Logo
    Search

    Do ‘pig butchering’ cyber scams make as much as half Cambodia’s GDP?

    enJune 22, 2024

    Podcast Summary

    • Pig Butchering ScamThe Pig Butchering Scam is a sophisticated form of fraud involving building trust and introducing victims to fake investment opportunities, leading to significant financial losses

      The "pig butchering" scam is a sophisticated and lucrative form of fraud that involves building trust with unsuspecting victims, often through romantic relationships, before stealing vast sums of their money. The name comes from the idea of "fattening up" the victim before the "butchering" or theft. The scam can start with a seemingly innocent message or encounter, and the victims are often introduced to lucrative investment opportunities that appear legitimate at first. However, the investments are actually fraudulent, and the victims can end up losing large sums of money. The BBC reported on a case where a woman lost over $2.5 million in such a scam. It's important to be cautious and verify the legitimacy of any investment opportunities before getting involved.

    • Crypto currency scams in Southeast AsiaCrypto currency scams in Southeast Asia, led by organized crime groups, can lead to significant financial losses for vulnerable individuals, with profits reaching up to 12.5 billion US dollars annually. Victims are often kept against their will and subjected to brutal punishments.

      Crypto currency scams, fueled by romantic enticements and promises of wealth, can lead vulnerable individuals to lose everything they have. The scammers, often based in Southeast Asian countries like Cambodia, use victims of human trafficking to send fraudulent messages. The profits from these scams are significant, with one conservative estimate suggesting they reach between 7.5 and 12.5 billion US dollars annually - almost half the GDP of a certain unnamed Southeast Asian country. The operation's organizers, mainly crime bosses from China and their associates, reap the benefits. The UNODC report did not name the country, but given the GDP size, it's likely to be Cambodia. The exact destination of this money is unknown, and it's unclear if any of it contributes to the local economy. The scam hotspots are in Cambodia, Myanmar, and Laos, and the victims are often kept against their will and subjected to brutal punishments. It's a vicious cycle of crime and exploitation.

    • Cambodian scam operationsExperts estimate 100,000 people might be involved in Cambodian scam operations, but the actual number could be much higher due to hidden compounds and underreporting.

      The estimates suggesting 100,000 people are involved in scam operations in Cambodia, each earning $400 per day, might be underestimating the actual scale of this criminal activity. Experts from the International Justice Mission, who have helped people escape from these compounds, believe the number could be much higher. They arrived at this estimate by mapping out known compounds and using witness statements to estimate the number of people inside. However, it's important to note that these are rough estimates as the illegal workers are hidden away in closed compounds and don't file tax returns. The Cambodian government has also indicated publicly that 80-100,000 people might be working in these compounds, but they're likely to underplay the scale. The scam operations are set up like production lines, with different people handling various parts of the scam. The estimate of each person earning $400 a day is also complex as the scam operations extract as much cash as possible from their victims. Overall, the actual number of people involved and their earnings might be significantly higher than current estimates.

    • Pig Butchering Scam Labor OutputThe estimated labor output of $300-$400 per person per day in pig butchering scams should be viewed skeptically, and the true scale of the fraud is likely much larger than reported, with losses exceeding $4 billion in the US in 2023.

      While escaped victims of scam compounds have reported being told they were expected to produce marginal labor output of three to four hundred dollars per person per day, this estimate should be taken with a grain of salt due to its vague and unverified nature. The scale of pig butchering fraud is massive and not limited to the US, with reported losses totaling $4 billion in the US alone in 2023, but the true extent is likely much greater as many cases go unreported due to embarrassment and shame. The victims, often desperate and humiliated, may not prioritize reporting the fraud to authorities.

    • Illegal logging industry in CambodiaThe illegal logging industry in Cambodia could be worth up to $12 billion, which is nearly half the country's GDP, but the exact figure is uncertain due to lack of transparency and regulation.

      The illegal logging industry in Cambodia is a complex and murky business, with estimates suggesting it could be worth up to $12 billion, which is nearly half the country's GDP. However, the exact figure is uncertain and may be much different. The lack of transparency and regulation in the industry makes it difficult to determine the truth. It's important to note that these figures are just estimates, and the real number could be quite different. Despite efforts to address illegal logging, the issue persists and remains a significant challenge for Cambodia. It's a reminder of the complex and often hidden realities behind global supply chains and the importance of transparency and accountability. If you have any questions or concerns about numbers you've come across, feel free to contact us at bbc.co.uk. We'll be back next week with more stories and insights. Until then, goodbye.

    Recent Episodes from More or Less: Behind the Stats

    Election claims and erection claims

    Election claims and erection claims

    Are Labour right about the Liz Truss effect on mortgages? Are the Conservatives right about pensioners? Are Plaid Cymru right about spending? Are the Lib Dems right about care funding? Is Count Binface right about croissants?

    Why are MRP polls coming up with such different numbers?

    Do erections require a litre of blood?

    Tim Harford investigates the numbers in the news.

    Presenter: Tim Harford Reporter: Kate Lamble Producers: Simon Tulett, Nathan Gower, Beth Ashmead Latham and Debbie Richford Series producer: Tom Colls Production coordinator: Brenda Brown Sound mix: Rod Farquhar Editor: Richard Vadon

    Do ‘pig butchering’ cyber scams make as much as half Cambodia’s GDP?

    Do ‘pig butchering’ cyber scams make as much as half Cambodia’s GDP?

    So-called “pig butchering” scams take billions of dollars from people around the globe. But do the cyber scams run from compounds in Cambodia really take an amount of money equivalent to half that country’s GDP? We investigate how the scale of these criminal operations has been calculated.

    Presenter: Tim Harford Reporter: Tom Colls Production coordinator: Brenda Brown Sound mix: Andrew Garratt Editor: Richard Vadon

    Worse mortgages, better readers, and potholes on the moon

    Worse mortgages, better readers, and potholes on the moon

    Will Conservative policies raise mortgages by £4800, as Labour claim? Are primary school kids in England the best readers in the (western) world, as the Conservatives claim? Are there more potholes in the UK than craters on the moon?

    Tim Harford investigates some of the numbers in the news.

    Presenter: Tim Harford Reporter: Kate Lamble Producers: Nathan Gower, Simon Tullet Beth Ashmead-Latham and Debbie Richford Production coordinator: Brenda Brown Sound mix: James Beard Editor: Richard Vadon

    Shakespeare’s maths

    Shakespeare’s maths

    AWilliam Shakespeare might well rank as the most influential writer in the English language. But it seems he also had a knack for numbers.

    Rob Eastaway, author of Much Ado about Numbers, tells Tim Harford about the simple maths that brings Shakespeare’s work to life.

    Presenter: Tim Harford Readings: Stella Harford and Jordan Dunbar Producer: Beth Ashmead-Latham Series producer: Tom Colls Production coordinator: Brenda Brown Sound mix: James Beard Editor: Richard Vadon

    Leaflets, taxes, oil workers and classrooms

    Leaflets, taxes, oil workers and classrooms

    What’s going on with the dodgy bar charts that political parties put on constituency campaign leaflets?

    What’s the truth about tax promises?

    Are 100,000 oil workers going to lose their jobs in Scotland?

    Will class sizes increase in state schools if private schools increase their fees?

    Tim Harford investigates some of the numbers in the news.

    Presenter: Tim Harford Reporter: Kate Lamble Producers: Nathan Gower, Beth Ashmead-Latham, Debbie Richford Production coordinator: Brenda Brown Sound mix: Neil Churchill Editor: Richard Vadon

    Why medical error is not the third leading cause of death in the US

    Why medical error is not the third leading cause of death in the US

    The claim that medical error is the third leading cause of death in the US has been zooming around the internet for years.

    This would mean that only heart disease and cancer killed more people than the very people trying to treat these diseases.

    But there are good reasons to be suspicious about the claim.

    Professor Mary Dixon-Woods, director of The Healthcare Improvement Studies Institute, or THIS Institute, at Cambridge University, explains what’s going on.

    Presenter: Tim Harford Series producer: Tom Colls Production coordinator: Brenda Brown Sound mix: Nigel Appleton Editor: Richard Vadon

    Debate, Reform, tax evasion and ants

    Debate, Reform, tax evasion and ants

    Were there any suspicious claims in the election debate between Rishi Sunak and Keir Starmer?

    Do the claims in Reform UK’s policy documents on excess deaths and climate change make sense?

    Can the Conservatives and Labour raise £6bn a year by cracking down on tax avoidance and evasion?

    And do all the humans on earth weigh more than all of the ants?

    Presenter: Tim Harford Reporters: Kate Lamble and Nathan Gower Producer: Beth Ashmead-Latham Series producer: Tom Colls Production coordinator: Brenda Brown Editor: Richard Vadon

    Data for India

    Data for India

    India’s election has been running since 19 April. With results imminent on 4th June, More or Less talks with Chennai based data communicator Rukmini S. She founded Data for India, a new website designed to make socioeconomic data on India easier to find and understand. She talks us through the changing trends to help give a better picture of the type of country the winning party will govern.

    Producers: Bethan Ashmead and Nathan Gower Sound Engineer: Nigel Appleton Production Coordinator: Brenda Brown Editor: Richard Vadon

    UK growth, prisons and Swiftonomics

    UK growth, prisons and Swiftonomics

    Prime Minister Rishi Sunak has said that the UK economy is growing faster than Germany, France and the US, while Labour says the typical household in the UK is worse off by £5,883 since 2019. Are these claims fair? We give some needed context.

    Net migration has fallen - we talk to someone who predicted it would - Dr Madeleine Sumption, director of the Migration Observatory at the University of Oxford.

    Is Taylor Swift about to add £1 bn to the British economy as some media outlets have claimed? The answer is ‘No’.

    Why are our prisons full? We ask Cassia Rowland from the Institute for Government.

    Presenter: Tim Harford Producers: Charlotte McDonald, Nathan Gower, Bethan Ashmead Latham and Ellie House Series producer: Tom Colls Sound mix: Neil Churchill Production coordinator: Brenda Brown Editor: Richard Vadon

    Is intermittent fasting going to kill you?

    Is intermittent fasting going to kill you?

    News stories earlier in the year appeared to suggest that time restricted eating – where you consume all your meals in an 8 hour time window – was associated with a 91% increase in the risk of death from cardiovascular disease.

    But is this true? Tim Harford looks into the claim with the help of Cardiologist Dr Donald Lloyd-Jones, chair of the Department of Preventive Medicine at Northwestern University in the US.

    Presenter: Tim Harford Producer: Debbie Richford Series producer: Tom Colls Production coordinator: Brenda Brown Sound mix: Nigel Appleton Editor: Richard Vadon