Logo

    Kate Forbes: How faith can make you political "roadkill", with Tim Farron

    enFebruary 23, 2023
    What affordable alternative do consumers have for wireless services?
    How does LinkedIn aid in hiring professionals?
    What was the public reaction to Tim Farron's views in 2017?
    What challenges does Kate Forbes face in the leadership race?
    How has public opinion on strikes changed over the past decade?

    • Understanding Consumer Needs, Business Effectiveness, and Public OpinionConsumers can save on wireless plans with alternatives like Mint Mobile. LinkedIn is a valuable resource for hiring professionals. Politicians' personal views often resonate with the public, regardless of societal norms or popular opinion.

      While big wireless companies may raise prices due to inflation, consumers can find more affordable alternatives like Mint Mobile. In the business world, LinkedIn is an effective tool for hiring professionals who might not be actively looking for a new job. Regarding politics, the public generally prefers politicians to hold firm to their personal views, even if they differ from societal norms or popular opinion. This was evident during the 2017 general election when the public's response to Tim Farron's views on gay sex did not significantly impact his party's campaign, despite concerns from strategists and activists. Overall, these discussions highlight the importance of understanding consumer needs, business effectiveness, and public opinion in various contexts.

    • SNP Membership and Same-Sex MarriageThough SNP membership holds varying views on same-sex marriage, the issue may not significantly impact the party's leadership or wider public appeal.

      The Scottish National Party (SNP) membership, though diverse in its pro-independence stance, may hold varying views on social issues like same-sex marriage. A discussion revealed that around 40% of respondents believed individuals should adhere to their personal religious views on the matter, while 30% were uncertain. However, the speaker expressed skepticism about the significance of this issue for the wider public and for the SNP's leadership candidate, Kate Forbes. The SNP experienced a surge in membership after Scotland's 2014 independence referendum, growing from around 100,000 to over 120,000. Despite this diversity, a significant portion of SNP voters in the 2015 election voted for Brexit. Academic surveys suggest that SNP members are as enthusiastic about same-sex marriage as Labour Party members. While the SNP may have more socially conservative members compared to other parties, Kate Forbes is still a minority within the party on this issue.

    • Uncertainty in Scottish Politics: No Clear Front-Runner in Leadership Race Amidst Faith ControversiesThe Scottish political landscape is uncertain following Nicola Sturgeon's departure, with Kate Forbes facing challenges due to her faith. The void left by Sturgeon could lead to a more competitive political landscape, but the outcome will depend on Westminster politics.

      The upcoming leadership race in Scottish politics following Nicola Sturgeon's departure is uncertain, with no clear front-runner emerging yet. Kate Forbes, one of the potential candidates, is facing challenges due to her Christian faith and its perceived compatibility with progressive views of society. This issue echoes Tim Farron's experience during the 2017 general election. The void left by Sturgeon's departure could significantly impact Scottish politics, including the Scottish National Party (SNP), Labour Party, and Scottish politics as a whole. The lack of a strong frontrunner and the potential clash between political beliefs and personal faith could lead to a more competitive political landscape. However, the outcome will also depend on what happens in Westminster politics.

    • Misconception of Secularism as NeutralitySecularism is not neutrality, genuine curiosity and defense of rights is true liberalism and pluralism. Embrace open-mindedness towards all faiths or none.

      The assumption of secularism equating to neutrality in society is a misconception. When it comes to religious beliefs, especially those held by political leaders, there is no neutrality. Society's tolerance and acceptance of faith should not be limited to those with cultural badges, but rather, genuine curiosity and defense of the rights of others to believe different things is what true liberalism and pluralism entail. The recent case of Kate Forbes, a liberal and evangelical Christian, highlights the illiberal and intellectually inconsistent approach of society towards faith, especially when it influences one's worldview. It is crucial for us to challenge this assumption and embrace a more open-minded and accepting society where people of all faiths or none can coexist and contribute without fear of judgment or marginalization.

    • Acknowledging the role of faith and values in the public sphereA true liberal society embraces diversity and tolerates differences, recognizing the importance of authenticity and the role of faith and values in shaping public discourse.

      There is no neutrality in the public sphere, and a true liberal society acknowledges this, allowing for open and tolerant competition of ideas. This was discussed in relation to the political career of Kate Forbes, a Scottish politician known for her competence and straightforwardness. The speaker, a former politician, expressed his belief in Forbes' potential as a leader, despite his personal desire for the UK to remain together. He also shared his past experiences of feeling unprepared for media interviews and the importance of authenticity. Forbes, on the other hand, is seen as a competent and honest candidate, making a virtue of her straightforward answers. The speaker emphasized the importance of acknowledging the role of faith and values in the public sphere, rather than trying to scrub them out. A real liberal society, he argued, is one that embraces diversity and tolerates differences, rather than striving for an anodyne and neutral environment.

    • Leaders who demonstrate honesty and authenticity are more trustedHonesty and authenticity are crucial for leaders. Nicola Sturgeon and Kate Forbes demonstrate these qualities, helping build trust and understanding on complex issues.

      Honesty and authenticity are essential qualities for a leader. Nicola Sturgeon, as an example, has demonstrated her honesty even when facing difficult questions, making it easier for people to trust her on other policies. Kate Forbes, another political figure, has expressed views that some might find controversial, but if these views disturb and contradict us, it could be a sign that we've encountered something real and significant. It's essential to take people on a journey and help them understand complex issues, especially during leadership campaigns. Our individual struggles and identities are significant to us, but they pale in comparison to the vastness and significance of the universe and a potential higher power. Ultimately, leaders who demonstrate honesty, authenticity, and the ability to help people understand complex issues are more likely to gain trust and succeed.

    • Politician's commitment to honesty earns respectA politician's authenticity and honesty can win respect and support, even if opinions on their stance on certain issues differ.

      Integrity is a valuable quality in politics, and the politician being discussed has demonstrated it by being unafraid to answer difficult questions honestly, even if it means potentially alienating some voters. This politician's stance on issues like gay rights and personal beliefs may be under scrutiny, but her commitment to speaking truthfully about them could ultimately win her respect and support from those who value authenticity. Additionally, public opinion on strikes varies depending on the profession involved. Nurses, for instance, are generally viewed more favorably than other striking workers, and the government may be more willing to accommodate their demands to prevent further disruption.

    • Public opinion towards strikes and workers' rights in the UKPublic opinion towards strikes and workers' rights in the UK has become more sympathetic, but figures leading these movements still face varying public approval.

      Public opinion towards strikes and workers' rights in the UK has shifted significantly over the past decade, even if opinions vary according to sector. The example given is the change in public sympathy for teachers' strikes, which was once met with disapproval but now enjoys a positive lead. However, this shift doesn't necessarily mean that figures like Mick Lynch, who leads the RMT union, are viewed favorably by the public. In fact, Lynch's approval rating is around 25-35%, with around 30-40% having an unfavorable view, and the rest not having an opinion. This shows that while there is more sympathy for workers' rights, the public still has varying opinions on the figures leading these movements. Additionally, the public's attitude towards Brexit and the Northern Ireland protocol has become increasingly apathetic and dismissive, with most not expressing strong opinions on the matter.

    • Brexit apathy among Leave voters may skew poll resultsBrexit apathy among Leave voters could underestimate their numbers in elections, impacting poll outcomes for EU rejoining.

      Despite increasing numbers of people believing that Brexit was the wrong decision, the apathy among Leave voters is causing them to stay home and not participate in opinion polls or elections. This apathy could significantly impact the outcome of hypothetical polls regarding rejoining the EU. At the same time, the recent by-election win for Labour in West Lancashire, as predicted by the Britain Predicts state of the nation model, shows that the current polling data may not accurately reflect the motivated voter base during an actual election campaign.

    • Tory voters staying home affecting polling resultsLabour may gain larger-than-expected majority in next election due to Tory voter apathy and potential tactical voting, while Lib Dems could perform well in certain areas.

      The current political landscape is seeing Tory voters staying home due to a lack of motivation, which could impact polling results. For instance, in the by-election in West Lancashire, Labour held onto the seat with a larger-than-expected margin, despite the area being seen as a dormitory town for Scousers. The Britain Predicts model accurately predicted this outcome, but it's important to remember that by-elections often produce different results and don't necessarily reflect the outcome of a general election. Currently, the aggregate of polls predicts a Labour majority of 370 seats in the next election, but this doesn't account for tactical voting or a campaign. If these factors come into play, the outcome could be closer to a Labour majority of 370, with the Tories gaining some seats back. The Lib Dems are also expected to have a good election, particularly in certain parts of "blue wall England." Britain Predicts' analysis can be found on the State of the Nation website at s0tn.newstatesman.com.

    • Rishi Sunak's Impact on UK Politics: Narrowing the Labour Party's LeadRishi Sunak has successfully reduced Labour Party's lead in UK politics from a large gap to a tight 20 point advantage, showcasing his ability to connect with voters and make progress in challenging circumstances.

      Rishi Sunak has significantly reduced the Labour Party's lead in UK politics since taking office, bringing it down from a 25-30 point lead to a tight 20 point advantage. This is a notable achievement given the initial large gap, and it highlights Sunak's ability to connect with voters and make progress despite challenging circumstances. The current political landscape remains fluid, and it will be interesting to see how Labour responds to this narrowed lead and whether Sunak can continue to close the gap in the coming months. Additionally, the discussion touched upon various listener questions and upcoming podcast topics, and a promotional mention was made for UnitedHealthcare's short term health insurance plans.

    Was this summary helpful?

    Recent Episodes from The New Statesman Podcast

    Giveaways and Sue Gray's pay, do they matter?

    Giveaways and Sue Gray's pay, do they matter?

    Labour Party Conference is just around the corner and the party needs to tell a story about the bigger picture for their time in government, but could this get lost amongst the smaller stories cropping up around free clothes and the chief of staff's pay?


    Hannah Barnes, associate editor, is joined in the studio by Andrew Marr, political editor, and George Eaton, senior editor.


    Sign up to the New Statesman's daily politics newsletter: Morning Call

     

    Submit a question for a future episode: You Ask Us



    Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.


    The New Statesman Podcast
    enSeptember 20, 2024

    Ed Davey thinks he could be leader of the opposition

    Ed Davey thinks he could be leader of the opposition

    Conference season is underway and Ed Davey sat down with the New Statesman's Rachel Cunliffe to set out his party's ambitions to become the party of opposition.


    We also hear from Wes Streeting and the political battle for NHS reform.


    Hannah Barnes is joined in the studio by Andrew Marr, political editor, and Rachel Cunliffe, associate political editor.


    Ed Davey: “The Conservatives are in our sights”


    Wes Streeting: “I don’t want to be the fun police”



    Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.


    The New Statesman Podcast
    enSeptember 19, 2024

    Led By Donkeys: "Liz Truss was fair game"

    Led By Donkeys: "Liz Truss was fair game"

    Will Dunn meets the political pranksters who sent Liz Truss fleeing in rage.


    **Follow on your podcast app to get new episodes as soon as they're released**


    From films detailing Conservative hypocrisy projected on Parliament buildings, to remote-controlled lettuce banners unfurling over the head of the former Prime Minister, Led By Donkeys have been a regular fixture of political activism over the past decade.


    Now with a Labour government in place after 14 years of Tory rule, will the group - with their predominantly progressive politics - change their approach?


    The New Statesman's Will Dunn meets Led By Donkeys in this extended interview.


    Led By Donkeys: Adventures in Art, Activism and Accountability is published by Thames & Hudson and available now.




    Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.


    The New Statesman Podcast
    enSeptember 16, 2024

    Why is US politics "so mad"?

    Why is US politics "so mad"?

    Freddie Hayward rejoins the podcast in his new role as US correspondent to answer listener questions on the weird world of US politics. 


    **Hit 'follow' on your podcast app to get new episodes first**


    He speaks to Hannah Barnes and Rachel Cunliffe to discuss how Keir Starmer’s commitment to “tough choices” compares with the Kamala Harris campaign, and how US election campaigns use the vast amounts of money they receive in donations.



    Read more: 

    Robert F Kennedy Jr and the end of the party

    https://www.newstatesman.com/comment/2024/08/robert-f-kennedy-tulsi-gabbard


    Kamala Harris wants to make America nice again

    https://www.newstatesman.com/international-politics/2024/08/cnn-interview-kamala-harris



    Submit a question:

    We answer listener questions every Friday. Submit your by commenting on this episode on Spotify, or at www.newstatesman.com/youaskus


    Become a New Statesman subscriber:

    Get access to all our reporting at newstatesman.com and receive your copy of our weekly magazine. Podcast listeners can get the first two months for just £2 at https://www.newstatesman.com/save


    Sign up for our daily politics email

    Receive a daily dose of politics coverage straight to your inbox every morning in our newsletter, Morning Call. Sign up for free here: https://morningcall.substack.com


    Watch the New Statesman podcast

    Find all episodes on our YouTube channel: https://www.youtube.com/@newstatesman



    Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.


    The New Statesman Podcast
    enSeptember 13, 2024

    Has Rachel Reeves made a “huge mistake”?

    Has Rachel Reeves made a “huge mistake”?

    “She’s done an awful lot of damage to morale,” says Andrew Marr.


    Hit “Follow” in your podcast app to get new episodes as soon as they publish


    Chancellor Rachel Reeves secured a victory in Parliament for her proposed changes to the Winter Fuel allowance. 


    But the move has divided the Labour party, angered voters, and possibly tarnished Keir Starmer’s authority. Is this a sign Rachel Reeves “is not very good at politics”? 


    Andrew Marr and George Eaton join Hannah Barnes on this episode of the New Statesman podcast.


    They also discuss Keir Starmer’s relationships with the trade unions following his speech at the TUC this week, and Freddie Hayward joins from the US to discuss the response to the Trump/Harris presidential debate.



    Read more: 

    Rachel Reeves’ great gamble, by George Eaton

    https://www.newstatesman.com/cover-story/2024/09/rachel-reeves-great-gamble


    Workers’ rights or growth: another tough choice for Labour, by Andrew Marr

    https://www.newstatesman.com/politics/uk-politics/2024/09/workers-rights-or-growth-another-tough-choice-for-labour


    Kamala Harris made Trump look like a loser, by Freddie Hayward

    https://www.newstatesman.com/international-politics/2024/09/kamala-harris-donald-trump-debate-loser



    Submit a question:

    We answer listener questions every Friday. Submit your by commenting on this episode on Spotify, or at www.newstatesman.com/youaskus


    Become a New Statesman subscriber:

    Get access to all our reporting at newstatesman.com and receive your copy of our weekly magazine. Podcast listeners can get the first two months for just £2 at https://www.newstatesman.com/save


    Sign up for our daily politics email

    Receive a daily dose of politics coverage straight to your inbox every morning in our newsletter, Morning Call. Sign up for free here: https://morningcall.substack.com


    Watch the New Statesman podcast

    Find all episodes on our YouTube channel: https://www.youtube.com/@newstatesman




    Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.


    The New Statesman Podcast
    enSeptember 12, 2024

    Losing Gaza

    Losing Gaza

    “We cannot know what sort of human beings will emerge from this.”


    Following Hamas’s deadly attack on 7 October 2023, Israel’s military response has been described as “inevitable”. Eleven months on, the scope and ferocity of that military response has stunned the world. 


    In this episode of the podcast we speak to four of the writers who contributed to the New Statesman essay collection Losing Gaza.


    Raja Shehadeh: “Palestinians are not treated as human beings deserving of human rights”


    Ghada Karmi: “The physical damage of Israel’s assault is real enough. The mental trauma will be far worse” 


    Raja Khalidi: “After the war, world leaders will need a new Marshall Plan for Palestine”


    Mezna Qato: “Without our libraries and universities, how will we tell the story of Gaza?”



    Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.


    The New Statesman Podcast
    enSeptember 09, 2024

    Is Jeremy Corbyn trolling Keir Starmer?

    Is Jeremy Corbyn trolling Keir Starmer?

    The former Labour leader’s new coalition could be “a real force” in Parliament, says Andrew Marr.


    **Hit ‘Follow’ in your podcast app to get every episode as soon as it drops**


    Jeremy Corbyn has formed a new “Independent Alliance” of MPs, united around opposition to the Gaza war. Answering a listener question on this “You Ask Us” episode, Andrew Marr says Corbyn could well attract more Labour MPs to his cause. This would make the Independent Alliance bigger than Reform UK, and could influence policy from the Left.


    Andrew Marr joins Hannah Barnes and Rachel Cunliffe on this listener questions episode of the podcast. They also discuss Keir Starmer’s plans for UK-EU relations, and whether the Prime Minister will row back on some Brexit agreements. 



    Read more: 

    Andrew Marr on Labour’s battle for Britain

    https://www.newstatesman.com/cover-story/2024/09/labours-battle-for-britain


    Submit a question:

    We answer listener questions every Friday. Submit your by commenting on this episode on Spotify, or at www.newstatesman.com/youaskus


    Become a New Statesman subscriber:

    Get access to all our reporting at newstatesman.com and receive your copy of our weekly magazine. Podcast listeners can get the first two months for just £2 at https://www.newstatesman.com/save


    Sign up for our daily politics email

    Receive a daily dose of politics coverage straight to your inbox every morning in our newsletter, Morning Call. Sign up for free here: https://morningcall.substack.com


    Watch the New Statesman podcast

    Find all episodes on our YouTube channel: https://www.youtube.com/@newstatesman




    Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.


    The New Statesman Podcast
    enSeptember 06, 2024

    Grenfell prosecutions are now “essential” - Andrew Marr

    Grenfell prosecutions are now “essential” - Andrew Marr

    The Grenfell report is damning. Will there finally be justice for Grenfell?


    --


    After seven long years the Grenfell Inquiry has published its damning verdict: the 72 deaths caused by the Grenfell Tower fire were completely avoidable.


    The 1500-page report names and shames companies and government bodies who’s choices and actions led to the deaths.


    In this episode, Andrew Marr and Rachel Cunliffe join Hannah Barnes to discuss the findings of the inquiry and why justice must finally come for Grenfell.


    They also review the Conservative leadership race following the first vote which saw former Home Secretary Priti Patel fall at the first hurdle. Andrew and Rachel report on view within Westminster of the remaining candidates, and why one in particular divides opinion among MPs in the Commons tea rooms.



    Read more: 

    Megan Kenyon on the Grenfell report: failure on an industrial scale https://www.newstatesman.com/politics/uk-politics/2024/09/grenfell-inquiry-failure-on-an-industrial-scale


    George Eaton: the Grenfell report is damning for David Cameron

    https://www.newstatesman.com/politics/uk-politics/2024/09/the-grenfell-report-is-damning-for-david-cameron


    Submit a question:

    We answer listener questions every Friday. Submit your by commenting on this episode on Spotify, or at www.newstatesman.com/youaskus


    Become a New Statesman subscriber:

    Get access to all our reporting at newstatesman.com and receive your copy of our weekly magazine. Podcast listeners can get the first two months for just £2 at https://www.newstatesman.com/save


    Sign up for our daily politics email

    Receive a daily dose of politics coverage straight to your inbox every morning in our newsletter, Morning Call. Sign up for free here: https://morningcall.substack.com


    Watch the New Statesman podcast

    Find all episodes on our YouTube channel: https://www.youtube.com/@newstatesman




    Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.


    The New Statesman Podcast
    enSeptember 05, 2024

    Can Oasis bring back Cool Britannia?

    Can Oasis bring back Cool Britannia?

    Noel and Liam Gallagher have managed the impossible. They've apparently buried the hatchet and announced that Oasis is coming back in 2025. Is this the return of Cool Britannia?


    Rachel Cunliffe, associate editor, is joined by George Eaton, senior editor, to answer listener questions about ex-MP's jobs, SPADs, and the politics of Britpop.


    Sign up to the New Statesman's daily politics newsletter: Morning Call

     

    Submit a question for a future episode: You Ask Us



    Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.


    The New Statesman Podcast
    enAugust 29, 2024

    "Things will get worse": is austerity back?

    "Things will get worse": is austerity back?

    On Tuesday morning Keir Starmer addressed the nation and warned that Labour’s first Budget “is going to be painful”, suggesting that tax rises are on the way. 


    While the prime minister stressed that those with the “broadest shoulders should bear the heavier burden”, he warned that he won’t “shy away from making unpopular decisions”, raising the question of whether Labour is bringing back austerity.


    Rachel Cunliffe, associate political editor, is joined by George Eaton, senior editor.



    Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.


    The New Statesman Podcast
    enAugust 28, 2024

    Related Episodes

    Conservative to Labour... with Iain Anderson

    Conservative to Labour... with Iain Anderson

    BUY YOUR TICKETS FOR OUR 25 YEARS OF DEVOLUTION SPECIAL


    Announced guests so far: Jack McConnell, Alex Salmond, Henry McLeish


    Click: https://holyroodsources.com/live


    Almost exactly a year on from our first episode, Calum and Andy are joined by Iain Anderson, founder and Executive Chairman of the lobbying group Cicero, who has switched allegiances to Labour after being a Conservative supporter for four decades. They discuss Labour's prospects as the self-proclaimed party of business, and how that might weigh on Scotland. After a chaotic week in Westminster, we try and figure out where we find ourselves now, and what we've learned. And ahead of Scottish Conservative Conference, the trio dissect the party's role within the Scottish political sphere, and why former leader Ruth Davidson could well have been First Minister, but was held back.


    In association with The Royal Bank of Scotland.

    Become a member at https://plus.acast.com/s/holyroodsources.



    Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.


    Ep 26: Touch Wood - (Part 1)

    Ep 26: Touch Wood - (Part 1)

    Welcome back to In Sickness and in Health, your favourite comedy podcast hosted by James and Clair Buckley.


    In today’s episode, James goes off on one of his rants about people who can’t handle spicy food…he’s vowed to do the One Chip Challenge so stay tuned for that! The Buckleys reveal which weird superstitions they believe in, and then go on to give advice on how to deal with in-laws who not-so-subtly suggest you’re hairy, overweight and smelly?!


    Tune in every Tuesday for more In Sickness and in Health, and keep your eyes peeled for future bonus episodes! Subscribe and follow us on social media to watch the best bits from the latest episodes - @insicknessandinhealthpodcast



    Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.


    Fighting the Post Office: Alan Bates at the inquiry

    Fighting the Post Office: Alan Bates at the inquiry

    Alan Bates, the campaigner who took on the Post Office to expose flaws in its IT systems which led to wrongful convictions, has appeared before the public inquiry into the scandal.

    Can this crucial stage of the inquiry take the victims a step closer to justice?

    This podcast was brought to you thanks to the support of readers of The Times and The Sunday Times. Subscribe today: http://thetimes.co.uk/thestory

    Guest: Tom Witherow, news and special projects reporter, The Times.  

    Host: Luke Jones. 

    Further listening: The Post Office scandal: How a TV drama delivered justice

    Clips: Channel 4 News, ITV. 

    Get in touch: thestory@thetimes.co.uk 

    Find out more about our bonus series for Times subscribers: 'Inside the newsroom'




    Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.


    Help I'm More Postman Than Post Box

    Help I'm More Postman Than Post Box
    This week we find out how Jordan’s been coping with having his parents stay with him for a few days, William has a vent about some uncouth theatre patrons and their lack of etiquette, and the boys come up with possibly the most bizarre television idea ever.

    Join Sexted Extra and laugh along to William Hanson and Jordan North helping you navigate the challenges of modern life ad free at https://plus.acast.com/s/sextedmyboss.



    Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

    Logo

    © 2024 Podcastworld. All rights reserved

    Stay up to date

    For any inquiries, please email us at hello@podcastworld.io