Logo

    Sam Stein: Violence Is Not the Answer

    en-usJuly 14, 2024
    What was the motive behind the shooting at the Trump rally?
    How did the public initially react to the shooting?
    What historical event is compared to the recent shooting?
    How are Democrats addressing the issue of gun control?
    What must both political parties do to reduce tensions?

    Podcast Summary

    • Political ViolenceA shooting at a Trump rally left one person dead and two others critically injured, leading to shock, anger, and frustration over the potential motivations and lack of security measures, and highlighting the dangers and divisiveness in politics

      The shooting at a Trump rally in Pennsylvania last week was a shocking and violent event that left one person dead and two others critically injured. The alleged shooter, Thomas Matthew Crook, is a 20-year-old with a history of making small political donations to various parties. The FBI is investigating the incident as an assassination attempt on Trump's life. The initial reaction to the news was one of shock and disbelief, followed by anger and frustration over the potential motivations behind the shooting and the lack of security measures in place. The incident has added to the increasing political tensions and violence in the United States, with many expressing anger towards the young man responsible and frustration with the political climate that has allowed such events to occur. The shooting also brought back memories of the 1968 Democratic National Convention, which was marked by similar acts of political violence. Overall, the shooting was a reminder of the dangers and divisiveness that can arise in politics, and the need for greater understanding and cooperation between different political factions.

    • Political ViolenceDuring the Trump era, the climate of anger and violent rhetoric led to multiple instances of political violence or threats against public figures. Normalization of this trend is dangerous and requires adults to take responsibility for deescalation.

      During the discussed time period, there have been multiple instances of political violence or threats against public figures, including Speaker Pelosi, Kavanaugh, Whitmer, and Giffords. The climate of anger and violent rhetoric, particularly during the Trump era, has contributed to this trend. Despite opportunities for leaders and critics to deescalate the situation, they have often missed these chances. The climate of violence and incitement has become more normalized, and fewer voices have spoken out against it. The Trump era saw a unique capitalization on this trend, creating a model for others to follow. The current climate is objectively not great, and it's essential for adults to take responsibility and work towards deescalation. The temperature of political discourse has significantly increased, and it's crucial to recognize the potential consequences of this trend.

    • Political UnityPolitical leaders should promote unity and understanding, urging caution and precision in actions and words during this precarious moment in our democracy.

      In the aftermath of the storming of the Capitol, it's essential for political leaders to promote unity and understanding, rather than contempt and disregard for one another. Randy Kent, a Democratic representative from New Jersey, gave a thoughtful and introspective statement, urging Americans to remember the commonality we share as one country with one destiny. He emphasized the need for caution and precision in our actions and words during this precarious moment in our democracy. Andy Kim, another politician, also emphasized the importance of finding our better angels and figuring out how to talk about divisive issues in a way that does not exacerbate anger and rage towards the other side. Ultimately, it's up to political leaders and the media to set an example and promote unity, rather than adding to the divisiveness and contempt that has been growing in our society.

    • Portraying Trump as a threat to democracyDemocrats and media figures must express disagreement with Trump's actions without fueling radicalization, while acknowledging potential consequences of their words. Republicans can emphasize commitment to working together to reduce tensions.

      Democrats and media figures grappling with portraying Donald Trump as a threat to democracy must find a way to express their disagreement without fueling radicalization. They believe Trump's actions, such as inciting the Capitol attack, warrant such concern. However, they face criticism from Republicans who argue that such rhetoric is unwarranted and dangerous. To move forward, Democrats must find a way to present their stance in a grown-up, problem-solving manner, while acknowledging the potential consequences of their words. Republicans, in turn, can offer contrast by emphasizing their commitment to working together and reducing tensions. Ultimately, both sides must strive to de-escalate the heated political climate and focus on finding common ground.

    • US Presidential Election 2020 Political ClimateThe political climate leading up to the 2020 US Presidential election is expected to remain heated, with outside events and calls for unity unlikely to calm the situation, and concerns over Trump's actions and rhetoric persist.

      The political rhetoric leading up to the 2020 US Presidential election is expected to remain heated, with both parties unlikely to dial down the temperature. The speaker expresses concern that the upcoming Republican convention may even escalate the situation further. The old norms of bipartisanship and unity seem to have faded, and the speaker doubts that outside events or calls for unity from leaders will be effective in calming the situation. Trump's actions and rhetoric have been cited as a significant concern, and the speaker believes that Biden's capacities as a candidate and president may not be enough to tone down the political climate before the election. The overall sentiment is one of worry and pessimism regarding the state of American politics.

    • Political Climate 2020The 2020 US presidential elections are taking place in a highly charged and volatile political climate, with an enthusiasm gap between the two parties potentially impacting the outcome.

      The political climate in the United States leading up to the 2020 presidential elections is highly charged and volatile, with both parties showing intense enthusiasm and uncertainty. The attempted assassination of a former president has added to the tension, and the potential for further violence cannot be ignored. The polling data suggests a static race between Trump and Biden, but the enthusiasm gap between the two parties could be a significant factor in the outcome. For those considering a career in public service, the current environment may seem daunting and unappealing. It's important to remember that the elections are not the only aspect of our society that matters, and we should remain vigilant and thoughtful in these uncertain times. The enthusiasm gap is a known issue, with Democrats currently showing historically low levels of confidence in their candidate, while Republicans are rallying behind Trump. The aftermath of the attempted assassination may further exacerbate this divide. While it's too early to predict the outcome of the elections, it's clear that the political climate is unlike anything we've seen in recent history.

    • Democratic Party infightingThe Democratic National Convention could lead to renewed infighting over Joe Biden's ability to win the election, requiring the party to balance messaging about the importance of the election with concerns for policy proposals in red states and unity

      The upcoming Democratic National Convention could lead to renewed uncertainty and infighting within the Democratic Party regarding Joe Biden's ability to win the election. The conversation around Biden's performance has been polarized, and there are persistent issues within the party that won't go away. The more interesting question is how the Democrats will respond to this situation. They may need to find a way to message that the election remains important and passionate, while also demonstrating concern for policy proposals in red states and uniting the country. The Republicans, on the other hand, are expected to rally around Trump and potentially stoke more tension. It's an unprecedented time, and the outcome of the convention remains uncertain.

    • Democrats gun control messagingDemocrats should focus on empathy and compassionate messaging, but also address larger questions about discourse and politics, and consider limiting access to assault rifles for young adults as a potential winning message.

      The Democrats face a complex challenge in responding to recent political events, particularly regarding gun control and rhetoric. While focusing on empathy and compassionate messaging is important, it may not be enough to sway voters or overshadow the divisive discourse. The consensus issue of gun control, specifically limiting access to assault rifles for young adults, is a potential winning message. However, it should not be the sole focus, as larger questions about discourse and politics also need to be addressed. The Democrats have attempted to include gun control measures in their bills, but the urgency and complexity of the situation call for more substantial action.

    • Political Climate, ViolenceThe assassination attempt on Trump and the rise of mass shootings underscore the complex and dangerous political climate in the US, with Democrats focusing on gun control as a potential solution.

      The recent assassination attempt on former President Trump's life serves as a stark reminder of the dangerous and unpredictable political climate in the United States. The discussion also highlighted how mass shootings and violence are complex issues, and Democrats are focusing on gun control as a solution. Additionally, the luck factor surrounding Trump's political success and survival is a topic of debate, with some arguing that his fortune is both fortunate and unfortunate for the country. Overall, the conversation emphasized the importance of acknowledging the gravity of these events and the potential consequences of violence and political instability.

    • Challenging TimesThe podcast explores uncertain and potentially challenging times, with young people expressing concerns and a call to action to address the issues

      We're facing uncertain and potentially challenging times, as hinted by the lyrics from the song "Stop Here" and the opening comments from the podcast hosts. The exact nature of these challenges isn't clear, but it seems that there's a sense of unease and resistance to change. The young people are expressing their concerns, and there's a call to action to address the issues at hand. The podcast will continue to explore these topics throughout the week, with guests like Bill Crystal joining the conversation. The production of the podcast is handled by Katie Cooper and Jason Brown.

    Recent Episodes from The Bulwark Podcast

    Neera Tanden and Heidi Heitkamp: Trump Playing the Media, Again

    Neera Tanden and Heidi Heitkamp: Trump Playing the Media, Again
    The media still haven't figured out how to cover Trump, so they don't scrutinize even his most shocking statements—like when he claimed he had the right to interfere in the '20 election. Plus, Kamala's strong Indian mom, the Dems' improved response to sexist and racist attacks, winning rural voters, Mark Robinson's porn habits, and how it looks in Trump country. 

    Neera Tanden and Sen. Heidi Heitkamp join Tim Miller.

    show notes:

    Heitkamp's One Country Project
    Heitkamp's "Hot Dish" podcast

    The Bulwark Podcast
    en-usSeptember 04, 2024

    Brian Schatz and Mona Charen: Democrats Don't Trust Happiness

    Brian Schatz and Mona Charen: Democrats Don't Trust Happiness
    Kamala is showing that she's good at politics by uniting the party's coalition and making appeals to the center. But many Democrats can't help themselves and are just waiting for all hell to break loose. Plus, building affordable homes, conserving the republic vs. preserving conservative policies—and Walz, the everyman. Sen. Brian Schatz and Mona Charen join Tim Miller.

    show notes:

    Mona's piece, "What Are We Conserving?"
    Pat Toomey on CNBC today
    The Bulwark Podcast
    en-usSeptember 03, 2024

    Bill Kristol: Stay on Offense

    Bill Kristol: Stay on Offense
    Kamala looks to have a very narrow lead in the polls, but she needs to do more to drive Trump down—a good target would be his announcement that he's voting against protecting abortion rights in Florida. Plus, his sudden concern for Pence and Vance's copious podcast blathering. 

    Bill Kristol joins Tim Miller for a special Labor Day pod. 

    show notes:

    USA Today piece about Will Selber
    Hersh Goldberg-Polin's childhood bedroom with art about Jerusalem 

    The Bulwark Podcast
    en-usSeptember 02, 2024

    Margaret Hoover: Kamala, the Real Apprentice

    Margaret Hoover: Kamala, the Real Apprentice
    Harris has been watching and learning about the ways of Washington, and she keeps sticking the landing like a gymnast. Meanwhile, Trump is desperately trying to unring the bell on abortion. Plus, what is his plan to delegitimize the election this time? PBS' Margaret Hoover joins Tim Miller for the holiday weekend pod.

    show notes:

    Margaret's Firing Line special, "Counting the Vote" on your local PBS station
    Margaret's Firing Line documentary on YouTube
    Tim's playlist
    John Avlon's congressional campaign website
    The Bulwark Podcast
    en-usAugust 30, 2024

    Adam Kinzinger: Trump Is Q

    Adam Kinzinger: Trump Is Q
    Policy differences pale in comparison to maintaining self-governance and restoring sanity in the country—high time for the anti-Trumpers to endorse the candidate who's not posting crap like a 17-year-old in his parents' basement. Plus, the Arlington incident, jealous Megyn Kelly, and why Russia is freaking out about the Telegram-related arrest. Adam Kinzinger joins Tim Miller.

    show notes:

    Will Selber on the Arlington episode and Section 60
    Tickets for The Bulwark LIVE next week in Dallas
    The Bulwark Podcast
    en-usAugust 29, 2024

    D.L. Hughley: Kamala Is the Main Character

    D.L. Hughley: Kamala Is the Main Character
    The pundit class keeps talking about how Trump hasn't figured out how to respond to Kamala—but she already knows how to deal with him. And the man who's used to controlling the narrative finds himself on the sidelines. Plus, maximizing the efficiency of Kamala's digital campaign over the next 10 weeks. 

    D.L. Hughley and Teddy Goff join Tim Miller.

    show notes:

    D.L.'s radio show, streaming
    D.L.'s radio show, terrestrial options

    The Bulwark Podcast
    en-usAugust 28, 2024

    Mark Leibovich: The Democrats' Rumor Mill

    Mark Leibovich: The Democrats' Rumor Mill
    Rumors have surfaced about Joe feeling sad and resentful about the re-energized party. At the same time, Kamala seems happy to share the limelight with party stars, like Pete Buttigieg. And over at Mar-a-Lago land, the flat-footed Trump campaign still doesn't know how to respond to the change in the Dem ticket. Plus, the mysterious and sketchy way Trump is allocating campaign contributions. Mark Leibovich and Juleanna Glover join Tim Miller.

    show notes:

    Mark's piece on the Buttigieg Bubble
    Elaina Plott Calabro's piece on Kash Patel
    Juleanna's essay for The New York Times on Trump's expenditures
    The "YIMBYs for Harris" event Tim is part of
    The Apple playlist link for Bulwark Pod music
    Tim's Spotify list
    The Bulwark Podcast
    en-usAugust 27, 2024

    Bill Kristol: Do Something

    Bill Kristol: Do Something
    Some of the people best suited to make the case against Trump are the jilted Cabinet members and others who worked with him—doing the right thing is never the wrong thing. Plus, McMaster's preposterous spin, appreciating the words Kamala didn't say in her speech, making Trump own RFK, Jr.'s antivax views, and the gamesmanship over the debates. Bill Kristol joins Tim Miller.

    show notes:

    Adam Kinzinger on speaking at the Democratic convention
    Tim on the big fish anti-Trumpers who should endorse Kamala already
    Bill on the key line in Kamala's speech
    The Bulwark Podcast
    en-usAugust 26, 2024

    A.B. Stoddard: Only in America

    A.B. Stoddard: Only in America
    Kamala delivered a real work of art—a perfect American story filled with love of country, democracy, family, and the pursuit of big dreams. She also spoke to the center of the electorate, and conveyed a strength to take on the bullies and protect the nation, all with a feminine touch. Meanwhile, the sitting black VP has positioned herself as the challenger against an incumbent Trump, infuriating him in the process. A.B. Stoddard joins Tim Miller for the weekend pod.

    show notes:

    Elaina Plott Calabro interview about Kamala that Tim referenced
    Tim's playlist
    The Bulwark Podcast
    en-usAugust 23, 2024