Podcast Summary
Bringing Quantitative Rigor to Private Markets with Helio: Helio uses algorithms and data sets to evaluate consumer and retail companies in private markets, discovering 8 out of 10 most predictive factors were already available in their applications
Ryan Kaldbeck, the CEO of CircleUp, set out to bring quantitative rigor to private markets by creating Helio, a system that uses algorithms and data sets to evaluate consumer and retail companies. The inspiration came from his experience in consumer-focused private equity where he found the process of manually reviewing companies to be repetitive and inefficient. He wanted to automate this process and initially built a classifier that evaluated companies based on their financials. However, they discovered that 8 out of the 10 most predictive factors were already available in the companies' applications without needing to be asked for. This highlights the potential for quantitative analysis in private markets and the importance of leveraging available data to make informed investment decisions.
Using Data and Relationships to Invest in Private Consumer Retail: Helio Capital combines quantitative analysis and relationship-building to identify and invest in private consumer retail opportunities.
Helio Capital used a quantitative approach to identify potential investments in the private consumer retail market by analyzing various dimensions related to brand, product, distribution, and other factors. However, the private markets are less efficient and more relationship-driven compared to the public markets. Therefore, while they built a sourcing engine to identify potential investments through data analysis, they also prioritize building deep relationships with entrepreneurs to increase their chances of success. This approach involves using data to reach out methodically while also adding a personal element. The funnel they use is similar to a B2B sales funnel, and they hire a team with both quantitative and relationship-building skills to effectively navigate the private markets.
Bringing transparency to private investments in consumer and retail sector: Helio uses data from thousands of companies to provide a fair and transparent investment experience in the consumer and retail sector
Helio is revolutionizing the way private investments in the consumer and retail sector are made by bringing transparency and data to the table. Traditionally, the process has felt like a used car buying experience, where the outcome is uncertain and leaves entrepreneurs feeling unsatisfied. Helio aims to change this by providing data on thousands of companies they've worked with over the past six years, allowing entrepreneurs to understand why they're being offered a certain valuation. This data-driven approach is particularly effective in the consumer and retail sector because business models are similar, making it easier to build models, and there is an abundance of data available. From product sales data to consumer feedback, this information forms the foundation of a consumer brand's success, and Helio has been collecting it for years. Although the process is messy and involves cleaning and normalizing the data, the end goal is to provide a fair and transparent experience for entrepreneurs.
Discovering new data sets for business insights: Analyzing diverse data sets can reveal valuable business insights, such as the importance of product differentiation in consumer space. CircleUp's success lies in finding unique, interpretable data sources to enhance prediction models and maintain a competitive edge.
Analyzing various data sets can provide valuable insights into a business's performance and future success. CircleUp, for instance, uses standardized financial statements and searches for new data sets to enhance their prediction models. Their philosophy is to find data sources that solve core problems and are interpretable for investors. An early example of this was their discovery of the importance of product differentiation in the consumer space. By analyzing product packaging, they found an inverse correlation between the number of words on the front of the package and revenue growth. This insight, while not a sole investment strategy, can be combined with other factors to identify trends and interpretable signals of future success. However, the challenge lies in staying ahead of commodification, where trends that were once unique become commoditized. CircleUp's models have not yet shown short half-lives, but the company continues to evaluate uniqueness as a trait related to revenue growth and looks for new data sets to maintain a competitive edge. The process of discovering new data sets started with stumbling upon new ideas and data sources, but CircleUp now has a robust methodology to find and evaluate new data sources. Their focus on interpretability and solving core problems has led to significant discoveries and insights in various industries.
Distribution and brand differentiation in consumer investing: Success in consumer businesses depends on identifying new areas of differentiation, such as unique distribution channels and strong brand intensity, to outperform competition and grow revenue.
Differentiation and uniqueness are crucial factors for success in consumer businesses, even as industries evolve and best practices become more widely known. While some companies may copy successful strategies, the long-term success often depends on identifying new areas of differentiation. Distribution and brand are two key areas that drive predictive power in consumer investing. Distribution refers to both the breadth and quality of channels through which a product is sold, with smaller, innovative retailers often leading the way. Brand intensity, or the emotional connection consumers have with a product, is another critical factor. Positive sentiment towards a brand, as expressed through social media, reviews, and other channels, is highly correlated with revenue growth. The absolute level and rate of change in these factors can impact predictive power, and it varies based on the size of the company and the category. Ultimately, the ability to identify and capitalize on new areas of differentiation is key to long-term success in consumer investing.
Understanding Consumer Industry Differences and Sales Channels: Recognize consumer sector and sales channel distinctions, prioritize revenue growth over percent growth, and consider price discipline and valuation trends for informed investment decisions.
While the consumer industry may seem homogeneous, it's essential to recognize the differences between sectors like personal care versus food, and sales channels such as online versus offline. Our research indicates a better correlation with dollar revenue growth than percent revenue growth. The debate between online and offline sales brings up interesting insights, with offline sales proving to matter more than many tech VCs believe. Direct-to-consumer (DTC) businesses, despite raising significant funds, have had few successful exits. The velocity metric, which investors prioritize, has not shown a relationship with success. However, the importance of price in all this cannot be overlooked. Mispricings in valuation are not well understood in the early-stage investing world, and it's crucial to consider the potential impact of high evaluations on revenue growth. Understanding price discipline and valuation trends, along with revenue growth, is vital for making informed investment decisions.
Helio Capital's Unique Approach to Private Market Pricing: Helio Capital uses a revenue multiple based on historical data and growth rates for private market pricing, while larger firms explore quantitative methods, but widespread adoption is uncertain.
Helio Capital, an investment firm, approaches pricing in private markets differently than some other firms. Instead of trying to predict how public market prices will respond, they use a revenue multiple based on historical data and growth rates. This method is still somewhat human heuristic-driven, but they're working on building a rules-based system. An example of their process is their investment in Liquid IV, a hydration company discovered through Helio's data analysis. The company took a lower evaluation offer from Helio because they wanted access to the technology and data. This sector, which includes consumer and retail, is particularly appealing due to the potential for disruption in categories where incumbents dominate a high percentage of the market. While some larger firms have started exploring the application of quantitative methods to private markets, the timeline for widespread adoption is unclear.
Expanding Quantitative Investing into Private Markets: Quantitative investing, relying on models and data, is becoming more attractive to large asset managers and LPs due to its scalability in private markets, especially in consumer markets with clear business models and abundant data.
Quantitative investing, which has seen significant success in the public markets, is poised to expand into the private markets due to the demand for scalable and repeatable investment strategies. Traditional methods of private equity and venture capital are not scalable, as they rely on a team of star analysts and manual sourcing. Quantitative investing, on the other hand, relies on models and data, making it more scalable and attractive to large asset managers and LPs. However, not every market is suitable for quantitative investing. Markets with clear business models and abundant data, such as consumer markets, are more likely to see success. Additionally, the use of data in venture capital is increasing, but many firms still lack the necessary resources and expertise to fully leverage data in their investment decisions.
Navigating Challenges in Tech Companies with Large Teams and Significant Funding: Despite having a large team and funding, tech companies face challenges in standing out in competitive markets, effectively utilizing data, attracting and retaining talent, and raising capital in private markets. Industries with repeatable business models and large amounts of data offer potential opportunities for data-driven strategies.
While having a large team and significant funding can be beneficial for a tech company, it doesn't guarantee success. The real challenge lies in standing out in competitive markets and effectively utilizing data and quant strategies. Attracting and retaining talent, particularly in the areas of business, finance, engineering, and data science, is a significant challenge. Additionally, demonstrating success and raising capital in the private markets, where feedback loops are longer and backtesting is more difficult, can be a major hurdle. Industries with repeatable business models and large amounts of data, such as real estate and media, offer potential opportunities for applying data-driven strategies. However, competition and talent acquisition remain key concerns.
Unique access to early-stage consumer investing: CircleUp offers LPs exposure to high-growth consumer brands, leveraging technology and a successful track record to deliver consistent returns.
CircleUp's approach to early-stage consumer investing offers LPs unique exposure to an asset class that cannot be accessed elsewhere. With the trend of large brands losing market share to small brands, CircleUp provides a reliable way for LPs to capitalize on this trend. The firm's successful track record with brands like Halo Top and Beyond Meat, along with its technology-driven process, has resonated with LPs. CircleUp aims for returns of around 3x, which is in line with industry standards, but the firm needs to prove its capabilities. Regarding the broader consumer-focused private equity (BCPE) landscape, there are concerns about a bubble in tech investing and tech VCs expanding into unfamiliar industries. In late-stage private equity, data is becoming increasingly important. CircleUp's ability to deliver consistent, predictable returns through its technology and process will be crucial in differentiating itself in the market. LPs are seeking long-term partnerships with firms that can navigate the evolving BCPE landscape and create value in the early-stage consumer space.
Data-driven approaches in consumer investing: Investment firms in consumer space use data-driven methods, partnering with quant hedge funds, hiring data scientists, and developing brawny and brainy models to understand brand performance and predict success.
Successful investment firms in the consumer space are increasingly focusing on data-driven approaches to understand and predict brand performance. They are partnering with quant hedge funds, hiring data scientists, and developing both "brawny" and "brainy" models. Brawny models, like machine learning algorithms, are non-interpretable and used for tasks like industry classification. Brainy models, on the other hand, are interpretable and used for understanding consumer behavior and predicting future revenue and distribution. These firms are particularly interested in the quantitative aspects of brand, such as consumer engagement on social media, which can be correlated with a company's success. For example, a company that sends a direct message in response to a negative comment on Twitter is three times more likely to not be successful. The number of stars a company has on review sites is less important than the volume and quality of engagement with the brand. Most firms are focusing on brainy models, but some vital brawny models, like entity resolution, are also being used. Overall, data-driven approaches are becoming essential for understanding and investing in consumer brands.
Focusing on a unique value proposition contributes to brand success: Identifying and addressing consumer pain points with a unique product can lead to exponential growth and investor attention.
Having a unique value proposition and focusing on it can significantly contribute to a brand's success. The example given is Halo Top, an ice cream company that identified a consumer pain point and addressed it by offering a low-calorie ice cream that allowed consumers to enjoy the whole pint without guilt. This shift in focus led to exponential growth for the company and attracted the attention of numerous investors. Another key point discussed was the importance of understanding the product as a brand billboard and the potential correlation between product uniqueness and brand performance. The conversation also touched upon the value of a unique distribution strategy, but the specific example was not explored in depth.
Dollar Shave Club's Success in DTC: Social Media Marketing and Commitment: Dollar Shave Club's success in the DTC space resulted from their innovative use of social media marketing and commitment to the channel. They relied on their successful B2C model and attracted Unilever's attention, ultimately teaching the larger corporation how to excel in the DTC space.
Dollar Shave Club's success in the DTC (Direct-to-Consumer) space can be attributed to their innovative use of social media marketing and their commitment to the DTC channel. They recognized the shift from traditional fixed-fee marketing to social media's variable cost marketing and invested heavily in a viral YouTube ad. Instead of seeking alternative marketing channels or raising funds, they relied on their successful B2C model, which ultimately made them an attractive acquisition target for Unilever. The ability to sell products online was the primary value Unilever sought, and Dollar Shave Club's CEO and team were expected to teach the larger corporation how to excel in the DTC space. Jeff Jordan from Andreessen Horowitz has been a significant influence on the speaker's professional growth, inspiring him with his high ethical standards, success, and ability to maintain his values in the tech industry. The speaker values integrity, perseverance, and being a solution in both his personal and professional life. He prefers working with individuals who offer solutions and focus on building rather than complaining. A quote from a book in the family office world resonated with the speaker, emphasizing the importance of being a solution.
The importance of having a long-term vision for personal and business growth: Focus on a 20-year vision for success, use OKRs to align and prioritize goals, and consider long-term customer needs for guidance.
Having a long-term vision for personal and business growth is crucial for success. This idea was emphasized by various influential figures, including the founder of Carnation Milk Company who believed that ultimate success lies in being useful, and Matt Christiansen, who encouraged focusing on a 20-year vision instead of a short-term one. The use of objectives and key results (OKRs) as a framework for setting and aligning on goals, both for companies and individuals, was also discussed. This approach helps prioritize and prevent micromanaging, but striking a balance between short-term and long-term goals can be challenging. Jeff Bezos' approach of focusing on things that will still be true in 10 or 20 years, such as customers wanting better, cheaper, faster products, can provide guidance for determining long-term vision.
Staying true to mission and values: Success comes from staying committed to mission and values, being open to new ideas, and learning from others.
Maintaining a clear mission, values, and focus are essential for a company, even when faced with tempting opportunities that may not align with those principles. The speaker, who is part of a team that helps entrepreneurs thrive by providing them with capital and resources, shared examples of how they've stayed true to their mission and values, such as turning down offers from large companies that wanted to use their services for non-consumer-related projects. Additionally, the speaker highlighted the importance of being open to new ideas and perspectives, even if they challenge one's preconceived notions. An example of this was when an investor suggested lowering the company's pricing, which forced the speaker to reconsider his approach and learn from other entrepreneurs and investors. Ultimately, the team's commitment to their mission and values, along with their willingness to learn and adapt, has helped them stay focused and successful.
The role of financial data in business success: Financial data from companies is crucial for predicting future success in the consumer industry. This data helps identify key factors like distribution, brand, and product. Entrepreneurs and consumer companies can partner for unique capital resources.
Access to comprehensive financial data played a crucial role in the success of a specific company's analysis and prediction of future success in the consumer industry. This extensive dataset, provided by the companies themselves, enabled the company to identify key factors such as distribution, brand, and product that are correlated with future success. The speaker emphasized the importance of this data set and the unique opportunity consumer companies have to partner with them, as they often lack alternative options for capital resources. Moreover, the speaker shared a personal story about the kindest thing anyone had ever done for him, which was his father's unwavering belief and support in his abilities, even when he doubted himself. This moment of confidence-building led him to pursue various opportunities, including attending Duke and starting CircleUp. The speaker highlighted the importance of self-worth and confidence in being an entrepreneur and as a parent, and expressed gratitude for his father's impact on his life. In summary, the discussion touched upon the significance of financial data and self-belief in achieving success, both in business and personal endeavors.
Join a community of investors and learn from experts: Sign up for the Investor Field Guide podcast, receive book recommendations, connect with the host, and access a comprehensive investor curriculum.
After signing up, you'll gain immediate access to a comprehensive investor curriculum and receive three to four book recommendations monthly. Additionally, you can connect with the host, Patrick O'Shag, on Twitter @patrick_oshag. Lastly, if you find value in the podcast, please leave a review on iTunes to help spread the word and reach more like-minded individuals.
