Logo

    Mehdi Hasan on Kamala Harris vs Donald Trump

    en-gbJuly 23, 2024
    What historic decision did Joe Biden make regarding re-election?
    How did political observers react to Harris leading the campaign?
    What key endorsements has Kamala Harris received?
    What issues could differentiate Harris from Biden's campaign?
    Why is this political period described as unprecedented and unpredictable?

    Podcast Summary

    • US Presidential Race Turning PointFirst sitting president since 1968 not to seek re-election, Kamala Harris takes control, offers vision for future, sets stage for significant election with two distinct visions

      The US presidential race took an unexpected turn when Kamala Harris took control of the Biden-Harris campaign following Joe Biden's decision not to seek re-election. This historic moment marks the first time a sitting president has decided not to run for re-election since 1968. Harris's speech at the campaign headquarters outlined her vision for the future, focusing on opportunities for every person to get ahead. Some political observers, like Matthew Husain of The Guardian, saw this as a chance for a fresh start and were advocating for Harris to take the lead earlier in the race. Despite previous criticisms of Harris's record as a California Attorney General and her campaign strategy, many party luminaries, including the Clintons and Nancy Pelosi, have endorsed her. This shift in the race sets the stage for a significant election with two distinct visions of the future on offer.

    • Kamala Harris' qualifications and experienceKamala Harris, with a record in high office spanning over two decades, has the qualifications and experience to potentially be a competitive contender in the 2024 presidential race, despite some negative perceptions. Her adaptability and ability to appeal to those looking for an alternative make her a formidable candidate.

      Kamala Harris, despite some negative perceptions, has a strong qualification and experience background to potentially be a competitive contender against Donald Trump in the 2024 presidential race. Her record in high office spans over two decades, making her one of the most experienced presidents in history, having been an elected DA, attorney general of California, senator from California, and vice president of the United States. While her politics have been seen as all over the place, she may run slightly to the left of Joe Biden's current position, particularly on immigration, Gaza, and labor relations. Polling suggests that Harris could benefit from being a new candidate and not being Biden or Trump, as many Americans are looking for an alternative. Additionally, her record and experience may be underappreciated, and her past campaigns show an ability to adapt to the political climate.

    • Kamala Harris' record and plansDespite her identity and experience as Vice President, Kamala Harris' record and plans should be the focus of evaluation in her presidential campaign, not her identity or Vice Presidency record.

      Kamala Harris' identity and experience as a black, South Asian woman, and her tenure as Vice President under Joe Biden, while important, should not be the sole basis for evaluating her presidential campaign. Her record prior to the Vice Presidency and her plans for the future should be the main focus. Harris is currently the frontrunner for the Democratic Party nomination, with strong support from key Democratic figures and a record-breaking fundraising total. However, her stance on issues like immigration, minimum wage, and voter turnout could differentiate her from Biden and energize the Democratic base. It remains to be seen if she will run to the left of Biden, but doing so could potentially increase votice turnout among marginalized communities. Ultimately, Harris' plans and policies should be the focus of evaluation, rather than her identity or vice presidential record.

    • Kamala Harris and GazaKamala Harris may show more empathy towards Palestinians and acknowledge their humanity in U.S. foreign policy towards Gaza, while her stance on abortion and democracy will remain a focus of her campaign.

      While Kamala Harris may not drastically change U.S. foreign policy towards Gaza compared to Joe Biden, she is expected to show more empathy towards the Palestinian people and acknowledge their humanity. Harris has already shown a stronger stance on the issue, speaking out about the humanitarian situation and advocating for a temporary ceasefire earlier than Biden. Additionally, Harris's commitment to issues like abortion and democracy is likely to remain a core focus of her campaign, given their importance to Democrats and her personal passion for these topics.

    • Harris' background and challengesKamala Harris' unique background and style could help her connect with people, but her campaign suspension and ongoing questions about America's readiness for a black woman president present challenges. The focus should be on her qualifications and ability to effectively address issues.

      Kamala Harris' unique background and style, which includes her ability to connect with people through relatable stories and humor, could be key assets in her role as Joe Biden's running mate. However, her campaign suspension in 2019 and the ongoing questions about America's readiness for a black woman president present challenges. The coconut tree joke, a viral meme from Harris' past, is an example of her ability to connect with people, but it also raises questions about whether the public is laughing with or at her. Despite these challenges, it's important to remember that many Western democracies have had female leaders, and Harris' gender and race should not be barriers to her potential success. The focus should be on her qualifications and ability to effectively address the issues facing the country.

    • Republican campaign strategy shiftThe unexpected exit of Joe Biden and Kamala Harris's nomination left the Republicans struggling to adapt their campaign message, as their attacks on Biden's age no longer apply to Harris. The Democrats are now able to use age against the Republicans, shifting the focus of the election to a referendum on Trump.

      The unexpected exit of Joe Biden from the presidential race and Kamala Harris's subsequent nomination has left the Trump campaign scrambling to adapt their message. The Republicans had built their entire campaign around attacking Biden's age and cognitive abilities, but now that Harris is the Democratic nominee, they are struggling to come up with an effective response. The Trump campaign's attempts to discredit Harris have been lackluster. Trump's nickname for Harris, "Laughing Kamala," falls flat compared to his past successful nicknames for opponents. The Democrats, on the other hand, are now able to use age against the Republicans, turning the tables on them. The focus of the election has shifted to a referendum on Donald Trump, and simply being seen as not him could be enough for a Democrat to win. The Trump campaign's emphasis on Biden's age has made him an easier target for the Democrats to attack, leaving the Republicans wishing they had not made age the key issue in the election.

    • Harris outreach to white working class votersKamala Harris must define herself beyond being anti-Trump, reach out to white working class voters in swing states, emphasize stance on abortion and labor, and campaign on the ground to avoid past mistakes.

      Kamala Harris needs to define herself beyond being a strong anti-Trump figure and reach out to white working class voters in crucial swing states like Wisconsin, Pennsylvania, and Michigan. Harris, who has experience leading labor relations policies, can appeal to these voters by emphasizing her stance on issues important to them, such as abortion and organized labor. The choice of her running mate could also play a crucial role in reassuring some voters. While an outside-the-box pick like Gretchen Whitmer could be a clever move, the Democrats may opt for a more traditional choice to mitigate risk. Ultimately, Harris must campaign on the ground in these swing states and avoid the mistakes of past Democratic candidates, such as Hillary Clinton's failure to do so in Wisconsin.

    • 2024 Democratic nominationKamala Harris' potential re-nomination as the Democratic candidate for the 2024 presidential race has reinvigorated the Democratic Party and shifted the narrative away from Republican momentum and unity behind Trump.

      The 2024 presidential race is seeing a significant shift following Joe Biden's decision to serve out his term and allow Kamala Harris to potentially run for re-election as the Democratic nominee. This decision has given the Democratic Party a boost, with Harris' potential candidacy reinvigorating the race and changing the narrative from the Republicans' momentum and unity behind Trump. Potential running mates for Harris include Josh Shapiro of Pennsylvania, Andy Beshear of Kentucky, and J.B. Pritzker of Illinois. The impact of Biden's continued presidency on Harris' campaign and the overall race remains uncertain.

    • American politics chaosThe upcoming months in American politics are unprecedented and unpredictable, with potentially once-in-a-lifetime events happening frequently.

      We are currently living through a historically unprecedented and unpredictable period in American politics. The recent events, including a former president coming close to assassination and a current president stepping down from the race, have added to the chaos and uncertainty. The next few months leading up to the voting day are expected to be the most consequential of our lifetimes, with many once-in-a-decade or once-in-a-century events happening every few weeks or even days. It's important for us to stay informed and prepared for the unexpected. As Mehdi Hasan, a Guardian columnist, put it, "We are living through a crazy period in history."

    Recent Episodes from Today in Focus