Healthcare transparency is essential for patients to make informed decisions, yet price disparities in the industry remain a major issue. In this podcast episode, we explore how financial incentives and contracts between hospitals and insurance companies can misalign the incentives of brokers, employers, doctors, and patients. We discuss the importance of understanding the influence of these incentives and the need for accountability in developing an equitable healthcare system. Through transparent communication and a focus on an equitable system, we can help ensure that patients receive the care they need and deserve.
Episode Outline:
(00:00:02) Healthcare Transparency
(00:04:42) Price Disparity in Healthcare
(00:09:37) Health Insurance Incentives
(00:14:21) Doctor Compensation Metrics
(00:19:05) Incentive Misalignment
Quotes:
(00:03:21) The thing that boggles my mind about healthcare is that in most of healthcare, neither the consumer, which in healthcare is the patient, nor the provider of the goods or services, which in most cases is the doctor, neither one of those parties know what the price is going to be until long after the services are already rendered.
(00:09:10) You might only be paying a copay or you might only be paying your $200 and $5500 out of pocket that's falling off of your coinsurance. And they have no idea until they get the EOB what the build charges were and what the allowed charge was. So I think they're so disconnected from how much health care actually costs.
(00:12:23) But I'm going to put it really bluntly and I think I got this from Dave Chase, this little metaphor here. But imagine for a minute if fire departments only got paid when there was a fire, they would want as many fires to occur as possible. And the bigger the fire, the more money they get.
(00:17:22) And not only that, I think to deny that you're influenced by the financial incentives is to deny you're human. I mean, we've operated on financial incentives long before currency even existed.
(00:21:08) I challenge you, if you are not already, if you're a consultant, even if you're a patient, if you're an employer, figure out what you can do. What one thing can you do differently to turn that incentive around?
Social Post:
Are you tired of feeling like you have a healthcare hangover? We've all been there. That's why we created the Healthcare Hangover podcast. We dive into the headaches we've been encountering in the healthcare system that are leaving us feeling a little hungover.
In our latest episode, we talk about the importance of healthcare transparency. We heard a story about a patient who was charged $475 for an X-ray at a hospital, when they could have gotten the same X-ray at a chiropractor's office for less than $75. We also spoke with a hernia surgeon who was able to do the same procedure for $7,200 instead of the $20,000 quoted by a local general hospital.
Tune in to the Healthcare Hangover podcast to learn more about the importance of healthcare transparency and how it can save you money.
Are you curious about how doctors are paid? Tune in to the latest episode of The Healthcare Hangover podcast to find out! From patient volume to RVUs, David Contorno and Emma Fox break down the complex system of doctor pay and how it influences health care decisions. Plus, they discuss how traditional brokers are put in an unfair position and how financial incentives can be used to deliver better outcomes. Don't miss out on this eye-opening episode! #TheHealthcareHangover #DoctorPay #Healthcare
Are you tired of the broken healthcare system? Tune in to the latest episode of The Healthcare Hangover to learn how the system was designed to benefit certain people and how you can help turn the incentives around! From the perverse incentives of commission-based compensation to the Cigna CEO's 20 million dollar salary, David Contorno and Emma Fox will take you through the details of the current system and how you can help build an alternative. Don't miss out! #TheHealthcareHangover #BrokenHealthcareSystem #Incentives
Blog Post:
The healthcare system is broken, and it's time to start fixing it. In this episode of Healthcare Hangover, hosts David Contorno and Emma Fox explore the lack of price transparency in healthcare, and how providers are taking advantage of patients by charging them more than necessary.
Insurance companies make money by renewing plans every year, regardless of how much they pay out, and people often think that more expensive care results in better outcomes, which is not true. Unfortunately, people often cannot afford their out-of-pocket costs, leading to debt or even lawsuits. Insurance companies do not provide any positive benefits to doctors, employers, or patients, and people have been led to believe that they need health insurance to get quality health care, which is false.
The hosts also discuss how fire departments operate on a fixed budget, while health care systems make more money the sicker people are. Health insurance companies have a massive workforce that they pay very little to, and they have bonus programs for brokers that are available on their websites. Hospitals are not changing their practices due to lack of consumer demand, and MRF (Machine Readable File) is not human readable, requiring a middleman to translate the data. Additionally, hospitals often put programming on their website to prevent spiders from finding the data.
David Contorno and Emma Fox also discuss how cash prices are almost always the lowest prices on hospital spreadsheets, and the disparity between prices for the same procedure from different carriers is outrageous. Commercial carriers pay the highest reimbursement rate to hospitals, and patients are disconnected from the cost of healthcare due to copays and coinsurance. To illustrate this, David Contorno visited a chiropractor for an X-ray of his shoulder and was asked if he was okay with the price before the X-ray was taken. The X-ray cost $75 at the chiropractor's office, but the same X-ray would have cost $475 at Atrium, the hospital system next door. Michael Reinhorn, a hernia surgeon in the Boston area, charges $7,200 for hernia surgery, while a local general hospital charges $20,000.
The hosts also compare the healthcare system to the veterinary system, noting that veterinarians often give customers options and prices up front before giving any treatment. Doctors, on the other hand, are typically paid based on two metrics: patient volume and RVU (Revenue Value Unit). Patient volume is the number of patients seen in a day, with some doctors having minimum patient volume requirements of up to 30 patients per day. RVU is a measurement of how much revenue a doctor is helping generate for the health system, often in areas outside of their office. Doctors are incentivized to prescribe opioids to deal with pain, and to send patients to the most expensive care, regardless of whether it is the appropriate treatment. The most likely outcome of back surgery in the US is a second back surgery.
Additionally, traditional brokers are paid more when they retain their book of business and cross-sell additional products that benefit the carrier they represent. Healthcare and health insurance employees often think they are doing good, even though the results they keep delivering are bad. The company bills their clients and has a performance bonus for achieving the client's goals of paying less for healthcare.
Ultimately, the hosts conclude that people should focus on changing one thing at a time to build an alternative system that is more affordable. The Cigna CEO made 20 million dollars last year, and the sicker people are, the more money they make. It's time to start demanding more transparency and accountability from health insurance companies, and for patients to take control of their own healthcare. We have the power to create a system of trust between providers and patients, and to make healthcare more affordable and accessible.
Episode Links:
Connect with Emma Fox
Connect with David Contorno
Other Materials
These materials help you promote your podcast. Quotes can be used for audio & video grams or quote cards. Blog and social posts will help your website and social media presence.
