Logo
    Search

    Bonus Episode 17 - Pirates of the Caribbean: Curse of the Black Pearl

    enSeptember 28, 2022

    About this Episode

    You best start believing in ghost stories, dear listeners - we're in one! We're tackling fan-favorite Disney franchise Pirates of the Caribbean for our latest bonus episode, so join us as we take our rubric to the first film, Curse of the Black Pearl.

    Don’t miss:

    • The sheer number of quotes the three of us throw into this episode
    • How the fights in this film do so much work for the character development
    • A discussion of the way this film has fed back into other Disney phenomena
    • Our final score, making this easily the best-ranked film of any of our bonus films thus far

     

    Links for you:

    • Our website has our ranking spreadsheet for all the movies we’ve rated so far
    • Become a Ko-fi member for exclusive content and access to your hosts and our team
    • Follow our guest Bray on Twitter
    • Join our ‘Ohana to be among the first to know about new content we’re developing
    • Follow us on Twitter @definingdisney
    • When our transcription is available, we’ll link it here

    Don’t forget to SUBSCRIBE so you don’t miss a single episode, and if you enjoyed this one, please leave us a rating and review. Thanks for listening and we’ll see ya real soon!

    Recent Episodes from Defining Disney Podcast

    Episode 5x11 - Lilo and Stitch

    Episode 5x11 - Lilo and Stitch

    Finish the canon with us with our take on Lilo and Stitch, a supersized episode with eight - yes, EIGHT - guests that make up part of our podcast ‘Ohana contributing their own unique perspectives to this fan favorite film. 

    ‘Ohana means family, and family means no one gets left behind or forgotten. We promise our long run time is worth not being left behind! 

    Don’t miss:

    • The way this movie breaks our hearts and puts them back together again a million and one times
    • How many elements of Hawaiian culture and specific Kauai references Chris Sanders and Dean DeBlois make central to this film’s story, characters, and landscape
    • A discussion of the various things that worked in this film that Disney was able to take forward into the Revival and beyond
    • Our final score, which may or may not surprise you based on our love for this film

    PLUS, we talk through all the thoughts our audience had when they watched the movie, including even more members of our podcast community!

     

    Links for you:

    • Our website has our ranking spreadsheet for the full Walt Disney Animation Studios canon
    • Join our ‘Ohana to be among the first to know about new content we’re developing
    • Follow us on Twitter @definingdisney and let us know your thoughts on Lilo and Stitch
    • When our transcription is available, we’ll link it here
    • Meet our guests: Stephen | Katy | Bray | Lauren | Kaitlyn | Tim of OSW | Darin of NostalgiaCast | Kevin

    Don’t forget to SUBSCRIBE so you don’t miss our return, and if you enjoyed this one, please leave us a rating and review. Thanks for listening and we’ll see ya real soon!

    Episode 5x10 - Encanto

    Episode 5x10 - Encanto

    Drawers, floors, doors - let’s go! Come with us and the family Madrigal as we unpack Encanto, a magical tale of a family blessed with gifts and riddled with trauma, set in beautiful Colombia.

    Don’t miss:

    • The way this film’s team learned from other past films to make this one the best it could possibly be
    • How many specific Colombian cultural elements the film incorporates
    • A discussion of the character development within this film, both in range and growth, that sets the new gold standard for the category in our rubric
    • Our final score, which sets the bar high for any future Disney films we may cover down the line

    PLUS, we talk through all the thoughts our audience had when they watched the movie, including several members of our community on Twitter!

     

    Links for you:

    • Our website has our ranking spreadsheet for all the movies we’ve rated so far
    • Join our ‘Ohana to be among the first to know about new content we’re developing
    • Follow us on Twitter @definingdisney and let us know your thoughts on Encanto
    • When our transcription is available, we’ll link it here

    Don’t forget to SUBSCRIBE so you don’t miss a single episode, and if you enjoyed this one, please leave us a rating and review. Thanks for listening and we’ll see ya real soon!

    Episode 5x09 - Make Mine Music

    Episode 5x09 - Make Mine Music

    Come along on another symphonic journey as we tackle our last package film in Make Mine Music! Fair warning - this one isn’t on Disney+, so you may not be able to watch it before listening.

    Don’t miss:

    • The short that really serves as the blueprint for discussing character development in music
    • How jazz ties all of these shorts together, even with all its wide-varying subjects
    • A discussion of the oddities that litter this film, including changed score segments, one anthropomorphic animal in an otherwise normal world, and a short that was cut entirely
    • Our final score, cementing the package era as the overall lowest in the canon

    PLUS, we talk through all the thoughts our audience had when they watched the movie, including several members of our community on Twitter!

     

    Links for you:

    • Our website has our ranking spreadsheet for all the movies we’ve rated so far
    • Join our ‘Ohana to be among the first to know about new content we’re developing
    • Follow us on Twitter @definingdisney and let us know your thoughts on Make Mine Music
    • When our transcription is available, we’ll link it here

    Don’t forget to SUBSCRIBE so you don’t miss a single episode, and if you enjoyed this one, please leave us a rating and review. Thanks for listening and we’ll see ya real soon!

    Episode 5x08 - Pocahontas

    Episode 5x08 - Pocahontas

    As historically inaccurate and insensitive as it is, the time has come in our journey to tackle Pocahontas, Disney’s very fictional retelling of historical events between the colonists of Jamestown and the Native American Powhatan tribe.

    Don’t miss:

    • The way the music of this film saves its bacon on several fronts
    • How interruptions from studio exec Jeffrey Katzenberg caused stumbling blocks in character development
    • A discussion of how many things Disney got wrong about Native Americans, despite the fact that they did make far more of an effort than most studios at the time
    • Our final score, which puts it near the bottom of the Renaissance

    PLUS, we talk through all the thoughts our audience had when they watched the movie, including several members of our community on Twitter!

     

    Links for you:

    • Our website has our ranking spreadsheet for all the movies we’ve rated so far
    • Become a Ko-fi member for exclusive content and access to your hosts and our team
    • Join our ‘Ohana to be among the first to know about new content we’re developing
    • Follow us on Twitter @definingdisney and let us know your thoughts on Pocahontas
    • When our transcription is available, we’ll link it here

    Don’t forget to SUBSCRIBE so you don’t miss a single episode, and if you enjoyed this one, please leave us a rating and review. Thanks for listening and we’ll see ya real soon!

    Episode 5x07 - The Fox and the Hound

    Episode 5x07 - The Fox and the Hound

    Get the tissues, y’all - it’s time for us to take on The Fox and the Hound, one of Disney’s Dark Age films that really pulls at the heartstrings. 

    Don’t miss:

    • The reason Amos Slade is one of the scarier villains we encounter in the canon, despite his immaturity of holding a grudge against a literal adolescent animal
    • How some of the imagery in this film quickly gets burned into your mind
    • A discussion of the theming nuances of this film that help us make a guess at where in America it might take place
    • Our final score, which strikes the balance between the strong moments and its lack of staying power

    PLUS, we talk through all the thoughts our audience had when they watched the movie, including several members of our community on Twitter!

     

    Links for you:

    • Our website has our ranking spreadsheet for all the movies we’ve rated so far
    • Become a Ko-fi member for exclusive content and access to your hosts and our team
    • Join our ‘Ohana to be among the first to know about new content we’re developing
    • Follow us on Twitter @definingdisney and let us know your thoughts on Fox and the Hound
    • When our transcription is available, we’ll link it here

    Don’t forget to SUBSCRIBE so you don’t miss a single episode, and if you enjoyed this one, please leave us a rating and review. Thanks for listening and we’ll see ya real soon!

    Episode 5x06 - Winnie the Pooh

    Episode 5x06 - Winnie the Pooh

    Join us for a trip down memory lane to the Hundred Acre Wood for 2011’s Winnie the Pooh, the last hand-drawn animated film at Walt Disney Animation Studios - for now.

    Don’t miss:

    • The surprisingly linear story for a Pooh film, which are typically episodic
    • How cleverly the dialogue is played on to create the main conflict of the story
    • A discussion of the film’s effect on the studio’s approach to hand-drawn animation and that outlook moving forward
    • Our final score, which reflects the strength of story and the nostalgic notes they didn’t quite hit

    PLUS, we talk through all the thoughts our audience had when they watched the movie, including those who joined us for #ddpwatchnight on Twitter!

     

    Links for you:

    • Our website has our ranking spreadsheet for all the movies we’ve rated so far
    • Become a Ko-fi member for exclusive content and access to your hosts and our team
    • Join our ‘Ohana to be among the first to know about new content we’re developing
    • Follow us on Twitter @definingdisney and let us know your thoughts on Winnie the Pooh
    • When our transcription is available, we’ll link it here

    Don’t forget to SUBSCRIBE so you don’t miss a single episode, and if you enjoyed this one, please leave us a rating and review. Thanks for listening and we’ll see ya real soon!

    Episode 5x05 - Pinocchio

    Episode 5x05 - Pinocchio

    We’re back for our home stretch of Disney’s animated canon with our take on Pinocchio, an early Golden Age classic where Disney pushed the envelope both in content and technology.

    Don’t miss:

    • The meandering, episodic nature of the story - a risk for Walt Disney in only his second film
    • How frighteningly sinister some of the villains are in this film, compared to others across the canon
    • A discussion of the film’s treatment of magic, which is… questionable at best
    • Our final score, which reflects the difficulties with story and character opposing the strength of visuals

    PLUS, we talk through all the thoughts our audience had when they watched the movie, including those who joined us for #ddpwatchnight on Twitter!

     

    Links for you:

    • Our website has our ranking spreadsheet for all the movies we’ve rated so far
    • Become a Ko-fi member for exclusive content and access to your hosts and our team
    • Join our ‘Ohana to be among the first to know about new content we’re developing
    • Follow us on Twitter @definingdisney and let us know your thoughts on Pinocchio
    • When our transcription is available, we’ll link it here

    Don’t forget to SUBSCRIBE so you don’t miss a single episode, and if you enjoyed this one, please leave us a rating and review. Thanks for listening and we’ll see ya real soon!

    Bonus Episode 17 - Pirates of the Caribbean: Curse of the Black Pearl

    Bonus Episode 17 - Pirates of the Caribbean: Curse of the Black Pearl

    You best start believing in ghost stories, dear listeners - we're in one! We're tackling fan-favorite Disney franchise Pirates of the Caribbean for our latest bonus episode, so join us as we take our rubric to the first film, Curse of the Black Pearl.

    Don’t miss:

    • The sheer number of quotes the three of us throw into this episode
    • How the fights in this film do so much work for the character development
    • A discussion of the way this film has fed back into other Disney phenomena
    • Our final score, making this easily the best-ranked film of any of our bonus films thus far

     

    Links for you:

    • Our website has our ranking spreadsheet for all the movies we’ve rated so far
    • Become a Ko-fi member for exclusive content and access to your hosts and our team
    • Follow our guest Bray on Twitter
    • Join our ‘Ohana to be among the first to know about new content we’re developing
    • Follow us on Twitter @definingdisney
    • When our transcription is available, we’ll link it here

    Don’t forget to SUBSCRIBE so you don’t miss a single episode, and if you enjoyed this one, please leave us a rating and review. Thanks for listening and we’ll see ya real soon!

    Episode 5x04 - Sleeping Beauty

    Episode 5x04 - Sleeping Beauty

    Confront the Mistress of All Evil with us as we discuss Sleeping Beauty, one of Disney’s most visual-forward films that unfortunately trades style for substance in some cases.

    Don’t miss:

    • The iconic art style of this film that makes nearly every shot a frameable masterpiece
    • How the title misleads the audience about who the real protagonist of the film is
    • A discussion of the film’s score, which is largely lifted from the original Tchaikovsky ballet
    • Our final score, which represents the peak of the Silver Age

    PLUS, we talk through all the thoughts our audience had when they watched the movie, including those who joined us for #ddpwatchnight on Twitter!

     

    Links for you:

    • Our website has our ranking spreadsheet for all the movies we’ve rated so far
    • Check out our guest Darin on his podcast, NostalgiaCast
    • Become a Ko-fi member for exclusive content and access to your hosts and our team
    • Join our ‘Ohana to be among the first to know about new content we’re developing
    • Follow us on Twitter @definingdisney and let us know your thoughts on Sleeping Beauty
    • When our transcription is available, we’ll link it here

    Don’t forget to SUBSCRIBE so you don’t miss a single episode, and if you enjoyed this one, please leave us a rating and review. Thanks for listening and we’ll see ya real soon!

    Episode 5x03 - Dinosaur

    Episode 5x03 - Dinosaur

    Travel back in time with us as we break down Dinosaur, Disney’s only prehistoric adventure, which combined incredible technological advances with an excellent score and still somehow ended up lackluster.

    Don’t miss:

    • The strong visual elements of the film that unfortunately couldn’t save its story
    • How the character development absolutely tanks this film’s score
    • A discussion of the sheer power of James Newton Howard’s score in this film
    • Our final score, which mirrors the beginning of the Digital Age

    PLUS, we talk through all the thoughts our audience had when they watched the movie, including some of our good friends on Twitter who love this movie despite its flaws. 

     

    Links for you:

    • Our website has our ranking spreadsheet for all the movies we’ve rated so far
    • Become a Ko-fi member for exclusive content and access to your hosts and our team
    • Join our ‘Ohana to be among the first to know about new content we’re developing
    • Follow us on Twitter @definingdisney and let us know your thoughts on Dinosaur
    • When our transcription is available, we’ll link it here

    Don’t forget to SUBSCRIBE so you don’t miss a single episode, and if you enjoyed this one, please leave us a rating and review. Thanks for listening and we’ll see ya real soon!