Logo
    Search

    Has Putin got the upper hand in Ukraine?

    en-gbNovember 15, 2023

    Podcast Summary

    • Ukraine War Reaches Stalemate, Winter Makes Advance DifficultThe Ukraine war has reached a stalemate, with significant losses for Ukraine, uncertain future, and winter adding to the challenges for troops to advance.

      The war in Ukraine has reached a stalemate, with both Ukrainian and Russian forces engaging in heavy fighting over a large area, resulting in significant losses for Ukraine. The counter offensive, which was expected to liberate large amounts of territory in the south, has not gone as planned due to the shifting political winds in America and the approaching winter, which makes it harder for troops to sustain themselves. Ukrainian forces have lost up to 20% of their frontline military equipment, and the future of the war is uncertain. On the ground, the situation is chaotic, with soldiers, military vehicles, and abandoned villages near the front line. Despite the challenges, people are trying to live in the middle of the war. The situation is particularly dire now as winter is setting in and making it even harder for troops to advance.

    • Ukraine Conflict Reaches a Trench Warfare Stalemate with Advanced TechnologyThe Ukraine conflict has turned into a prolonged, costly stalemate due to heavy reliance on advanced technology, specifically drones, making surprise attacks and secrecy nearly impossible.

      The ongoing conflict in Ukraine between Russian and Ukrainian forces has reached a stalemate, according to the commander in chief of the Ukrainian military, General Valerius Zaluzhny. Both sides are heavily reliant on advanced technology, specifically drones, which has made it nearly impossible to launch surprise attacks or ambushes. The Ukrainian forces have suffered significant losses attempting to advance against the Russians' deeply mined defensive lines. As a result, soldiers are now deploying in small groups to clear minefields and advance slowly, often on their hands and knees. The use of drones for reconnaissance has made the battlefield almost transparent, leaving little room for secrecy and increasing vulnerability for both sides. The war has transformed into a grueling, 21st-century trench warfare with the addition of advanced technology, resulting in a costly and seemingly endless stalemate.

    • Ukraine War: A Bloody Conflict with Human CostDespite military deadlock, Ukrainian president insists on progress and resistance against Russian aggression, causing immense human cost and growing despair among civilians.

      The war in Ukraine is far from a stalemate as some assess, but rather a massive, bloody conflict with immense human cost. The speaker recounts his experience at a field hospital in the Donbas region, where he witnessed the efficient treatment of a severely wounded Ukrainian soldier. Despite the military deadlock, the Ukrainian president, Volodymyr Zelensky, insists that Ukraine is making progress and cannot afford to stop fighting against Russian aggression. The war's impact on civilians is significant, with widespread casualties and a growing sense of despair as the conflict drags on. Last year, there was a sense of optimism that Kyiv would fall and Ukraine would crumble under Russian control, but the Ukrainian resistance has been strong. However, the mood among civilians is now darker and angrier, as everyone knows someone who has been killed. The war's stalemate means that both sides are digging in for a long, brutal conflict, with no clear end in sight.

    • Ukraine's struggle for survival amidst conflict and uncertaintyUkraine faces a long conflict against Russia with limited resources, fearing a reduction in US military aid and delays in receiving requested equipment, but maintains high morale and needs continued international support for defense and peace

      The situation in Ukraine is complex and uncertain, with the focus of many individuals, like Veronica, being on saving lives amidst the ongoing conflict. The strategic problem for Ukraine is that their material resources are not equal to those of Russia, leading to concerns that a long conflict may ultimately favor Putin. The fear in Kyiv is that the return of Donald Trump as US president could result in a significant reduction in military aid to Ukraine, further limiting their ability to defend against Russian attacks. Despite this, Ukrainian morale remains high, but translating that morale into battlefield success has been a challenge due to delays in receiving requested military equipment. The US, as an existential partner to Ukraine, has provided significant military support, but the timely delivery of requested equipment has been a challenge. It's crucial for the international community to continue supporting Ukraine with the necessary resources to defend themselves and work towards a peaceful resolution to the conflict.

    • Ukraine's Plea for Continued Support in Its War Against RussiaUkraine urges Western allies to invest in its cause against Russian occupation, as the war has become a stalemate due to drone usage and Russia's goal to occupy Ukraine remains unchanged.

      The war in Ukraine continues to be a significant concern, despite shifting global attention to the Middle East. Ukraine is making a plea to its Western backers to keep investing in its cause, as it believes there is no alternative to fighting against Russian occupation. The war has become a stalemate due in large part to the use of drones, and military planners around the world should take note of how modern warfare has changed. The Biden administration has been hesitant to provide Ukraine with the weapons it needs due to concerns about instability and chaos if Russia collapses. However, the speaker argues that Ukraine needs everything it can get, and the Europeans should start investing as well. The war is taking a heavy toll on Ukraine, but the Ukrainian people are determined to fight for their freedom and regain control of Crimea. The Russians' original goal of occupying Ukraine and destroying its culture remains unchanged, so the fighting must continue.

    • Asymmetric Warfare: A Billion-Dollar Russian Platform vs. A $20,000 Ukrainian DroneInnovation and resourcefulness can outmatch raw power in asymmetric warfare. International support with advanced weaponry can disrupt enemy logistics and increase chances of victory.

      The ongoing conflict in Ukraine has showcased an example of asymmetric warfare at its finest. With a billion-dollar Russian platform being taken down by a $20,000 Ukrainian drone, it highlights how resourcefulness and innovation can outmatch raw power. As the war's future hangs in the balance, the international community's support in providing advanced weaponry to Ukraine becomes crucial. This not only aids in disrupting Russian logistics but also increases Ukraine's chances of securing a victory. Despite the challenges ahead, including the upcoming winter, the Ukrainian spirit remains unbroken. In fact, their culture has seen a resurgence, with literature, publishing, and the arts thriving amidst the turmoil.

    • Ukrainian resistance goes beyond militaryDespite Putin's underestimation, Ukrainians' deep connection to their country, culture, and language fuels a formidable resistance, with everyone involved, not just young men.

      Learning from the discussion with Luke Harding, a senior international correspondent with The Guardian, is that the Ukrainian resistance against Russian invasion goes beyond just the military. Ukrainians are deeply connected to their country, culture, and language, and this collective spirit is fueling their resistance. Putin underestimated the strength of this unity and is now facing a formidable opponent in the form of a "great superorganism" made up of 40 million people, including women and older people. The war is not just being fought by young men, but by everyone. Despite Putin's initial belief that most Ukrainians were Russians who would welcome his takeover, the reality is that Ukraine has become a united front where everyone is struggling for victory. The resistance is not stopping, and neither is the determination of the Ukrainian people.

    Recent Episodes from Today in Focus

    Rishi Sunak staggers on – but for how long?

    Rishi Sunak staggers on – but for how long?
    The prime minister is another MP down after Natalie Elphicke crossed the floor to join Labour. With the Conservatives trailing by 30 points after heavy local election losses, what options does Rishi Sunak now have? Guardian political correspondent Kiran Stacey tells Helen Pidd what these losses mean for the PM, and looks at what calculation Keir Starmer made in taking in a rightwing Tory. Help support our independent journalism at theguardian.com/infocus

    The London Bridge ‘hero’ who could go to prison for 99 years

    The London Bridge ‘hero’ who could go to prison for 99 years
    In 2019, ex-offender Marc Conway helped hold down a knifeman who killed two people in a terror attack. But by doing so he risked being recalled to prison. Simon Hattenstone reports Marc Conway risked his life to stop the London Bridge terror attack. Why did he fear being sent to prison for it?. Help support our independent journalism at theguardian.com/infocus

    Related Episodes

    How the war in Ukraine changed the world – Politics Weekly UK

    How the war in Ukraine changed the world – Politics Weekly UK
    This week marks one year since Russia sent its troops into Ukraine. The Guardian’s John Harris is joined by defence and security editor, Dan Sabbagh, and the Ukrainian MP, Kira Rudik, to look at how the war has changed world politics. And, what the future may look like for Ukraine and Russia.. Help support our independent journalism at theguardian.com/politicspod