Logo
    Search

    A.B. Stoddard: Dead Ends after Iowa

    en-usJanuary 16, 2024

    Podcast Summary

    • Donald Trump wins Iowa caucuses, solidifying his position as 2024 GOP frontrunnerTrump wins Iowa caucuses, securing front-runner status, while DeSantis struggles with poor showing and lack of support in upcoming states.

      Donald Trump has solidified his position as the front-runner in the 2024 Republican presidential primaries after winning the Iowa caucuses with a substantial lead. Ron DeSantis finished in second place but with a significant gap to Trump, raising questions about his continued participation in the race. Despite losing in all 99 counties and failing to win the endorsement of Iowa's major evangelical leaders, DeSantis plans to move on to New Hampshire and South Carolina. However, his poor showing in Iowa and lack of significant support in those states may make it difficult for him to continue his campaign. DeSantis' refusal to debate Nikki Haley, who finished in third place, further highlights his weakened position. The race is now officially a two-person race between Trump and DeSantis, but DeSantis' future in the race remains uncertain.

    • Desperate DeSantis clings to magical thinking for GOP nominationDeSantis' continued presidential bid is driven by unrealistic hopes and a need to preserve his political future, despite past disillusionment and failed attempts to distance himself from Trump and Fox News.

      Ron DeSantis' continued presence in the Republican presidential primary race is driven by magical thinking and a desperate attempt to preserve a political future for himself and his wife, despite his disillusionment with Donald Trump and the right-wing media's bias towards the former president. DeSantis' efforts to suck up to Trump while running against him have been unsuccessful, and his recent criticism of Fox News may be a weak attempt to distance himself, but it is unlikely to change his long-term plan of groveling for forgiveness and humiliation if he wants any future in the Republican Party. The meteor unicorn strategy, where something miraculous will happen to secure the nomination, is the only line of thinking keeping him in the race. However, the reality is that he will have to crawl through broken glass to Mar-a-Lago and kiss the ring if he wants any future in the Republican Party.

    • Discussion on Nikki Haley and Vivek Ramaswamy's presidential campaignsFormer SC Governor Nikki Haley's presidential campaign is seen as futile and damaging, while Vivek Ramaswamy's unfounded claims and exit left a strange impression in the MAGA world

      During the discussion, it was suggested that former South Carolina Governor Nikki Haley's campaign for the Republican presidential nomination is a futile and injurious path for her, and the best course of action for her would be to concede and support Donald Trump. Additionally, Vivek Ramaswamy, another Republican contender, was criticized for his unfounded claims about Trump being in danger and his subsequent exit from the race, which was seen as a stupid game with a weird ending. Despite initial thoughts, Vivek is not likely to be forgotten in the MAGA world due to his unhinged demagogue persona and may find a place in the Republican party.

    • The Future of the Republican PartyRamaswami's controversial past may not be welcomed in the GOP, but his skills could make him a formidable figure. Haley's underwhelming performance in Iowa may lead to a VP bid, but Trump's consideration is uncertain.

      The future of the Republican Party may not have a place for individuals like Vivek Ramaswami, who have been associated with conspiracy theories, raw racism, and demagogic behavior. Despite his controversial past, Ramaswami's skill set, which includes being glib, demagogic, and utterly without principles, may make him a formidable figure in the party. His exit from the race is seen as good news for Donald Trump, as Ramaswami's voters are likely to shift their support to him. Nikki Haley's performance in the Iowa caucus was underwhelming, and she failed to secure the surprise second place finish her supporters had hoped for. Despite her claims of being in a two-person race and her congratulatory tweet to Trump, there is speculation that she is preserving herself for a potential vice presidential nomination. However, it is unclear whether Trump would ever consider her for the role.

    • Nikki Haley's Slim Chances of Challenging TrumpDespite a weak showing in Iowa, Nikki Haley's chances of challenging Trump for the Republican nomination are slim due to his preference for loyalists and her underperformance in closed primaries.

      Nikki Haley's chances of challenging Donald Trump for the Republican nomination are slim. She's not expected to run against him directly due to Trump's preference for loyalists. Her performance in the Iowa caucus was weaker than it appeared, with low enthusiasm from Republican voters. Chris Christie's assessment that she won't make it in the race was correct, as Trump outperformed her with moderates and college-educated Republicans. New Hampshire, which could be a surprise for Haley, might not matter much as her underwhelming showings in Iowa, South Carolina, and other closed primaries are likely to deny her the nomination. The anticipatory surrender of Republicans like Marco Rubio, Mike Lee, and others who have endorsed Trump before the first vote further underscores this reality.

    • Republican Senators' Positioning for a Potential Trump Second TermThe dynamic among GOP senators reveals a lack of opposition to Trump's potential second term, with some openly supporting him and others compromising principles for endorsements, indicating a Senate under Trump would not serve as a check on his power.

      The dynamic among Republican senators regarding a potential second term for Donald Trump is one of jockeying for position and loyalty. Mike Lee, one of the senators openly opposed to Mitch McConnell, is attempting to position himself as the chief Trump supporter. Marco Rubio, despite attempts to frame his endorsement as policy-focused, is still seen as compromising his principles. John Barrasso, who wants to replace McConnell, is a staunch Trump supporter. Other senators, like Joni Ernst, have shown a willingness to overlook past criticisms of Trump and support him again. This suggests that a Republican-controlled Senate under a Trump presidency would not serve as a check on his power, but rather would enable and support his actions. The institutions and supposed "adults in the room" are not providing any meaningful opposition, making the prospect of another Trump presidency a concerning one.

    • The Influence of Trump on the Republican PartyDespite divisive actions and legal issues, Trump retains strong support from the GOP due to fear of political consequences.

      The support for Donald Trump within the Republican Party remains strong despite his divisive actions and controversial behavior. Joni Ernst, a potential Republican contender, illustrates this conflict as she has expressed reservations about Trump but ultimately will endorse him due to fear of political consequences. Meanwhile, Trump continues to make inflammatory statements and face legal issues, yet his base remains unphased and continues to support him. This dynamic highlights the deep divide within the Republican Party and the influence Trump holds over it.

    • Trump's Conviction Could Impact Republican Support in Swing StatesA Trump conviction could deter Republican voters in swing states from supporting him, potentially impacting the election outcome.

      Donald Trump's decision to attend his trials and play the victim card may have worked in his favor during the Republican primary, but its effectiveness in the general election is uncertain. Trump's image as a man charged with numerous felonies may not convince undecided voters to support him. In fact, a significant number of Republican voters in key swing states might be turned off by a Trump conviction. The Iowa Republican caucus revealed that 25% of Iowa caucus goers would not vote for Trump in the general election, and a conviction could pose problems for him in states like Pennsylvania, Arizona, Michigan, Wisconsin, and Georgia. The erosion of Republican support is critical for the anti-Trump coalition, and any effort to get them to stay home or come on board could be decisive.

    • Impact of Chris Christie's exit from the presidential raceChristie's exit may sway voters in key states and clear the way for other candidates, while his potential endorsement of Biden could be crucial in the upcoming election.

      Chris Christie's decision to drop out of the presidential race and potentially endorse Joe Biden may significantly impact the election results, particularly in states like Wisconsin where Republican voters may have undervoted for the president. Christie's candidacy provided a truthful critique of Donald Trump that resonated with some Republicans, and his exit may clear the way for other candidates to gain support. However, his impact extends beyond the horse race as he continues to speak out against Trump and potentially influences Republican voters to consider other options. While it's unfortunate to lose Christie's voice in the race, his potential endorsement of Biden could prove crucial in the upcoming election.

    • Christie's authentic speech contrasts programmed politiciansChristie's speech offered historical references and deep thoughts, contrasting scripted speeches. Stakes high with global concerns, potential consequences include gridlock and lack of support for critical issues.

      Chris Christie's authentic and liberated speech during the Republican National Convention stood out in contrast to other politicians who appear programmed and formulaic. Christie's deep thoughts and historical references in his speech were a refreshing departure from the usual scripted speeches. The stakes of the upcoming election are high, as the rest of the world is closely watching the political divide in America and expressing concerns about the potential impact on national security and the global community. The corrosion brought by the current political climate may remain even if a different party wins, leading to potential consequences such as gridlock and lack of support for critical issues like Ukraine and military funding.

    • Republican Party's Shift Towards IsolationismThe Republican Party is moving towards isolationism, which could lead to geopolitical consequences like Putin invading Eastern European countries if the U.S. leaves NATO.

      The Republican Party's foreign policy stance is shifting towards isolationism, which could have significant geopolitical consequences. Nikki Haley, a potential Republican primary candidate, cannot appeal to the base by expressing concern for the world's perception of American democracy. Instead, the America First narrative prevails. Mitch McConnell, a pro-Western and internationalist voice in the Senate, is on the losing end of this intra-party fight. The refusal to pass immigration policy or provide security aid to allies while prioritizing border security is indicative of this trend. McConnell's tenure as Senate leader may also be coming to an end, potentially leaving the Republican Party without a significant voice advocating for Western alliances. This shift towards isolationism could have serious implications, including the potential for Putin to invade Eastern European countries if the U.S. withdraws from NATO in a second Trump term.

    Recent Episodes from The Bulwark Podcast

    Sarah Longwell, Jonathan V. Last, and Jonathan Martin: A Disaster

    Sarah Longwell, Jonathan V. Last, and Jonathan Martin: A Disaster
    The Secret Pod makes an emergency appearance to work through last night's terrible performance by Biden and to urge the Democratic Party to do the responsible thing in this moment. And Jonathan Martin discusses the strategy behind Biden's failed gamble and whether sitting Democrats would actually publicly push the president to leave the ticket. Sarah Longwell, JVL, and Martin join Tim Miller for the weekend pod.

    show notes:

    Claire McCaskill on Biden's performance
    David Frum on the debate
    Tim's playlist 

    The Bulwark Podcast
    en-usJune 28, 2024

    Kate Bedingfield and Marc Caputo: Debate Day

    Kate Bedingfield and Marc Caputo: Debate Day
    Former White House comms director Kate Bedingfield serves up some keen insights into Poppa Joe—he is a night person, he regularly seeks out Jill's opinion, and he is a calming influence. And he's probably not as anxious as Tim Miller is about tonight's debate. Meanwhile, Marc Caputo reports from Magaville on Trump's posturing that he is definitely, absolutely not at all prepping for the debate. Your pre-fight night comfort food to calm the jitters.

    show notes:

    Kevin Williamson piece Tim mentioned

    The Bulwark Podcast
    en-usJune 27, 2024

    Stuart Stevens: I think Joe Biden Has Been A Great President

    Stuart Stevens: I think Joe Biden Has Been A Great President
    So many of the people who worked around POTUS 44 think no one will ever be as good as Obama, but Stuart Stevens argues that Democrats need to make the case that Joe Biden is a great president. Meanwhile, Dems on Tuesday showed they are the one party holding their crazy people to account. Plus, Vance is too smart to be Trump's VP pick, more Republicans need to follow Kinzinger's example, and Ole Miss, college sports and civil rights. Tim Miller's show today.

    show notes:

    Stuart's latest book, "The Conspiracy to End America"
    Stuart's book, "The Last Season: A Father, a Son, and a Lifetime of College Football"
    Wright Thompson's piece on Ole Miss in 1962
    Stuart's piece on calling Biden a great president 

    The Bulwark Podcast
    en-usJune 26, 2024

    Symone Sanders-Townsend: Don't Say We Didn't Warn You

    Symone Sanders-Townsend: Don't Say We Didn't Warn You
    Project 2025 sounds mundane, but it would institutionalize Trumpism, eliminate the Department of Education, mass deport 11 million people, and turn the Department of Health and Human Services into the Department of "Life." Plus, more from the mailbag, and Biden finding the sweet spot between Uncle Joe and punching Trump in the face. Symone Sanders-Townsend joins Tim Miller.

    show notes:

    Symone's interview on Project 2025
    MSNBC Live: Democracy 2024 event in September

    Tim's Mount Rushmore of political books:
    The Bulwark Podcast
    en-usJune 25, 2024

    Jared Polis and Bill Kristol: Live from Denver

    Jared Polis and Bill Kristol: Live from Denver
    Gov. Jared Polis says Biden should focus on what he'll do for the American people in his campaign, rather than getting caught up in the crazy of Trump. Plus, guns, weed, the value of talking across party lines, and how Colorado is trying to avoid California's housing and growth problems. Tim Miller was live with Polis on Friday. And Bill Kristol joined Monday to discuss Trump's penchant for lying and to preview Tuesday's primaries.

    The Bulwark Podcast
    en-usJune 24, 2024

    Jane Coaston: He's So Not a Badass

    Jane Coaston: He's So Not a Badass
    Trump is not drawing support from black voters because of his criminality—that's just MAGA's bigotry of low expectations. Meanwhile, he's now promising a green card to every foreign Harvard grad to please tech bro donors. Plus, the attempt to create a race war over Caitlin Clark, the annoying liberals on the coasts are creating MAGA reactionaries, and more from the mailbag. Jane Coaston joins Tim Miller for the weekend pod.

    show notes:

    Reid Hoffman's reply to David Sacks
    Tim interviews Reid Hoffman
    Tim's playlist 

    The Bulwark Podcast
    en-usJune 21, 2024

    Adam Kinzinger: Bat**** Crazy

    Adam Kinzinger: Bat**** Crazy
    Felon 45 didn't even really like being president and no one is taking his ludicrous tariff plan seriously—but Republicans can't stop tripping over each other to show him their fealty. Plus, Putin's desperate trip to North Korea, Netanyahu shows his ingratitude to Biden, the national debt keeps growing, and Trump's fond memories for his glory days on The Apprentice.
    The Bulwark Podcast
    en-usJune 20, 2024

    George Packer: Phoenix, the Most American City

    George Packer: Phoenix, the Most American City
    Phoenix is a microcosm of the big issues in the election and the country generally, including political extremism, climate change, and the border. But when it comes to the state's water crisis, Arizonians are showing signs of sanity—by accepting facts and downplaying partisanship. Could the city be a guide for America's future? George Packer joins Tim Miller.

    show notes:

    George's piece on Phoenix
    George's 2019 piece on his son's education

    The Bulwark Podcast
    en-usJune 19, 2024

    Lauren Windsor and Ben Wittes: A Deep Rot

    Lauren Windsor and Ben Wittes: A Deep Rot
    Justice Alito and his wife seem to have some pretty deep and dark feelings about the people they dislike. Tim Miller also asks Lauren Windsor about the ethics of her undercover recordings. Plus, Ben Wittes shares his predictions for a presidential immunity ruling, his praise for Amy Coney Barrett's handing of the case, and his observations about the criminals Trump unapologetically hangs out with.

    show notes:

    Justice Alito's 2022 Notre Dame speech
    Lawfare's piece on a presidential self-pardon
    The Bulwark Podcast
    en-usJune 18, 2024

    Will Saletan: Nonstop Shamelessness

    Will Saletan: Nonstop Shamelessness
    Trump visited an African American church in Detroit and the pews were filled with white people; Republicans keep flooding social media with cropped videos to smear Biden; and foreign policy hawks, like Tom Cotton, now say we should be standing up to our allies, not Putin. MAGA land can't quit its shamelessness. Will Saletan joins Tim Miller, who is back from vacation.

    show notes:

    Detroit reporter shared images from Trump's Black church event
    The Bulwark Podcast
    en-usJune 17, 2024

    Related Episodes

    The 2024 Campaign: Trump vs. Biden or Are We in for A Surprise?

    The 2024 Campaign: Trump vs. Biden or Are We in for A Surprise?
    As Greg heads off on vacation, he and Jim break down the current state of the 2024 presidential campaign for Republicans and Democrats. Does Trump have a stranglehold on the GOP nomination despite big negatives with the general electorate and four major legal fights looming next year? And do his leads in some polls against President Biden undercut the DeSantis argument that he is the better bet next year?

    They also dissect where the Democrats stand. Biden has a massive lead among Democrats but his polling is terrible, especially on the economy. Will Democrats roll the dice and stick with Biden in hopes Trump is even more unpopular? Will they move on to Vice President Harris, whom very few in the party seem to have any confidence in? Or will Gov. Gavin Newsom or some other Democrat emerge the worse Biden's health and poll numbers get?

    Finally, they consider the Senate map for 2024, where Republicans could gain seats, where they risk wasting more good opportunities, and much more.

    Please visit our great sponsors:

    4Patriot
    https://4Patriots.com
    Use code MARTINI to get 10% off your purchase.

    Handel on the News

    Handel on the News
    Neil Saavedra & Amy King Join Bill for Handel on the News. Takeaways from the CNN Republican presidential debate with Nikki Haley and Ron DeSantis. Right-wing GOP shuts down House action over government funding plan. Christie ends his presidential bid in an effort to blunt Trump’s momentum before Iowa’s GOP caucuses. House GOP votes to cite Hunter Biden for contempt for defying subpoena. Starbucks sued for alleged deceptive marketing of its ‘100% ethically’ sourced coffee. One man was killed and another person injured in an avalanche at a Tahoe-area resort. Mortgage applications soar in the first week of the year as rates trend lower.