Logo
    Search

    “The Media’s Afghanistan Amnesia.”

    enAugust 24, 2021

    Podcast Summary

    • President Biden's efforts to evacuate Americans and Afghans from AfghanistanAmidst chaotic conditions, Biden is increasing evacuation pace, but potential ISIS attacks and large crowds pose ongoing risks. He promises to bring all evacuated Afghan refugees to the US and expresses empathy for the process.

      President Biden is working to evacuate thousands of Americans and Afghans from Afghanistan amidst chaotic and dangerous conditions. Despite the challenges, the pace of evacuations is increasing, but potential ISIS attacks and large crowds at the airport pose ongoing risks. Biden has promised to bring all evacuated Afghan refugees to the United States and has expressed empathy for the heartbreaking images of the evacuation process. Meanwhile, Republican politicians are catering to an increasingly extreme base, and there are numerous gubernatorial candidates in California that may be unfamiliar to some. In other news, Jon Lovett's comedy show, "Lovett or Leavett," is coming to New York City for a live performance at the New York Comedy Festival, and Rebecca Nagle's podcast, "This Land," is exploring custody battles over Native American children and the efforts of right-wing activists to dismantle American Indian tribes.

    • The Chaotic Evacuation from Afghanistan and its Human CostDespite the focus on evacuation chaos, remember the significant human cost of the Afghanistan war, estimated at over 170,000 lives since 2001.

      The recent evacuation from Afghanistan was unexpectedly chaotic, and the administration could have communicated better about the potential challenges. The Afghan military was overestimated in its ability to function independently, leading to a larger number of people trying to leave as the US withdrew. While the focus has been on the heartbreaking images of people unable to evacuate, it's essential to remember the significant human cost of the war in Afghanistan over the past 20 years. The Costs of War project estimates that over 170,000 Afghan citizens have been killed directly since 2001, including civilians, soldiers, and Taliban. The best-case scenario for the evacuation would have been a more efficient visa process and an earlier start to the withdrawal. Ultimately, the chaos of the evacuation underscores the importance of acknowledging the human cost of war and the need for effective communication and planning in military withdrawals.

    • Complex factors influenced chaotic Afghanistan withdrawalThe chaotic withdrawal from Afghanistan was caused by the Afghan govt's fear of losing confidence, logistical challenges, fragile military, and underestimation of Taliban's advance.

      The chaotic withdrawal from Afghanistan was influenced by complex factors including the Afghan government's fear of a mass evacuation being perceived as a vote of no confidence, logistical challenges, and the fragility of the Afghan military. The US embassy advised American citizens to leave as early as May 15th, but many chose to stay due to personal reasons or commitment to their mission. The Afghan military, which had been reportedly inflated in numbers, faced challenges such as ghost soldiers, lack of proper training, and loyalty to the Taliban. The Biden administration, believing they had more time, underestimated the speed of the Taliban's advance. These factors combined led to the chaotic scenes witnessed during the evacuation.

    • Reflections on America's role in the world post-AfghanistanThe chaotic withdrawal from Afghanistan raises questions about America's leadership and direction in the face of global challenges like the pandemic and climate change.

      The withdrawal from Afghanistan has sparked intense reflection on the larger meaning and direction of America as a global power. The chaos of the withdrawal has overshadowed discussions on the lessons learned from the 20-year conflict. The juxtaposition of America's inability to successfully manage the Afghan withdrawal against the backdrop of other global challenges, such as the pandemic and climate change, leaves many questioning the country's leadership and direction. The media coverage has primarily focused on the human stories and the chaos of the withdrawal, with fewer voices expressing humility and introspection. Institutional and political leaders have yet to engage in meaningful conversations about America's role in the world and where it is heading. The lack of these conversations in mainstream media outlets is a cause for concern, as the world continues to grapple with complex issues that require collective action and leadership.

    • Discussing the complexities of protecting human rights around the worldMilitary intervention vs other methods, human cost of war, rebuilding trust, declining approval ratings, helping Afghan interpreters, thoughtful foreign policy discussions

      Protecting human rights around the world is a complex issue with no easy answers. The discussion raised questions about the effectiveness and morality of military intervention versus other methods. The ongoing situation in Afghanistan serves as a reminder of the human cost of war, including civilian casualties, and the challenges of rebuilding trust after military intervention. The recent polls indicating declining approval ratings for President Biden, particularly among independents and rural voters, may be influenced by concerns over Afghanistan and the pandemic, but it's important to remember that these issues exist within a larger context. The desire for helping Afghan interpreters to come to the US highlights the humanitarian aspect of the situation, but there are also concerns about potential backlash and increased risks from terrorist groups. Overall, the conversation underscores the need for thoughtful and nuanced discussions on foreign policy and human rights.

    • Swing Voters' Disengagement from PoliticsDespite their crucial role, swing voters are less engaged in politics, leading to unpredictable voting patterns due to ongoing crises and economic uncertainty, while Biden's approval rating remains relatively stable due to political polarization.

      Swing voters, who are crucial in elections, are less engaged in politics compared to other voters. This disengagement could lead to unpredictable voting patterns closer to the election. The current state of the country, with ongoing crises and economic uncertainty, may keep Americans focused on their personal lives rather than politics. Biden's approval rating, though it has dropped below 50%, is expected to maintain a certain level due to growing political polarization, which has made Democrats more supportive of their politicians. The issues driving votes in the midterms are unpredictable, with the pandemic and the economy remaining significant factors.

    • Polarization and Extremism in US PoliticsRight-wing extremists are using inflammatory language and threatening violence, with some receiving sympathetic responses from elected officials. It's important to address the root causes and hold individuals accountable, while also recognizing the potential desensitizing effect of constant exposure.

      The political climate in the United States is becoming increasingly polarized, with extremist factions using inflammatory language and threatening violence against democratically elected institutions. The case of a right-wing extremist receiving a sympathetic tweet from a Republican congressman, and the actions of Marjorie Taylor Greene and Matt Gaetz, highlight this trend. The mainstream media's coverage of these events is a subject of debate, with some arguing that it gives these individuals undeserved attention and others believing that it's important to hold them accountable for their words and actions. The larger conversation should focus on how we as a society can address the root causes of this extremism and prevent it from spreading further. The numbing effect of constant exposure to such behavior is also a concern, as it may desensitize us to the dangers it poses. Ultimately, it's crucial to recognize the severity of these threats and take steps to address them before they escalate further.

    • Political divide rooted in racial coding and white supremacyUnderstand the connection between race, white supremacy, and the political divide in America. Recognize the role of the Republican Party and our own complicity in allowing these issues to persist. Reflect on past events and engage in macro-level conversations to shape global politics.

      The political divide in America, as exemplified by figures like Marjorie Taylor Greene and Matt Gaetz, is deeply rooted in racial coding and white supremacy. These issues are not only present in extreme rhetoric but also influence our notions of American idealism and hegemony. It's crucial for us to acknowledge the through line of race in these stories and engage in a higher-level conversation about moving past it. The Republican Party, as a major political force, cannot be ignored, and we must also recognize our own complicity in allowing these issues to persist. The ongoing political discourse often leaves little room for reflection and introspection, but it's essential to examine the lessons from past events, such as the withdrawal from Afghanistan, and engage in macro-level conversations about our role in shaping global politics. Ultimately, Marjorie Taylor Greene and other extremist figures are a product of our society and require a collective effort to address the root causes and prevent their continued influence.

    • The Extreme Political Landscape and the Challenge of Vaccine Narrative ControlPoliticians struggle to control the narrative on vaccines due to the extreme political climate, resulting in boos for pro-vaccine messages and prioritization of power over public health.

      The political landscape, particularly within the Republican Party, has become so extreme that even figures like Donald Trump can no longer fully control the narrative. This was evident in the boos Trump received for speaking positively about vaccines at a rally. Many attendees were not genuinely opposed, but rather expressing their frustration and commitment to the party's current stance. The situation is reminiscent of the January 6th attack, where some politicians, including Trump, seemed surprised by the radicalism of their supporters. Despite this, these politicians continue to prioritize power over public health and are unwilling to change course, even in the face of misinformation. Engaging with those who remain skeptical about vaccines requires a personal, local approach, focusing on trusted sources like doctors and family members. The situation is complex, but open dialogue and understanding may be key to making progress.

    • Messaging matters during the pandemic and electionsFocus on constructive messaging to encourage vaccinations and precautions, address pandemic-related kitchen table issues, and highlight Republican extremism to resonate with voters and influence midterm outcomes.

      During discussions about the impact of the pandemic and the upcoming elections, it's essential to consider the power of messaging and the human cost behind various perspectives. While it's understandable for individuals to have strong opinions, it's crucial to be mindful of the potential harm caused by sneering at those who have died or living in constant fear and alarm. Instead, focusing on helpful and constructive messaging that encourages vaccinations and precautions can make a significant difference in ending the pandemic and saving lives. From a political standpoint, Democrats should prioritize addressing pandemic-related kitchen table issues, but not ignore the importance of highlighting the extremism of the Republican party. Balancing both messages effectively can resonate with voters and influence the outcome of the midterms.

    • Focusing on kitchen table issues for midterm successDemocrats should prioritize policies on healthcare, jobs, and climate change to resonate with voters and win midterm elections, rather than solely relying on fear or offensive statements from opponents.

      For Democrats to win midterm elections, they need to focus on kitchen table issues that resonate with regular people, rather than solely on offensive statements made by their opponents. While it's important to acknowledge the presence of extremism and violence within the political landscape, Democrats should not rely solely on fear as a motivator. Instead, they should frame the choice for voters by highlighting the potential consequences of Republican control. Delivering on key policies, particularly those related to healthcare, jobs, and climate change, could help turn out the necessary voters and make a difference in people's lives. Ultimately, the state of the pandemic and economy will play a significant role in the outcome of the midterms, and Democrats should focus on policies that address these issues.

    • Effective communication for Democrats in midtermsDemocrats should focus on COVID-19 relief, reach out to base, moderates, and new voters to maintain coalition, and communicate effectively in upcoming midterm elections.

      The Democrats need to effectively communicate their accomplishments and contrast their policies with the Republicans in the upcoming midterm elections. They should focus on issues that will help end the pandemic and improve the economy, such as signing legislation for COVID-19 relief checks. Additionally, they need to reach out to both their base and moderate voters, as well as new voters who have recently become politically engaged. The Democrats' success in the 2020 election was due to a diverse coalition, and they must maintain this coalition in the midterms. The stakes are high, as the winner of a potential recall election in California only needs a plurality of votes to become governor. It's essential for voters to take this seriously and stay informed.

    • Understanding the Complex California Recall ElectionConsider the potential consequences of a recall, fact-check information, and participate actively and informedly in the democratic process.

      The California gubernatorial recall election is a complex issue with significant implications. While some voters may not be motivated to participate, it's important to consider the potential consequences of a recall. If successful, the replacement governor could push for policies that contradict current ones on minimum wage, environmental protections, and more. Voters should consider their preferences carefully and understand that their choices matter. Additionally, some names and bios discussed during the conversation were real, while others were not. It's crucial to fact-check information before making decisions. Lastly, the controversy surrounding the second question of the recall election adds complexity, with some suggesting voting "no" on question 1 and leaving question 2 blank, while others advocate for writing in a candidate. Ultimately, informed and active participation in the democratic process is essential.

    • Controversial facts about Larry Elder revealed on podcastLarry Elder, California gubernatorial recall election front runner, has made controversial statements and actions in the past, including calling diversity a form of fascism, arguing black families were better off as slaves, and demanding an ex-girlfriend to get a tattoo. Voters should be informed before making their decision.

      During a discussion on a podcast about the California gubernatorial recall election, the hosts revealed some controversial facts about the current Republican front runner, Larry Elder. Elder, a right-wing radio host, has made several controversial statements and actions in the past, including calling diversity a form of liberal fascism, arguing that black families were better off as slaves, and demanding an ex-girlfriend to get a tattoo. These facts were confirmed as real during the podcast's "Jeopardy-style" game. It's important to note that these revelations come as Elder is running for governor in California, and voters should be aware of these facts when making their decision. Additionally, the podcast reminded listeners that they can vote by mail or in person during the upcoming recall election.

    • Collaboration of digital team membersEffective team communication involves collaboration from all departments, including the digital team, which produces and shares content as videos, expanding reach and impact.

      Effective communication in a team setting requires collaboration from various departments, including the digital team. The digital team, specifically Elijah Cone, Phoebe Bradford, Milo Kim, Gail Fried, and Narmel Konian, play a crucial role in producing and sharing content as videos every week. Their contributions ensure that the team's messages reach a wider audience through multiple platforms. By working together, each team member brings their unique skills and expertise to the table, ultimately enhancing the overall impact and reach of the team's communication efforts.

    Recent Episodes from Pod Save America

    Joe vs. The Unknown

    Joe vs. The Unknown

    Democrats begin to grapple with two huge questions: is it possible to replace Biden at the top of the ticket—and is it wise? Mehdi Hasan joins Jon, Lovett, Tommy, and Dan, live in Boston, to debate the options. Plus, Gov. Maura Healey joins the show to give her own debate reaction and talk about rising to the challenge on immigration and abortion.

    The First (and Last?) Debate

    The First (and Last?) Debate

    The first debate is upon us, and you’re not the only one feeling nervous. Guest host Stacey Abrams joins Jon, Jon, Tommy, and Dan, live in Brooklyn, to talk about what we can learn from the 2020 debates, and what would constitute a win for Biden on Thursday night. Then, Strict Scrutiny’s Melissa Murray joins the hosts to break down the latest from the Supreme Court and what’s still to come this term, and Run for Something co-founder Amanda Litman talks with Dan about why it’s so important to have progressive candidates running in local races.Democracy or Else is out now! 

     

    Pick up your copy wherever you buy books, or at http://crooked.com/books.

     

    Want to join Crooked’s subscriber live chat for the presidential debate? Sign up at http://crooked.com/friends.

    This Is Your Debate on Drugs

    This Is Your Debate on Drugs

    Donald Trump vows to cut education funding by half, throws his support behind displaying the Ten Commandments in public classrooms, and offers a new, anatomically specific theory for how Joe Biden gets his pre-debate uppers. With Biden holed up in debate camp, his campaign works to set expectations, and marks the second anniversary of the end of Roe v. Wade with a blistering new attack ad and waves of surrogate events around the country. Plus, it’s publication day at last: Democracy or Else: How to Save America in 10 Easy Steps is out now! Head to your local bookstore or www.crooked.com/books to order your copy.

     

    For a closed-captioned version of this episode, click here. For a transcript of this episode, please email transcripts@crooked.com and include the name of the podcast.

    How Democrats Can Win Latinos Back (Ep. 4)

    How Democrats Can Win Latinos Back (Ep. 4)

    Jon is joined by Carlos Odio and Stephanie Valencia, founders of Equis Research, the nation’s leading polling and research firm focused on the Latino electorate, to talk about what Democrats can do to win back the Latino voters who left the party for Trump in 2016 and 2020. Why are some of them leaning towards Trump? How did they react to Biden’s border actions? And what issues are they most focused on in 2024? Jon, Carlos, and Stephanie dive into the focus groups to answer these questions and Leo Murrieta, Director of Make the Road Nevada, joins to talk about his trip to the White House and offer his advice for the Biden campaign.

    Take action with Vote Save America: Visit votesaveamerica.com/2024  

    Pre-order Democracy or Else: How to Save America in 10 Easy Steps at crooked.com/books or wherever books are sold. Out June 25th.

    Pod Save America
    enJune 23, 2024

    Trump Loses It Over Fox News Poll

    Trump Loses It Over Fox News Poll

    Joe Biden heads to Camp David to prepare for next week's debate, Donald Trump bungles the expectations game, and both sides prepare for the post-broadcast clip war. Meanwhile, a new Fox News poll shows Biden ahead, and Trump lashes out at the betrayal. Then, former White House Counsel Bob Bauer stops by to talk about playing Trump in debate prep in 2020, the Supreme Court, and his new book, The Unraveling: Reflections on Politics without Ethics and Democracy in Crisis. 

     

    To pre-order Democracy or Else, out June 25th, visit www.crooked.com/books 

     

    To buy tickets for book events and live shows, visit www.crooked.com/events

    The Plan to Fight Trump's Second-Term Agenda

    The Plan to Fight Trump's Second-Term Agenda

    Joe Biden makes a big new move on immigration, and Democratic governors and progressive groups quietly make plans to fight back against the second-term agenda that Trump is promising, from mass deportations to bans on medication abortion and gutting the civil service. Strict Scrutiny's Kate Shaw joins Jon and Lovett to talk about the legal challenges in store for both Trump and Biden, the Supreme Court's dangerous decision on bump stocks, and what else we can expect from the justices with so many opinions yet to drop.

     

    For a closed-captioned version of this episode, click here. For a transcript of this episode, please email transcripts@crooked.com and include the name of the podcast.

    Biden Campaign Unloads on Trump's Conviction

    Biden Campaign Unloads on Trump's Conviction

    The Biden campaign puts big money into a new ad slamming Trump as a convicted felon, fraudster, and sexual predator, and painting Biden as a fighter for working families. Trump courts the Black vote in front of a mostly white audience in Detroit, and CNN announces the final rules for next week’s debate. Plus: Jon, Lovett, and Tommy talk about who’s up and who’s down in the race to be Trump’s VP.To preorder you copy of Democracy or Else, visit http://crooked.com/booksFor tickets to upcoming live shows and book events, visit http://crooked.com/events

    For a closed-captioned version of this episode, click here. For a transcript of this episode, please email transcripts@crooked.com and include the name of the podcast.

    Trump Returns to the Scene of the Crime

    Trump Returns to the Scene of the Crime

    Trump returns to the Capitol for the first time since January 6th and receives a hero’s welcome from House and Senate Republicans—where he calls Milwaukee a “horrible city,” refers to the Justice Department as “dirty bastards,” and complains about Taylor Swift not endorsing him. Meanwhile, the same Republicans attempting to overturn Trump’s conviction are instead trying to prosecute Attorney General Merrick Garland. Plus, SCOTUS affirms legal access to abortion medication, Biden takes voters’ cost of living concerns head on, and Trump tries to woo CEOs with more tax cuts.

    The GOP Meltdown Over Hunter's Conviction

    The GOP Meltdown Over Hunter's Conviction

    Dan and The Bulwark’s Sarah Longwell break down the chaotic Republican response to the Hunter Biden news and what the conviction might mean for the Biden campaign, which of Donald Trump’s rumored VP picks scare them the most, and the latest from Tuesday’s primaries.

     

    For a closed-captioned version of this episode, click here. For a transcript of this episode, please email transcripts@crooked.com and include the name of the podcast.

    Related Episodes

    Sgt. Dan McKnight on Why the Afghanistan Withdrawal Became a Disaster - A Neighbor's Choice

    Sgt. Dan McKnight on Why the Afghanistan Withdrawal Became a Disaster - A Neighbor's Choice

    Sgt. Dan McKnight of Bring Our Troops Home joins David Gornoski to comment on the withdrawal from Afghanistan. What had happened during the negotiations with the Taliban at Doha last year? Did General Milley tell the truth in saying there was no intelligence to predict a swift Taliban takeover? Is there trouble brewing in the White House between Kamala Harris and Joe Biden? What did Assange reveal about the Afghanistan war? Listen to the full episode to find out and more.

    Visit the website of Bring Our Troops Home at bringourtroopshome.us
    Visit A Neighbor's Choice at aneighborschoice.com

    Rules for Thee but Not for Me - A Neighbor's Choice

    Rules for Thee but Not for Me - A Neighbor's Choice

    Morgan Streetman, host of the Morgan Streetman Show, guest hosts this exciting episode of A Neighbor's Choice. What do we make of the rules like the mask mandates being multiplied for average Americans like us? Shouldn't we be allowed to "feel the spirit" like London Breed? Will there be any accountability for the Afghanistan debacle? Why is Biden too eager for illegal immigrants to surge the border? Listen to the full episode to find out and more.

    Visit A Neighbor's Choice at aneighborschoice.com

    Fall of Grand Narratives - A Neighbor's Choice

    Fall of Grand Narratives - A Neighbor's Choice

    Was it "white rage" that caused Gen. Milley to carry out a drone strike on innocent people in Afghanistan? David Gornoski asks this question as he deciphers the victimhood optics of DC elites who divide and cause chaos in America. Surit Dasgupta, writer at A Neighbor's Choice, joins David to explore some of the themes and narratives being spun by the status quo while reflecting on what might come ahead.

    Visit A Neighbor's Choice at aneighborschoice.com

    Episode 264: Nate's Thoughts Bonus Episode: ModState Podcast Episode 264

    Episode 264: Nate's Thoughts Bonus Episode: ModState Podcast Episode 264

    Welcome back to the ModState Podcast! 

    As John and his family race from the largest storm since 1850, Nate sites down on a lovely Denver Sunday to discuss his thoughts. 

    On this episode Nate begins with the developing tragedy across the US as Covid-19 cases spike. At what point did we lose the idea of Freedom with responsibility to Freedom without responsibility. Has the forest been lost from the trees?

    Nate finishes the episode discussion the fall of Afghanistan the death of American Service members. 

    As always thank you for tuning into ModState. Please leave your comments at ModState@ModState.com or wherever you leave your comments. Stay Safe!