and Before He Was Super by Steven Rogers 

    Ashley Ray would like to plug her album Ice Cream Money and her podcast TV, I Say and recommends Household Name by Niles Abston

    And finally, Dave Holmes is on Twitter @DaveHolmes.Dave would like to recommend All of Us Strangers

    Find us on Twitter and Instagram! We are @TroubledPod

    Written by Riley Silverman and John-Luke Roberts, recorded remotely over Zoom and produced by Christian Dueñas and Laura Swisher.

    Join the MaxFun fam:

    maximumfun.org/join

    Troubled Waters
    enMarch 01, 2024

    T-Plane vs Prince Sweat

    T-Plane vs Prince Sweat

    Our friends from the new MaxFun podcast Sound Heap, John-Luke Roberts and Eleanor Morton join Dave Holmes for some garbled Elton John tunes, niche podcast pitches, and fake reality tv show.

    John-Luke Roberts  would like to plug Sound Heap, now on Maximum Fun and recommends the podcast Poetry Unbound 

    Eleanor Morton would like to plug her show Haunted House and recommends Sound Heap

    And finally, Dave Holmes is on Twitter @DaveHolmes.Dave would like to recommend Tartovski by Bodega

    Find us on Twitter and Instagram! We are @TroubledPod

    Written by Riley Silverman and John-Luke Roberts, recorded remotely over Zoom and produced by Christian Dueñas and Laura Swisher.

    Join the MaxFun fam:

    maximumfun.org/join

    Troubled Waters
    enFebruary 15, 2024

    Epizempic vs Smelton

    Epizempic vs Smelton

    This week, our MaxFun friends Ella McLeod and Jeremy Bent join host Dave Holmes for discontinued snack talk, EGOT trivia, and motiviational speeches

    Jeremy Bent would like to plug Eurovangelists and recommends The Overstory by Richard Powers

    Ella McLeod would like to plug Comfort Creatures and her books Rapunzella and The Map That Led to You and recommends Ordinary Unhappiness

    And finally, Dave Holmes is on Twitter @DaveHolmes.Dave would like to recommend Beautiful Song

    Find us on Twitter and Instagram! We are @TroubledPod

    Written by Riley Silverman and John-Luke Roberts, recorded remotely over Zoom and produced by Christian Dueñas and Laura Swisher.

    Join the MaxFun fam:

    maximumfun.org/join

    Troubled Waters
    enFebruary 01, 2024

    YouTube vs Taylor Swift

    YouTube vs Taylor Swift

    This week, our friends Tom Lum and Adam Cayton-Holland join host Dave Holmes for some self-help tips, musical trivia, and Steamboat Willie's insane behavior.

    Tom Lum would like to plug Let's Learn Everything here on MaxFun and recommends Answer in Progress

    Adam Cayton-Holland would like to plug his comedy special Wallpaper and recommends Stella Maris by Cormac McCarthy

    And finally, Dave Holmes is on Twitter @DaveHolmes.Dave would like to recommend Tartovski by Bodega

    Find us on Twitter and Instagram! We are @TroubledPod

    Written by Riley Silverman and John-Luke Roberts, recorded remotely over Zoom and produced by Christian Dueñas and Laura Swisher.

    Join the MaxFun fam:

    maximumfun.org/join

    Troubled Waters
    enJanuary 16, 2024

    January vs March

    January vs March

    This week we ring in the new year with Andie Main and Josh Gondelman. They give the year 2024 a performance review, create a new Word of the Year, give each other pep talks for cringeworthy moments of the past year.

    Andie Main would like to plug her album Rocky Mountain Bi and her podcast Recovering with Andie Main and recommends Ben Roy's Hyena and Adam Cayton Holland's  Wallpaper

    Josh Gondelman would like to plug his upcoming tour dates and his weekly pep talk newsletter and recommends Kenny Deforest's Don't You Know Who I Am?

    And finally, Dave Holmes is on Twitter @DaveHolmes.Dave would like to recommend All of Us Strangers

    Find us on Twitter and Instagram! We are @TroubledPod

    Written by Riley Silverman and John-Luke Roberts, recorded remotely over Zoom and produced by Christian Dueñas and Laura Swisher.

    Join the MaxFun fam:

    maximumfun.org/join

    Troubled Waters
    enJanuary 03, 2024

    Four Christmases vs Serendipity

    Four Christmases vs Serendipity

    This week, our friends Jessica Sele and Shawn Carter join host Dave Holmes for our annual holiday special!

    Jessica Sele would like to plug her album Weird Vibes and you can check out her live dates and recommends Jimmy Marble

    Shawn Carter would like to plug his album Boston to Bristol and his comedy club Blue Ridge Comedy Club and recommends Milo and the Not So Scary Day After All by Matt Bedell

    And finally, Dave Holmes is on Twitter @DaveHolmes.Dave would like to recommend All of Us Strangers

    Find us on Twitter and Instagram! We are @TroubledPod

    Written by Riley Silverman and John-Luke Roberts, recorded remotely over Zoom and produced by Christian Dueñas and Laura Swisher.

    Join the MaxFun fam:

    maximumfun.org/join

     

    Music used:

    "Jingle Bells" Kevin MacLeod (incompetech.com)
    Licensed under Creative Commons: By Attribution 4.0 License
    http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/

     

    "We Wish you a Merry Christmas" Kevin MacLeod (incompetech.com)
    Licensed under Creative Commons: By Attribution 4.0 License
    http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/

    Troubled Waters
    enDecember 15, 2023

    Dogs vs Authenticity

    Dogs vs Authenticity

    This week, our friends Danny Tamberelli and Katelyn Detweiler join host Dave Holmes for some Garfield trivia, musical wordclouds, and 100 years of Disney.

    Danny Tamberelli would like to plug The First Date Prophecy and recommends Good Burger 2

    Katelyn Detweiler would like to plug Road Trip Rewind and recommends Water Underground by Real Estate 

    And finally, Dave Holmes is on Twitter @DaveHolmes

    Find us on Twitter and Instagram! We are @TroubledPod

    Written by Riley Silverman and John-Luke Roberts, recorded remotely over Zoom and produced by Christian Dueñas and Laura Swisher.

    Join the MaxFun fam:

    maximumfun.org/join

    Troubled Waters
    enDecember 01, 2023

    Taters vs Crisp

    Taters vs Crisp

    This week, our friends Brian Fernandes and Leah Rudick join host Dave Holmes for some Loony Tunes rebuses, Thanksgiving confessions, and try and remember what movies were released during the SAG-AFTRA strike.

    Brian Fernandes would like to plug Ghost Town's recent episodes on Chateau Marmont

    Leah Rudick would like to plug her special Spiraling and recommends Festif Amaro

    And finally, Dave Holmes is on Twitter @DaveHolmes. Catch Dave on Pluto TV 90's throwback channel on December 5th . Dave would like to plug Dirtbag, Massachusetts by Isaac Fitzgerald

    Find us on Twitter and Instagram! We are @TroubledPod

    Written by Riley Silverman and John-Luke Roberts, recorded remotely over Zoom and produced by Christian Dueñas and Laura Swisher.

    Join the MaxFun fam:

    maximumfun.org/join

    Troubled Waters
    enNovember 16, 2023

    Swizzler vs Brotebook

    Swizzler vs Brotebook

    This week, our friends Kristine Kimmel and Graham Kay join host Dave Holmes for some Taylor Swift clothing trivia, cuffing season debates, and celebrity Scorpios

    Kristine Kimmel would like to plug How to Survive and recommends the podcast Valley Heat

    Graham Kay would like to plug his show Pete and Me at New York Comedy Festival and recommends Django Gold

    And finally, Dave Holmes is on Twitter @DaveHolmes. Catch the Friday Forty on November 10th! 

    Find us on Twitter and Instagram! We are @TroubledPod

    Written by Riley Silverman and John-Luke Roberts, recorded remotely over Zoom and produced by Christian Dueñas and Laura Swisher.

    Join the MaxFun fam:

    maximumfun.org/join

    Bridenstine vs Cyclops

    Bridenstine vs Cyclops

    This week, our friends Lizzy Cooperman and Matt Lieb join host Dave Holmes for a spooky good time with scary songs, Monster Mash trivia, and real and fake creature from folklore.

    Lizzy Cooperman would like to plug her tarot readings and her UCB show Tasting Menu and recommends The Power of Receiving by Amanda Owen

    Matt Lieb would like to plug Pod Yourself a Gun and recommends The Perfect Amount of Wrong by Mike Bridenstine and The Bitchuation Room

    And finally, Dave Holmes is on Twitter @DaveHolmes. Catch the Friday Forty on November 10th! Dave would like to recommend Holy Smokes by Matt Sucich

    Find us on Twitter and Instagram! We are @TroubledPod

    Written by Riley Silverman and John-Luke Roberts, recorded remotely over Zoom and produced by Christian Dueñas and Laura Swisher.

    Join the MaxFun fam:

    maximumfun.org/join

    Ranch vs Bench

    Ranch vs Bench

    This week, our friends Laser the Boy and Gabe Mollica join host Dave Holmes for some pumpkin spice products, motivational speeches, and fall-related trivia.

    Laser the Boy would like to plug Teaching A Robot to Love and recommends Amy Spalding

    Gabe Mollica would like to plug Solo: A Show About Friendship and recommends Pete and Me by Graham Kay

    And finally, Dave Holmes is on Twitter @DaveHolmes. Dave would like to recommend the Landed app

    Find us on Twitter and Instagram! We are @TroubledPod

    Written by Riley Silverman and John-Luke Roberts, recorded remotely over Zoom and produced by Christian Dueñas and Laura Swisher.

    Join the MaxFun fam:

    maximumfun.org/join

    Guts vs Random

    Guts vs Random

    This week, our friends Casey O'Brien and Glenn Boozan join host Dave Holmes for some terrible relationship advice, spooky song lyrics, and lesser-known Mortal Kombat kombatants.

    Glenn Boozan would like to plug There Are Moms Way Worse Than You and the upcoming sequel There Are Dads Way Worse Than You and recommends Return of the Obra Dinn

    Casey O'Brien would like to plug the podcasts Farthouse and That's Messed Up: An SVU Podcast and I Saw What You Did and recommends The History of the Minnesota Vikings

    And finally, Dave Holmes is on Twitter @DaveHolmes. Dave would like to recommend Desolation Center and I Could Not Believe It: The 1979 Teenage Diaries of Sean Delear

    Find us on Twitter and Instagram! We are @TroubledPod

    Written by Riley Silverman and John-Luke Roberts, recorded remotely over Zoom and produced by Christian Dueñas and Laura Swisher.

    Join the MaxFun fam:

    maximumfun.org/join

    Che vs Nessie

    Che vs Nessie

    This week, our friends Alexis Preston and Alex Steed join host Dave Holmes for some Dusty Springfield trivia, animals named after celebrities, and a truly unhinged ranking of foodstuffs.

    Alexis Preston would like to plug Comfort Creatures here on MaxFun and recommends Piranesi by Susanna Clarke

    Alex Steed would like to plug You Are Good and their upcoming live shows and recommends Raw Dog by Jamie Loftus and Silence by Julie Klausner

    And finally, Dave Holmes is on Twitter @DaveHolmes.

    Find us on Twitter and Instagram! We are @TroubledPod

    Written by Riley Silverman and John-Luke Roberts, recorded remotely over Zoom and produced by Christian Dueñas and Laura Swisher.

    Join the MaxFun fam:

    maximumfun.org/join

    Buckaroo vs Swifties

    Buckaroo vs Swifties

    This week, Glen Tickle and Caitlin Cook join Dave Holmes for some strike-proof trivia, Sinead O'Connor covers, and tequila!

    Glen Tickle would like to plug his special Glen Tickle Against The World Crime League and recommends Eric Smith's Jagged Little Pill: The Novel

    Caitlin Cook would like to plug The Writing On The Stall and the studio album and recommends Alex Edelman's Just for Us and Edinburgh Fringe Fest

    And finally, Dave Holmes is on Twitter @DaveHolmes. Dave would like to recommend Daniel Ellsworth 

    Find us on Twitter and Instagram! We are @TroubledPod

    Written by Riley Silverman and John-Luke Roberts, recorded remotely over Zoom and produced by Christian Dueñas and Laura Swisher.

    Join the MaxFun fam:

    maximumfun.org/join

    Troubled Waters
    enAugust 15, 2023

    Lana vs Gerry

    Lana vs Gerry

    This week, John Moe and Liz Barrett join host Dave Holmes to talk about the best ways to beat the heat this summer, learn some weird fun facts about our favorite food mascots, and try their best to make the most boring things sound exciting. 

    John Moe would like to plug Sleeping with Celebrities and Depresh Mode here on Maximum Fun and his book The Hilarious World of Depression and recommends Edi Patterson on The Righteous Gemstones

    Liz Barrett would like to plug her album Gettin' By and recommends Maria Bamford's upcoming book Sure, I'll Join Your Cult

    And finally, Dave Holmes is on Twitter @DaveHolmes. Dave would like to recommend Pete Zia on Instagram

    Find us on Twitter and Instagram! We are @TroubledPod

    Written by Riley Silverman and John-Luke Roberts, recorded remotely over Zoom and produced by Christian Dueñas and Laura Swisher.

    Join the MaxFun fam:

    maximumfun.org/join

    Troubled Waters
    enAugust 01, 2023

    Barbie vs Oppenheimer

    Barbie vs Oppenheimer

    This week, our friends Dan McCoy and Jessica Lynn Verdi join Dave for some Barbie puns, surprise toys and bombs, and  learn more than they ever wanted to learn about the Fall Out Boy "We Didn't Start the Fire" cover song.

    Dan McCoy would like to plug The Flop House and recommends The Museum of Nostalgia 

    Jessica Lynn Verdi would like to plug her podcasts on JLV Podcasts, including Podcast of the Rings and No 2 Gays About It and recommends Naming Your Little Geek

    And finally, Dave Holmes is on Twitter @DaveHolmes. Dave would like to recommend The She Series Book, featuring essays by Riley Silverman! 

    Find us on Twitter! We are @TroubledPod

    Written by Riley Silverman and John-Luke Roberts, recorded remotely over Zoom and produced by Christian Dueñas and Laura Swisher.

    Join the MaxFun fam:

    maximumfun.org/join

     

    Barbie House vs Human Meat

    Barbie House vs Human Meat

    This week, Emma Arnold and Greg Barris join Dave Holmes for some fun in the sun! We hear some summer blockbuster limericks, secretly bummer summer songs, and give some good old fashion motivational speeches

    Emma Arnold would like to plug her album Myself and Yes Please and recommends Brad Wentzel

    Greg Barris would like to plug  his album Deep Healings and his podcast Deep Healing 

    And Finally, Dave Holmes is on Twitter @DaveHolmes

    Find us on Twitter! We are @TroubledPod

    Written by Riley Silverman and John-Luke Roberts, recorded remotely over Zoom and produced by Christian Dueñas and Laura Swisher.

    Join the MaxFun fam:

    maximumfun.org/join

    Music used:

    "Carefree" Kevin MacLeod (incompetech.com)
    Licensed under Creative Commons: By Attribution 4.0 License
    http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/

    Troubled Waters
    enJuly 03, 2023

    RuPaul vs Sexy Fox

    RuPaul vs Sexy Fox

    This week, Rachel Green and Kale Hills join Dave Holmes for a very special Pride-themed episode of Troubled Waters! We learn about real and fake corporate Pride products, new queer horror anthems, and musical word associations.

    Rachel Green would like to plug The Boss Bitch Show, her appearance on The Other Two, and recommends Titanique

    Kale Hills would like to plug PONY at UCB and recommends Dating Gayme

    And Finally, Dave Holmes is on Twitter @DaveHolmes. Dave would like to plug the app Landed

    Find us on Twitter! We are @TroubledPod

    Written by Riley Silverman and John-Luke Roberts, recorded remotely over Zoom and produced by Christian Dueñas and Laura Swisher.

    Join the MaxFun fam:

    maximumfun.org/join

    Troubled Waters
    enJune 15, 2023

    Tooter vs Tony

    Tooter vs Tony

    This week, Cat Alvarado and Heather Brooker join Dave for some foodstuffs karaoke, advice for the graduating class of 2023 and songs about friends and/or family. 

    Cat Alvarado would like to plug her album Off-White and recommends Tom McClain

    Heather Brooker would like to plug her stand up dates and the Brooker Family Popcast and recommends Reality Life with Kate Casey

    And Finally, Dave Holmes is on Twitter @DaveHolmes.

    Find us on Twitter! We are @TroubledPod

    Written by Riley Silverman and John-Luke Roberts, recorded remotely over Zoom and produced by Christian Dueñas and Laura Swisher.

    Join the MaxFun fam:

    maximumfun.org/join

     

    Music used:

    "honey jam" by massobeats

    Willie vs Pete

    Willie vs Pete

    This week, our friends Manolo Moreno and Matt McCarthy join host Dave Holmes for some writerly trivia, corporate biopics, and songs about moms.

    Manolo Moreno would like to plug Dr. Gameshow and recommends Club Video

    Matt McCarthy would like to plug his TIkTok, We Watch Wrestling, and Watch It, and recommends Going Up by Sara Schaefer

    And Finally, Dave Holmes is on Twitter @DaveHolmes

    Find us on Twitter! We are @TroubledPod

    Written by Riley Silverman and John-Luke Roberts, recorded remotely over Zoom and produced by Christian Dueñas and Laura Swisher.

    Join the MaxFun fam:

    maximumfun.org/join

     

    Music used:

    "Windswept" Kevin MacLeod (incompetech.com)

    Licensed under Creative Commons: By Attribution 4.0 License

    http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/