Logo

    Crosshairs and Crossbars: Trump’s Close Call & Southgate’s England Misfire

    enJuly 16, 2024
    What factors contribute to England's potential success in the Euros?
    How does media influence young English fans' perceptions?
    What contrasting behaviors were observed among English soccer fans?
    What cultural differences exist between English and Spanish football?
    Why is open dialogue vital during political tension?

    Podcast Summary

    • English soccer cultureThe speaker believes in England's potential to win Euros, but expresses concern about negative media impact and hostile fan behavior tarnishing its reputation

      The speaker expresses a strong belief in England's potential to win the Euros, with the emergence of talented midfielders like Bellingham and Rice. The speaker also expresses concern about the negative impact of certain media outlets, such as News Round, on young English fans' perception of their country. Additionally, the speaker shares a personal experience of witnessing hostile behavior from English soccer fans during international matches, which contrasts with the older generation's memories of English atrocities in Ireland. Overall, the speaker expresses a complex view of English soccer culture, recognizing both its positive aspects and the negative ones that can tarnish its reputation.

    • English vs Spanish football cultureEnglish football culture is criticized for its lack of sportsmanship and aggressive fan behavior compared to Spanish football culture, which values appreciation for beautiful goals by the opposition.

      The English soccer community, as depicted in the BBC's coverage of the Euro 2020 final, was contrasted with their Spanish counterparts in terms of sportsmanship and fan behavior. The English pundits were criticized for their crossness and banality compared to the Spanish, with players like Juan Mata taking meticulous notes. The English football fans' behavior was also highlighted as a cause for concern, with memories of past riots and hooliganism. The English team's coach, Gareth Southgate, has attempted to be a good ambassador for England, but the underlying belligerence and aggression in English football remains a problem. This is in stark contrast to the Spanish fans' applause for beautiful goals by the opposition, reflecting a different tone and appreciation for the game.

    • Political sensitivity during times of tensionLeaders should be mindful of their constituents' sensitivities and avoid actions that may be perceived as alienating or insensitive during times of political tension

      During times of political tension, it's important to be mindful of the historical context and the emotions involved. The speaker expressed disappointment towards a political figure, Mary Lou McDonald, for seemingly supporting England during the Euro 2020 soccer final against Italy. The speaker criticized this action as insensitive to the loyalist community in Northern Ireland, who have a long-standing animosity towards England. The speaker also praised another political figure, Pippa Hackett, for her support during the same situation. The speaker's overall message was that leaders should be mindful of the sensitivities of their constituents and avoid actions that may be perceived as alienating or insensitive. Additionally, the speaker expressed frustration with the media's obsession with the topic and their repetition of the question of whether or not people should support England.

    • English football team's anti-intellectualismThe English football team's lack of intellectual approach and reliance on foreign players and managers has hindered their success in international tournaments, resulting in a lack of unity and clear philosophy.

      The English football team's inability to think for themselves and the outsourcing of intelligence to foreign players and managers is a major reason for their consistent failure in international tournaments. This anti-intellectualism and fear of the unknown has led to a lack of unity and philosophy in team selection, resulting in a lackluster performance on the field. The Spanish football culture, on the other hand, values intelligence and sophistication, allowing for a more unified and successful approach. The English team's reliance on popularity and political expediency instead of youth, talent, and a clear philosophy is a major hindrance to their success. The case of Stormy Daniels serves as a reminder of the importance of having a clear vision and the courage to make bold decisions.

    • American democracy subversionFormer President Trump's actions and certain powerful interests pose a threat to American democracy, with his election seen as inevitable due to electorate understanding and the Supreme Court's ruling on presidential immunity, but hope remains for the American people to protect their democracy.

      The speaker expresses deep concern about the potential for American democracy to be subverted towards an autocratic regime, as seen in the actions and rhetoric of former President Trump and certain powerful interests. They believe that Trump's election was not only likely but inevitable due to his ability to generate excitement and his understanding of the American electorate. The speaker also references the Supreme Court's ruling on presidential immunity as a concerning step in this direction. Despite the challenges, the speaker remains hopeful that the American people will ultimately prevail in protecting their democracy.

    • Trump's political strategyTrump's strategy relies on performance, exploiting opponent's weaknesses, and tapping into societal polarization and violence. Democrats face challenge in attacking his dangerous tendencies towards democracy without appearing impolite. US grapples with violent society and military interventions fueling Trump's rhetoric and actions.

      Donald Trump's political strategy relies heavily on performance and exploiting perceived weaknesses of his opponents. His ability to use sound bites effectively and tap into societal polarization and violence makes him a formidable opponent. The Democrats face a challenge in attacking Trump's dangerous tendencies towards democracy without appearing to cross polite boundaries. Meanwhile, the United States grapples with an extremely violent society, with high gun ownership and a history of military interventions. Trump's rhetoric and actions have only fueled this violence. Despite calls for him to step down, his martyr image and refusal to adhere to polite boundaries make him a difficult opponent to defeat.

    • Desensitization to human cost of conflictsDesensitization to human cost of conflicts abroad could lead to dangerous political situations, such as an oligarchy, betraying America's commitment to education and a better future.

      The culture of war in America desensitizes its people to the human cost of conflicts abroad, as seen in the case of Gaza. This desensitization, fueled by a constant readiness for military intervention, could potentially lead to dangerous political situations, such as an oligarchy under a figure like Trump. This is a betrayal of the values that once made America great, including its commitment to education and the belief in a better future for generations to come. The current political climate, with its disregard for humanity, is a cause for concern.

    • DUP community support for TrumpDespite Trump's controversial actions, the DUP community in Northern Ireland shows strong support. Engaging in open dialogue and understanding different perspectives is crucial during political tension.

      There is strong support for Donald Trump among certain political groups in Northern Ireland, specifically the DUP community. This was highlighted during our discussion when Lord Peter Weir, a DUP peer, tweeted about the attempted assassination of Trump, but instead chose to celebrate Spain's win in the Euro 2020 soccer final. Our focus as progressives should be on addressing this issue and engaging with those who hold opposing views, rather than getting distracted by less important matters. It's crucial to remember the importance of open dialogue and understanding different perspectives, especially during times of political tension.

    Recent Episodes from Free State with Joe Brolly and Dion Fanning

    The coal man’s son

    The coal man’s son

    What is more rewarding? Winning or glory? If you are Donald Trump or the modern GAA coach then nothing matters except winning. But can we as Trump said, get tired of winning? Is the story of the coalman’s son, Tommy Loughran, the moment when people had enough? On Free State today, Joe and Dion talk about the decision to give a marking job on Tommy Loughran to two players in an U-14 match. Why has Gaelic football gone this way? Joe doesn’t believe the suggested rule changes will save it and makes some proposals of his own. Dion has a more radical solution and announces also that he has entered the c-suite.


    This episode of Free State is sponsored by Manscaped. Visit https://www.manscaped.com/ and get 20% off and free shipping by using code freestate20


    Free State with Joe Brolly and Dion Fanning is a Gold Hat Production in association with SwanMcG.


    For more on Free State: https://freestatepodcast.com/



    Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.


    From Elon to Enoch: The entrepreneurs of hate

    From Elon to Enoch: The entrepreneurs of hate

    Enoch Burke is in jail again. He is unwavering in his beliefs but is he a pawn in other people’s games? On Free State, Dion and Joe look at foot soldiers like Enoch Burke and what they are doing for their beliefs. Brazil has banned X as they attempt to protect their country. Elon Musk insists free speech is the cornerstone of democracy but is free speech on social media, the instrument that will destroy democracy while promoting fascism? Joe is not an Oasis fan. He recalls the night he tried to get a Gallagher brother’s autograph and the unpleasantness that followed.


    This episode of Free State is sponsored by Manscaped. Visit https://www.manscaped.com/ and get 20% off and free shipping by using code freestate20


    Free State with Joe Brolly and Dion Fanning is a Gold Hat Production in association with SwanMcG.


    For more on Free State: https://freestatepodcast.com/



    Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.


    Will they ever get tired of walking backwards? Kicking the Brits out, Part 2

    Will they ever get tired of walking backwards? Kicking the Brits out, Part 2

    On August 31, 1994, the Provisional IRA announced that “there will be a complete cessation of military operations. All our units have been instructed accordingly”. It was a statement that brought joy, tears and relief to so many in Northern Ireland who had endured violence. So much that would follow came from the ceasefire and the delicate negotiations that brought it about. As the 30th anniversary of the ceasefire approaches, Joe and Dion consider the people who made that possible, the role of the US and the refusal of unionism to move forward. They also ask why the lessons of the north are being ignored in Gaza. And can Dion, a Protestant in his heart, pass the Orange Lodge test?


    This episode of Free State is sponsored by Manscaped. Visit https://www.manscaped.com/ and get 20% off and free shipping by using code freestate20


    Free State with Joe Brolly and Dion Fanning is a Gold Hat Production in association with SwanMcG.


    For more on Free State: https://freestatepodcast.com/



    Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.


    Kicking The Brits Out, Part 1

    Kicking The Brits Out, Part 1

    More than 30 years ago, Bill Clinton said he still believed in a town called Hope. At the Democratic National Convention, Michelle Obama said hope is making a comeback. Is this just a tagline for a bad movie or if Kamala Harris was elected would she make a difference in Gaza and in fixing structural inequality in the US? On Free State today, Dion and Joe look at the choice in the US presidential election and ask if it is a choice at all. They also ask if there is a chance of real change in Ireland or have the same forces taken hold here?


    This episode of Free State is sponsored by Manscaped. Visit https://www.manscaped.com/ and get 20% off and free shipping by using code freestate20


    Free State with Joe Brolly and Dion Fanning is a Gold Hat Production in association with SwanMcG.


    For more on Free State: https://freestatepodcast.com/



    Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.


    Keep a light at the window. The rise and fall of Douglas Beattie

    Keep a light at the window. The rise and fall of Douglas Beattie

    When Doug Beattie sank a bayonet into Taliban fighter during a hellish fight for survival in Afghanistan, he could never escape his actions. Yet the trauma of killing also brought an empathy that was missing in other unionists leaders. On Free State today Dion and Joe look at the fall of Doug Beattie. Joe recalls his day with Beattie when he talked emotionally about how it feels to take a man’s life. They consider how a life marked by conflict at an early age, shaped a leader until he was undone by the tyranny that is unionism in Northern Ireland.


    This episode of Free State is sponsored by Manscaped. Visit https://www.manscaped.com/ and get 20% off and free shipping by using code freestate20


    Free State with Joe Brolly and Dion Fanning is a Gold Hat Production in association with SwanMcG.


    For more on Free State: https://freestatepodcast.com/



    Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.


    Tommy guns, car chases & All Irelands. The life and times of a great Irish man.

    Tommy guns, car chases & All Irelands. The life and times of a great Irish man.

    Funerals matter in Ireland. They are an expression of community. On Free State today, Joe recalls the extraordinary life of Colm McCusker and why his funeral told so much about the man. Colm McCusker was 91 when he died and he didn’t waste a minute during a life packed with love and family, but also car chases, tommy guns and All-Irelands. Joe also prescribes a surprising cure for Dion’s boredom.


    This episode of Free State is sponsored by Manscaped. Visit https://www.manscaped.com/ and get 20% off and free shipping by using code freestate20


    Free State with Joe Brolly and Dion Fanning is a Gold Hat Production in association with SwanMcG.


    For more on Free State: https://freestatepodcast.com/



    Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.


    Drinking with Loyalists, Part 2. Conor McGregor is not at war. While he sails his yacht in the Med, it’s your kids who go to prison.

    Drinking with Loyalists, Part 2. Conor McGregor is not at war. While he sails his yacht in the Med, it’s your kids who go to prison.

    As people are sentenced to years in prison for their part in the riots, what is the real purpose of the pogroms? There are those who will say it is a cry for attention from the dispossessed but what do those in control want? On Free State, Dion and Joe look at how countries are being destabilised by astroturf movements designed to seem like community-driven groups. They explore the funding of those like Tommy Robinson who encouraged riots while in a five star hotel in Ayia Napa. They ask why there is a light touch being applied in Ireland to the far right and ask what Elon Musk’s mission is. They also wonder where Dion and Joe should go if they wanted a mini break?


    This episode of Free State is sponsored by Manscaped. Visit https://www.manscaped.com/ and get 20% off and free shipping by using code freestate20


    Free State with Joe Brolly and Dion Fanning is a Gold Hat Production in association with SwanMcG.


    For more on Free State: https://freestatepodcast.com/



    Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.


    Drinking with Loyalists, Part 1. Ulster (and Coolock) says No

    Drinking with Loyalists, Part 1. Ulster (and Coolock) says No

    At their best, the Olympics represent all that is good about humanity. For Ireland the Olympics brought an outpouring of spontaneous joy and happiness, at least until the homecoming parade. But the hate and fear that is being weaponised across Ireland and Britain won’t be combated by two weeks in Paris.


    On Free State, Dion and Joe discuss the far right pogroms and what needs to be done to stop them. While communities have stood up for the marginalised, the Coolock Says No leaders are drinking with loyalist paramilitaries on Sandy Row. And the powerful have used the trouble for their own end and as a dress rehearsal for what is to come.


    This episode of Free State is sponsored by Manscaped. Visit https://www.manscaped.com/ and get 20% off and free shipping by using code freestate20


    Free State with Joe Brolly and Dion Fanning is a Gold Hat Production in association with SwanMcG.


    For more on Free State: https://freestatepodcast.com/



    Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.


    The surprising truth about Pat Spillane, part 2

    The surprising truth about Pat Spillane, part 2

    For Pat Spillane, the golden years with Kerry were about a lot more than winning. The game for him was, in Danny Blanchflower’s words, about glory. It was also, sometimes, about holidays. On part two of his conversation with Joe, Pat recalls the brilliance of Mick O’Dwyer, how he motivated a team of geniuses and the lock-ins across the north that were a central part of Kerry’s challenge matches.


    This episode of Free State is sponsored by Manscaped. Visit https://www.manscaped.com/ and get 20% off and free shipping by using code freestate20


    Free State with Joe Brolly and Dion Fanning is a Gold Hat Production in association with SwanMcG.


    For more on Free State: https://freestatepodcast.com/



    Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.