Podcast Summary
The Extended Mind: Our Thinking Goes Beyond Our Skulls: Recognizing the role of our bodies, environment, and relationships in shaping our thoughts can enhance cognitive abilities and improve overall thinking
Learning from this episode of the 10 Percent Happier podcast is that our thinking is not limited to our skulls, but rather, it extends to our bodies, our surroundings, and the people around us. This concept, known as the extended mind, suggests that the best thinking requires us to access these external resources. Annie Murphy Paul, the science writer and fellow at New America, explores this idea in her latest book, "The Extended Mind." She argues that by recognizing the role of our bodies, our environment, and our relationships in shaping our thoughts, we can enhance our cognitive abilities and improve our overall thinking. This may sound abstract, but Paul provides practical techniques to help us make the most of these external resources. If you're interested in upgrading your mind, this is a must-listen interview.
The mind extends beyond the skull: The extended mind concept challenges the traditional view of the mind being solely located within the brain, suggesting that our surroundings, relationships, and tools are integral to our thought processes and can enhance our cognitive abilities
The mind does not stop at the skull but extends beyond it into our physical surroundings, relationships, and tools. This idea, proposed by philosophers Andy Clark and David Chalmers, challenges the conventional view that the mind is solely located within the brain. By recognizing this extended mind concept, we can see ourselves as creatures of the world and potentially improve our thinking abilities by utilizing the resources around us. This perspective, though deep and abstract, has practical implications and can lead to a transformative view of learning and understanding.
Embracing the extended mind: The extended mind perspective encourages us to expand our understanding of thinking beyond our minds, embracing the richness of our embodied experiences for improved awareness and decision-making.
Our thinking is not limited to our minds, but is deeply connected to our bodies and surroundings. This idea, which is explored in the concept of the "extended mind," shares similarities with Buddhism in its rejection of a fixed, essential self. By embracing this perspective, we can live and think better by becoming more attuned to our bodies and the world around us. This includes practices like interoception, or paying attention to internal sensations, which can lead to increased awareness and better decision-making. In essence, the extended mind encourages us to expand our understanding of thinking beyond the confines of our minds and embrace the richness of our embodied experiences.
Our bodies provide subtle cues for important information and potential dangers: Interoceptive signals from our bodies can guide us towards important information and help us make informed decisions, even if they seem to be based on intuition or gut feelings.
Our bodies play a crucial role in accessing nonconscious experience and knowledge. Interoceptive signals, such as feelings of nervousness or excitement, act as subtle cues from our bodies, guiding us towards important information or potential dangers. The concept of intuition and gut feelings can be seen as related phenomena. While we may have been conditioned to view these as less reliable than conscious thought processes, research shows that they can be more informed and adaptive at times. However, it's essential to be aware of our biases and evaluate the evidence from both our thinking mind and body before making decisions. Additionally, incorporating movement into our thinking process can help us approach complex problems more effectively. Contrary to the common belief that deep thinking requires complete stillness, thinking with movement allows us to engage our bodies and minds in a dynamic way, leading to clearer and more innovative thought processes.
The connection between movement and thinking: Our intelligence evolved through activities combining cognitive and physical effort. Movements stimulate creativity by influencing our minds, as described in phrases like 'ideas are flowing' or 'on a roll'.
Our evolutionary history as human beings shows that we are designed to think and move at the same time. Our intelligence was developed through activities that required both cognitive and physical effort. The idea of separating these two aspects of our lives, working with our brains during the day and then exercising after work, is not in line with our nature as embodied creatures. Movements and physical activities can help us solve problems and think more creatively. This is because our minds can influence our bodies just as our bodies can influence our minds. We use language to reflect this, with phrases like "ideas are flowing" or "on a roll," which describe a fluid mental state. Engaging in activities that mimic this fluidity, such as walking or swimming, can help us think more creatively. Research supports this idea, suggesting that people who move in more fluid ways come up with more creative ideas. Embracing this idea and allowing ourselves to fidget or engage in micromovements can help us think more clearly and effectively.
Regulating alertness and mental state through fidgeting: Fidgeting and small body movements help regulate alertness, arousal, and mental state, and can even enhance thinking abilities for individuals with ADHD. In certain settings, these movements may be perceived as disruptive, but flexibility in work arrangements and activity-permissive environments in education can lead to increased focus and attention.
Fidgeting and small body movements, such as those made at a standing desk, are not just distracting behaviors, but rather important ways for us to regulate our alertness, arousal, and mental state. For individuals with ADHD, these movements can even enhance their thinking abilities. However, in certain settings like classrooms and meetings, these movements may be perceived as disruptive. The shift to remote work has provided more flexibility for those who need to move while working. In education, some schools have adopted activity-permissive environments, allowing students to use tools like yoga balls or standing desks, which has led to increased focus and attention. Additionally, gesture is an essential aspect of communication and thinking, often preceding spoken language. When we restrict gestures, our thinking and expression become less effective. Therefore, encouraging the use of body movements and gestures can enhance our cognitive processes and overall productivity.
Body language matters in communication: Effective communication involves both words and body language. Use gestures naturally to help convey meaning and engage audience, remember viewers remember and pay more attention to comments accompanied by gestures.
Effective communication goes beyond just the words we speak. Our body language, including gestures, plays a significant role in how our messages are received. Research suggests that audiences pay as much attention to our body language as they do to our words. Symbolic gestures can help convey the meaning of our messages, while beat gestures can establish a cadence and engage our audience. When we're struggling to understand or explain complex ideas, we naturally gesture more. However, it's important not to overthink our gestures and instead let them feel natural. Studies show that viewers remember and pay more attention to comments accompanied by gestures, not just for the benefit of the audience, but for ourselves as well. By incorporating gestures into our communication, we can make our thought processes less effortful and more fluid.
Affordable Ethical Fashion with Quince: Quince offers stylish, ethical clothing at lower prices by cutting out the middleman and maintaining safe manufacturing practices. Audible provides access to a wide range of audiobooks and one free title per month for new members.
Quince is a company offering high-quality, stylish, and ethically-produced clothing at affordable prices. The host has been impressed with their selection of seasonal must-haves, such as linen shirts, polos, and active wear, all priced 50-80% less than similar brands. Quince cuts out the middleman, allowing for lower prices while maintaining safe, ethical, and responsible manufacturing practices. Additionally, Audible offers an extensive selection of audiobooks across various genres with one title a month to keep for new members, and a 30-day free trial. Another key takeaway is the idea of "thinking with your surroundings," which refers to the human brain's sensitivity to context. Our brains process stimuli most effortlessly and easily in natural environments, leading to mental calm and relaxation. This is in contrast to the intense concentration required in work or school settings, which can quickly drain mental resources.
The Benefits of Nature for Cognitive Function and Well-being: Spending time outside improves cognitive function and overall well-being, while indoor plants and greenery bring the benefits of nature inside. Our brains function differently in nature, allowing for better focus and productivity. Design of workspaces and use of evocative objects can enhance cognitive performance.
Spending time outside and incorporating natural elements into our surroundings can significantly improve our cognitive function and overall well-being. Our brains function differently when we're outside, and this diffuse attention mode can help replenish our attentional resources when they're drained. Indoor plants and greenery are also beneficial in bringing the outdoors inside. Furthermore, the design of our workspaces plays a crucial role in how our minds function. Evocative objects, such as reminders of our identity and belonging, can help us feel more focused and productive. Additionally, getting ideas and information out of our heads and onto physical space can make our thinking more efficient and effective, as our brains are better suited for navigating through physical space and manipulating material objects than wrestling with abstract concepts.
Engage Bodies for Enhanced Communication and Productivity: Incorporating physical spaces and activities can significantly enhance communication and productivity by engaging our bodies and improving focus, understanding, and group cohesion.
Effective communication and productivity can be significantly enhanced by incorporating embodied resources beyond just our brains. This can be achieved through the use of physical spaces like whiteboards or post-it notes, as well as activities like walking meetings or synchronized movements. By engaging our bodies in the process, we can better understand and organize ideas, improve focus, and foster a stronger sense of group cohesion. This approach can be particularly beneficial in educational and workplace settings, where the traditional "factory model" of sitting and absorbing information may no longer be the most effective or engaging way to learn or work. So, if you're looking to run a more productive and engaging meeting, consider encouraging physical activity, synchronized movements, and the use of large, visible spaces to help your team connect and communicate more effectively.
Recognize the value of collaboration in thinking: In a Buddhist perspective, everything is interconnected and rigid divides between people are an illusion. Collaboration is key to breaking down complex processes and making knowledge more accessible to novices. Engage in productive dialogue to form a 'group mind' and tackle complex issues together.
Thinking is not an individualistic activity, but rather a collaborative one. According to the speaker, in our individualistic culture, we often view our ideas and achievements as solely our own. However, if we adopt a Buddhist perspective, we would see that everything is interconnected and that rigid divides between people are an illusion. Thinking with our relationships means recognizing the value of collaboration and making experts' knowledge more accessible to novices. This can be done by breaking down complex processes into steps and making conscious choices more explicit. Additionally, we should not separate intellectual life from social life, but rather engage in productive dialogue with others to form a "group mind" and tackle complex issues together.
Social activities enhance cognitive abilities: Engaging in social activities like debates, storytelling, teaching, and even arguments can deepen our thinking and learning, while strong relationships and open communication further enrich our cognitive processes
Our social nature plays a crucial role in our thinking and learning processes. Instead of viewing social activities as distractions, we should harness them to enhance our cognitive abilities. Engaging in debates, telling stories, and teaching others are examples of deeply social activities that activate our minds in ways that solitary work cannot. Even arguments, when productive, can help clarify thoughts and perspectives. As philosopher Andy Clark puts it, we are "intrinsically loopy creatures," benefiting from making mental loops with others. While groupthink can have negative consequences, working in groups is essential for tackling complex challenges. Building strong relationships and communicating openly about our thoughts and feelings, as exemplified by therapy, further enriches our thinking processes. In essence, our social connections are not just nice-to-haves, but necessary tools for effective thinking and learning.
Creating a sense of groupiness leads to effective group thinking: Synchronized activities, cognitive apprenticeship, and a transactive memory system can foster a sense of unity in groups, enhancing their intellectual capabilities.
Effective group thinking goes beyond the sum of individual intellects and can lead to great achievements. This can be achieved by creating a sense of groupiness, which is an embodied, metaphorical feeling of unity. Synchronized activities like walking in rhythm or taking part in group projects can foster this feeling. Another approach is cognitive apprenticeship, where one models and makes explicit their thought process for others. Additionally, a transactive memory system, where team members know who possesses the necessary knowledge, can exponentially increase access to information. However, it's important to note that the extended mind concept does not apply equally to all people, leading to what's called extension inequality. This means that some individuals and groups have greater access to the extended mind due to various factors like resources, education, and opportunities.
The importance of external resources in shaping our intelligence: Access to resources like green spaces, expertise, and mobility significantly impacts our thinking abilities and overall intelligence, extending beyond brain-bound abilities
Access to external resources, such as green spaces, expertise, and the freedom to move, significantly impacts our thinking abilities and overall intelligence. The traditional measures of intelligence, which focus solely on brain-bound abilities, overlook the importance of these external factors. The concept of the "extended mind" suggests that our thinking is not limited to our brains, but rather assembled from the raw materials we have access to in the world. Therefore, it's crucial to consider this access when evaluating people and making decisions, such as hiring or university admissions. We should encourage the development of all of our extended minds as we tackle the complex challenges of the world. The author, Annie Murphy Paul, emphasizes the importance of this concept, drawing from her observation of children's learning and development. Her book, "The Extended Mind: The Power of Thinking Outside the Brain," explores this idea in more depth. Check it out for further insights.
Two New Podcasts from Wondery and Tinkercast: 'Once Upon A Beat' and 'The Competition': Wondery and Tinkercast introduce 'Once Upon A Beat', a hip hop podcast for kids and families, and 'The Competition', a scholarship event podcast for high school senior girls. Both shows offer early and ad-free access with a Wondery Plus subscription.
Wondery and Tinkercast are bringing you a new podcast called "Once Upon A Beat," where classic fables get a fresh hip hop spin for kids and families. The team behind the podcast includes Kevin O'Connell as director of audio and post production, DJ Cashmere as managing producer, and Nick Thorburn of the band Islands as theme writer. Listeners can access early and ad-free episodes by subscribing to Wondery Plus or Wondery Kids Plus. Shimole Yai, the host, invites listeners to join her and Baby Scratch as they reimagine old tales in a weekly music-filled podcast. Meanwhile, Pineapple Street Studios and Wondery present "The Competition," where 50 high school senior girls compete in a scholarship event. Hosted by Shimole Yai, this podcast offers insights into the experiences of young women in America today. Both shows are available for early and ad-free listening with a Wondery Plus subscription.