Logo
    Search

    The Cognitive Dissonance of Exorcisms

    enAugust 02, 2011

    Podcast Summary

    • Emphasizing the role of technology and hope in our livesFrom coping with personal struggles to exploring technological advancements, this podcast episode highlights the importance of hope and technology in our lives, with a surprising nod to the belief in demonic possession.

      Technology, particularly artificial intelligence (AI), will play a significant role in shaping the future. This was emphasized in the introduction of the Technically Speaking podcast by Intel. Meanwhile, in a personal story, a father shared how hope and community support helped him cope during his child's cancer diagnosis. He urged listeners to become St. Jude partners in hope. Separately, in a light-hearted conversation, the hosts of Stuff to Blow Your Mind joked about exorcisms and the confusion of class offerings at the YMCA. However, a 2005 Gallup poll revealed that a considerable number of Americans believe in the literal existence of demonic possession. These diverse topics illustrate the importance of hope, technology, and understanding different beliefs in our lives.

    • Exploring the belief and experience of exorcismsDespite lacking factual evidence, the belief and experience of exorcisms offer insights into human psychology and sociology, with potential harm caused by the practice being a concern.

      While the belief in possession and the practice of exorcisms may not be based on factual evidence, the experiences and beliefs of those involved are still worth exploring. Exorcisms, an ancient practice believed to remove evil foreign forces from a person's body, have seen a rise in modern times. While it's important to note that these events are not actual possessions by demonic creatures, the psychological and sociological aspects of the belief and experience are fascinating. The idea of being possessed or experiencing unexplained phenomena is not unique to exorcisms, and it shares similarities with beliefs in alien abductions. The danger lies in the potential harm caused by these beliefs and the actions taken in the name of exorcism. The practice, with its roots in various cultures, often involves a holy figure removing the evil force. While popular culture may portray exorcisms as dramatic and terrifying encounters, the most disturbing aspects may lie in the early stages of the belief and the impact it has on the individual and their community.

    • Beliefs in evil spirits and curses across culturesCultures worldwide hold unique beliefs in evil spirits or curses, with practices that range from seemingly harmless to extreme methods, serving as a reminder of the power of the human mind and the importance of community and ritual in dealing with fear and uncertainty.

      Exorcisms and the belief in the existence of evil spirits or curses are not unique to any one culture or religion. From the Roman Catholic Church's definition of possession, to the Israeli practice of removing a dybbuk via Skype, to the Bedouin tradition of removing the evil eye, various cultures around the world have their own unique ways of dealing with the belief in evil spirits or curses. These practices can range from seemingly harmless, like a strange stare causing distress, to more extreme methods like rolling people up in rugs and beating them with sticks. It's important to remember that while these practices may seem strange or even comical to some, they hold deep significance to the communities that practice them. Ultimately, the belief in the existence of evil spirits or curses serves as a reminder of the power of the human mind and the importance of community and ritual in dealing with fear and uncertainty.

    • Understanding the complex practice of exorcism in the Catholic ChurchExorcism is a ritual used in the Catholic Church to address beliefs of demonic possession, involving prayers, medical evaluation, and social role-playing.

      The practice of exorcism in the Roman Catholic Church is a complex ritual used to address beliefs of demonic possession. It involves a manual of prayers and responses, and the person claiming possession must be medically evaluated to rule out physical or mental illness. The use of exorcism has seen a resurgence in recent years as part of a larger movement towards returning to traditional Catholic practices. People may seek out exorcisms as a way to explain and deal with conflicting beliefs or parts of their personality that they find shameful or uncomfortable, a phenomenon known as cognitive dissonance. This practice can be seen as a form of social role-playing, with the exorcist acting as an authority figure. In earlier times, this could also serve as a way to explain and cope with societal taboos, such as homosexuality. Overall, the practice of exorcism reflects the deep-rooted human desire to understand and make sense of the unexplained or uncomfortable aspects of ourselves and our world.

    • Exploring the reasons behind the fascination with exorcismsExorcisms offer a way for individuals to explain and cope with internal conflicts, and confirmation bias can make the concept appealing for those struggling with shame, mental illness, or personal issues.

      The concept of exorcism can be seen as a way for individuals to explain and cope with internal conflicts or behaviors that they find difficult to understand or accept. This can involve attributing these behaviors to an external force, such as the devil, and entering into a social contract where both the person experiencing the behavior and the exorcist play specific roles. This phenomenon, known as confirmation bias, can lead individuals to focus on patterns that confirm their beliefs rather than searching for evidence to the contrary. The ease of fitting certain behaviors into the framework of possession can be particularly appealing for those struggling with shame, mental illness, or other personal issues. Understanding this dynamic sheds light on the historical prevalence and continued fascination with exorcisms.

    • Belief in supernatural possession in childrenHistorically, unexplained behaviors in children were attributed to supernatural possession, providing a sense of control and validation, but can cause harm

      Throughout history, people have attributed unexplained behaviors in children, such as night terrors, to supernatural possession. This belief provides a sense of control and validation for both the child and the adults involved. During certain periods, particularly in the context of teenage spiritual exploration, this belief can become even more prevalent, leading to practices like exorcisms. These events offer a sense of power and importance to those involved, allowing them to feel like they are making a difference in the world. However, it is essential to remember that these beliefs are not based on factual evidence and can cause harm to the individuals involved.

    • The role of touch and release in exorcisms and therapyTouch and release can offer positive responses in exorcisms and therapy, but it's crucial to ensure consent and safety, especially for vulnerable individuals.

      The role of touch and release in various contexts, including exorcisms and therapy, can provide significant positive responses. The speaker's experience at a supposed exorcism as a teenager highlights this idea, as the environment offered a safe space for the individual to deal with their emotions. The speaker suggests that this concept can be compared to traditional therapeutic methods, where individuals seek help to work through their issues. However, it's essential to recognize the potential dangers when exorcisms are imposed upon individuals who lack the ability to consent or have a voice for themselves. The speaker acknowledges the existence of tragic instances, particularly involving children and mentally ill individuals, where the use of exorcisms has resulted in harm. Overall, the discussion emphasizes the importance of understanding the nuances of touch and release in various contexts and the potential risks and benefits they bring.

    • Deadly Consequences of ExorcismsExorcisms, though seen as metaphorical solutions, can lead to deadly consequences, including starvation, dehydration, suffocation, and drowning, particularly for children. Seek evidence-based treatments for mental and emotional health issues instead.

      While some people may view exorcisms as a metaphorical solution for spiritual or emotional struggles, the physical and potentially deadly consequences cannot be ignored. There have been numerous reported cases of deaths due to exorcisms throughout history, including instances of starvation, dehydration, suffocation, and even drowning. These practices, often carried out by religious figures, have led to tragic outcomes, particularly for children. Although the Catholic Church claims to screen for those in need and distinguish between those requiring exorcisms and psychiatric care, the prevalence of such practices in the US, Poland, and Mexico raises concerns. It's essential to recognize the potential dangers and encourage individuals to seek alternative, evidence-based treatments for mental and emotional health issues.

    • The Church's Unique Supernatural Identity and ExorcismsThe Church's commitment to exorcisms raises questions about the spiritual vulnerability of highly spiritual individuals and the hierarchy's power play, but it also underscores the unique supernatural identity of the Church.

      The restoration of exorcisms in the church, as observed by Doctor Appleby, is an attempt to preserve the church's unique supernatural identity. However, the cynical perspective sees it as a power play by the hierarchy and priests. The case of Mother Teresa, who reportedly underwent an exorcism late in life due to insomnia, raises questions about the spiritual vulnerability of highly spiritual individuals and the potential for demonic interference. Despite her holiness, some believe that her deep spiritual connection left her open to such attacks. The existence of a pope-appointed chief exorcist further underscores the church's commitment to this practice. Ultimately, the debate surrounding exorcisms remains contentious, with some viewing it as a necessary spiritual intervention and others as an unnecessary complication in religious life.

    • The Catholic Church's Diverse Beliefs and RolesDespite the Catholic Church's complexity, it houses individuals with contrasting beliefs like exorcists and astronomers, highlighting its intricacies and the coexistence of diverse roles.

      The Catholic Church, as depicted by Father Gabriela Amorth, is a complex institution with individuals holding vastly different beliefs and roles. Amidst this diversity, the contrasting figures of Father Amorth, an exorcist, and Consilmagna, a Vatican astronomer, highlight the polarizing ends of the Church's beliefs in modern times. While Father Amorth sees Satan's presence and believes in the existence of evil, Consilmagna focuses on the cosmos and science. The Christmas party anecdote illustrates the unlikely pairing of these two individuals, emphasizing the vast divide between their roles and beliefs within the Church. Alicia's story about the hilarious word "svigamamonometer" serves as a light-hearted interlude in the discussion. Overall, the conversation highlights the intricacies and complexities within the Catholic Church, showcasing the coexistence of various beliefs and roles.

    • Religion in Space: Maintenance, Exorcisms, and Personal ExperiencesSome people believe religion could evolve around space maintenance tasks, while others find the concept unsettling. Atheist Richard Dawkins might react negatively. Listeners share thoughts on exorcisms and personal experiences. New video podcast 'Stuff From the Future' and sponsors were mentioned.

      The idea of religion in space was discussed, with some suggesting it could evolve around maintenance tasks, while others might find the concept unsettling. The podcast "Religion in Space" brought up the possibility of famous atheist Richard Dawkins reacting negatively to this concept. Listeners are encouraged to share their thoughts on the topic and any personal experiences with exorcisms or religious phenomena. The podcast also mentioned a request for an episode on the prevalence of exorcisms and why they occur. Additionally, the podcast promoted their new video podcast, "Stuff From the Future," and mentioned various sponsors, including Visible and American Express. The episode also shared personal stories, including one about a family's experience with St. Jude Children's Research Hospital and the hope it brought during a child's cancer diagnosis.

    Recent Episodes from Stuff To Blow Your Mind

    Smart Talks with IBM: AI & the Productivity Paradox

    Smart Talks with IBM: AI & the Productivity Paradox

    In a rapidly evolving world, we need to balance the fear surrounding AI and its role in the workplace with its potential to drive productivity growth. In this special live episode of Smart Talks with IBM, Malcolm Gladwell is joined onstage by Rob Thomas, senior vice president of software and chief commercial officer at IBM, during NY Tech Week. They discuss “the productivity paradox,” the importance of open-source AI, and a future where AI will touch every industry.

    This is a paid advertisement from IBM. The conversations on this podcast don't necessarily represent IBM's positions, strategies or opinions.

    Visit us at ibm.com/smarttalks

    See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

    Weirdhouse Cinema: The Dungeonmaster

    Weirdhouse Cinema: The Dungeonmaster

    In this episode of Weirdhouse Cinema, Rob and Joe return to the glorious world of 80s Charles Band productions with 1984’s “The Dungeonmaster,” a supernatural dreamscape with eight directors starring Jeffrey Byron, Richard Moll and Leslie Wing. It’s time to reject the devil’s reality and substitute your own! 

    See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

    Related Episodes

    18. Black/White Thinking

    18. Black/White Thinking

    Yes or no. Save your explanations! It’s my way or the highway. Black/white thinking—hardly an uncommon style, needless to say. It is not stoic thinking, not elegant in its simplicity: is is merely lazy. It is a problem, it certainly creates problems, and though around since time immemorial—should now be condemned as an offense of callous thoughtlessness. It’s not a good way to be.

    ~~~

    YouTube:
    https://youtube.com/@subtlerevolution1

    Twitter / X:
    https://x.com/thoughtreserve

    Instagram:
    https://instagram.com/subtlerevolution1

    Email:
    subtlerevolution1@gmail.com

    17. Rigidity

    17. Rigidity

    The unyielding, the proud beings of stone…we know these people. They are not rare. They are in our families; they are at our places of employment. We elect many of them to positions of importance. But should we? Is this a quality we want in our leaders?

    ~~~

    YouTube:
    https://youtube.com/@subtlerevolution1

    Twitter / X:
    https://x.com/thoughtreserve

    Instagram:
    https://instagram.com/subtlerevolution1

    Email:
    subtlerevolution1@gmail.com

    Fundamentalism

    19. Nuanced Thinking

    19. Nuanced Thinking

    To simplify is a thing to which most of us aspire. Anything that will bring some apparent clarity in this increasingly noisy world…we are looking for it. That is always an ideal. However, not all things are simple. When we over-simplify, across the board—even on matters which are quite complex—the simple solutions generated tend to fail. We must know when to go for “cut and dry,” but also when nuance is the right approach.

    ~~~

    YouTube:
    https://youtube.com/@subtlerevolution1

    Twitter / X:
    https://x.com/thoughtreserve

    Instagram:
    https://instagram.com/subtlerevolution1

    Email:
    subtlerevolution1@gmail.com