Logo
    Search

    From the Vault: Brain and Head Theft, Part 2

    enFebruary 12, 2022

    Podcast Summary

    • Connecting with community and exploring innovationBuild relationships, prepare for emergencies, and engage with technology through community networks and podcasts to navigate uncertain times

      Community connection is essential, especially during uncertain times. Neighbor to Neighbor, a California volunteer network, emphasizes the importance of building relationships with those around us and preparing for emergencies. Meanwhile, technology, such as artificial intelligence, will play a significant role in shaping the future. In the realm of podcasts, shows like Technically Speaking, Conversations with UNK, and Stuff to Blow Your Mind offer insights into various topics, from AI's impact on industries to the history of stolen brains. In essence, community and innovation are key to navigating the present and future. To connect with your community and explore intriguing topics, visit Neighbor to Neighbor's website, listen to podcasts, or engage in meaningful conversations.

    • Jeremy Bentham's Unique Philosophies and Unconventional LifeBentham, a liberal and utilitarian thinker, advocated for actions bringing greatest happiness to most people, supported women's rights and decriminalizing homosexuality, but opposed privacy. His eccentric personality included a talking stick, teapot, and cat, and after death, his preserved head is a macabre artifact.

      Jeremy Bentham, a key figure in liberalism and utilitarian ethics, believed that right and wrong were determined by actions that brought the greatest happiness to the most people. His philosophies were radical for his time, with support for women's equality and decriminalizing homosexuality, but also controversial ideas like opposing privacy. Bentham's personality was as unique as his ideas, with a walking stick named Dapple, a teapot named Dicky, and a cat named Reverend Sir John Langbourn. After his death in 1832, Bentham's wishes included having his preserved head wheeled out to parties as a conversation starter. Today, his mummified head, with glass eyes and real hair, remains a fascinating and eerie artifact.

    • Jeremy Bentham's Preserved Bodies: One with a Wax Head and the Other with the Real OneUtilitarian philosopher Jeremy Bentham's unique approach to death resulted in the preservation of his bodies, one with a wax head and the other with his real, frequently stolen one.

      Jeremy Bentham, the utilitarian philosopher, has two preserved bodies on display - one with a fake wax head at University College London, and another with his actual, poorly preserved, and frequently stolen head. Bentham had requested that his head be preserved in the Maori style, but his friend and executor, Southwood Smith, wasn't skilled enough to execute it satisfactorily. This led to the creation of a wax model for display instead. The actual head has been stolen multiple times throughout history, most notably by students from rival universities, making it a subject of pranks and mischief. Despite these events, Bentham's preserved bodies remain on display, showcasing his unique approach to death and the afterlife.

    • Museums and complex issuesMuseums should make their collections accessible and respect cultural heritage while addressing issues of accessibility and ethical sourcing.

      While the preservation and display of artifacts in museums can be valuable for learning from history, it raises complex issues such as accessibility and ethical sourcing. Many artifacts are housed in museums in wealthy countries, limiting access for people in other parts of the world. Additionally, the acquisition of human remains and other artifacts can be controversial and border on theft. Museums should strive to address these issues and make their collections accessible to a wider audience while respecting the cultural heritage and rights of the original communities. The love for museums and their role in preserving history should not overshadow the need for ethical and equitable practices.

    • Impact of Our Choices: Adventure vs Wasted Time vs Skull TheftOur choices shape our experiences, and they can lead to either opportunities for adventure or harmful consequences, such as theft of human skulls based on flawed beliefs.

      Our choices can significantly impact our experiences. The advertisement encourages us to seize opportunities for adventure instead of wasting time. Meanwhile, in history, the pseudoscience of phrenology, which involved measuring skulls to infer mental characteristics, led to the theft of Franz Joseph Haydn's skull. While some strains of phrenology may seem harmless, others were used for racist purposes and caused people to collect human skulls for research, often non-consensually. These collections were more for display than actual research. These examples remind us of the power of our decisions and the potential consequences, whether in our everyday lives or in the realm of scientific exploration.

    • Skull collecting in the 19th century: A morbid obsession with disregard for human dignitySkull collecting during the 19th century involved unethical practices, disregarding human dignity, and was driven by a belief in determining mental qualities from skull measurements, which has not held up to scientific scrutiny.

      During the early to mid 19th century, skull collecting was a morbid obsession driven by a disregard for human dignity. Skulls were often obtained through unethical means, including theft from graves, battlefields, and even hospitals, with the less wealthy and marginalized communities being disproportionately affected. Notable collectors like Joseph Barnard Davis and Samuel George Morton saw skulls as potential additions to their collections, often disregarding the humanity of the deceased individuals. The findings of these early craniometrists, who believed they could determine mental qualities based on skull measurements, have not held up to scientific scrutiny due to poor methodology and inconsistency in samples and measurements. Skulls were favored due to their compact size, durability, and ease of preservation. Despite these practices, it's essential to remember the humanity of those whose skulls were taken and the ethical implications of these historical practices.

    • The Fascination with Skulls: Scientific or Practical?While the collection and study of skulls can have scientific value, it's important to consider practical and ethical implications, such as respecting individual autonomy and cultural traditions.

      The fascination with collecting and studying skulls, while seemingly scientific, can sometimes be driven by practical and aesthetic considerations rather than sound scientific principles. This was evident in the case of individuals who collected skulls, often neglecting the importance of proper scientific methods. Furthermore, the story of Ishi, a Native American man whose brain was taken against his wishes after his death, serves as a reminder of the ethical considerations involved in scientific research. Despite his explicit request to not have his body subjected to an autopsy, his brain was removed and preserved for scientific study. This raises questions about the balance between scientific curiosity and respect for individual autonomy and cultural traditions.

    • Respecting the dignity and privacy of deceased individuals and communitiesThe importance of informed consent, cultural traditions, and respecting the wishes of the deceased and their communities in scientific research involving human remains.

      When it comes to scientific research, especially involving human remains, it's crucial to remember that individuals are people first, not just sources of information. The story of Ishi, a Native American man whose remains were studied without his consent, serves as a reminder of the importance of informed consent and respecting the wishes of the deceased and their communities. The case raises complex questions about what to do with the remains of people who have been dead for a long time and could not express their wishes. The return of Ishi's brain to his tribe represents a step towards acknowledging and respecting the importance of cultural traditions and the wishes of indigenous communities. The story also highlights the potential dangers of scientific curiosity and the importance of balancing the desire to preserve and learn with respect for the dignity and privacy of individuals and communities.

    • Building Meaningful Connections: Neighbors, Unique Items, and HistoryIn uncertain times, connecting with neighbors and cherishing unique items are universal themes. Neighbor to Neighbor fosters community connections, while eBay Motors offers customizable car parts.

      Even in an uncertain world, there are ways to build meaningful connections within your community. Neighbor to Neighbor, a California volunteer network, encourages people to engage with their neighbors and prepare for emergencies together. Meanwhile, when it comes to personal belongings, there's joy in finding and customizing unique items, like cars, through platforms like eBay Motors. And throughout history, taking heads has been a long-standing practice, with skulls serving as icons in mythology and folklore, even before the modern understanding of the brain. Regardless of the era or context, connecting with others and cherishing what we have are universal themes. To learn more about Neighbor to Neighbor, visit CA neighbors.com. For unique car parts, go to ebaymotors.com.

    • Ancient Nazca trophy heads had religious significanceAncient Nazca society used trophy heads in shamanic rituals, possibly involving hallucinogenics, for communing with the spirit realm and controlling natural resources.

      The use of trophy heads in ancient Nazca society was more complex than just a symbol of victory or a sign of disrespect. While war was an important part of their culture, the heads were believed to be used in shamanic rituals, possibly involving hallucinogenics to commune with the spirit realm and control natural resources. The heads were not merely displayed or carried as trophies but were believed to be necessary for these religious practices. The brains were discarded, likely due to their quick decomposition. Despite some arguments suggesting these were the heads of honored ancestors, they were defined as trophies of warfare collected for ritual purposes. The idea of trophy taking in ancient cultures may seem barbaric to modern minds, but the Nazca example shows it was a more intricate part of their religious practices.

    • Ancient beliefs and stories surrounding disembodied headsAncient cultures used disembodied heads as symbols of power, knowledge, and connection to the divine or ancestral realm, reflecting their beliefs and values.

      Across various ancient cultures and mythologies, there are numerous stories and beliefs surrounding the significance of disembodied heads, often used for communicating with spirits or the dead, or as sources of wisdom and inspiration. From the mummified heads of the Maya and the plastered heads of Catalhoyuk, to the use of human heads in ancient Mediterranean practices, and the mythological figures like Mimir in Norse mythology and Chinnamasta in Hinduism, the theme of disembodied heads as vessels of power, knowledge, and connection to the divine or ancestral realm is a recurring one. These stories not only reflect the cultural beliefs and values of their time, but also continue to captivate our imagination and inspire various artistic and literary expressions.

    • Power and significance of heads and faces in mythologiesMythologies from different cultures symbolize heads and faces as communication tools, protectors, and transformers

      Mythologies from different cultures, such as Hinduism and Greek, share common themes, including the symbolism of heads or faces. In Hindu mythology, the talking head represents a broader perspective on the world, while the head of glory (Kirtanukha) serves as a guardian. In Greek mythology, the head of Medusa is a weapon. Another example from Hinduism is Rahu, the eclipse entity whose head attempts to consume the sun. In Welsh mythology, the head of the giant king, Bronn, was believed to speak before it grew silent and was buried facing France as a protective measure. These stories illustrate the power and significance of heads and faces in various mythologies, serving as symbols of communication, protection, and even transformation.

    • Decapitation and Disembodied Heads in Mythology and FolkloreMyths and folktales from diverse cultures feature decapitation and disembodied heads, showcasing the enduring fascination with this concept. These stories often involve magical or supernatural abilities and serve to illustrate the significance of the head in human belief systems.

      Decapitation and disembodied heads are common themes in mythology and folklore from various cultures around the world. These motifs can be found in tales of decapitation contests, head swapping, and disembodied heads that prey on people or lead them astray. Examples include the fiery red creatures in Labyrinth, the Maya hero twins, the singing head of Orpheus, the head of Bahamut in the Templar trials, the Karasu in Southeast Asian mythology, the melee in Japanese folklore, and the flying heads of the Iroquois. These stories often involve heads that possess magical or supernatural abilities, and they serve to illustrate the enduring fascination humans have had with the concept of the disembodied head.

    • Stories of Disembodied Heads and Self-Decapitating SpiritsThroughout history, tales of disembodied heads and self-decapitating spirits have explored themes of identity, mortality, and the nature of existence, offering intriguing insights into the human condition and our fascination with life and death.

      Throughout history and in various cultures, the concept of disembodied heads and self-decapitating spirits has been a source of fascination and contemplation, raising questions about identity, mortality, and the nature of existence. These imaginative tales often depict disembodied heads as being angry, jovial, or even indifferent, reflecting a sense of freedom from the physical body. Whether in mythology, literature, or animation, these stories offer intriguing insights into the human condition and our fascination with the mysteries of life and death. We encourage listeners to share any examples of such tales or experiences they may have had with disembodied heads or brain preservation in museums or other contexts.

    Recent Episodes from Stuff To Blow Your Mind

    Smart Talks with IBM: AI & the Productivity Paradox

    Smart Talks with IBM: AI & the Productivity Paradox

    In a rapidly evolving world, we need to balance the fear surrounding AI and its role in the workplace with its potential to drive productivity growth. In this special live episode of Smart Talks with IBM, Malcolm Gladwell is joined onstage by Rob Thomas, senior vice president of software and chief commercial officer at IBM, during NY Tech Week. They discuss “the productivity paradox,” the importance of open-source AI, and a future where AI will touch every industry.

    This is a paid advertisement from IBM. The conversations on this podcast don't necessarily represent IBM's positions, strategies or opinions.

    Visit us at ibm.com/smarttalks

    See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

    Weirdhouse Cinema: The Dungeonmaster

    Weirdhouse Cinema: The Dungeonmaster

    In this episode of Weirdhouse Cinema, Rob and Joe return to the glorious world of 80s Charles Band productions with 1984’s “The Dungeonmaster,” a supernatural dreamscape with eight directors starring Jeffrey Byron, Richard Moll and Leslie Wing. It’s time to reject the devil’s reality and substitute your own! 

    See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

    New Season of Smart Talks with IBM Coming Soon

    New Season of Smart Talks with IBM Coming Soon

    Smart Talks with IBM returns with a new season on Tuesday, June 25th. This season, we’re diving back into the world of artificial intelligence, but with a focus on the powerful concept of “open,” and how it applies to AI. Host Malcolm Gladwell will invite curious colleagues from Pushkin Industries to explore how openness is already reshaping industries, ways of doing business, and our very notion of what's possible.

    This is a paid advertisement from IBM.

    Visit us at ibm.com/smarttalks

    See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

    Related Episodes

    6: Whacking Vreenak

    6: Whacking Vreenak

    Consequentialism vs. Deontological Ethics.

    In the Deep Space Nine episode "In the Pale Moonlight," was Captain Sisko justified in using less-then-honorable means to bring the Romulans into the war with the Dominion in order to end the war and save lives? Or were Sisko's actions unjustified because they violated universally valid moral rules and principles? 

    In this episode of Meta Treks, hosts Mike Morrison and Zachary Fruhling analyze "In the Pale Moonlight" from the contrasting ethical theories of consequentalist ethics (or utilitarianism) and deontological ethics (or rule-based ethics). Mike and Zachary consider the applicability of different forms of consequentialism, such as Jeremy Bentham's quantitative approach to utilitarianism, John Start Mill's more qualitative approach to utilitarianism, and rule utilitarianism as a middle-ground between ethics emphasizing consequences and ethics emphasizing rules.

    This episode of Meta Treks covers the crucial concepts of deontological/Kantian ethics, such as Kant's Categorical Imperative, the notion that some actions are intrinsically right or wrong regardless of consequences, and treating others as ends in themselves and not merely as means to your own ends. Mike and Zachary wrap up the conversation with a discussion of whether the justification for the Prime Directive is chiefly consequentialist or whether the Prime Directive, as the Federation's highest law or rule, is grounded in the intrinsic worth of the natural development of other worlds and cultures.

    Chapters
    Welcome to Episode 6 (00:01:06)
    Discussing the CBS Star Trek Announcement (00:02:22)
    Introducing the Topic (00:15:10)
    Consequentialism (00:16:40)
    Example - In The Pale Moonlight (00:19:31)
    Utilitarianism (00:32:09)
    Deontological Ethics (00:44:00)
    Kantian Ethics (00:44:40)
    The Categorical Imperative (00:49:00)
    The Prime Directive (01:05:38)
    Rule Utilitarianism (01:10:05)
    Virtue Based Ethics (01:17:46)
    Final Thoughts (01:20:06)

    Hosts
    Mike Morrison and Zachary Fruhling

     

    Production

    Dennis Castello (Editor and Producer) Norman C. Lao (Executive Producer) C Bryan Jones (Executive Producer) Matthew Rushing (Executive Producer) Charlynn Schmiedt (Executive Producer) Will Nguyen (Content Manager) Richard Marquez (Production Manager)

     

    Send us your feedback!

    Twitter: @trekfm 
    Facebook: http://facebook.com/trekfm 
    Voicemail: http://www.speakpipe.com/trekfm 
    Contact Form: http://www.trek.fm/contact 
    Visit the Trek.fm website at http://trek.fm/ 
    Subscribe in iTunes: http://itunes.com/trekfm


    Support the Network!

    Become a Trek.fm Patron on Patreon and help us keep Star Trek talk coming every week. We have great perks for you at http://patreon.com/trekfm

    Life and Death

    Life and Death
    If a patient decides she doesn't want to live any longer, should she be allowed to die? Should she be allowed to kill herself? If a patient is in no position to decide - perhaps she's in a coma - then should somebody else be able to decide to kill her? Who? Is there a moral difference between killing and allowing someone to die? And is the role of the doctor always to prolong life? Peter Singer, of Princeton University, is one of the world's leading bio-ethicists, and has been reflecting on life and death issues for four decades.

    The Places That Break You

    The Places That Break You

    In this wide ranging talk, Amalayodhin gives an introduction to the history and symbol of the cremation grounds. Given on a summer men's Great Gathering at Padmaloka, the talk covers topics such as death, taking responsibility and avoiding blame and resentment. He draws out the necessity of seeking out those places that demand more of us then we can give in our current form, and in process break and reform as more potent, loving and effective beings.

    Given at Padmaloka Retreat Centre, 2022.

    ***

    Subscribe to our Free Buddhist Audio podcast:  On Apple Podcasts | On Spotify | On Google Podcasts

    A full, curated, quality Dharma talk, every week. 3,000,000 downloads and counting!

    Subscribe to our Dharmabytes podcast:  On Apple Podcasts | On Spotify | On Google Podcasts

    Bite-sized inspiration three times every week.

    Subscribe using these RSS feeds or search for Free Buddhist Audio or Dharmabytes in your favorite podcast service!

    Help us keep FBA Podcasts free for everyone: donate now!

    Follow Free Buddhist Audio: YouTube  |  Instagram  |  Twitter  |  Facebook  |  Soundcloud