Logo
    Search

    Haley's path & Biden's only move - with Mike Murphy

    enDecember 03, 2023

    Podcast Summary

    • US Politics and Israel-Hamas ConflictBiden faces pressure from political opponents and base on Israel support, condemning anti-Israel actions, and asserting stance to maintain position. Complexity of Israel-Hamas conflict highlights US role in Middle Eastern stability.

      The situation between Israel and Hamas continues to be volatile, with potential significant implications for US politics and Middle Eastern policy. Biden faces pressure from both the Republican primary contest and his base coalition on the hard left regarding his support for Israel. While condemning anti-Israel actions on college campuses, Biden may need to assert his stance to maintain his political position. The events in Israel, such as the Hamas massacre, highlight the complexity and depth of the conflict, which requires clear differentiation between good and bad actors. The ongoing situation underscores the importance of the US's role in maintaining stability in the Middle East.

    • Learning from Past Military OperationsExamining past military actions can provide valuable insights for future conflicts, but balancing tactical necessities with long-term strategic concerns is complex, particularly in the Israeli-Palestinian context.

      The current conflict between Israel and Hamas, and the resulting displacement of civilians, is a complex and pressing issue with deep historical and geopolitical implications. The speaker emphasizes the importance of self-examination and learning from past military operations, drawing parallels between the events of the past and the present. He also highlights the challenges of balancing tactical necessities with long-term strategic concerns, particularly in the context of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. The speaker's son's observation about the relatively recent history of mass violence against Jews underscores the importance of remembering the past and the potential for recurring conflict. Ultimately, the speaker argues that Israel's security is existential, and eradicating Hamas is a necessary step for ensuring the safety and well-being of its people. However, the challenges of rebuilding trust and security in the aftermath of military action are significant and require careful consideration.

    • Biden's handling of Israel-Palestine conflictBiden earned high marks for leadership, but faces challenges balancing public pressure and maintaining US stance in Israel-Palestine conflict

      President Biden's handling of the Israel-Palestine conflict has been largely effective, earning an "A" grade for his leadership and decision-making, despite some missteps. However, there are concerns about the impact of public pressure on the situation, as it could be perceived as weakness by adversaries and potentially escalate the conflict further. Additionally, there is a disconnect between public opinion towards Israel and Hamas within the American electorate, with Hamas having an extremely unpopular rating. Biden faces the challenge of balancing these issues and maintaining a strong US stance on the matter. Despite these challenges, Biden's unwavering support for Israel has been notable, with actions speaking louder than words, including a visit to Israel and meetings with key figures. It's crucial for the administration to navigate these complexities carefully to ensure US interests and the stability of the region are protected.

    • Political Challenges for Biden in Israel-Palestine ConflictBiden faces challenges in winning back progressive voters due to Israel-Palestine conflict, Israeli public's stance against Hamas complicates peace efforts, and risk of further isolation for Israel is a concern.

      The Biden administration is facing political challenges at home due to the ongoing conflict between Israel and Palestine. Younger voters, who are more progressive and less pro-Israel than older generations, are a particular concern. The administration is hoping that a ceasefire and humanitarian aid will help win back these voters, but the Israeli public's desire for a strong stance against Hamas may make it difficult for Biden to declare victory and move on. The conflict also risks isolating Israel further, which is a major concern for the administration. Despite Biden's desire for peace, the complexities on the ground mean that managing the situation and maintaining support for Israel will be an ongoing challenge. The administration is trying to be a beacon for a ceasefire and provide aid, but the Israeli public's desire for a strong stance against Hamas may make it difficult to achieve a lasting peace.

    • Preventing the emergence of a new HamasPresident Biden could use a strong stance against anti-Israel protests in the US to address Hamas and appeal to voters, while the Republican primary race might not be as clear-cut as it seems, with unexpected developments possible.

      While eliminating Hamas as a threat is crucial, the real challenge lies in preventing the emergence of a new Hamas. The unpopularity of Hamas in the polls does not diminish the importance of addressing the issue, and President Biden could potentially use a strong stance against anti-Israel protests in the US as an opportunity to appeal to voters. Meanwhile, the Republican primary race might not be as clear-cut as it seems, with Donald Trump's dominance being challenged, as seen in the Walter Mondale versus Gary Hart democratic primaries of 1984. Despite Trump's current lead, there's a possibility for unexpected developments in the race.

    • The Race for Second Place in the Republican PrimaryNikki Haley and Ron DeSantis are competing for second place in the Republican primary, with Haley gaining momentum and DeSantis struggling. Endorsements from influential figures could sway voters, but their impact is uncertain. Marlus Patma's support for Haley is a wildcard in the race.

      The Republican primary race for the 2024 presidential nomination is heating up, with Nikki Haley and Ron DeSantis currently vying for the second place spot behind Donald Trump. Haley has been gaining momentum in both Iowa and New Hampshire, while DeSantis has struggled in recent polls. Endorsements from influential figures like Iowa Governor Kim Reynolds and Christian conservative leader Bob Vander Plaats could potentially sway voters, but their impact is uncertain. A wildcard in the race is Marlus Patma, a prominent Iowa grassroots operative who recently announced her support for Haley. As the race continues, Haley's ability to capitalize on DeSantis' decline and secure key endorsements will be crucial in her bid to challenge Trump for the nomination.

    • The Republican primary race in Iowa is heating up with Haley and DeSantis leading, but Haley's late financial surge could give her an edge.The Iowa caucus could see unexpected shifts as Haley's late financial surge and potential crossover voters impact the outcome.

      The Republican primary race is heating up in Iowa, with Nikki Haley and Ron DeSantis leading the charge. However, the hype surrounding DeSantis may be overdone, and Haley's late financial surge, fueled by the Koch network, could give her an edge in voter contact and advertising spend. Additionally, there is a possibility that up to 170,000 Democrats and independents who caucused for the Democrats in the last election could switch parties and vote in the Republican caucus, which could significantly impact the turnout and outcome. Looking back to 1984, Mondale's campaign was mugged in the Democratic primaries by Gary Hart in New Hampshire, who was an attractive retail candidate with a better message. The Iowa caucus, which was once a fundraising dinner, was transformed into a media spectacle by Carter's team, allowing him to exceed expectations and emerge as a contender. The upcoming Iowa caucus could see a similar unexpected shift in the Republican race.

    • Unpredictability of Democratic Primaries: Hart vs MondaleEarly primary success doesn't guarantee the nomination; infrastructure and organization in later states are crucial for securing delegates.

      The primary race for the Democratic nomination can be unpredictable, even for seemingly unbeatable frontrunners. As seen in Gary Hart's campaign against Walter Mondale in 1984, a strong showing in early primary states like New Hampshire can lead to a surge in momentum, making the race a competitive one despite initial polling numbers. However, infrastructure and organization in later states, crucial for securing delegates, can ultimately determine the nominee. It's essential to remember that primary elections are about more than just votes – they're about delegates, which are allocated based on the results of those votes. In the case of Hart, he lacked the infrastructure to effectively compete in later states and ultimately fell short of the nomination. This historical context offers valuable insights into the current primary race and the importance of effective campaigning and organization in securing the nomination.

    • Primaries: Late Moves Can Lead to Unexpected OutcomesHoward Dean's unexpected fall from grace in Iowa caucus shows late moves can change the game. Nikki Haley's rise from 6% to 16% in polls demonstrates the impact of debates and funding. Chris Christie's continued presence could split votes, while Biden's weaknesses may leave him vulnerable in the general election.

      The primaries can see significant shifts in support close to the caucus or convention, and late moves can lead to unexpected outcomes. For instance, Howard Dean was once the invincible front-runner in the Iowa caucus but was surpassed by Keri in just a few weeks. The Iowa caucus is still over 50 days away, and there's plenty of time for candidates like Nikki Haley to gain ground. The debates and increased funding have helped her rise from 6% to 16% in recent polls. However, there are still several candidates in the race, and their decisions to exit the race could significantly impact the outcome. For example, Chris Christie's continued presence in the race could split the vote for Haley in New Hampshire. The sooner he exits, the better for Haley and potentially for the Republican Party as a whole. In a potential worst-case scenario, a weak Democratic challenger like Biden could struggle against Trump in the general election, despite widespread dislike for Trump. Biden's weaknesses could open him up to criticism, and his lack of experience in tough elections could hinder his ability to effectively challenge Trump. Ultimately, the outcome of the primaries and the general election will depend on the candidates' performances and strategic decisions.

    • 2022 Presidential Election: A Closely Contested BattleDemocrats focus on young voters and voters of color, Republicans lean into cultural issues. Economy may not save GOP from midterm losses. Geopolitical landscape adds complexity.

      The upcoming presidential election is shaping up to be a battle between the two parties, with the Democrats focusing on appealing to young voters and voters of color, while the Republicans may lean into cultural issues like abortion. The Democrats are also working to distance themselves from President Biden and focus on the contrasting outcomes and motivations between the two parties. The economy, while still strong, may not be enough to save the Republicans from potential losses in the midterms, as the Republican brand is seen as an unattractive alternative. The geopolitical landscape, including tensions with China and access to military assets in the Middle East, also adds complexity to the political landscape. Overall, the election is expected to be a closely contested battle between the two parties, with both sides bringing their unique strategies and motivations to the table.

    Recent Episodes from Call Me Back - with Dan Senor

    The ‘Day After’ Document - with Prof. Netta Barak-Corren

    The ‘Day After’ Document - with Prof. Netta Barak-Corren
    Share on X: https://tinyurl.com/yc8jb3m6 Is now the time for Israeli decision-makers to begin serious internal deliberations and planning for the “day after” in Gaza? According to Nadav Eyal in his column last Friday in Yediot, over 95% of Hamas rockets are gone, Hamas’s smuggling routes have been closed, and its munitions production capacity is zero. Is progress in defeating Hamas appears much better than one would think from reading popular press accounts? It’s against that backdrop that we’ve learned of a 28-page document -- this is not publica -- and is circulating among Israeli military leaders and war strategy decision-makers within the government. Some we spoke to suggested that this document is being treated as the basis for ‘day after’ planning in the government. It’s called: "From a murderous regime to a moderate society: the transformation and rehabilitation of Gaza after Hamas". The researchers are Prof. Netta Barak-Corren, a law professor who works on conflict resolution; Prof. Danny Orbach, a military historian; Dr. Nati Flamer who specializes in Hamas and Hezbollah; and Dr. Harel Chorev, an expert on Palestinian society. To help us understand these recommendations, we are joined today by one of its authors, Prof. Netta Barak-Corren, who is a legal scholar with degrees from the Hebrew University (where she is a professor). She clerked for the Chief Justice of the Israeli Supreme Court, and then pursued doctoral studies at Harvard, graduating in 2016. She currently is on leave from Hebrew University, while she’s visiting faculty at Princeton. She’s previously taught at University of Pennsylvania and University of Chicago.

    Call me Back LIVE - with Michael Rapaport

    Call me Back LIVE - with Michael Rapaport
    Share on X: https://rb.gy/un15s6 Today in this special episode, we are releasing the first episode of the Call me Back podcast recorded before a very enthusiastic live audience at the Comedy Cellar in Manhattan. Our guest was actor, director and comedian Michael Rapaport. The focus of our conversation is about how Michael became such an energetic, provocative, and hilarious voice on behalf of Israel and the Jewish people since 10/07, as well as his observations on why more Jews from the creative arts and entertainment industry have not been as outspoken as him (or, even worse, why so many have remained silent). We also discuss his reaction to those who criticize Israel “as a Jew”, and his experience dealing with the professional cost of proudly advocating for Israel and the Jewish people. You can follow Michael on X here: https://x.com/MichaelRapaport And on IG here: https://www.instagram.com/michaelrapaport/ Find Michael's podcast, I AM RAPAPORT here: https://www.iamrapaport.com/

    Is Israel headed for a two-front war? - with Nadav Eyal

    Is Israel headed for a two-front war? - with Nadav Eyal
    First, a housekeeping note: many of you filled out the survey we published in our previous episode, and we are very grateful for that. If you haven't filled out this short survey, we would greatly appreciate it if you took 2 minutes to fill it out. It is extremely helpful to us in thinking through ways to improve the podcast and understand our audience. Please follow this link to the survey: https://forms.gle/nZh8ZRA5YjJxmdEW6 - As for today's episode - I've been in Israel for the past couple of days, for my 4th visit here since 10/07. Something that has struck me in my conversations with Israelis is the degree to which a war with Hezbollah is not discussed in terms of IF, but rather in terms of WHEN. And as for the WHEN, some are suggesting quite soon. In fact, Defense Minister Gallant said that the goal should be that for those Israelis evacuated from the North, they should be back in their evacuated communities and homes in time for the next school year.  This would put to the test the IDF’s capacity to fight a multi front war. In other words - while the IDF is getting closer to the point of defeating Hamas in Gaza - it might also be at the early stages of a war with Hezbollah. - To help us understand what’s going on here, our guest today is NADAV EYAL, who returns to the podcast. I sat down with him today in Tel Aviv. He is a columnist for Yediot. Eyal has been covering Middle-Eastern and international politics for the last two decades for Israeli radio, print and television news.  - Nadav's latest column, which we discussed in this episode: https://tinyurl.com/msk43n53

    Divisions in Israeli society - with Dr. Micah Goodman

    Divisions in Israeli society - with Dr. Micah Goodman
    First, a housekeeping note: Over the past eight months the audience for this podcast has grown in ways we could never have imagined, but there is no real way for us to know who is listening - age group, ideological leanings, the country you are living in, etc. These are all very helpful data points for us to improve the podcast and understand our audience. So, please fill out this 2 minute survey: https://forms.gle/nZh8ZRA5YjJxmdEW6 And one other item we wanted to bring to your attention. We are repeatedly reminded how the NYPD has continued to bravely protect our community— most recently 10 days ago at the Nova Music Festival exhibition where a mob of antisemitic rioters attempted to intimidate Jewish New Yorkers, and just before that when the NYPD helped ensure a smooth Israel Day Parade here in New York in which over 100,000 people participated. To express our thanks for helping to keep our Jewish community and all New Yorkers safe, The Paul E. Singer Foundation is matching donations up to $200,000 made to the New York City Police Foundation. Donations must be made Monday, June 24, 2024. Join us to meet and exceed this goal. If interested in donating, you can do it here: https://secure.anedot.com/nycpolicefoundation/thepesfoundation As for today's episode, as we discussed at length in our last episode -- "Haviv Unplugged!" -- the issue of a military service exemption for Haredi Jews (ultra-Orthodox Jews) is coming to a head right now, as Israel is at war. Or maybe it's coming to a head with such ferocity precisely because Israel is at war, and it's raising all sorts of questions about whether Israel has the manpower to fight a continued war in Gaza and possibly other fronts that could open up. It does seem like Israel is in an entirely new military environment, across multiple fronts. Also, are some parts of the Israeli population paying a disproportionately high price? These are questions that are being considered right now by Israel's government. These are questions that are weighing especially heavy on society after 12 soldiers over the past few days. Dr. Micah Goodman is our guest today, to help us unpack all of this. Micah is on the speed-dial of a number of Israeli political leaders – from right to left, but especially on the center-left and the center-right. He is a polymath, a podcaster and one of Israel’s most influential public intellectuals, having written books ranging from biblical lessons for the modern age to Israel’s geopolitics. One book in particular, had an outsized impact in terms of its framing of the conundrum that Israel has been in with the Palestinians since 1967. That book is called "Catch-67: The Left, the Right, and the Legacy of the Six-Day War", Not only have all of his books been bestsellers in Israel, he essentially created a new genre; books that bring core texts of Jewish thought to a general, secular audience. In his new book – called "The Eighth Day", which Micah wrote in a four-month sprint after October 7th – Micah tries to understand the implications of the nation’s trauma and what it means for the other ‘day after’ (not the ‘day after’ in Gaza, but the ‘day after’ inside Israel). What does this moment mean for Israelis? How will 10/07 re-shape Israeli society…and its politics? Micah Goodman’s books: Catch-67 — https://www.barnesandnoble.com/w/catch-67-micah-goodman/1128089735?ean=9780300248418 The Wondering Jew — https://www.barnesandnoble.com/w/the-wondering-jew-micah-goodman/1136574622?ean=9780300252248

    Haviv Unplugged!

    Haviv Unplugged!
    Share on X: https://tinyurl.com/2s4x4j2h In recent days, there have been a lot of war-related developments that have taken place in Israel and outside of Israel. So it was good that we had the opportunity to catch up with Haviv Rettig Gur as Shavuot came to a close in Israel. In this episode, we wound up having a spirited conversation about: I.The mood in Israel days after after Operation Arnon, and also why the day after the successful resuce operation we saw Benny Gantz's long anticipated exit from the unity government; II. The ultra orthodox or 'Haredi' IDF exemption bill that passed in the Knesset; and III. Hamas's rejection (yet again) of Israel's ceasefire proposal.

    OPERATION ARNON - with Nadav Eyal

    OPERATION ARNON - with Nadav Eyal
    Share on X: https://tinyurl.com/ymmv7m8u We have just witnessed one of the most extraordinary 48-hour periods in Israel since October 7th, as we learned news of an extremely complex military, intelligence and hostage rescue operation. We are seeing — and many of us are experiencing — the impact that this development is having on Israeli society, and on the Jewish people worldwide. This operation has been renamed OPERATION ARNON, after Colonel Arnon Zamora, who was the chief inspector of the Israeli Police’s special commando Counterterrorosim Unit. He was the only Israeli to have fallen in this operation. May Arnon's memory be a blessing. To learn more about Arnon's life, you can read here: https://www.timesofisrael.com/hero-of-israel-thousands-pay-last-respects-to-officer-killed-in-hostage-rescue-op/ In this episode, NADAV EYAL provides a comprehensive picture and analysis of what actually happened in this operation. Nadav is a columnist for Yediot. He has been covering Middle-Eastern and international politics for the last two decades for Israeli radio, print and television news. To read Nadav's piece in Yediot: https://www.ynetnews.com/article/syo00lyxs0

    The Great Powers and the War in Gaza - with Walter Russell Mead

    The Great Powers and the War in Gaza - with Walter Russell Mead
    Share on X: https://tinyurl.com/ytm9656f Over the past 8 months, we've focused most of our attention on Israel's perspective and the American perspective since October 7th. But what we wanted to do today is gradually zoom out from Israel and Gaza, to the perspective of other regional players in the Middle East, and finally examine this war from the perspective of the global powers, especially China and Russia. Has the Israel-Hamas war advanced their interests or reversed them? Our guest today is Walter Russell Mead. He is at the Hudson Institute, he is the Global View Columnist at The Wall Street Journal. He was previously the Henry Kissinger fellow at the Council on Foreign Relations. He also has a terrific podcast at Tablet Magazine, called What Really Matters: https://www.tabletmag.com/podcasts/what-really-matters He is also a prolific author. His most recent book is -- The Arc of a Covenant: The United States, Israel, and the Fate of the Jewish People, which you order here -- shorturl.at/bdhpz

    The last Israeli to negotiate with the Palestinians - with Tzipi Livni (Part 2)

    The last Israeli to negotiate with the Palestinians - with Tzipi Livni (Part 2)
    Share on Twitter/X: https://tinyurl.com/nvmznb7m Tzipi Livni has served as a minister of eight different cabinet ministries under three prime ministers: Ariel Sharon, Ehud Olmert, and Benjamin Netanyahu. Her positions have included Justice Minister, Foreign Minister and Vice-Prime Minister. She has also been the official leader of the opposition. As foreign minister, Tzipi Livni led negotiations with the Palestinian Authority, she was a key government figure during Israel’s disengagement from Gaza and during Hamas’s subsequent takeover of Gaza. She was foreign minister during Israel’s Second Lebanon War and during Israel’s operation to take out Syria’s nuclear reactor. She began her service as a member of the Likud Party, and then the Kadima Party, and later the Hatnua Party and Zionist Union. Earlier in her career, Tzipi served in the Mossad (including in the elite unit famous for being responsible for the assassinations following the Munich massacre). No major Israeli political figure has had more recent experience trying to negotiate a two-state solution than Tzipi Livni.

    The last Israeli to negotiate with the Palestinians - with Tzipi Livni (Part 1)

    The last Israeli to negotiate with the Palestinians - with Tzipi Livni (Part 1)
    Share on Twitter/X: https://tinyurl.com/3jzjamfh Tzipi Livni has served as a minister of eight different cabinet ministries under three prime ministers: Ariel Sharon, Ehud Olmert, and Benjamin Netanyahu. Her positions have included Justice Minister, Foreign Minister and Vice-Prime Minister. She has also been the official leader of the opposition. As foreign minister, Tzipi Livni led negotiations with the Palestinian Authority, she was a key government figure during Israel’s disengagement from Gaza and during Hamas’s subsequent takeover of Gaza. She was foreign minister during Israel’s Second Lebanon War and during Israel’s operation to take out Syria’s nuclear reactor. She began her service as a member of the Likud Party, and then the Kadima Party, and later the Hatnua Party and Zionist Union. Earlier in her career, Tzipi served in the Mossad (including in the elite unit famous for being responsible for the assassinations following the Munich massacre). No major Israeli political figure has had more recent experience trying to negotiate a two-state solution than Tzipi Livni. Tzipi Livni on X: https://x.com/Tzipi_Livni

    A proposal to end the war? — with Haviv Rettig Gur

    A proposal to end the war? — with Haviv Rettig Gur
    Share on Twitter/X: https://tinyurl.com/3h7ryskc Today during one of our regular check-ins with Haviv Rettig Gur, we had some big questions: I) How is the war actually going? What do we know? II) Following President Biden’s announcement last Friday, was the proposal he revealed the official proposal that Israel is offering Hamas? And if it is, why did the war cabinet approve it? III) As for Egypt, do we now have a clearer picture of why Egypt was so hysterically opposed to an IDF operation in Rafah? IV) And, finally, Prime Minister Netanyahu has been invited to address the U.S. Congress? What’s likely to happen when he comes to the nation’s capital?

    Related Episodes

    EP: 251 - Just Ask the Press - Does the New York Times poll signal Biden's doom?

    EP: 251 - Just Ask the Press - Does the New York Times poll signal Biden's doom?

    This week on Just Ask the Press: Does the New York Times poll signal Biden's doom? Does it matter at all? Trump runs into more court troubles, Nikki Haley wins her first primary and Mitch McConnell leaves the Republican leadership. This and a whole lot more . . .
    Follow us on Twitter: https://twitter.com/JATQPodcast

    Intragram: https://www.instagram.com/jatqpodcast

    Youtube:https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCET7k2_Y9P9Fz0MZRARGqVw

    This Show is Available Ad-Free And Early For Patreon supporters here: https://www.patreon.com/justaskthequestionpodcast

    Purchase Brian's book "Free The Press

    Follow Brian's Salon articles!

    Live Coverage: Analysis of the Haley vs. DeSantis Debate

    Live Coverage: Analysis of the Haley vs. DeSantis Debate

    Rachel Maddow and an expert team of analysts break down the fifth Republican presidential debate, which took place just hours after former New Jersey Governor Chris Christie dropped out of the race. Rachel and the rest of MSNBC's political team discussed the best and worst moments of the night as Former U.N. Ambassador Nikki Haley and Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis battled for second place behind former President Donald Trump. While Haley and DeSantis debated, Trump held a town hall on Fox News.

    Big Wins and Small Debates

    Big Wins and Small Debates

    Donald Trump's rivals took aim at each other in the third GOP debate while the ex-president mocked them from afar. Former Sen. Claire McCaskill and Jennifer Palmieri explain why they think the debate “means squat.” Plus, VA Sen. Tim Kaine joins us to discuss Democrats’ big wins on election night and what the party needs to do to win in 2024.