arizona murders

Today we go from Lake Havasu City, AZ down to the most charming town in the world.... GILBERT, AZ! Unfortunately the story doesn't have a charming ending. Then we scoot to the East Coast for a disturbing matriarchal theme murder(s).

Today the girls talk about how one of the most notorious serial killers in Florida history (Bobby Joe Long) gets taken down by 17 year old survivor, Lisa McVey,  who defied the odds and helped bring him to justice. We also talk about the still unsolved case of murderer Jason Derek Brown in Ahwatukee, Arizona!

The girl's share a story of a marriage to murdy based in Tucson, Arizona and then head south to listener hotspot Georgia to hear the baffling case of Tex & Diane McIver!

Today we have a Valentines/AZ/Football crossover episode. We talk about one of the longest running cold case murder victims in Arizona known as Valentine Sally, and then pop over to Nashville, Tennessee for the sad story of former NFL player Steve McNair.

The girls stick to the West Coast today with the stories of murdered SDSU student Cara Knott, and then the Trunk Murders by Winnie Ruth Judd in Phoenix!

Today the girls head to the Big Easy and discuss the murder of Liz Marinello, and the tragic murder of Mary Anne Holmes which rocked the small town of Thatcher, Arizona. 

Yay - today is the 50th episode of TMTM! Today we cover the case of the Phoenix Serial Shooters & Sarah Garone.

Melissa racks up another win in RPS and tells Sarah the listener suggested story of local Phoenix murderer, Angela Simpson. Sarah tells Melissa a tale from Sweden she's been hinting at covering for months, the death of Agneta Westlund. 

Melissa starts another streak with a quick win. She tells Sarah about Robert Charles Comer, who at one point was called the worst criminal in the entire Arizona prison system. Sarah tells Melissa about the Whitaker Family Murder from Sugarland, Texas.

Melissa crushes RPS in one sweet throw. She tells Sarah about the abduction and murder of local Arizona girl Vicki Lynne Hoskinsons in the 80s. Then Sarah shares the unbelievable story of the Unicorn Killer, Ira Einhorn.

Sarah beats the spurs off Melissa in one throw. She tells Melissa a nightmare of a story from Phoenix where Scott Falater sleep kills?? Melissa shares the story from South Carolina of Shari Faye Smith and Debra May Helmick who were both abducted  from their own front yards.

It's the last episode of 2020 and Melissa ends it with a win at RPS in one throw. She tells Sarah about the local story from Tempe of missing and murdered teenage paper girl, Christy Ann Fornoff. Sarah tells Melissa about the Richardson Family tragedy from Canada. 

Sarah takes the 3 peat in RPS. She tells Melissa about the suspected mafia hit on Don Bolles... THAT MIGHT HAVE BEEN PLANNED IN THEIR GRANDFATHER'S BAR??? Melissa tells Sarah the twisted tale that took the life of 13 year old Hillary Norskog.

Melissa stays camp champ at RPS. She tells Sarah the sad story of Linda Watson, a missing Tucson mother, and her own mother’s never ending quest to find her. Sarah shares the story of missing Connecticut mother Helle Craft, and what it took for the police to catch her killer. And then they both agreed to never get married because men are obvs cray. 

Melissa takes RPS today in one battle. She tells Sarah about a local Arizona murder from the 70s of armored van drivers Russell Dempsey and Cecil Newkirk. Sarah goes in depth on the White House Farm Murders from Essex, England. 

Melissa can't pull off the threepeat and loses at RPS. Sarah tells the incredibly depressing story of Charles "Charlie" Starkweather's murder spree in 1950's Nebraska with not so innocent Caril Fugate. Melissa counters with the tale of Valerie Pape, the French murderess in Scottsdale from the 90's.