Logo
    Search

    Against Narrative: Are stories bad for us? Part 2

    enApril 11, 2019

    Podcast Summary

    • Our preference for stories can shape perception of realityStories offer insights and entertainment but may overlook complexities and nuances of real-life situations

      Stories, whether fictional or non-fictional, have the power to shape our perception of reality. They offer comfort, escape, and a simplified understanding of complex situations. However, as discussed in the latest episode of Technically Speaking, an Intel podcast, and in the Conversations with UNK podcast, there can be downsides to this narrative obsession. Duke University professor and philosopher of science Alex Rosenberg argues that our preference for stories can cloud our understanding of history and current events. By engaging in theory of mind and identifying with characters, we may overlook the complexities and nuances of real-life situations. So, while stories can provide valuable insights and entertainment, it's essential to remember that they are just one perspective and may not always offer a complete or accurate representation of the world.

    • Perception of Reality Influenced by Narratives and StorytellingUnderstanding objective reality requires relying on scientific evidence and facts, not narratives or stories that may distort or misrepresent the truth.

      The way we perceive and understand reality is influenced by narratives and storytelling, which can sometimes be maladaptive in the context of complex issues like global warming. The science of global warming is clear, but misinformation and narratives that contradict the scientific consensus can be persuasive due to the adaptive nature of our perception of reality. Our brains use heuristics and shortcuts to make sense of the world, but these can sometimes lead to inaccurate or misleading perceptions. For instance, some memories may be based on stories rather than actual experiences. In the case of global warming, it's essential to distinguish between the scientific consensus and narratives that may have different agendas. The best way to understand objective reality and make informed decisions is to rely on scientific evidence and facts, rather than stories or narratives that may distort or misrepresent the truth.

    • The stories we tell ourselves shape our memories and understanding of realityOur memories and understanding of reality are influenced by the narratives we create, even if they're not entirely objective accounts of events. Repeating illusory truths or lies can also impact our perception of reality.

      Our memories and understanding of reality are often shaped by the stories we tell ourselves, which may not be purely objective accounts of events. We can take seemingly unrelated experiences and fit them into a narrative structure, like a rising tension in a story, to make sense of them. This can lead us to remember the story we created about an event rather than the actual event itself. Furthermore, even lies or illusory truths can impact our understanding of reality if we hear them enough times. This concept is reminiscent of ancient beliefs about time being cyclical and the importance of repeating acts and rituals. However, the shift to linear time has allowed for different narrative structures to emerge, including tales of fall and redemption, which can bring about modern anxieties and the realization of our own failings. Ultimately, our understanding of the past shapes our present and future.

    • The Power of StoriesStories shape our self-narratives, influence our perceptions, persuade effectively, provide therapeutic benefits, and shape cultural values.

      Stories have a profound impact on our lives, both in shaping our self-narratives and influencing how we perceive the world around us. Repetition and recollection are interconnected, as the stories we tell about ourselves or hear from others can influence our future actions. Stories have the power to persuade, often more effectively than facts alone, and can be used for good or evil purposes. Narratives can be therapeutic, helping us process emotions and heal, and they shape our cultural values and perceptions of a good life. Research suggests we identify with characters in stories much like we do with real people, making the impact of narratives even more significant.

    • The power of narratives in shaping historyNarratives can shape history by emboldening groups, but it's crucial to strike a balance between making characters relatable and maintaining objectivity.

      The way we tell stories about history and people can have significant consequences. The Nazi regime serves as a cautionary tale of how a powerful narrative can embolden a group at the expense of others. However, it's essential not to demonize historical figures too much, as doing so may prevent us from understanding the material conditions that contributed to their actions. When creating narratives, it's crucial to strike a balance between making characters relatable and maintaining an objective lesson. The responsibility of crafting stories is significant, and it's often taken lightly. Those who focus on narrative storytelling should exercise greater caution than those who merely collect factual information about history. The way narratives about history are presented can be breathtaking in their impact, and it's essential to approach them with care.

    • Understanding the Complexities of Historical NarrativesBe aware of simplified heroic narratives in history, recognize potential distortions, and seek out the full context of events.

      Historical events, like the adaptation of the film "300," can be interpreted in various ways. While some may view it as a simplified, heroic narrative, others recognize the complexities and potential distortions of historical storytelling. The film's portrayal of historical figures and cultures as heroes or villains can be problematic, as further research often reveals more nuanced truths. Ultimately, it's essential to be aware of the power of narrative and the potential for distortion, while also recognizing the importance of understanding the full context of historical events. The speaker also touched upon the role of unreliable narrators and the complications that come with getting too acquainted with the personal histories of contemporary heroes. The speaker acknowledged the allure of tidy, bold narratives but warned against creating unnecessary heroes and villains in history. Additionally, the speaker shared their personal experience with the film "300" and how they would approach it differently today. They also mentioned the importance of Astepro's fast-acting nasal allergy spray for allergy sufferers and the upcoming 2024 NFL schedule release. The episode was sponsored by eBay Motors.

    • The Power of Stories in CommunicationStories create deeper connections between individuals through synchronized brain activity called neural entrainment.

      Our brains are wired for stories. Uri Hasson, a psychologist and neuroscientist from Princeton University, has conducted research using fMRI to understand how our brains respond when we engage in storytelling or story listening. When people are engaged in successful verbal communication, their brain activity becomes physically aligned or coupled, meaning their brain responses become synchronized. This synchronization, known as neural entrainment, can occur even without a coherent story. However, when a story is present, the neural responses of both the storyteller and the listener become even more synchronized, creating a unique connection between the two. This research suggests that communication in the form of a story creates a deeper connection between individuals, akin to a melding of minds. So whether you're working on your car or sharing a personal narrative, remember the power of stories to bring us closer together.

    • Brain responds strongly to stories regardless of language or mediumStudies reveal aligned brain activation patterns for stories in various languages and mediums, suggesting a fundamental human adaptation for sharing information and understanding experiences

      Stories, regardless of language or medium, can elicit similar patterns of brain activation in listeners or viewers. This was discovered through various studies where participants were exposed to words, sentences, and stories in different languages, and despite the differences in language, brain imaging showed aligned patterns of activation in areas associated with early language processing, as well as higher brain functions like the frontal and parietal cortexes. This suggests that the brain responds strongly to stories as stories, and not just to the specific language or medium used to convey them. This could be a fundamental adaptation for humans, allowing us to share information and understand each other's experiences. The research also showed that people watching TV shows, retelling stories out loud, and even listening to recordings of others retelling stories, all showed similar brain activity scene by scene. This cross-media alignment further supports the idea that brain activity can be aligned by the content of the story itself, rather than the specific sensory task involved.

    • EBay Motors and AutoZone provide auto parts solutionsEBay Motors ensures a guaranteed fit for auto parts, while AutoZone offers free battery testing and recycling

      EBay Motors and AutoZone offer a wide range of auto parts to keep your vehicle running smoothly, with eBay Motors providing a guaranteed fit and AutoZone offering free battery testing and recycling. Meanwhile, Snagajob is a platform for hiring hourly workers, boasting a large talent pool and easy-to-use posting and filling system. In the realm of neurochemistry, oxytocin is a complex hormone associated with trust, cooperation, and social behavior, but its effects go beyond mother-infant bonding. It's important to remember that the popular press often oversimplifies the role of oxytocin, making it seem like a "love drug" or "moral molecule," but the truth is much more nuanced.

    • Narratives trigger oxytocin release, leading to pro-social behaviorsExperiencing a well-crafted narrative can increase oxytocin levels, promoting trust, generosity, and cooperation.

      Narratives have the power to trigger neurochemical reactions in our brains, specifically the release of oxytocin. This hormone is associated with feelings of trust, generosity, and cooperation. Research by neuroeconomist Paul Zak and his team shows that experiencing a narrative with a classic arc, such as a story of a father and son, can increase blood oxytocin levels. This can lead to pro-social behaviors like increased cooperation, charitable giving, and trust. However, it's important to note that the relationship between narratives and oxytocin release is still a subject of research and debate. Additionally, while narratives can have a positive impact, it's also possible that they could potentially increase aggressive behaviors if the narrative implies such actions. The key is in the narrative itself - a good story should have a rising tension, keep the audience engaged, and escalate the tension effectively. Despite this knowledge, many professionally told stories still fail to engage audiences emotionally and escalate tension effectively. A simple, well-told story can make all the difference, even in a stylish or low-budget film.

    • Oxytocin's Complex Role in Social BehaviorsOxytocin influences social behaviors beyond positive emotions and prosocial behaviors, including prejudice, dishonesty, and envy. Its effects are context-dependent and more research is needed to fully understand its role.

      Oxytocin, often referred to as the "love hormone" or "cuddle chemical," plays a complex role in social behaviors and emotions, beyond just fostering positive emotions and prosocial behaviors. While it may increase the salience of socially relevant information, it can also contribute to negative emotions and behaviors, such as prejudice, dishonesty, and envy. Furthermore, the effects of oxytocin are highly context-dependent, and more research is needed to fully understand its complex role in human behavior. Additionally, consuming narratives, such as stories or movies, may increase oxytocin levels and make individuals more socially receptive, potentially leading to motivations for action, but not necessarily good ones. It's important to remember that oxytocin is just one of many chemicals that contribute to the human experience, and its effects are complex and nuanced.

    • Understanding the Power and Pitfalls of NarrativesBeing aware of narratives' influence on our perception can help us navigate their pitfalls. Breaking focus on a narrative can disrupt its hold.

      Narratives have a profound impact on how we think, behave, and understand the world. They are deeply ingrained in human nature, akin to language. Depriving someone of stories is unimaginable and monstrous. However, narratives can cloud our understanding of reality by preventing us from seeing causes and effects clearly. While it may be impossible to eliminate the power of narratives, awareness of their influence is key to navigating their pitfalls. Practically, if you find yourself ensnared by a narrative, breaking your attention by focusing on something else can help disrupt its hold. This concept is echoed in various philosophies, such as Buddhism, which emphasizes self-awareness as a means of understanding and overcoming influences on perception.

    • Gaining a Zoomed-Out Perspective on StoriesPaying less focus can enhance understanding of a story's structure, while unexpected elements can offer fresh perspectives. Engaging with stories differently can lead to new insights and appreciation.

      Paying less close attention to a movie or story, while counterintuitive, can actually help improve understanding of its structure. This is because stepping back and gaining a more zoomed-out perspective can provide clarity on the beats and shape of the narrative. However, introducing an unexpected element, like imagining Nicholas Cage in every role, can also disrupt the narrative and provide a fresh perspective. Ultimately, engaging with stories in various ways can lead to new insights and appreciation. To support the show, listeners are encouraged to subscribe, rate, and review Stuff to Blow Your Mind, and check out their merchandise and social media accounts. The new email address for feedback is contact@stufftoblowyourmind.com. The upcoming NFL schedule release and the release of "Kingdom of the Planet of the Apes" are also highlighted.

    • Revolutionizing Daily Routines with Modern TechnologyThe Baby Brezza Bottle Washer Pro automates bottle washing, sterilization, and drying, while the Dexcom G7 helps manage diabetes with real-time glucose monitoring and eliminating painful finger sticks

      Modern technology is revolutionizing daily routines, making them more efficient and convenient. The Baby Brezza Bottle Washer Pro is an excellent example, as it automatically washes, sterilizes, and dries bottles, pump parts, and sippy cups with just the push of a button. Its 20 spray jets clean everything thoroughly, and it sterilizes with steam before drying with germ-free air. This machine saves parents valuable time and effort, allowing them to focus on other aspects of care. Another game-changer is the Dexcom G7, which helps people with diabetes monitor their glucose levels more effectively. This device sends glucose numbers to a compatible phone or watch, eliminating the need for painful finger sticks. It also allows users to see how food and exercise affect their glucose levels, making it easier to manage their condition and spend more time in range. The Dexcom G7 is the number one recommended CGM brand and is easy to get started with today. These innovations showcase how technology can simplify and improve various aspects of daily life, from parenting to diabetes management.

    Recent Episodes from Stuff To Blow Your Mind

    Smart Talks with IBM: AI & the Productivity Paradox

    Smart Talks with IBM: AI & the Productivity Paradox

    In a rapidly evolving world, we need to balance the fear surrounding AI and its role in the workplace with its potential to drive productivity growth. In this special live episode of Smart Talks with IBM, Malcolm Gladwell is joined onstage by Rob Thomas, senior vice president of software and chief commercial officer at IBM, during NY Tech Week. They discuss “the productivity paradox,” the importance of open-source AI, and a future where AI will touch every industry.

    This is a paid advertisement from IBM. The conversations on this podcast don't necessarily represent IBM's positions, strategies or opinions.

    Visit us at ibm.com/smarttalks

    See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

    Weirdhouse Cinema: The Dungeonmaster

    Weirdhouse Cinema: The Dungeonmaster

    In this episode of Weirdhouse Cinema, Rob and Joe return to the glorious world of 80s Charles Band productions with 1984’s “The Dungeonmaster,” a supernatural dreamscape with eight directors starring Jeffrey Byron, Richard Moll and Leslie Wing. It’s time to reject the devil’s reality and substitute your own! 

    See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

    New Season of Smart Talks with IBM Coming Soon

    New Season of Smart Talks with IBM Coming Soon

    Smart Talks with IBM returns with a new season on Tuesday, June 25th. This season, we’re diving back into the world of artificial intelligence, but with a focus on the powerful concept of “open,” and how it applies to AI. Host Malcolm Gladwell will invite curious colleagues from Pushkin Industries to explore how openness is already reshaping industries, ways of doing business, and our very notion of what's possible.

    This is a paid advertisement from IBM.

    Visit us at ibm.com/smarttalks

    See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

    Related Episodes

    EP142: Reverse Funnel Systems

    EP142: Reverse Funnel Systems

    My mom and I just wing it today and we end up talking about pyramid schemes. We’ve been a part of them and we wanna know if you’re one of the people who are super successful at it! Some of our friends are amazing sales women, we definitely aren’t. Enjoy the mother & daughter banter.

    Get 20% off your first order at https://www.sakara.com/coco or enter code: COCO at checkout!

    More podcasts at WAVE:

    https://podcasts.apple.com/us/artist/wave-podcast-network/1437831426

    See Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info.

    EP100: Topics from a hat with Nic & Vic

    EP100: Topics from a hat with Nic & Vic

    Nic and Vic each write 5 topics to discuss on this weeks pod and throw them into a hat. During the episode they randomly pull out the topics and have to talk about them! They don’t know what the other one wrote. Enjoy this improv dose of Coco.

    Get $15 off your first visit with a board-certified dermatologist at Apostrophe.com/COCO & use our code: COCO

    Activate free content tailored to your child’s age & get a peek inside The Play Kits at Lovevery.com/COCO

    More podcasts at WAVE!

    See Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info.

    EP85: Thanksgiving Traditions

    EP85: Thanksgiving Traditions

    Happy Thanksgiving! This week Nic and Vic chat about their different Thanksgiving traditions growing up with their families. Learn about everything from the midwestern green bean casseroles to Puerto Rican mofongo! Enjoy and laugh with them in this grateful dose of Coco.

    Listen to other podcasts similar to this on iTunes!

    See Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info.

    ML92: Kyle Pearce on How To Become a DIY Genius, Getting into Flow and Learning from Other Cultures

    ML92: Kyle Pearce on How To Become a DIY Genius, Getting into Flow and Learning from Other Cultures

    Kyle Pearce is the Founder of DIY Genius – a self-education platform that helps people learn faster online. In this episode we discuss:
    - How Kyle learns best and the skills needed to thrive in the 21st century
    - How to access the flow state that produces optimal performance
    - Kyle’s travel experiences and what he’s learned from other cultures
    So whether you’re looking to learn more effectively online, build a mobile business, or get into flow this episode will give you all you need and more.

    EP98: OBGYN Dr. Shannon Clark

    EP98: OBGYN Dr. Shannon Clark

    Nic and Vic discuss their 20 week anatomy ultrasound and give pregnancy updates. Dr. Shannon Clark is here today to discuss her own journey through pregnancy and her passion in helping/researching women who are over 35 years old and want to get pregnant. Dr. Shannon Clark aka the “tiktokbabydoc” has tons of knowledge to share and we hope you learn something new and helpful. Enjoy your weekly dose of Coco!

    Go to https://kittypooclub.com & enter promo code coco, to get 20% off when you set up auto-ship!

    More podcasts on WAVE:
    https://podcasts.apple.com/us/artist/wave-podcast-network/1437831426 

    See Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info.