Logo
    Search

    Election claims and erection claims

    enJune 26, 2024

    Podcast Summary

    • Mortgage rates and pension taxesPolitical leaders Keir Starmer and Rishi Sunak made contrasting claims during the Sun Leaders event, with Starmer suggesting temporary mortgage rate increases and Sunak warning of potential pension tax hikes for retirees.

      During the recent Sun Leaders event, political leaders Keir Starmer and Rishi Sunak made significant claims regarding mortgage rates and pension taxes respectively. While Keir Starmer suggested that Liz Truss' mini-budget had led to increased mortgages for several years, Professor Stephen Millard clarified that this effect was only temporary. Rishi Sunak, on the other hand, claimed that pensioners would face a retirement tax on their state pension unless the Conservative policy to increase the tax threshold was implemented. These claims add to the political discourse in the final week of the election campaign.

    • Elderly care fundingThe Liberal Democrats' promise of free personal care for elderly or disabled people could cost more than twice the estimated amount due to uncertain funding sources from previous policies

      During the election discourse, the Liberal Democrats pledged to provide free personal care for elderly or disabled people, which they estimated would cost £2.7 billion a year. However, researchers suggest that the actual cost could be more than twice that amount. The Liberal Democrats claim they can fund this promise by using the government's previous policy to introduce a cap on care costs, but that policy isn't yet in effect and the funding for it has already been used. The Conservatives, too, are committed to that cap but haven't set aside additional funds to pay for it. The Liberal Democrats' plan relies on this previous policy as a building block, but its availability as a funding source is uncertain. This highlights the importance of clear and transparent financial planning in political manifestos.

    • Blood flow during erectionDuring an erection, the volume of blood that flows into the penis is significantly less than 20% of the total blood volume in the body, instead, blood flow increases and veins constrict causing blood to get trapped

      During an erection, the volume of blood that flows into the penis is significantly less than a fifth of the total blood volume in the body. Dr. Simon Cork, a senior lecturer in physiology at Anglia Ruskin University, debunked the claim that a fifth of the blood volume in the body gets pumped to the penis during an erection. Instead, blood flow to the penis increases, but the veins that carry blood away constrict, causing the blood to get trapped. The study that measured the volume of blood in the penis during an erection found it to be around 32 milliliters, which is a small fraction of the total blood volume in the body. The heart pumps out about five liters of blood per minute, and the increased flow rate during an erection is about 10 milliliters per minute. Therefore, maintaining an erection for 100 minutes would be necessary to reach the claimed 20% figure, but this is not recommended as it can lead to dangerous conditions like ischemic priapism.

    • MRP polls uncertaintyMRP polls, which use demographic data and large samples to predict seat-by-seat election results, can have significant variations due to different assumptions and methods used by pollsters, leading to uncertainty in the projected number of seats for each party.

      The results of MRP (Multilevel Regression and Post-Stratification) polls, which use large samples and demographic data to project seat-by-seat election results, can vary significantly due to different assumptions and methods used by pollsters. Last week, three MRP polls predicted a poor showing for the Conservatives, but the number of seats they were projected to win differed widely. This uncertainty is a result of the complex nature of these models, which involve various assumptions about demographics, tactical voting, turnout, and voter intentions. While there is a general expectation of a significant swing from the Conservatives to Labour, the exact distribution of this swing is uncertain and may vary between different MRP projections.

    • Swing votes impact on seat projectionsIn the UK's first-past-the-post system, the distribution of swing votes can significantly impact seat projections, especially in elections with multiple parties and narrow margins. Proportional swing can lead to unexpected outcomes and challenges in accurately predicting final seat distribution.

      The distribution of swing votes in elections, particularly in the first-past-the-post system used in the UK, can have a significant impact on seat projections. This uncertainty is amplified by the presence of multiple parties and a large number of seats with narrow margins. For instance, the Conservatives, who currently hold a small percentage of the national vote share, could still win a substantial number of seats if those votes are concentrated in specific areas. Conversely, a party with a larger national vote share but less well-distributed support could lose a large number of seats. This concept, known as proportional swing, can lead to unexpected election outcomes and makes it challenging to accurately predict the final seat distribution using modeling tools like MRPs. Additionally, the discussion touched upon the potential impact of price caps on goods and services, with examples of governments implementing such measures to control food and rent prices. However, the implementation of a price cap on croissants could have unintended consequences and is a topic of debate among economists.

    • Price cap on croissantsPrice caps on croissants could lead to decreased quality, shrinking sizes, or even their disappearance. Alternatives like subsidies or state-sponsored croissants require effective implementation and enforcement to succeed.

      Implementing a price cap on croissants could lead to unintended consequences such as decreased product quality, shrinking sizes, or even the disappearance of croissants from the market altogether. Defining what constitutes a croissant and ensuring compliance with that definition would be a challenge. A more economically efficient alternative could be for the government to subsidize the cost of croissants or introduce a state-sponsored croissant to price into the market, allowing competition to encourage other vendors to sell at the desired price. However, the success of such policies depends on effective implementation and enforcement. The discussion also highlighted the potential for a black market for croissants sold above the price ceiling if there are shortages. Ultimately, while the intention behind a price cap may be to make croissants more affordable, the complexities of the market and the potential for unintended consequences must be carefully considered.

    Recent Episodes from More or Less: Behind the Stats

    Election claims and erection claims

    Election claims and erection claims

    Are Labour right about the Liz Truss effect on mortgages? Are the Conservatives right about pensioners? Are Plaid Cymru right about spending? Are the Lib Dems right about care funding? Is Count Binface right about croissants?

    Why are MRP polls coming up with such different numbers?

    Do erections require a litre of blood?

    Tim Harford investigates the numbers in the news.

    Presenter: Tim Harford Reporter: Kate Lamble Producers: Simon Tulett, Nathan Gower, Beth Ashmead Latham and Debbie Richford Series producer: Tom Colls Production coordinator: Brenda Brown Sound mix: Rod Farquhar Editor: Richard Vadon

    Do ‘pig butchering’ cyber scams make as much as half Cambodia’s GDP?

    Do ‘pig butchering’ cyber scams make as much as half Cambodia’s GDP?

    So-called “pig butchering” scams take billions of dollars from people around the globe. But do the cyber scams run from compounds in Cambodia really take an amount of money equivalent to half that country’s GDP? We investigate how the scale of these criminal operations has been calculated.

    Presenter: Tim Harford Reporter: Tom Colls Production coordinator: Brenda Brown Sound mix: Andrew Garratt Editor: Richard Vadon

    Worse mortgages, better readers, and potholes on the moon

    Worse mortgages, better readers, and potholes on the moon

    Will Conservative policies raise mortgages by £4800, as Labour claim? Are primary school kids in England the best readers in the (western) world, as the Conservatives claim? Are there more potholes in the UK than craters on the moon?

    Tim Harford investigates some of the numbers in the news.

    Presenter: Tim Harford Reporter: Kate Lamble Producers: Nathan Gower, Simon Tullet Beth Ashmead-Latham and Debbie Richford Production coordinator: Brenda Brown Sound mix: James Beard Editor: Richard Vadon

    Shakespeare’s maths

    Shakespeare’s maths

    AWilliam Shakespeare might well rank as the most influential writer in the English language. But it seems he also had a knack for numbers.

    Rob Eastaway, author of Much Ado about Numbers, tells Tim Harford about the simple maths that brings Shakespeare’s work to life.

    Presenter: Tim Harford Readings: Stella Harford and Jordan Dunbar Producer: Beth Ashmead-Latham Series producer: Tom Colls Production coordinator: Brenda Brown Sound mix: James Beard Editor: Richard Vadon

    Leaflets, taxes, oil workers and classrooms

    Leaflets, taxes, oil workers and classrooms

    What’s going on with the dodgy bar charts that political parties put on constituency campaign leaflets?

    What’s the truth about tax promises?

    Are 100,000 oil workers going to lose their jobs in Scotland?

    Will class sizes increase in state schools if private schools increase their fees?

    Tim Harford investigates some of the numbers in the news.

    Presenter: Tim Harford Reporter: Kate Lamble Producers: Nathan Gower, Beth Ashmead-Latham, Debbie Richford Production coordinator: Brenda Brown Sound mix: Neil Churchill Editor: Richard Vadon

    Why medical error is not the third leading cause of death in the US

    Why medical error is not the third leading cause of death in the US

    The claim that medical error is the third leading cause of death in the US has been zooming around the internet for years.

    This would mean that only heart disease and cancer killed more people than the very people trying to treat these diseases.

    But there are good reasons to be suspicious about the claim.

    Professor Mary Dixon-Woods, director of The Healthcare Improvement Studies Institute, or THIS Institute, at Cambridge University, explains what’s going on.

    Presenter: Tim Harford Series producer: Tom Colls Production coordinator: Brenda Brown Sound mix: Nigel Appleton Editor: Richard Vadon

    Debate, Reform, tax evasion and ants

    Debate, Reform, tax evasion and ants

    Were there any suspicious claims in the election debate between Rishi Sunak and Keir Starmer?

    Do the claims in Reform UK’s policy documents on excess deaths and climate change make sense?

    Can the Conservatives and Labour raise £6bn a year by cracking down on tax avoidance and evasion?

    And do all the humans on earth weigh more than all of the ants?

    Presenter: Tim Harford Reporters: Kate Lamble and Nathan Gower Producer: Beth Ashmead-Latham Series producer: Tom Colls Production coordinator: Brenda Brown Editor: Richard Vadon

    Data for India

    Data for India

    India’s election has been running since 19 April. With results imminent on 4th June, More or Less talks with Chennai based data communicator Rukmini S. She founded Data for India, a new website designed to make socioeconomic data on India easier to find and understand. She talks us through the changing trends to help give a better picture of the type of country the winning party will govern.

    Producers: Bethan Ashmead and Nathan Gower Sound Engineer: Nigel Appleton Production Coordinator: Brenda Brown Editor: Richard Vadon

    UK growth, prisons and Swiftonomics

    UK growth, prisons and Swiftonomics

    Prime Minister Rishi Sunak has said that the UK economy is growing faster than Germany, France and the US, while Labour says the typical household in the UK is worse off by £5,883 since 2019. Are these claims fair? We give some needed context.

    Net migration has fallen - we talk to someone who predicted it would - Dr Madeleine Sumption, director of the Migration Observatory at the University of Oxford.

    Is Taylor Swift about to add £1 bn to the British economy as some media outlets have claimed? The answer is ‘No’.

    Why are our prisons full? We ask Cassia Rowland from the Institute for Government.

    Presenter: Tim Harford Producers: Charlotte McDonald, Nathan Gower, Bethan Ashmead Latham and Ellie House Series producer: Tom Colls Sound mix: Neil Churchill Production coordinator: Brenda Brown Editor: Richard Vadon

    Is intermittent fasting going to kill you?

    Is intermittent fasting going to kill you?

    News stories earlier in the year appeared to suggest that time restricted eating – where you consume all your meals in an 8 hour time window – was associated with a 91% increase in the risk of death from cardiovascular disease.

    But is this true? Tim Harford looks into the claim with the help of Cardiologist Dr Donald Lloyd-Jones, chair of the Department of Preventive Medicine at Northwestern University in the US.

    Presenter: Tim Harford Producer: Debbie Richford Series producer: Tom Colls Production coordinator: Brenda Brown Sound mix: Nigel Appleton Editor: Richard Vadon