Logo
    Search

    Caregiving as a source of stress and strength, with William Haley, PhD

    enNovember 08, 2023

    Podcast Summary

    • Caring for Loved Ones: A Significant Role with Complexities38M Americans provide caregiving, 17M care for mobility/self-care issues, 8.5M care for Alzheimer's/dementias, caregiving impacts mental health positively/negatively, employers/institutions/policymakers can support caregivers.

      Caregiving in the US is a significant issue with millions of people providing unpaid care to their loved ones every year. According to estimates, around 38 million Americans have provided caregiving assistance, with 17 million of these caregivers caring for individuals with mobility or self-care issues. Among these caregivers, 8.5 million are providing heavy caregiving to those with Alzheimer's, dementias, or other conditions with multiple limitations. Caregiving can be stressful and challenging, but it's essential to note that it can also be a source of strength for caregivers. Research suggests that caregiving can positively impact mental health by fostering feelings of purpose and fulfillment. However, it can also negatively affect physical health due to the physical demands and emotional stress. Circumstances such as lack of social support, poor health of the caregiver, and the care recipient's behavior can increase stress. Employers, institutions, and policymakers can help support caregivers by implementing flexible work arrangements, offering caregiver benefits, and providing access to community resources. Ultimately, understanding the complexities of caregiving and implementing supportive measures can help mitigate the negative effects and enhance the positive aspects of this important role.

    • Caregiving's Impact on Health: Debunking MythsDespite early concerns, recent research shows caregiving may have minimal negative impact on physical health and even a slight mortality benefit. However, psychological distress and societal support remain major concerns.

      The negative health effects of caregiving, particularly in terms of physical health, have been exaggerated based on early, small-scale studies. More recent research suggests that caregiving may even lead to a slight mortality benefit and minimal impact on inflammation. However, it's important to note that psychological distress, such as depression and anxiety, can still be significant challenges for caregivers. Additionally, the lack of societal support for caregivers, who often put in full-time hours, is a major concern. Caregiving is not as detrimental to health as smoking, but we need to do better in providing resources and assistance to those who are caring for loved ones.

    • Medicare's Limited Support for Long-Term CareMedicare does not cover custodial care, leading to financial burdens and emotional stress for caregivers of individuals with dementia, necessitating a more comprehensive approach to long-term care.

      The current healthcare system, specifically Medicare, falls short in providing adequate support for long-term care, particularly for caregivers of individuals with dementia and other cognitive impairments. While Medicare covers medical conditions, it does not extend to custodial care, such as bathing, dressing, and managing incontinence, which are essential tasks for many caregivers. This mismatch results in financial burdens for families, who often bear the costs out of pocket. Moreover, the stressors for caregivers are compounded by the behavioral challenges associated with dementia. People with dementia may wander, become agitated, or exhibit embarrassing behavior in public, creating additional emotional strain for caregivers. Effective communication strategies, such as avoiding arguments and focusing on nonverbal cues, can help mitigate these challenges. To address these issues, there is a need for a more comprehensive approach to long-term care, which could involve expanding the role of insurers, both public and private, to cover custodial care. Additionally, providing resources and support for caregivers, such as counseling interventions and communication training, can help alleviate the emotional and physical demands of caregiving.

    • Effective Strategies for Caring for a Person with DementiaDistracting a person with dementia, connecting with support networks, and utilizing evidence-based interventions can help improve caregiving experience and delay nursing home placement.

      Caring for a person with dementia can be challenging and stressful, but there are effective strategies and resources available to help. Distracting a person with dementia, such as offering them a candy or taking them outside for a few minutes, can help de-escalate arguments or stressful situations. For caregivers seeking to learn these skills and connect with support networks, resources include clinical geropsychologists, psychotherapists, counselors, social workers, the Alzheimer's Association, area agencies on aging, and geriatric care managers. Additionally, evidence-based psychological interventions, such as cognitive behavioral therapy, mindfulness therapy, and psychoeducational approaches, have been shown to improve caregivers' well-being and delay nursing home placement. Caregivers often face multiple roles, such as being a spouse and a caregiver, which can make it difficult to manage all responsibilities effectively. Seeking help and utilizing available resources can make a significant difference in the caregiving experience.

    • Learning to Ask for Help and Take Breaks as a CaregiverCaregivers must ask for help and take breaks to avoid burnout. The 'village' concept, where communities help each other age in place, is gaining popularity as a solution.

      Caregivers, who are often selfless and used to helping others, need to learn to ask for help and take breaks to avoid reaching a crisis point. Caregiving comes with numerous responsibilities, from managing finances to personal care, and it's essential to delegate some tasks to family or professional services. Unfortunately, many caregivers wait until they're in crisis before seeking help, which can lead to burnout. The lack of affordable support services adds to the challenge. The "village" concept, where communities help each other age in place, is gaining popularity as a solution. It involves educating the whole community to create aging-friendly environments and offering services like dementia cafes for caregivers and their loved ones. I first became interested in caregiving research in 1981, recognizing the importance of understanding and supporting those who dedicate their lives to caring for others.

    • Discovering the crucial role of psychologists in supporting family caregivers of individuals with dementiaTeaching coping skills and communication strategies to family caregivers of individuals with dementia leads to grateful clients and can predict well-being for designing interventions. The US is making progress with recent legislation, but more resources are needed.

      The role of psychologists in supporting family caregivers of individuals with dementia is not only rewarding but also crucial for understanding psychological stress. In the late 1980s, the speaker, a psychologist, discovered this firsthand during her postdoctoral fellowship at the University of Washington Seattle, where she worked in one of the first dementia clinics in the US. She found that teaching caregivers coping skills and communication strategies led to her most grateful clients. Furthermore, she realized that studying caregiver stress could lead to predicting well-being and designing interventions. The speaker also noted that while the US lags behind in providing resources for family caregivers compared to Western European and UK countries, recent federal legislation, such as the RAISE Family Caregiver Act, is a step in the right direction. Overall, this area of work is essential for every psychologist due to the increasing number of people with dementia and severe impairments.

    • Preparing for caregiving needs in an aging populationStart preparing early for potential caregiving needs, manage legal and financial affairs, have conversations, expand education, and recognize caregiving as a cultural norm.

      Preparing for potential caregiving needs is crucial for individuals and families as the baby boomer population ages. This includes managing legal and financial affairs through trusts and long-term care insurance, having conversations about caregiving before it becomes necessary, and understanding cultural differences and their impact on caregiving approaches. While it's important to start preparing early, resources and education about caregiving, particularly at the college level, should also be expanded to better equip future generations. Additionally, recognizing caregiving as a cultural norm and family responsibility in certain communities can help make the experience less burdensome.

    • Caring for Elderly Family Members: Challenges and Benefits for Black FamiliesBlack families prioritize caregiving at home due to financial reasons and cultural preferences, but it comes with stress and personal growth. Society should value caregiving and offer support to caregivers to focus on benefits.

      Caregiving, especially for elderly family members, is a complex experience that comes with both challenges and benefits. Black families are less likely to place their loved ones in nursing homes due to financial reasons, racial discrimination, and a strong preference to keep them at home. Caregiving can be stressful, but the majority of caregivers report it as a positive experience that helps them grow as individuals and feel more connected to others. The psychological benefits of caregiving include personal growth, increased meaning in life, and a sense of doing something meaningful. Society could improve the caregiving experience by valuing the role as equally important as employment and recognizing the economic value of caregiving. Caregivers can also be encouraged to focus on the pleasures and benefits of caregiving as part of successful coping strategies.

    • Recognizing Caregiving as a Productive RoleValuing caregiving through policies like paid leave and compensation is crucial for the well-being of caregivers and the communities they serve.

      Caregiving, an essential role in our communities, often goes uncompensated. Dr. Haley emphasized the importance of recognizing caregiving as a productive role and advocated for policies such as paid leave and compensation for caregivers. The Veterans Administration offers a model for this with their payments to caregivers. Employers could also play a role by offering paid break time for caregiving. This requires a shift in thinking, but it's a necessary change to ensure caregivers can continue contributing to the labor market without financial strain. Overall, valuing caregiving and implementing supportive policies is crucial for the well-being of caregivers and the communities they serve.

    Recent Episodes from Speaking of Psychology

    How noise pollution harms our health, with Arline Bronzaft, PhD

    How noise pollution harms our health, with Arline Bronzaft, PhD

    From roaring leaf blowers to screeching trains, the world is full of unwelcome noise – and researchers have found that noisy environments can take a real toll on people’s mental and physical health. Arline Bronzaft, PhD, talks about how noise affects health and well-being, how it can harm kids’ learning, why it’s not just a problem in big cities, and the most unusual noise complaints she’s heard in her five decades of advocacy combating noise pollution.

    Speaking of Psychology
    enJune 26, 2024

    Mental health in a warming world, with Kim Meidenbauer, PhD, and Amruta Nori-Sarma, PhD

    Mental health in a warming world, with Kim Meidenbauer, PhD, and Amruta Nori-Sarma, PhD

    Last year -- 2023 -- was the world’s warmest on record, and 2024 could bring another record-shattering summer. Psychologist Kim Meidenbauer, PhD, and public health researcher Amruta Nori-Sarma, PhD, discuss how heat affects people’s mental health, emotions and even cognitive abilities; the link between heat, violence and aggression; who is most vulnerable to the effects of extreme heat; and what policy makers could be doing to mitigate its effects.

    Speaking of Psychology
    enJune 19, 2024

    How to motivate yourself and others, with Wendy Grolnick, PhD, and Frank Worrell, PhD

    How to motivate yourself and others, with Wendy Grolnick, PhD, and Frank Worrell, PhD

    Why can’t I get myself to run that 5K? Why isn’t my child getting better grades? We all have things that we struggle to accomplish – or that we struggle to get someone else to accomplish. Frank Worrell, PhD, and Wendy Grolnick, PhD, co-authors of “Motivation Myth Busters: Science-based Strategies to Boost Motivation in Yourself and Others,” discuss how our misconceptions about motivation get in the way of reaching our goals, why there’s no such thing as an “unmotivated” person, and the merits and drawbacks of strategies like rewards, competition and praise.

    Speaking of Psychology
    enJune 12, 2024

    The benefits of solitude, with Thuy-vy Nguyen, PhD, and Netta Weinstein, PhD

    The benefits of solitude, with Thuy-vy Nguyen, PhD, and Netta Weinstein, PhD

    The average American adult spends up to one-third of their waking hours alone. Psychologists are exploring how those hours spent on our own affect us – including the potential benefits, as well as the challenges, of solitude. Thuy-vy Nguyen, PhD, and Netta Weinstein, PhD, discuss the difference between solitude and loneliness, how solitude affects our emotions and stress levels, why some people crave solitude more than others, and why the stigma against solitude can make us uncomfortable with being alone.

    Speaking of Psychology
    enJune 05, 2024

    Which countries are happiest and why? With Lara Aknin, PhD

    Which countries are happiest and why? With Lara Aknin, PhD

    The 2024 World Happiness Report, which ranks the happiness levels of countries around the world, found that young Americans are less happy than their peers in many other countries. Psychology professor Lara Aknin, PhD, an editor of the report, talks about how the report defines happiness, why young people’s happiness levels may have dropped in the U.S, what drives happiness, and why being generous makes people happy – even when they don’t have much to spare.

    Choosing to be child free, with Jennifer Watling Neal, PhD

    Choosing to be child free, with Jennifer Watling Neal, PhD

    A growing number of adults in the U.S. are choosing not to have children. Jenna Watling Neal, PhD, of Michigan State University, talks about her research that’s found 1 in 5 adults are child free, why people are choosing not to have kids, the stigma child-free adults face, whether people who decide not to have kids early in life usually stick with that choice, and how the prevalence of child-free adults in the U.S. compares with other countries.

    How to cope with political stress this election season, with Brett Q. Ford, PhD, and Kevin Smith, PhD

    How to cope with political stress this election season, with Brett Q. Ford, PhD, and Kevin Smith, PhD

    If the thought of the upcoming election sends your stress level through the roof, you’re not alone. Psychologist Brett Q. Ford, PhD, and political scientist Kevin Smith, PhD, talk about how political stress affects people’s well-being; what high levels of political stress mean for people’s lives, for the U.S. and for democracy; and how to stay politically engaged while still maintaining your mental health.

    For transcripts, links and more information, please visit the Speaking of Psychology Homepage.

    How Sesame Street teaches kids about emotional well-being, with Rosemarie Truglio, PhD

    How Sesame Street teaches kids about emotional well-being, with Rosemarie Truglio, PhD

    Sesame Street has entertained and educated generations of children. Developmental psychologist Rosemarie Truglio, PhD, Sesame Workshop’s senior vice president of curriculum and content, talks about why the show has a new focus on young children’s emotional well-being; how Sesame Street translates complicated concepts into stories that young kids can connect with; the research that underpins all of the content on Sesame Street; and why the Sesame Street characters still resonate with so many adults.

    For transcripts, links and more information, please visit the Speaking of Psychology Homepage.

    What déjà vu can teach us about memory, with Chris Moulin, PhD

    What déjà vu can teach us about memory, with Chris Moulin, PhD

    The eerie sensation of “déjà vu” -- feeling a strong sense of familiarity in a new place or situation -- is one of memory’s strangest tricks. Researcher Chris Moulin, PhD, of Grenoble Alpes University, talks about why déjà vu happens; why both déjà vu and its lesser-known opposite, jamais vu, may actually be signs of a healthy memory at work; why young people are more prone to déjà vu; how he and others study déjà vu and jamais vu in the lab; and what these experiences can teach us about memory more broadly.

    For transcripts, links and more information, please visit the Speaking of Psychology Homepage.

    The psychology of sports fans, with Daniel Wann, PhD

    The psychology of sports fans, with Daniel Wann, PhD

    Are you a sports “superfan”? Or do you wonder what’s driving the superfans in your life? Daniel Wann, PhD, of Murray State University, talks about why being a fan is usually good for people’s mental health, how they choose the teams they root for, why some are fair-weather fans while others love to cheer for the underdog, how fandom is changing among younger people, and whether a crowd of supportive fans can affect the outcome of a game.

    For transcripts, links and more information, please visit the Speaking of Psychology Homepage.

    Related Episodes

    How is long term disability insurance different than LTC insurance?

    How is long term disability insurance different than LTC insurance?
    In this episode, Melanie Erb-Wokurka with Juice Plus in Tampa, Florida, wants to know how LTC insurance is different than the long term disability plan her company is offering.  Listen as Diane shares how the products are different and where each fits into our planning puzzle.  For asking, we'll send Melanie a gift to say thank you for helping listeners understand what to consider when preparing for tomorrow.

    Can I use my 401(k) to fund an LTC plan?

    Can I use my 401(k) to fund an LTC plan?
    This week, Bill asks if he can avoid paying taxes on 401 (k) withdrawals to pay for LTC insurance.  Diane shares how tax-qualified accounts can be used to build tax-free long term care benefits.  There are a lot of numbers in this episode, so you may want to listen twice to take it all in.  The concept is more important than the numbers.