Logo
    Search

    Supreme Court Refuses to Exonerate Trump for Jan. 6th

    enMarch 05, 2024

    Podcast Summary

    • Supreme Court Rules Only Congress Can Disqualify a Presidential Candidate for InsurrectionThe Supreme Court determined that only Congress, not states, has the authority to disqualify a presidential candidate for their involvement in insurrection.

      The Supreme Court ruled that only Congress, not individual states, has the power to disqualify a presidential candidate for engaging in insurrection. The ruling came in response to Colorado's attempt to keep Donald Trump off the ballot due to his role in the Capitol riots. The decision was met with differing opinions among the justices, with some arguing that the ruling went too far in limiting the power of states. The ruling comes as the 2024 presidential race heats up, with figures like Nikki Haley and Joe Biden making moves. The California primary is also a major focus, with a big Senate race underway. In other news, the crypto market continues to be a topic of interest.

    • Disqualifying Trump: Political Divisions and Legal UncertaintiesThe Supreme Court's refusal to disqualify Trump from office despite his conviction raises questions about the political will and legal implications of barring a former president from running again.

      The recent discussion revolves around the constitutionality of disqualifying a former president or insurrectionist from holding office. The Congress's inaction on passing a law to bar Donald Trump and his associates from running for office raises questions about their intentions. The Supreme Court, in a recent document, expressed concerns about potential chaos and the implications of a federal court disqualifying a president. Despite Trump's conviction in a federal court for election subversion, the Court declined to absolve him of engaging in insurrection. Trump's recent electoral victories and rhetoric have further fueled debates about his eligibility to run for office. The overall tone of the discussion suggests a deeply divided political landscape and uncertainty regarding the legal implications of disqualifying a president.

    • Trump's divisive rhetoric and stance on vaccine mandates could impact his coalition and appeal to votersTrump's divisive comments towards fellow Republicans and opposition to vaccine mandates may deter independent and moderate voters, and could limit his ability to grow his coalition.

      Trump's divisive rhetoric towards fellow Republicans and his stance against vaccine mandates could potentially harm his coalition and appeal to independent and moderate voters. While Trump's comments received attention, Nikki Haley's victory in the DC primary, despite being in a small and mostly Democratic town, highlights the potential for defections from the Republican Party. Haley's refusal to commit to supporting Trump, despite previously signing the RNC pledge, indicates that some Republicans may not follow suit. Additionally, Trump's stance against vaccine mandates could alienate voters who prioritize public health, potentially leading to more measles outbreaks and other preventable diseases. Overall, these actions could limit Trump's ability to grow his coalition and may deter voters from supporting him in the general election.

    • Nikki Haley's Interview: Careful Approach Towards Trump EndorsementNikki Haley expressed concerns about both Trump and Biden but didn't rule out endorsing Trump, highlighting political complexities and strategic maneuvering in the race for power.

      Nikki Haley's interview on "60 Minutes" showcased her careful approach towards endorsing Donald Trump for the 2024 presidential race. She expressed concerns about both Trump and Joe Biden but did not explicitly rule out endorsing Trump. Her interview contained inconsistencies, such as her previous stance against Trump and her recent statement about lying to get out of debates. Some believe she's trying to bring in voters who are not anti-Trump, while others think she's positioning herself for a potential 2028 run. Her hesitance to fully condemn Trump may be an attempt to avoid alienating the Republican base, despite her criticisms of his unfit leadership. The interview's nuances highlight the complexities of political alliances and the strategic maneuvering that often occurs in the race for power.

    • Democratic advisors believe focus on democracy and Jan 6th events could shift election narrativeDemocratic advisors express skepticism about polling accuracy and believe focus on democracy and Jan 6th events could sway voters in their favor, despite economic improvements and Trump's policy benefits for some demographics.

      While national polls suggest a close race between President Trump and Joe Biden, senior advisors to the Democratic nominee believe that polling may be inaccurate and that the focus on democracy and the events of January 6th could shift the narrative in their favor. Meanwhile, economic indicators show improvements, but Biden's approval ratings on the economy have not kept pace. Additionally, Trump's policies are seen as helping more voters personally across various demographics, contributing to the White House's frustration. The advisors also expressed skepticism about the accuracy of the polls and expressed confidence that the election focus will shift towards democracy and the events of January 6th.

    • Focusing on policy achievements and contrasting with Trump's presidencyTo address concerns about Biden's age and perceived ineffectiveness, the administration should highlight policy successes and contrast them with Trump's tenure. Communicating how policies benefit people's lives and raising awareness of potential Trump dangers can sway undecided voters.

      Addressing concerns about President Biden's age and perceived ineffectiveness can be achieved by focusing on his policy achievements and the contrast between his administration and that of Donald Trump. Many voters have forgotten the negative aspects of the Trump presidency and view his economic policies more favorably than Biden's. To win over voters, the Biden administration needs to increase Biden's popularity and effectively communicate how their policies will improve people's lives. Additionally, raising awareness of the potential dangers of a Trump presidency could help sway undecided voters. Key policy areas that are likely to resonate with voters include opposition to repealing Obamacare, pardoning January 6th insurrectionists, and encouraging Russia to invade NATO allies.

    • 2024 Presidential Race: Biden vs. Trump's MemoryBiden's team is confident voters will return despite Trump's crimes allegations, but they need to clearly communicate their vision and balance democracy and economic messages.

      The 2024 presidential race pits the real and current Joe Biden against the potential and somewhat romanticized memory of Donald Trump. A significant portion of Trump's voter base believes he committed federal crimes, but the Biden team is confident that voters will come back once reminded of the stakes. The CBS poll shows that voters view Biden as having a vision for the country, but Trump is seen as having a dark vision. However, Biden's team needs to clearly communicate their vision and message going forward. The abortion issue is a challenge for Biden, with only 33% of voters blaming Trump for Roe v. Wade being overturned. Biden has identified democracy as the central cause of his presidency, and it's a theme that resonates with him and is also Trump's greatest weakness. However, the Biden team may need to balance their focus on democracy with an economic message to be successful.

    • Effectively Communicating Biden's Domestic Policy AchievementsUnderstanding voter sentiment and crafting a clear, compelling theme are crucial for effectively communicating Biden's domestic policy achievements to voters, despite the age question and changing media environment.

      While President Biden has an impressive record of domestic policy achievements, communicating this to voters effectively is crucial. The age question surrounding Biden's presidency has clouded people's perception of his accomplishments, and it's essential to make the argument about freedom and economic security tangible for voters. The media environment has changed, and all of us have a role in getting the message out. The Biden campaign will invest heavily in their messaging, but individual efforts are also essential. Analyzing polls and understanding voter sentiment can help identify the most effective arguments to persuade voters. The top-line numbers in polls may not be entirely accurate, but the insights they provide about voter attitudes on key issues are valuable. Ultimately, having a clear and compelling theme is essential for Democrats to win elections.

    • Navigating the Challenges of Campaigning in a Broken Media EnvironmentDemocrats in California must carefully consider their choices in November, as supporting a weak Republican candidate could lead to more effort and resources needed to secure a win.

      The current political climate, including a broken media environment and the presence of a right-wing propaganda machine, makes it challenging for presidential campaigns, like the Biden campaign, to effectively reach and inform voters. The competition, including older candidates like Biden, is not just within the campaigns but also due to these external factors. However, it's essential for all of us to do our part in promoting accurate information and understanding the implications of various political strategies. For instance, in the California Senate race, while attacking a Republican opponent like Steve Garvey may boost his name recognition, it could also lead to a shift versus goofy Republican race, requiring more effort and resources to turn out the Democratic vote. Ultimately, it's crucial for Democrats in California to consider their preferred choice in November between two Democrats they truly support or one Democrat and one Republican, as the latter could lead to more hard work to secure a win.

    • California Senate race could impact Senate controlThe California Senate race between Porter and Schiff could boost voter turnout and potentially impact Senate control, while Shift's involvement and new merchandise offer opportunities for engagement and support.

      The California Senate race between Katie Porter and Adam Schiff, while expensive, could potentially benefit Democrats by driving voter turnout. The famous baseball player Shift's involvement in the race may also attract more attention and voters. Some argue that resources could be better spent in other states, but ultimately, the outcome of this race could impact the control of the Senate. Additionally, the upcoming book "Democracy or Else" by Kurka, with profits going to Vote Save America and other organizations, and new t-shirt designs inspired by states with threatened abortion rights, offer opportunities for engagement and support for various causes.

    • Congressman Rokana calls for permanent ceasefire in Gaza, threatens UN actionCongressman Rokana urges a permanent ceasefire, pressures U.S. to protect human rights, and questions Netanyahu's commitment to a six-week truce.

      Congressman Rokana emphasizes the need for a permanent ceasefire in the Gaza conflict, rather than just a six-week one. He suggests the U.S. should pressure both Israel and Hamas to release all hostages and make it clear that the U.S. will no longer protect Israel at the UN if a ceasefire isn't permanent. Rokana expresses doubt that Netanyahu will honor a six-week ceasefire and believes his political survival depends on continuing the conflict. He also mentions that proceeds from a store on kirker.com will go to support abortion rights organizations.

    • US Intervention Needed for Israeli-Palestinian Peace TalksThe US must recognize a Palestinian state, facilitate a summit of key players, and provide an alternative to Hamas' ideology to advance Israeli-Palestinian peace talks. US diplomatic efforts require credibility and effectiveness, achieved through adherence to constitutional processes.

      The ongoing conflict between Israel and Palestine, particularly the negotiations for a two-state solution, have been stalled for years due to various complexities and lack of meaningful US intervention. Hamas' desire for a longer negotiation duration and the US' unwillingness to impose consequences on obstructionist parties have hindered progress. The normalization of relations between Israel and Gulf countries, while beneficial, is not enough to achieve a Palestinian state. To move forward, the US needs to recognize a Palestinian state, facilitate a summit of key players, and provide an alternative to Hamas' ideology of armed resistance. Additionally, the US should adhere to constitutional processes, such as seeking congressional approval for military actions, to maintain credibility and effectiveness in diplomatic efforts.

    • Seeking Congressional authorization for offensive actionsPresidents must involve Congress when considering offensive actions, leading to informed debates and decisions.

      While the president has the right to take defensive actions, the involvement of Congress is crucial when offensive actions are considered. This was exemplified in the case of Thomas Jefferson and the pirates, where Jefferson sought Congress's authorization after defensive actions. The process of coming to Congress for authorization can lead to important debates and informed decision-making. The Obama administration's handling of the Syrian chemical weapons situation was an example of the president following this process, despite the complications. As for the role of bridging the gap between the Biden White House and the progressive community, it was a result of the president recognizing the influence of progressive voices in the Democratic Party and making an effort to build relationships and take their ideas seriously.

    • Collaboration and disagreements in US politicsThe American Rescue Plan and Inflation Reduction Act's success hinged on Democratic unity, but disagreements on foreign policy and progressive policies emerged. Tech leaders in Silicon Valley have conflicting views on government intervention, acknowledging its importance while maintaining a libertarian stance.

      The success of the American Rescue Plan and the Inflation Reduction Act was due to the collaboration between House Democrats, President Biden, and their shared progressive goals. However, disagreements arose on certain issues, such as the $15 wage and expanding Medicare, but overall, they were aligned in their domestic politics vision. The coalition faced its first major disagreement on foreign policy regarding Gaza. Moving forward, the president's team needs to understand the importance of progressive voter turnout and offer an inspiring vision for the future. Regarding tech leaders in Silicon Valley, such as Mark Andreessen and Elon Musk, they have amassed great power but hold a victim mentality, despite the government's role in their success. They have adopted a libertarian view that government regulation is the obstacle, rather than a lack of investment. However, they acknowledge the need for government collaboration in building industries and technological advancements.

    • Balancing DEI programs and entrepreneurshipHistory shows a balanced approach is necessary for DEI programs and entrepreneurship, with concerns for retail investor protection in volatile industries like cryptocurrency, while providing opportunities for underrepresented communities to participate in economic wealth generation

      While there are ongoing debates about the role of DEI programs and government support for entrepreneurship, history shows that a balanced approach is necessary. In the context of cryptocurrency, the industry's volatility and lack of regulation have led to concerns about retail investor protection. Despite this, many people, particularly those from underrepresented communities, see crypto and blockchain as their only opportunity to participate in modern economic wealth generation. Regarding the California primary, there's a strategy among some campaigns to boost a Republican candidate in the hope of easier runoff victories. However, this approach has drawn criticism from Democrats, who fear it could help down-ballot Republicans turn out voters. Ultimately, it's crucial to expand economic opportunities for all, ensuring a balanced and inclusive digital economy.

    • Political tactics and their impact on down ballot racesThe use of manipulative tactics in politics may be legal but uncertainly affects down ballot races. The upcoming Super Tuesday elections and family dynamics are also impacted by the ongoing political climate.

      While some political tactics, such as those employed by Representative Adam Schiff, may be legal but manipulative, the overall impact on down ballot races is uncertain. The discussion also touched upon the upcoming Super Tuesday elections and the potential impact of the ongoing political climate on family dynamics, including the selling of controversial onesies. Despite the controversial tactics, there is optimism about winning four house races with Trump as the nominee. The conversation also included light-hearted moments, such as the discussion about wearing specific campaign shirts to family gatherings. Overall, the episode highlighted the complexities and nuances of the current political landscape.

    Recent Episodes from Pod Save America

    Joe vs. The Unknown

    Joe vs. The Unknown

    Democrats begin to grapple with two huge questions: is it possible to replace Biden at the top of the ticket—and is it wise? Mehdi Hasan joins Jon, Lovett, Tommy, and Dan, live in Boston, to debate the options. Plus, Gov. Maura Healey joins the show to give her own debate reaction and talk about rising to the challenge on immigration and abortion.

    The First (and Last?) Debate

    The First (and Last?) Debate

    The first debate is upon us, and you’re not the only one feeling nervous. Guest host Stacey Abrams joins Jon, Jon, Tommy, and Dan, live in Brooklyn, to talk about what we can learn from the 2020 debates, and what would constitute a win for Biden on Thursday night. Then, Strict Scrutiny’s Melissa Murray joins the hosts to break down the latest from the Supreme Court and what’s still to come this term, and Run for Something co-founder Amanda Litman talks with Dan about why it’s so important to have progressive candidates running in local races.Democracy or Else is out now! 

     

    Pick up your copy wherever you buy books, or at http://crooked.com/books.

     

    Want to join Crooked’s subscriber live chat for the presidential debate? Sign up at http://crooked.com/friends.

    This Is Your Debate on Drugs

    This Is Your Debate on Drugs

    Donald Trump vows to cut education funding by half, throws his support behind displaying the Ten Commandments in public classrooms, and offers a new, anatomically specific theory for how Joe Biden gets his pre-debate uppers. With Biden holed up in debate camp, his campaign works to set expectations, and marks the second anniversary of the end of Roe v. Wade with a blistering new attack ad and waves of surrogate events around the country. Plus, it’s publication day at last: Democracy or Else: How to Save America in 10 Easy Steps is out now! Head to your local bookstore or www.crooked.com/books to order your copy.

     

    For a closed-captioned version of this episode, click here. For a transcript of this episode, please email transcripts@crooked.com and include the name of the podcast.

    How Democrats Can Win Latinos Back (Ep. 4)

    How Democrats Can Win Latinos Back (Ep. 4)

    Jon is joined by Carlos Odio and Stephanie Valencia, founders of Equis Research, the nation’s leading polling and research firm focused on the Latino electorate, to talk about what Democrats can do to win back the Latino voters who left the party for Trump in 2016 and 2020. Why are some of them leaning towards Trump? How did they react to Biden’s border actions? And what issues are they most focused on in 2024? Jon, Carlos, and Stephanie dive into the focus groups to answer these questions and Leo Murrieta, Director of Make the Road Nevada, joins to talk about his trip to the White House and offer his advice for the Biden campaign.

    Take action with Vote Save America: Visit votesaveamerica.com/2024  

    Pre-order Democracy or Else: How to Save America in 10 Easy Steps at crooked.com/books or wherever books are sold. Out June 25th.

    Pod Save America
    enJune 23, 2024

    Trump Loses It Over Fox News Poll

    Trump Loses It Over Fox News Poll

    Joe Biden heads to Camp David to prepare for next week's debate, Donald Trump bungles the expectations game, and both sides prepare for the post-broadcast clip war. Meanwhile, a new Fox News poll shows Biden ahead, and Trump lashes out at the betrayal. Then, former White House Counsel Bob Bauer stops by to talk about playing Trump in debate prep in 2020, the Supreme Court, and his new book, The Unraveling: Reflections on Politics without Ethics and Democracy in Crisis. 

     

    To pre-order Democracy or Else, out June 25th, visit www.crooked.com/books 

     

    To buy tickets for book events and live shows, visit www.crooked.com/events

    The Plan to Fight Trump's Second-Term Agenda

    The Plan to Fight Trump's Second-Term Agenda

    Joe Biden makes a big new move on immigration, and Democratic governors and progressive groups quietly make plans to fight back against the second-term agenda that Trump is promising, from mass deportations to bans on medication abortion and gutting the civil service. Strict Scrutiny's Kate Shaw joins Jon and Lovett to talk about the legal challenges in store for both Trump and Biden, the Supreme Court's dangerous decision on bump stocks, and what else we can expect from the justices with so many opinions yet to drop.

     

    For a closed-captioned version of this episode, click here. For a transcript of this episode, please email transcripts@crooked.com and include the name of the podcast.

    Biden Campaign Unloads on Trump's Conviction

    Biden Campaign Unloads on Trump's Conviction

    The Biden campaign puts big money into a new ad slamming Trump as a convicted felon, fraudster, and sexual predator, and painting Biden as a fighter for working families. Trump courts the Black vote in front of a mostly white audience in Detroit, and CNN announces the final rules for next week’s debate. Plus: Jon, Lovett, and Tommy talk about who’s up and who’s down in the race to be Trump’s VP.To preorder you copy of Democracy or Else, visit http://crooked.com/booksFor tickets to upcoming live shows and book events, visit http://crooked.com/events

    For a closed-captioned version of this episode, click here. For a transcript of this episode, please email transcripts@crooked.com and include the name of the podcast.

    Trump Returns to the Scene of the Crime

    Trump Returns to the Scene of the Crime

    Trump returns to the Capitol for the first time since January 6th and receives a hero’s welcome from House and Senate Republicans—where he calls Milwaukee a “horrible city,” refers to the Justice Department as “dirty bastards,” and complains about Taylor Swift not endorsing him. Meanwhile, the same Republicans attempting to overturn Trump’s conviction are instead trying to prosecute Attorney General Merrick Garland. Plus, SCOTUS affirms legal access to abortion medication, Biden takes voters’ cost of living concerns head on, and Trump tries to woo CEOs with more tax cuts.

    The GOP Meltdown Over Hunter's Conviction

    The GOP Meltdown Over Hunter's Conviction

    Dan and The Bulwark’s Sarah Longwell break down the chaotic Republican response to the Hunter Biden news and what the conviction might mean for the Biden campaign, which of Donald Trump’s rumored VP picks scare them the most, and the latest from Tuesday’s primaries.

     

    For a closed-captioned version of this episode, click here. For a transcript of this episode, please email transcripts@crooked.com and include the name of the podcast.

    Related Episodes

    GOP lawmakers pushing new ways to undermine voters in 2024

    GOP lawmakers pushing new ways to undermine voters in 2024
    MSNBC's Ari Melber hosts "The Beat" on Monday, February 5, and reports on lawmakers supporting false electors and the 2024 Grammy Awards. Neal Katyal, Andrew Weissmann, and Chai Komanduri join to discuss. Plus, Academy Award-winning producer Brian Grazer joins Melber in a special edition of The Summit Series.

    Trump Goes Birther on Haley

    Trump Goes Birther on Haley

    With the New Hampshire primary just five days away, Trump attacks Nikki Haley using an all-too-familiar line of attack. The Granite State is Haley's last, best chance—but is she even fighting to win it anymore? New Hampshire Public Radio's Josh Rogers stops by to talk about what he's seeing—and what's missing—on the campaign trail.

     

    For a closed-captioned version of this episode, click here. For a transcript of this episode, please email transcripts@crooked.com and include the name of the podcast.

    The Sunday Show with Jonathan Capehart: February 11, 2024

    The Sunday Show with Jonathan Capehart: February 11, 2024

    On this week's episode of 'The Sunday Show with Jonathan Capehart': In a rare Sunday vote, a critical aid bill for Ukraine and Israel passes a key hurdle in the Senate as Donald Trump says he'd let Russia attack America's NATO allies if they don't pay their member dues. Senator Chris Van Hollen of the Senate Foreign Relations Committee offers his thoughts. California Gov. Gavin Newsom tells me about the moment he went rogue 20 years ago tomorrow when he was mayor of San Francisco and issued the city's first same sex-marriage licenses.  And A closer look at why the phrase "working class voters" has become synonymous with Whites, and why African-American workers need to be included in this political conversation. Acclaimed historian Blair LM Kelley discusses her powerful new book. All that and more on “The Sunday Show with Jonathan Capehart.” 

    What starts with the Jews, rarely ends with just the Jews - with Yuval Levin

    What starts with the Jews, rarely ends with just the Jews - with Yuval Levin
    On previous episodes of this podcast we’ve discussed the origins and history of antisemitism. But what does this antisemitic moment tell us about society more generally? If you look back throughout history, the persecution of Jews has often coincided with an even bigger crack-up in society. Is this antisemitic moment the first sign of something bigger going on – is it a vessel for broader and deepers trends? This is what we will discuss with Yuvan Levin. Yuval currently wears three hats: At the American Enterprise Institute think tank, he’s the Director of Social, Cultural, and Constitutional Studies. He’s the editor-in-chief of National Affairs, a quarterly journal of essays about domestic policy, political economy, and political thought. He’s also authored numerous books. “The Fractured Republic” is especially relevant to today’s conversation. Yuval served as a member of the White House domestic policy staff under President George W. Bush. He earned his masters and PhD from the University of Chicago. To subscribe to National Affairs: https://www.nationalaffairs.com/

    Nikki Haley’s Last Dance

    Nikki Haley’s Last Dance

    Erin Ryan and Alyssa Mastromonaco discuss Nikki Haley and the Iowa Caucus, Trump’s latest E Jean Carroll lawsuit, and the state of anti-trans legislation in news. Then, Megan Gailey and Dana Schwartz join to talk about Ariana Grande, homewreckers and “the other woman,” and the way women are held to higher moral standards than men are. Finally, Sani-Petty (are we reliving John Tucker Must Die?). 

    For a closed-captioned version of this episode, click here. For a transcript of this episode, please email transcripts@crooked.com and include the name of the podcast.

    Show Notes
    Fact Check: 9 anti-trans bills in Missouri on Wednesday, not 7! (Source)
    Ariana Grande - yes, and? (official music video)