Logo
    Search

    Despite Billion-Dollar Jackpots, Critics Say the Lottery Is a Losing Game

    en-usJanuary 21, 2023

    Podcast Summary

    • Lottery's Popularity and Perception as a Societal GoodThough lottery proceeds support important causes, their actual contribution is minimal. The perception of lotteries as societal good makes addressing addiction issues more challenging.

      Despite the odds being nearly impossible, the lottery remains a popular cultural phenomenon in America, with roughly half of all Americans buying at least one ticket a year. The perception of the lottery as a societal good, rather than a form of gambling, is reinforced by the messaging that the proceeds support important causes like schools and services for the elderly. However, the actual contribution of lottery proceeds to school budgets is minimal, and the difficulty in associating lotteries with gambling makes it harder to address potential addiction issues. So while the dream of winning a life-changing jackpot may be enticing, it's essential to be aware of the realities and potential risks involved.

    • Lottery Gambling: A Potential Pathway to AddictionDespite small odds, lottery can lead to addiction for some individuals, causing significant financial harm.

      While the lottery may seem like harmless entertainment and even a potential pathway to financial success, it can actually be a form of gambling that leads to addiction for some individuals. Aaron, a YouTube content creator who makes a living buying and scratching off lottery tickets, admitted to losing over $33,000 last year despite the minuscule odds of winning. Psychiatrist Dr. Timothy Fung, codirector of the UCLA Gambling Studies Program, emphasized that playing the lottery shares similarities with other forms of gambling, such as casino slot machines, where luck is the only deciding factor and the odds are stacked against the player. The lottery is the fourth most common reported form of gambling addiction in California, and it's essential to consider the potential harm it can cause, especially to vulnerable or at-risk communities.

    • Lotteries Harm Low-Income Communities and Communities of ColorLotteries disproportionately target and harm low-income communities and communities of color, perpetuating cycles of poverty through predatory marketing and slim chances of winning, while wealthier individuals focus on building wealth through education, savings, and investments.

      State lotteries, particularly scratch-offs and instant tickets, disproportionately target and harm low-income communities and communities of color, perpetuating cycles of poverty. These products, which are available everywhere from corner stores to grocery vending machines, are marketed aggressively in these areas, and their sale often coexists with other predatory businesses like liquor stores. Despite the slim chances of winning and the wealth extraction involved, the lottery industry continues to profit immensely, leaving the majority of players in debt. Middle and upper-class individuals, who have the means to save and invest, rarely participate in the lottery. Instead, they focus on building wealth through education, emergency funds, retirement savings, and homeownership. The lottery's targeting of low-income communities is a significant example of systemic racism in the United States, perpetuating wealth inequality and exploiting those most in need.

    • Collective loss of over $1 trillion from lotteries in 8 yearsAmericans stand to lose over $1 trillion from lotteries, despite longshot odds, driven by large jackpots' allure.

      Americans are projected to collectively lose over $1 trillion over the next eight years to government-sanctioned gambling, primarily through state lotteries. The size of jackpots has grown significantly due to ticket price increases and worsening odds. Despite the longshot chances of winning, people continue to buy tickets, fueled by the allure of large jackpots. Cohen's book, "For A Dollar and A Dream," explores the implications of this phenomenon on the perception of upward mobility in America. The odds of winning may be astronomical, but as the New York lottery's longtime tagline goes, "somebody's gotta win. Might as well be me."

    • Lower income, nonwhite, less educated, and male demographics contribute significantly to lottery salesDespite making up a small percentage of total lottery players, these demographics generate a large portion of lottery sales due to perceived potential for social mobility

      Lotteries in the United States continue to attract a significant number of participants, particularly those from lower income, nonwhite, less educated, and male demographics. This group, which makes up a small percentage of total lottery players, contributes a large portion of total lottery sales. The appeal of lotteries lies in their perceived potential for social mobility, offering hope to those who feel they have limited opportunities for improvement through traditional means. While lottery revenue is often claimed to support education and public health, the actual contribution is often smaller than advertised, and in some cases, may merely replace existing budget allocations rather than supplement them.

    • State lotteries and their impact on lower income and non-white populationsState lotteries, while marketed as funding public goods, raise ethical concerns due to their disproportionate impact on lower income and non-white communities, potentially distracting from more significant conversations about inequality and social mobility. The role of state governments in gambling is a complex issue.

      The operation of state lotteries, while presented as a means to fund education and other public goods, raises ethical questions regarding its impact on lower income and non-white populations. The lottery may distract from more significant conversations about inequality and social mobility. The question remains whether it's appropriate for state governments to be involved in gambling, especially when it disproportionately affects certain communities. Furthermore, the existence and scale of lotteries might influence people's perspectives on social mobility and inequality. These are complex issues, and it's up to individuals to consider the role of lotteries in society and their potential impact on the common good.

    Recent Episodes from Consider This from NPR

    The evolution of Pride

    The evolution of Pride
    More than 50 years of Pride marches, parades, festivals, and now partnership deals with major brands has increased LGBTQ visibility and community. And as a result, it's also made Pride the target of a backlash.

    Host Scott Detrow speaks with Eric Marcus, the creator of the podcast "Making Gay History" about how Pride has evolved into what it is today.

    Learn more about sponsor message choices: podcastchoices.com/adchoices

    NPR Privacy Policy
    Consider This from NPR
    en-usJune 30, 2024

    Biden tries to reassure voters after a shaky debate performance

    Biden tries to reassure voters after a shaky debate performance
    The day after a debate in which he faltered many times, President Joe Biden hit the campaign trail to try and reassure supporters that he is still up for the job and capable of beating former President Donald Trump in November.

    His performance in the CNN debate on Thursday led many Democrats to panic about his chances of winning reelection. Some commentators who have long supported Biden even called for him to step aside.

    NPR's Scott Detrow speaks with NPR Senior White House Correspondent Tamara Keith and Congressional Correspondent Deirdre Walsh about what happens next and whether Biden can quell Democrats' fears.

    For sponsor-free episodes of Consider This, sign up for Consider This+ via Apple Podcasts or at plus.npr.org.

    Email us at considerthis@npr.org.

    Learn more about sponsor message choices: podcastchoices.com/adchoices

    NPR Privacy Policy
    Consider This from NPR
    en-usJune 28, 2024

    Gun violence is getting worse. Is this the solution?

    Gun violence is getting worse. Is this the solution?
    The surgeon general's office has declared gun violence a national public health crisis.

    It's the first time the body has ever issued a public health advisory about firearms, and for Surgeon General Vivek Murthy, it's a step in reframing the conversation about death by gunfire.

    According to the CDC, more than 48,000 Americans were killed by gun violence in 2021, and over half of those deaths were by suicide.

    Learn more about sponsor message choices: podcastchoices.com/adchoices

    NPR Privacy Policy
    Consider This from NPR
    en-usJune 27, 2024

    Biden's executive actions on immigration send mixed signals

    Biden's executive actions on immigration send mixed signals
    In early June, President Joe Biden severely restricted asylum requests from migrants attempting to cross the U.S.-Mexico border without authorization.

    Two weeks later, the President struck a more welcoming tone, saying he'd protect hundreds of thousands of undocumented immigrants married to U.S. citizens.

    Immigration has become a big issue, for both parties. Policy experts say Biden hopes that in a close election year, these executive actions will sway voters to his side.

    But will that strategy pay off and how will it affect migrants?

    NPR's Adrian Florido speaks with immigration correspondent Jasmine Garsd who is reporting from the San Diego border with Mexico.

    For sponsor-free episodes of Consider This, sign up for Consider This+ via Apple Podcasts or at plus.npr.org.

    Email us at considerthis@npr.org.

    Learn more about sponsor message choices: podcastchoices.com/adchoices

    NPR Privacy Policy
    Consider This from NPR
    en-usJune 23, 2024

    The U.S. election results will reverberate around the world

    The U.S. election results will reverberate around the world
    Polls – and NPR's own reporting – tell a story of many Americans fatigued by the upcoming presidential race. They're not satisfied with the choice between two men who have both already held the office of President.

    But American allies and partners are watching the race intently, including South Korea, Japan, Ukraine and Israel. The fates of those countries are closely tied to whether Donald Trump or Joe Biden ends up sitting in the White House next year.

    The NPR correspondents who cover those countries, Anthony Kuhn in South Korea, Joanna Kakissis in Ukraine, and Daniel Estrin in Israel, discuss the stakes each of those countries have in the outcome of America's presidential election.

    For sponsor-free episodes of Consider This, sign up for Consider This+ via Apple Podcasts or at plus.npr.org.

    Email us at considerthis@npr.org.

    Learn more about sponsor message choices: podcastchoices.com/adchoices

    NPR Privacy Policy
    Consider This from NPR
    en-usJune 20, 2024

    Federal student aid still up in the air for many

    Federal student aid still up in the air for many
    This year's college application process was supposed to get easier.

    That's because last year, the U.S. Department of Education announced changes to the Free Application for Federal Student Aid, or FAFSA.

    The problems with the FAFSA form began last fall.

    And with August and September around the corner, some applicants continue to experience technical issues.

    Before this year, students would already know how much aid they're getting. But in 2024, not knowing, which is the case for many, could mean they can't go to college.

    For sponsor-free episodes of Consider This, sign up for Consider This+ via Apple Podcasts or at plus.npr.org.

    Email us at considerthis@npr.org.

    Learn more about sponsor message choices: podcastchoices.com/adchoices

    NPR Privacy Policy
    Consider This from NPR
    en-usJune 19, 2024

    Related Episodes

    Poverty Matters: Family income, parenting and child outcomes

    Poverty Matters: Family income, parenting and child outcomes
    Naomi Eisenstadt presents evidence that low income itself reduces the chances of good outcomes for children and causes stress in families which exacerbates the risk. Much of the current discussion on children’s outcomes has focused on educational attainment, schools, and parental behaviours. This lecture will provide evidence that low income itself reduces the chances of good outcomes for children and that the stress caused in families by low income exacerbates the risk. While supportive and engaged parents, good early childhood education and good schools all reduce the risk of poor outcomes, money makes at least as much difference as parents and teachers.

    The secret to upward mobility: Friends (Indicator favorite)

    The secret to upward mobility: Friends (Indicator favorite)
    This week, we're sharing some of our favorite Indicator episodes from 2022! Today, we hear one of our most downloaded from the year. This episode originally came out in August.

    Who your friends are may be the key to your economic success story. In a groundbreaking study by Harvard researchers, find out why cross-class friendships may be the key ingredient to the American Dream.

    Learn more about sponsor message choices: podcastchoices.com/adchoices

    NPR Privacy Policy

    The power of creativity: How early intervention programmes can support young people from low-income backgrounds

    The power of creativity: How early intervention programmes can support young people from low-income backgrounds

    Mona Bitar, EY UK&I Vice Chair, sits down with Yeshua Carter, Founder of EY Outreach to deep dive into the topic of social mobility and discuss his mission to deter young people from risk of exclusion and criminality. Yeshua and his team, work with the government and infrastructure sectors to tackle challenges faced by young people. They create early intervention initiatives to support and empower young individuals. Yeshua's work and insights are reflective of the role businesses can play in addressing social inequalities. Read the full transcript here.

    Jon Cruddas MP: “We’re shutting the door, kicking the ladder away”

    Jon Cruddas MP: “We’re shutting the door, kicking the ladder away”

    Jon Cruddas is MP for Dagenham, Rainham, South Hornchurch and Elm Park. During his time as deputy political secretary to Tony Blair, he helped introduce the minimum wage, and played a key role in improving a number of socio-economic issues in the UK. He’s also been hugely involved in trade union reforms and improving workers’ rights. Jon comes from a large family who benefited from being socially mobile, and believes the lack of social mobility has actually become worse over time, and says we're going backwards when it comes to access, life chances, and routes to equality. In this open and frank discussion, Jon delves into his own life and the road to becoming an MP, explores the problems caused by a lack of access for some to higher education, and shares his hopes for a national living wage and fairer tax justice.

    Your host is Tunde Banjoko OBE, founder of Making The Leap.