Logo
    Search

    Selects: How Police Lineups Work

    enJuly 15, 2023

    Podcast Summary

    • Exploring Everyday Expenses and Premium Travel BenefitsCapital One Venture X Card offers unlimited 2X miles on purchases, airport lounge access, and a $300 annual travel credit, while Kroger ensures customer satisfaction with their products or a refund, and Ridiculous History podcast delves into overlooked, bizarre historical moments.

      The Capital One Venture X Card offers unlimited 2X miles on every purchase, providing an opportunity to turn everyday expenses into travel rewards. Additionally, cardholders can enjoy premium travel benefits such as airport lounge access and a $300 annual credit for bookings through Capital One Travel. Elsewhere, Kroger guarantees customer satisfaction with their brand products, offering proven quality at affordable prices, or a refund. In the world of podcasts, Ben and Noel, hosts of Mini Crush, Movie Crush, have come together to explore the bizarre and often unbelievable moments in history that are usually overlooked. Their show, Ridiculous History, brings to light the cartoonish and extraordinary events throughout human civilization, providing a fun and entertaining listening experience.

    • Exploring the absurd side of historyThe Ridiculous History podcast delves into the funny, serious, and ridiculous aspects of history, inviting listeners to join the hosts on their journey of discovery.

      The Ridiculous History podcast covers a wide range of historical topics, some of which are funny, some serious, and some downright ridiculous. From Napoleon Bonaparte being attacked by bunnies to racist special Olympics and STD labor camps, the show explores the absurd side of history. You can find the podcast on various platforms including their website, Apple Podcast, and Spotify. They also have a community page on Facebook called Ridiculous Historians. Despite the sometimes challenging topics, the hosts are passionate about sharing these stories and invite listeners to join them on their journey through history. So, whether you're looking for a good laugh or to learn something new, tune in to Ridiculous History.

    • The Imperfect System of Police LineupsDespite efforts to refine police lineups, human memory remains an inherent limitation, emphasizing the importance of continuous improvement.

      Police lineups, while a common investigative tool, are an imperfect system. The discussion highlights the case of Jerry Miller, who was wrongfully convicted based on flawed eyewitness testimony in a police lineup. This incident underscores the fallibility of human memory and the importance of continuously striving to improve the process. Brittany Schiff's suggestion to explore police lineups led to this episode, emphasizing the value of listener input. The NIJ Journal article by Beth Shuster, which was also mentioned, sheds light on the efforts to minimize wrongful convictions. Overall, this episode serves as a reminder that while we can refine police lineups, human memory remains an inherent limitation.

    • Limitations of human memory in identifying suspectsEyewitness testimony is unreliable during high-stress situations and can lead to incorrect identifications, making it a challenge for criminal investigations.

      Eyewitness testimony is an imperfect method for identifying individuals, especially during high-stress situations. Our brains are not designed to record and recall detailed information under normal circumstances, let alone during traumatic events. In the story shared, the speaker's attempt to identify the perpetrators of a hit-and-run failed despite their best intentions to remember important details. The inability to identify the suspects led to their release, even though they were caught with the damaged car. This incident highlights the limitations of human memory and the challenges in relying solely on eyewitness testimony for criminal investigations.

    • Flaws in the use of eyewitness testimony and police lineups75% of first 183 DNA exonerations in US due to eyewitness testimony error, complex and easily contaminated, reliability impacted by racial differences, improving system crucial to reduce wrongful convictions.

      The use of eyewitness testimony and police lineups in criminal investigations is a flawed system with significant room for error. The wrongful conviction of innocent individuals based on eyewitness testimony is a major concern, as demonstrated by the fact that 75% of the first 183 DNA exonerations in the US were due to this type of evidence. Eyewitness testimony is complex and difficult to handle, as it can be easily contaminated and memories can be influenced by various factors, including the presence of weapons or stressful situations. Additionally, the reliability of eyewitness testimony can be impacted by racial or ethnic differences. It's crucial that efforts continue to be made to improve this system and reduce the number of wrongful convictions.

    • Exploring Alternatives: Jackfruit, Zigazoo, LinkedIn Jobs, and BettermentDiscover jackfruit as a versatile vegan alternative, engage kids safely on Zigazoo, streamline hiring with LinkedIn Jobs, and grow your savings with Betterment

      Jackfruit is a large fruit with a versatile use, often serving as a vegan barbeque alternative or shredded pork substitute. Meanwhile, Zigazoo is a safe and fun social media platform for kids, allowing them to create content, interact with friends, and try out trends without commenting or text messaging. For small businesses, LinkedIn Jobs offers free tools to help find qualified candidates from a vast network of professionals, making hiring easier and more efficient. Lastly, Betterment is an automated investing and savings app that helps your money work for you, earning high yields and optimizing investments with tax-efficient strategies. In the realm of police lineups, the sequential method, where individuals are viewed one at a time, is considered more effective than the simultaneous method, which is commonly depicted in movies and TV shows.

    • Impact of Lineup Administration on Witness IdentificationDouble-blind administration, simultaneous presentation, and avoiding leading cues or suggestions can help ensure accurate witness identification in a lineup.

      The administration of a lineup in a criminal investigation can significantly impact the accuracy of witness identification. The ideal method is double-blind, where the administrator does not know the identity of the perpetrator. Another effective technique is the simultaneous presentation of all potential suspects, which can help reduce mistaken identifications. The administrator should also avoid leading the witness through nonverbal cues or verbal suggestions. Additionally, informing the witness that the suspect may or may not be present in the lineup can help reduce the pressure to identify someone and potentially prevent false identifications. Overall, the goal is to create a fair and unbiased lineup process to ensure the most accurate identification possible.

    • Challenging the Common Recommendation of Double-Blind LineupsThe effectiveness of double-blind versus simultaneous lineups for suspect identification remains debated, with concerns over methodology and witness-officer relationships.

      The use of double-blind, sequential lineups for identifying suspects in criminal investigations is a common recommendation based on research. However, a study in Illinois challenged this notion, suggesting that simultaneous, non-double-blind lineups may produce better results. However, the methodology of this study has been questioned, leaving the issue unresolved. The ideal is for witnesses to use absolute judgment when identifying suspects, comparing each person only to their memory, rather than relative judgment where they compare suspects to one another. The Illinois study compared apples to oranges by using different procedures for sequential and simultaneous lineups, potentially skewing the results. Despite the ongoing debate, many officers express concerns that using a blind administrator disrupts the relationship they try to build with witnesses. Ultimately, the best method for conducting lineups remains a topic of ongoing research and debate.

    • Improving criminal investigations and children's social media safetyHaving a dedicated administrator for lineups in criminal investigations can improve accuracy and efficiency. Safe and age-appropriate social media platforms like Zigazoo are essential for children's online safety. Consumers can save on DoorDash delivery fees with Dash Pass.

      Outdated methods in criminal investigations, such as using multiple administrators for lineups, can cause confusion and inefficiency. Instead, having a dedicated administrator for this task could streamline the process and improve accuracy. Another point discussed was the potential issue of placing multiple suspects in the same lineup, which can lead to confusion for the witness. In the realm of technology, the importance of safe and age-appropriate social media platforms for children was emphasized, with Zigazoo being highlighted as an example. Lastly, the affordability and convenience of Dash Pass for DoorDash users was promoted as a way to save on delivery fees. Variety's Entertainment Marketing Summit was also mentioned as an event for entertainment marketers to network and learn from industry leaders. Overall, the discussion touched upon various topics, including criminal investigations, social media, and consumer savings.

    • Using multiple suspects in a lineup increases the chance of errorUsing multiple suspects in a lineup instead of one can lead to incorrect identifications due to the complexity of the process and potential distractions for eyewitnesses.

      Creating lineups with multiple suspects instead of one increases the chances of an incorrect identification. This is because the presence of additional suspects can make it harder for eyewitnesses to focus on the actual suspect, potentially leading to random guesses or mistaken identifications. Additionally, the process of creating lineups can be complex, as it involves ensuring that all individuals in the lineup resemble the perpetrator's description or the suspect's appearance. This can be challenging when dealing with multiple witnesses who provide different descriptions. The field implementation of lineup procedures also varies from lab studies, highlighting the need for collaboration and standardization. Overall, the goal is to minimize the chances of incorrect identifications by ensuring that each lineup consists of one suspect and individuals who closely match the perpetrator's description.

    • Facial hair can influence eyewitness identificationsEyewitness identifications can be influenced by factors like facial hair. If not mentioned, suspects are assumed clean-shaven. Misidentifications can occur when a clean-shaven suspect is surrounded by bearded suspects.

      The accuracy of a lineup identification can be influenced by various factors, including the suspects' facial hair. If an eyewitness doesn't specifically mention the presence or absence of facial hair, it's assumed that the suspects are clean-shaven. However, if a suspect is clean-shaven and surrounded by bearded suspects, they may stand out and be mistakenly identified. Additionally, the process of creating a lineup can be influenced by external factors, such as the perpetrator trying to blend in by wearing hats or other clothing items. For instance, in the case of Robert Weston, a casting agent who helped create lineups for the Bronx police department, he only earned $10 for each lineup and sometimes did as few as zero or as many as four in a day. This shows the importance of considering the context and potential biases when evaluating eyewitness identifications.

    • Creating Lineups for Criminal InvestigationsEnsure fair and representative lineups to prevent misidentifications and maintain justice system integrity.

      Law enforcement agencies often use casting agents or find people on the street to create lineups for investigations due to budget constraints and time limitations. However, the quality of these lineups can vary greatly, and the worst-case scenario is a "show up" where a witness is brought to the scene with a suspect already in custody, leading to potential inaccurate identifications. It's crucial to ensure that lineups are put together with care and that witnesses are presented with a fair and representative selection of individuals to prevent misidentifications and maintain the integrity of the justice system.

    • The fallibility of eyewitness testimonyEyewitness testimony can be unreliable due to memory fades and misidentifications, potentially leading to wrongful convictions. It's important to re-evaluate its weight in court cases and improve identification processes.

      Eyewitness testimony, though it may seem reliable, can be flawed and uncertain. Memories fade and misidentifications can occur, leading to potential wrongful convictions. The discussion highlights the importance of re-evaluating the weight given to eyewitness testimony in court cases. Misidentifications can have devastating consequences, as seen in cases where innocent individuals serve decades in prison for crimes they did not commit. It is crucial to acknowledge these flaws and work towards improving identification processes to prevent such miscarriages of justice.

    • Exploring Different Ways to Connect and EngageFind platforms and communities that suit your needs and make you feel valued, such as iHeartRadio, Zigazoo, or industry events.

      There are various ways to connect and engage with different platforms and communities. For instance, to connect with Stuff You Should Know, you can visit their website, social media channels, or send an email. Stuff You Should Know is a production of iHeartRadio, and you can find more podcasts on the iHeartRadio app or Apple Podcasts. Sarah, from the discussion, seems to enjoy using Zigazoo, a social media network for kids, where all community members are verified kids, and all content is fully human moderated. For entertainment marketers, Variety's annual Entertainment Marketing Summit is an excellent opportunity to network and learn from industry leaders. Discover card offers 24-7 live customer service and $0 fraud liability to make everyone feel special and valued. Additionally, there are events like Variety's Entertainment Marketing Summit that provide excellent networking opportunities and chances to learn from industry leaders. Overall, it's essential to find the right platforms and communities that suit your needs and make you feel valued.

    Recent Episodes from Stuff You Should Know

    How Dopamine Works

    How Dopamine Works

    Dopamine is perhaps the most talked-about, most misunderstood biochemical in our bodies. It’s linked to not only addiction and depravity, but also focus, motivation, and living a productive life. How can one molecule be so many things to so many people?

    See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

    Stuff You Should Know
    enJuly 02, 2024

    Selects: How Restaurant Health Inspections Work

    Selects: How Restaurant Health Inspections Work

    If you've ever worked in a restaurant, you know the feeling that occurs when the health inspector pays a visit. While nerve wracking, it's the best insurance patrons have that their food will be prepared and served in a proper environment. Learn all about how these inspections work, from their past history to current incarnation, in this classic episode.

    See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

    Stuff You Should Know
    enJune 29, 2024

    Whistling!

    Whistling!

    Whistling is pretty cool when you think about it because it can mean many things, from simple happy tunes to legit communication. Learn all about this ubiquitous skill today. 

    See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

    Stuff You Should Know
    enJune 25, 2024

    The Big Episode on Wikipedia

    The Big Episode on Wikipedia

    Wikipedia changed the world. Before it came along, you had to go to the library to get the answers you sought. And you and your friends had to just agree to disagree on facts. And as the internet grew and commercialized, Wikipedia remains free and open.

    See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

    Stuff You Should Know
    enJune 20, 2024

    Related Episodes

    Susie: Women Hunted-The Progression of Robert Hansen

    Susie: Women Hunted-The Progression of Robert Hansen

    Robert Hansen is known for hunting his victims in the Alaskan wilderness by plane. The truth is that Bob experimented with trying to get women to satisfy his perverse desire. Episode one: Susie gives a snapshot of the first court-recorded offense against a woman.

    Visit our Website https://truecrime49.libsyn.com/

    Purchase Merch at TC49 Podcast Etsy

    Find us on Kindle Vella

    Listen to our Patreon only Podcasts, Inches in Mercury; an Alaskan Aviation podcast, and AIH Calendar Girls, a podcast about the women in Joe Boehm's Alaska Industrial Hardware calendars. 

     

    M U S I C   C R E D I T 
    Constant_Fear ~ Horror Music by Alleviative Musical World
    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1EcZMauVAnI

    Hidden_Secret_Hacked by Alleviative Musical World
    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=d4ObCfISwc0

    VIllage Ambiance by Alexander Nakarada | https://www.serpentsoundstudios.com
    Music promoted by https://www.free-stock-music.com
    Attribution 4.0 International (CC BY 4.0)

    The hidden village (music for drama) by Daniel Lederman. 2018.
    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tObJ7fIHUUw

    Dar Golan 70's music

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tQfi5MHbH3Q

    Office Sounds Ambience (Background Sound Effect) SoundEffectsFactory
    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pNhxg4dOlig

     

    S O U R C E S 

    The Butcher Baker (book) by Leland Hale

    Fair Game By Bernard DuClos


    https://www.distractify.com/p/robert-hansen-kids


    CrimeLibrary.com
    https://allthatsinteresting.com/robert-hansen

    December 10, 1990 | Anchorage Daily News (AK)
    Author: SHEILA TOOMEY Daily News Reporter Staff

    https://medium.com/the-true-crime-edition/the-butcher-baker-of-alaska-f353effd754


    https://madisontramel.medium.com/eklutna-annie-horseshoe-harriet-and-the-story-of-robert-hansen-467da472e7ef

     

     

    Copyright Disclaimer under section 107 of the Copyright Act of 1976, allowance is made for “fair use” for purposes such as criticism, comment, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, education, and research.

    PLEASE NOTE: ALL NAMES, TRADEMARKS, AND IMAGES ARE COPYRIGHT THEIR RESPECTIVE OWNERS. AFFILIATE LINKS USED WHENEVER AVAILABLE

    The views and opinions expressed in this article are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the official policy or position of True Crime 49.

    Episode 129: One Year Out from Election Day 2024

    Episode 129: One Year Out from Election Day 2024

    One year out from the 2024 election, Lindsay Langholz checks in with Jessica Huseman from VoteBeat about the election issues that are consuming her attention and could shape the 2024 election space, including the growing obsession with hand counting ballots and the odd steps certain states are taking to "update" their voter registration lists.  

    Join the Progressive Legal Movement Today: ACSLaw.org

    Today's Host: Lindsay Langholz , ACS Sr Director of Policy and Program

    Guest: Jessica Huseman, Editorial Director, VoteBeat

    Link: "The drive to hand count ballots is growing. The GOP could stop it," by Jessica Huseman

    Link: "Where an Obsession With Election Integrity Can Lead," by Jessica Huseman

    Link: Take the ACS Pledge: Become a Poll Worker

    Visit the Podcast Website: Broken Law Podcast

    Email the Show: Podcast@ACSLaw.org

    Follow ACS on Social Media: Facebook | Instagram | Twitter | LinkedIn | YouTube

    -----------------

    Production House: Flint Stone Media

    Copyright of American Constitution Society 2023.

    -----------------
    Broken Law: About the law, who it serves, and who it doesn’t.
    -----------------

    Production House: Flint Stone Media

    Copyright of American Constitution Society 2024.

    Episode 29: State of Democracy, Part III

    Episode 29: State of Democracy, Part III

    In this final episode of our State of Democracy series, we discuss the importance of a vibrant civil society, which is frequently discussed in foreign policy circles, but less so here at home. Jeanne Hruska speaks with Sarah Holewinski from Human Rights Watch and Jon Temin from Freedom House about what we, as civil society stakeholders, can do to strengthen democracy, and whether our involvement is actually a prerequisite for this task. They also reflect back on President Biden's Summit for Democracy and what needs to happen moving forward to reverse the decline in global freedom.

    -----------------

    Join the Progressive Legal Movement Today: ACSLaw.org

    Today's Host: Jeanne Hruska, ACS Senior Advisor for Communications and Strategy

    Guest: Sarah Holewinski , Washington Director, Human Rights Watch

    Guest: Jon Temin, Director of the Africa Program at Freedom House

    Link: Human Rights Watch

    Link: Freedom House

    Link: The Summit for Democracy, U.S. Department of State

    Link: White House Fact Sheet: Announcing the Presidential Initiative for Democracy Renewal

    Visit the Podcast Website: Broken Law Podcast

    Email the Show: Podcast@ACSLaw.org

    Follow ACS on Social Media: Facebook | Instagram | Twitter | LinkedIn | YouTube

    -----------------

    Production House: Flint Stone Media

    Copyright of American Constitution Society 2021.

    -----------------
    Broken Law: About the law, who it serves, and who it doesn’t.
    -----------------

    Production House: Flint Stone Media

    Copyright of American Constitution Society 2024.

    Episode 51: The Domino Effect of Dobbs

    Episode 51: The Domino Effect of Dobbs

    The leaked draft opinion in Dobbs v. Jackson Women’s Health Organization, if officially released by the Supreme Court, would wipe out the federal constitutional right to abortion and directly impact the lives of millions of people. Already, the conservative legal movement is mobilizing to take advantage of the groundwork being laid in Dobbs to put same-sex marriage, contraception, and even interracial marriage in jeopardy. How wide will the impact of the Dobbs decision be and who will be affected? This week, Lindsay Langholz speaks with Kimberly Mutcherson, Professor and Co-Dean of Rutgers Law School, about the potential domino effect of Dobbs.

    -----------------

    Join the Progressive Legal Movement Today: ACSLaw.org

    Today's Host: Lindsay Langholz, ACS Director of Policy and Programs

    Guest: Kimberly Mutcherson, Co-Dean and Professor of Law, Rutgers Law School

    Guest: "Pregnancy and Childbirth Endanger Women’s Lives and Health: 'Pregnancy Is Not a Benign Condition,'" by Carrie Baker

    Link: "The People Who Promised Roe Was Safe Are Already Selling Their Next Bridge," by Dahlia Lithwick

    Link: "Most Women Denied Abortions by Texas Law Got Them Another Way," by Margot Sanger-Katz, Claire Cain Miller and Quoctrung Bui

    Link: "‘It will be chaos’: 26 states in US will ban abortion if supreme court ruling stands," by Jessica Glenza

    Link: "How the Right to Birth Control Could Be Undone," by Melissa Murray

    Visit the Podcast Website: Broken Law Podcast

    Email the Show: Podcast@ACSLaw.org

    Follow ACS on Social Media: Facebook | Instagram | Twitter | LinkedIn | YouTube

    -----------------

    -----------------
    Broken Law: About the law, who it serves, and who it doesn’t.
    -----------------

    Production House: Flint Stone Media

    Copyright of American Constitution Society 2024.

    Episode 62: Lessons Learned from Elections Abroad

    Episode 62: Lessons Learned from Elections Abroad

    It can be easy to think that the U.S. democratic system is somehow exceptional, a product and an idea to be exported abroad. But the reality is far more complicated. As U.S. democracy faces a moment of truth, there are lessons to be learned from how elections are conducted and secured in other countries. Lindsay Langholz speaks this week with Ann Ravel, former FEC Commissioner, who has served as an election observer and expert in a number of countries. They delve into how other countries prevent voter suppression and ensure more gender and racial representation.

    Join the Progressive Legal Movement Today: ACSLaw.org

    Today's Host: Lindsay Langholz, ACS Director of Policy and Program

    Guest: Ann Ravel, International election observer and Former FEC Commissioner

    Link: ACS Poll Worker Pledge

    Link: "U.S. should be attending, not hosting, a democracy summit" by Ann Ravel and Kevin Frazier

    Link: "The Reform Law Needed to Counter Citizens United: H.R. 1" by Ian Vandewalker and Kevin Morris, Brennan Center

    Visit the Podcast Website: Broken Law Podcast

    Email the Show: Podcast@ACSLaw.org

    Follow ACS on Social Media: Facebook | Instagram | Twitter | LinkedIn | YouTube

    -----------------

    Production House: Flint Stone Media

    Copyright of American Constitution Society 2022.

    -----------------
    Broken Law: About the law, who it serves, and who it doesn’t.
    -----------------

    Production House: Flint Stone Media

    Copyright of American Constitution Society 2024.