Logo

    Native American Reservations

    enSeptember 07, 2023
    What initiated the Native American reservation system?
    How have Native American communities been affected by displacement?
    What are some efforts to revitalize Native American culture?
    Why are language preservation initiatives important for Native Americans?
    What challenges do Native American reservations currently face?

    Podcast Summary

    • The Native American reservation system: a legacy of displacement and lossThe Native American reservation system stands as evidence of the historical injustice and displacement suffered by indigenous communities, highlighting the need for reconciliation and justice.

      The Native American reservation system is a result of the removal and displacement of Native Americans from their traditional lands. This ongoing process, which began in the 19th century, continues to have a lasting impact today. The reservation system serves as proof that land was taken away from indigenous people, often through negotiation or outright seizure. While some may argue that there were treaties and deals involved, it is undeniable that Native Americans have experienced significant loss and displacement. The effects of this historical injustice are still felt by Native American communities, and it is essential to acknowledge and address these issues to work towards reconciliation and justice.

    • Native Americans and Reservations in the United StatesReservations provide Native Americans with self-determination and cultural preservation, but the majority of Native Americans live outside of reservations. Reservations have unique opportunities and operate under federal law with limited state jurisdiction.

      Native Americans living on reservations have a certain level of self-determination and are considered sovereign nations within the United States. While the census may not accurately reflect the Native population, it is estimated that 1.2 million people, or 13%, live on reservations. However, the majority of Native Americans do not live on reservations and instead reside in other parts of the country. For those who do live on reservations, it is often because they were born there and want to maintain their cultural heritage. Reservations operate under federal law and have limited state jurisdiction, which allows for unique opportunities such as the existence of casinos. The history of Native American displacement and broken treaties has led to the creation of reservations, particularly in Indian territory, which is now primarily in Oklahoma.

    • The Struggle for Native American Rights and SovereigntyThroughout history, the federal government imposed forced assimilation, displacement, and termination policies on Native Americans, but through resistance movements, they fought for tribal recognition and self-determination, highlighting an ongoing struggle.

      The federal government's treatment of Native Americans throughout history has been marked by forced assimilation, displacement, and termination policies. From the Indian Appropriations Act of 1851 to the Indian Reorganization Act and the termination era of the 1950s and 60s, Native American tribes were subjected to government control and manipulation. They were moved onto Reservations, forced to rely on government-supplied food, and pressured to adopt American lifestyles and farming practices. The termination policies aimed to dissolve tribes and urge Native Americans to assimilate into urban areas. However, resistance movements like the American Indian Movement successfully fought for tribal recognition and self-determination, leading to the Indian Self-Determination and Education Act of 1975. This highlights the ongoing struggle for Native American rights and sovereignty.

    • The Complex History and Ongoing Struggle of Native AmericansNative American tribes in the US have endured displacement, disregard for their rights, and limited sovereignty on reservations. Recognition, understanding, and respect are vital to address their painful history and ongoing struggles.

      Native American tribes in the United States have faced centuries of evolving policies and treatment, from displacement to the establishment of Reservations. This constant upheaval and disregard for their rights and territories is a painful part of their history. The United States tucked Native Americans away on Reservations and has often forgotten about them, refusing to face the harsh reality of what they have endured. The Reservations, though held in trust by the US federal government for the benefit of the tribes, provide a precarious form of sovereignty. Without this arrangement, the tribes would be subject to state laws and taxes, which would further diminish their autonomy. The complex history and ongoing struggle of Native Americans highlight the need for recognition, understanding, and respect.

    • The Complex and Diverse Reservation System in the United StatesThe reservation system in the United States is a patchwork of differing rules and arrangements, varying from tribe to tribe and state to state, with some tribes achieving self-sufficiency through enterprises like casinos.

      The reservation system in the United States is complex and diverse. Not every tribe has their own reservation, and some tribes may share reservations. Surprisingly, non-native people can live on reservations, and some reservations have a majority of non-native residents. The Oneida Indian Nation in upstate New York is an example of a tribe that has American Indians and non-native people living together. Some tribes, like the Oneida, have become self-sufficient and wealthy through enterprises like casinos. The reservation system varies from state to state, with Oklahoma having a significant amount of reservation land and California having smaller rancherias. Additionally, Alaska has a unique system where all federally recognized tribes share one reservation and receive dividends from resource extraction. Overall, the reservation system is a patchwork with different rules and arrangements depending on the tribe and location.

    • Revitalizing Native American culture and preserving languagesEfforts are being made to acknowledge and preserve Native American cultural heritage through teaching tribal cultures in schools and preserving endangered languages. This helps reclaim identities and ensure the continuity of traditions.

      There are ongoing efforts to revitalize Native American culture and preserve their languages. Historically, Native American tribes have faced immense oppression and cultural erasure through policies like compulsory boarding schools. However, in recent times, there is a shift towards acknowledging the importance of Native American cultural heritage. Native American schools and boarding schools are now teaching tribal cultures, with elders playing a vital role in transmitting cultural information. Additionally, initiatives like the Durbin Feeling Language Center are working to preserve endangered Native languages, such as Cherokee. By embracing and preserving their culture, Native American communities are reclaiming their identities and ensuring the continuity of their traditions for future generations.

    • Preserving Native American languages for future generationsNative American languages are vital for preserving cultural identity, and it is important for governments to provide consistent support and resources to ensure their survival and the well-being of Native American communities.

      Preserving Native American languages is crucial for the preservation of their culture. Many Native American languages are oral and not written, making it essential to pass down the oral tradition and also create tech-based resources for future generations. The United States government has shown some support by donating grants to tribes for language preservation. However, the political landscape has varied over the years, with different administrations having different approaches. The Trump administration faced criticism for its lack of support and actions that negatively affected Native American communities. Additionally, there is a need for both political parties to prioritize their obligations to help improve the lives of Native Americans on reservations. The conversation also highlights the contrast between different reservations, such as the Navajo Nation, the Ola Sioux Nation, and the Seminole, showcasing the diverse experiences and challenges faced by these communities.

    • Challenges and Injustices Faced by Native American TribesNative American tribes have suffered injustices throughout history, including forced relocation and insufficient resources. Increased support is needed to improve living conditions and address the issues faced by these communities.

      Native American tribes, such as the Navajo and Lakota, have faced significant challenges and injustices throughout history. While the Navajo were able to negotiate a treaty and reclaim their ancestral lands, many other tribes were relocated to reservations that were not their original territory. These reservations often lack basic resources and infrastructure, with a high percentage of households living below the federal poverty level and lacking access to running water and reliable internet. The conversation also highlights the need for increased support and attention to address these issues and improve the living conditions of Native American communities.

    • Contrasting Realities of Native American Tribes in the USNative American tribes in the US face stark disparities, as some struggle with poverty, lack of basic amenities, and high rates of addiction and crime, while others thrive and achieve recognition.

      There is a stark contrast between the conditions and opportunities faced by different Native American tribes in the United States. Pine Ridge, located in South Dakota, represents the worst end of the spectrum, with high poverty rates, lack of basic amenities like running water and electricity, low employment opportunities, and high rates of drug addiction and crime. This has led to a shockingly low life expectancy, comparable to that of Haiti. On the other hand, the Seminole Tribe in Florida has been able to thrive and achieve recognition, adopting their own constitution and experiencing growth and success. These disparities highlight the historical and ongoing struggles faced by Native American communities in the United States.

    • The Seminole tribe's business success through the casino industry and ownership of the Hard Rock franchise.The Seminole tribe's ownership of the Hard Rock franchise has brought financial prosperity to their tribe members, with each member receiving a yearly payment of $128,000.

      The Seminole tribe of Florida has achieved great success and financial prosperity through their business ventures, primarily the casino industry. They own the Hard Rock franchise, including the iconic Hard Rock Cafe, which they acquired in 2006. As the owners of the brand, they have been able to generate significant profits and distribute the earnings among their tribe members. Each member receives a yearly payment of $128,000, even including infants whose funds are held in trust. Additionally, the Seminole tribe played a pivotal role in establishing Native American casinos in the 1970s, leading to the economic growth of several tribes across the country.

    • Increasing Native American Voter Registration and the Power of Diaries in HistoryNative American voter registration needs to be addressed, with organizations like Native Voter Impact and vote.narf.org playing a crucial role. The diary of Martha Ballard reminds us of the influential impact ordinary individuals have had throughout history.

      There is a need to increase voter registration among Native Americans living on Reservations. Currently, only around 60 percent of eligible Native American population is registered to vote, and efforts like the Million Vote opportunity are being made to address this issue. Supporting organizations such as Native Voter Impact or vote.narf.org can contribute to getting them registered and ensuring their rights are protected. Additionally, the conversation highlights the importance of diaries in humanizing the past and bringing different perspectives. The story mentions the diary of Martha Ballard, a midwife who chronicled her everyday life in Frontier America. It serves as a reminder that ordinary people have always made a significant impact throughout history.

    Recent Episodes from Stuff You Should Know

    Selects: How Futurology Works

    Selects: How Futurology Works

    Science fiction writers have made some amazingly accurate predictions over the years, but in 1945 the pace of technological change created a field that spun off of sci-fi forecasting, futurology. Learn all about it with Josh and Chuck in this classic episode.

    See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

    Stuff You Should Know
    enSeptember 07, 2024

    Selects: The Manson Family Murders Part 1

    Selects: The Manson Family Murders Part 1

    The '60s ended with a lot of turbulence, not the least of which was the Manson Family Murders. What made Charles Manson so alluring to his family? What makes one person kill for another? And what did The Beatles have to do with it all? Learn all this and more in this first part of our two part classic episode.

    See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

    Stuff You Should Know
    enAugust 31, 2024

    How Bomb Disposal Works

    How Bomb Disposal Works

    Out of all the jobs a person can have, few are as overtly dangerous as making sure bombs don’t go off and if they do, making sure they’re away from people. Learn how bomb technicians do it safely, without a 100% turnover rate.

    See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

    Stuff You Should Know
    enAugust 29, 2024

    Related Episodes

    The Only Native American Winemaker in the U.S. Speaks Up: Tara Gomez

    The Only Native American Winemaker in the U.S. Speaks Up: Tara Gomez

    The elders had questions, the community was not entirely supportive, yet Native American winemaker Tara Gomez persisted. When her Santa Ynes Band of Chumash tribe bought land that included a parcel with a vineyard, Tara created Kita Wines. Listen in to episode #114 and hear about Tara's struggles with learning disabilities and distrust, as well as her love of Europe and its winemaking techniques.

    Want to stay up to date on the latest Speaking Broadly episodes? To hear more conversations with Dana Cowin and her fierce guests, subscribe to Speaking Broadly (it’s free!) on iTunes or Stitcher. If you like what you hear, please take a moment to rate + review us on Apple’s podcast store and follow Dana on Instagram @speakingbroadly and @fwscout. Thanks for tuning in!

    Speaking Broadly is powered by Simplecast.