Logo

    S.E. Cupp: Grieving the Insanity

    en-usJuly 19, 2024
    How was the DNC compared to the RNC?
    What aspects of Trump's speech were criticized?
    Why do some view political figures as cult-like?
    What concerns were raised about President Biden's leadership?
    What is emphasized as important in political discourse?

    Podcast Summary

    • DNC vs RNCThe DNC was seen as more organized, disciplined, and unifying than the RNC, while Trump's speech was criticized for its rambling and lack of substance.

      The Democratic National Convention (DNC) was seen as more organized, disciplined, and unifying compared to the Republican National Convention (RNC) and President Trump's speech. The DNC's operation was praised for its focus and cohesiveness, while Trump's speech was criticized for its rambling and undisciplined nature. The RNC may have achieved their goal of not scaring away voters, but the lack of a unifying message and the absence of a charismatic figure like Barack Obama left many feeling underwhelmed. Trump's speech, which was the longest in history, was described as disjointed and lacking substance, with the first 20 minutes being compared to a retired person reading a story to children and the remaining time filled with personal anecdotes and recognitions. Despite the criticisms, some argued that Trump did not come across as authoritarian or threatening, which could be a positive for his campaign. Overall, the DNC was seen as more successful in delivering a unified message and a sense of unity, while the RNC and Trump's speech left many feeling uncertain and underwhelmed.

    • Trump's unconventional speechTrump's unscripted and lengthy speech included controversial and off-topic remarks, causing concerns over the party's shift away from conservatism, but his base remains strong and the party is embracing his unconventional approach.

      Donald Trump's nomination acceptance speech at the Republican National Convention was characterized by his desire to be the one speaking, despite appearing bored during other speeches. The convention aimed for a happier and more upbeat tone, but Trump's unscripted and lengthy speech included controversial and off-topic remarks. The speakers discussed their concerns about the party's shift away from conservatism as a set of values, with Trump's actions and policies seemingly disregarding traditional Republican principles. Despite these concerns, Trump's base remains strong, and the party appears to be embracing his unconventional approach. The conversation ended with a sense of disbelief and sadness over the current state of American politics and the Republican Party.

    • RNC shooting impactThe RNC shooting incident had a significant impact on the news cycle but its staying power was limited, leaving some to wonder about its effect on Trump and the political climate.

      The shooting incident at the RNC had a significant impact on the news cycle but its staying power seems to be limited. The speaker expresses her surprise that the news quickly moved on to the next story after the RNC, leaving the shooting incident in the background. She also shares her views on gun control and the unusual moments during the convention, including Savannah Chrisley's appearance. However, she believes that the incident may have had a profound effect on Donald Trump, transforming him from a political figure to the leader of a nation. Despite her sadness over the state of liberalism and the current political climate, she remains hopeful and focused on taking it back.

    • Political legitimacy and shifting viewsThe presidency doesn't grant inherent legitimacy, and some political figures like Trump gain cult-like followings through charisma and connection to base, reflecting changing political landscape.

      The presidency, while holding great power, does not inherently confer legitimacy. Some political figures, like Tucker Carlson, have shifted their views on Donald Trump from demonic force to divine figure, appealing to a cult-like following within the Republican Party. This shift, while concerning to some, is a reflection of the changing political landscape and the increasing acceptance of unconventional political figures. The appeal of such figures, whether seen as demonic or divine, lies in their charisma and ability to connect with their base. However, it's important to note that not all political figures or supporters fit into this category, and the nuances of political beliefs and motivations are complex and multifaceted.

    • Political landscape concernsSome individuals express frustration with current political figures and parties, with concerns over disinformation and leadership, while others maintain objectivity. The speaker advocated for change in leadership, specifically regarding President Biden, emphasizing the importance of clear vision and honesty.

      There are conflicting perspectives on the current political landscape, with some expressing frustration towards the actions of political figures and parties, while others maintain a more objective view. During a discussion, the speaker expressed concern over the advocacy for disinformation and the perceived need for change in leadership, specifically regarding President Joe Biden. They emphasized that Biden's continued presence in office is hurting the country and the Democratic Party, and called for a clear succession plan. Additionally, the speaker addressed criticisms of their perspective, acknowledging their past political affiliations but emphasizing the importance of clear vision and honesty in political discourse. Overall, the conversation highlighted the complexity and nuance of political opinions and the importance of open and respectful dialogue.

    • Democratic Party's internal conflictThe Democratic Party is facing an internal conflict over whether Joe Biden should step down and be replaced on the ticket, with some advocating for an open convention and others urging unity around Biden. The stakes are high, and the challenge is to minimize internal strife and maximize chances of success in the election.

      Despite some progressive voices calling for an open convention or even Joe Biden's resignation, the consensus among many Democrats, including those close to the Biden campaign, is that the best way forward is for Biden to step down and be replaced on the ticket by someone like Kamala Harris. This view is held due to the dangerous stakes of the situation and the need to unify the party quickly and effectively. AOC's stance, which seems to be encouraging the idea of an open convention, is seen as confusing and potentially divisive by some Democrats. The challenge for the party is to navigate these conflicting viewpoints and come to a decision that minimizes internal strife and maximizes the chances of success in the upcoming election.

    • Democratic Party preparation for Harris presidencyThe Democratic Party should have better prepared voters for a potential Kamala Harris presidency and consider a unified ticket to avoid internal criticism and external attacks. Harris's selection as VP helped win moderate and independent voters, but her lack of presidential experience is a vulnerability, and the party may want to consider experienced leaders for future nominations.

      The Democratic Party could have better prepared voters for a potential Kamala Harris presidency and should consider a unified ticket instead of an open process to avoid internal criticism and external attacks. Harris's selection as vice president was a significant factor in winning over moderate and independent voters, and she has shown the ability to handle debates and interviews effectively. However, her lack of experience as a president could be a vulnerability, and the party may want to consider candidates with a proven track record of leadership and strong communication skills, such as Chris Murphy or Mark Kelly, to mitigate potential challenges. Authenticity and unity are key in politics, and the Democratic Party should focus on presenting a unified front to the public.

    • Biden's determination to stay in the raceGuest Harris Gore believes Biden is the best candidate to beat Trump, despite campaign challenges, and encourages listeners to take a break from the chaos

      Despite recent challenges, Joe Biden is determined to stay in the presidential race and is considered the best candidate to take on Donald Trump. Harris Gore, a guest on the podcast, expressed his confidence in Biden's ability to win, despite the tough weeks the campaign has faced. Gore emphasized the importance of reassuring people and urged listeners to take a break from the political chaos and enjoy their weekends. The podcast also mentioned that Bill Crystal would be a guest on the following episode, unless Biden drops out of the race. The podcast is produced by Katie Cooper with audio engineering and editing by Jason Brown.

    Recent Episodes from The Bulwark Podcast

    Neera Tanden and Heidi Heitkamp: Trump Playing the Media, Again

    Neera Tanden and Heidi Heitkamp: Trump Playing the Media, Again
    The media still haven't figured out how to cover Trump, so they don't scrutinize even his most shocking statements—like when he claimed he had the right to interfere in the '20 election. Plus, Kamala's strong Indian mom, the Dems' improved response to sexist and racist attacks, winning rural voters, Mark Robinson's porn habits, and how it looks in Trump country. 

    Neera Tanden and Sen. Heidi Heitkamp join Tim Miller.

    show notes:

    Heitkamp's One Country Project
    Heitkamp's "Hot Dish" podcast

    The Bulwark Podcast
    en-usSeptember 04, 2024

    Brian Schatz and Mona Charen: Democrats Don't Trust Happiness

    Brian Schatz and Mona Charen: Democrats Don't Trust Happiness
    Kamala is showing that she's good at politics by uniting the party's coalition and making appeals to the center. But many Democrats can't help themselves and are just waiting for all hell to break loose. Plus, building affordable homes, conserving the republic vs. preserving conservative policies—and Walz, the everyman. Sen. Brian Schatz and Mona Charen join Tim Miller.

    show notes:

    Mona's piece, "What Are We Conserving?"
    Pat Toomey on CNBC today
    The Bulwark Podcast
    en-usSeptember 03, 2024

    Bill Kristol: Stay on Offense

    Bill Kristol: Stay on Offense
    Kamala looks to have a very narrow lead in the polls, but she needs to do more to drive Trump down—a good target would be his announcement that he's voting against protecting abortion rights in Florida. Plus, his sudden concern for Pence and Vance's copious podcast blathering. 

    Bill Kristol joins Tim Miller for a special Labor Day pod. 

    show notes:

    USA Today piece about Will Selber
    Hersh Goldberg-Polin's childhood bedroom with art about Jerusalem 

    The Bulwark Podcast
    en-usSeptember 02, 2024

    Margaret Hoover: Kamala, the Real Apprentice

    Margaret Hoover: Kamala, the Real Apprentice
    Harris has been watching and learning about the ways of Washington, and she keeps sticking the landing like a gymnast. Meanwhile, Trump is desperately trying to unring the bell on abortion. Plus, what is his plan to delegitimize the election this time? PBS' Margaret Hoover joins Tim Miller for the holiday weekend pod.

    show notes:

    Margaret's Firing Line special, "Counting the Vote" on your local PBS station
    Margaret's Firing Line documentary on YouTube
    Tim's playlist
    John Avlon's congressional campaign website
    The Bulwark Podcast
    en-usAugust 30, 2024

    Adam Kinzinger: Trump Is Q

    Adam Kinzinger: Trump Is Q
    Policy differences pale in comparison to maintaining self-governance and restoring sanity in the country—high time for the anti-Trumpers to endorse the candidate who's not posting crap like a 17-year-old in his parents' basement. Plus, the Arlington incident, jealous Megyn Kelly, and why Russia is freaking out about the Telegram-related arrest. Adam Kinzinger joins Tim Miller.

    show notes:

    Will Selber on the Arlington episode and Section 60
    Tickets for The Bulwark LIVE next week in Dallas
    The Bulwark Podcast
    en-usAugust 29, 2024

    D.L. Hughley: Kamala Is the Main Character

    D.L. Hughley: Kamala Is the Main Character
    The pundit class keeps talking about how Trump hasn't figured out how to respond to Kamala—but she already knows how to deal with him. And the man who's used to controlling the narrative finds himself on the sidelines. Plus, maximizing the efficiency of Kamala's digital campaign over the next 10 weeks. 

    D.L. Hughley and Teddy Goff join Tim Miller.

    show notes:

    D.L.'s radio show, streaming
    D.L.'s radio show, terrestrial options

    The Bulwark Podcast
    en-usAugust 28, 2024

    Mark Leibovich: The Democrats' Rumor Mill

    Mark Leibovich: The Democrats' Rumor Mill
    Rumors have surfaced about Joe feeling sad and resentful about the re-energized party. At the same time, Kamala seems happy to share the limelight with party stars, like Pete Buttigieg. And over at Mar-a-Lago land, the flat-footed Trump campaign still doesn't know how to respond to the change in the Dem ticket. Plus, the mysterious and sketchy way Trump is allocating campaign contributions. Mark Leibovich and Juleanna Glover join Tim Miller.

    show notes:

    Mark's piece on the Buttigieg Bubble
    Elaina Plott Calabro's piece on Kash Patel
    Juleanna's essay for The New York Times on Trump's expenditures
    The "YIMBYs for Harris" event Tim is part of
    The Apple playlist link for Bulwark Pod music
    Tim's Spotify list
    The Bulwark Podcast
    en-usAugust 27, 2024

    Bill Kristol: Do Something

    Bill Kristol: Do Something
    Some of the people best suited to make the case against Trump are the jilted Cabinet members and others who worked with him—doing the right thing is never the wrong thing. Plus, McMaster's preposterous spin, appreciating the words Kamala didn't say in her speech, making Trump own RFK, Jr.'s antivax views, and the gamesmanship over the debates. Bill Kristol joins Tim Miller.

    show notes:

    Adam Kinzinger on speaking at the Democratic convention
    Tim on the big fish anti-Trumpers who should endorse Kamala already
    Bill on the key line in Kamala's speech
    The Bulwark Podcast
    en-usAugust 26, 2024

    A.B. Stoddard: Only in America

    A.B. Stoddard: Only in America
    Kamala delivered a real work of art—a perfect American story filled with love of country, democracy, family, and the pursuit of big dreams. She also spoke to the center of the electorate, and conveyed a strength to take on the bullies and protect the nation, all with a feminine touch. Meanwhile, the sitting black VP has positioned herself as the challenger against an incumbent Trump, infuriating him in the process. A.B. Stoddard joins Tim Miller for the weekend pod.

    show notes:

    Elaina Plott Calabro interview about Kamala that Tim referenced
    Tim's playlist
    The Bulwark Podcast
    en-usAugust 23, 2024