Podcast Summary
The Interconnected Relationship Between the Real Economy and Financial Markets: Central banks' influence on asset prices creates a cycle of growth, inequality, and intervention, which has been intensified by the pandemic. Proposed solutions include fiscal stimulus and full employment policies to promote sustainable growth, while financialization can mitigate downturns but also risks inequality and bubbles.
The relationship between the real economy and financial markets is increasingly interconnected, with asset prices playing a significant role in driving economic growth. Central banks, through interest rates, have become a major influence on asset prices, creating a cycle of growth, inequality, and central bank intervention. This cycle has been accelerated by the COVID-19 pandemic. The question then becomes, how to break this cycle and promote sustainable economic growth. Some proposed solutions include fiscal stimulus and full employment policies. The financialization of the economy, including the rise of private sector debt and corporate leverage, can mitigate the impact of economic downturns, but also risks exacerbating inequality and asset price bubbles. The discomfort felt by some as the real economy struggles while financial assets boom highlights the need for a balanced approach to economic policy.
Central banks' actions causing markets to rely on them for support: Central banks' efforts to suppress financial volatility have created a 'carry regime' where markets rely on them for support, potentially leading to dangerous consequences in the future.
Central banks' actions in suppressing financial volatility have become the primary transmission mechanism of their monetary policy over the past two decades. This has led to markets becoming increasingly disconnected from the real economy, resulting in a vicious cycle of asset price dependency, market crashes, and central bank intervention. The authors of the book "The Rise of Carry, The Dangerous Consequences of Volatility Suppression and the New Financial Order of Decaying Growth and Recurring Crisis" argue that this "carry regime" is the main driver of markets' spectacular rises and crashes over the past 25 years. Traders and investors have come to rely on central bank utterances as if they were divine decrees, rather than recognizing the larger economic trends and cycles at play. The authors warn that this reliance on central banks to support markets may lead to dangerous consequences in the future.
Carry trades and improved financial conditions: Carry trades provide liquidity to higher-interest-rate economies, improving financial conditions, but central banks must intervene during reversals to prevent liquidity drying up.
The carry regime, where financial structures and transactions dominated by carry trades have become the primary drivers of asset prices, has led to easier financial conditions and increased liquidity in the real economy. A concrete example of this is currency carry trades, where a trader borrows in a low-interest-rate market, like the US dollar, and provides those funds to a higher-interest-rate economy, such as Turkey. This provides much-needed liquidity to the higher-interest-rate economy, making it easier for businesses and individuals to access credit and conduct transactions. However, when the carry trade begins to reverse, financial conditions tighten, and central banks step in to prevent credit and liquidity from drying up for the real economy. The ease of transacting in financial assets, or market liquidity, is a crucial aspect of carry trades. The carry regime has changed the nature of money itself, with many financial assets becoming contingent liabilities of the central bank and appearing more money-like. However, during crashes, there is a sudden evaporation of liquidity across the board, forcing central banks to take drastic measures to prevent a complete financial meltdown.
Carry Trades: Making Money When Nothing Significant Happens: Carry trades involve using leverage to provide liquidity, generating consistent income but carrying the risk of sudden market shifts.
Carry trades, which involve using leverage to provide liquidity in a market, can be found in various forms, such as volatility selling trades in the stock market or real estate investments like buy-to-let properties. These trades generate consistent income but come with the risk of occasional sharp drawdowns. The stock market and overall economy are starting to exhibit similar characteristics as carry trades, leading to steady profits but potential crashes. A simple explanation of carry trades is that they make money when nothing significant happens, such as borrowing yen to invest in the Australian dollar or selling put options for a premium income. By providing liquidity to future traders, carry traders take on liquidity risk themselves. The buy-to-let property market is another example of a carry trade, where investors use leverage to purchase properties and convert them into short-term lease assets. Overall, carry trades are an essential part of financial markets, offering consistent income but carrying the risk of sudden market shifts.
Continuous earning of small profits in carry trades leads to major market crashes: Carry trades, where traders borrow in a low-interest currency to invest in a high-interest one, can lead to significant losses during market volatility. Central banks act as lenders of last resort, limiting losses but also encouraging more traders to enter the trade, potentially leading to more frequent crashes.
The underlying nature of financial risks in the market mirrors carry trades, leading to big crashes every decade. This is due to the idea of continuously earning small profits until a major blow-up occurs. For instance, in March of this year, hedge funds suffered significant losses due to the volatility in the treasury market, which was based on tiny differences between cash treasuries and futures contracts. Central banks, acting as lenders of last resort, truncate volatility and losses, making the balance sheets of natural carry traders stronger and encouraging more players to enter the trade. This expansion of carry trades can lead to fewer recessions or bear markets and more frequent crashes, as the moment income or asset prices start to decline, everything unravels quickly until a central bank intervenes.
Leveraged investments in low-interest currencies for income difference: Carry trades involve borrowing in a low-interest currency to invest in a high-interest one for income difference, but can lead to economic imbalances, unsustainable debt, and potential crashes.
Carry trades, as defined in the discussion, are liquidity providing, leveraged investments that aim to extract income. They involve borrowing in a low-interest currency and investing in an asset or high-interest currency. The primary goal is to benefit from the income difference, but the rise in the asset price creates imbalances and potential overvaluation. These imbalances can lead to unsustainable debt and current account deficits, making the economy increasingly asset price-dependent. Central banks' interventions can mitigate some of the crashes, but they also increase the risk and volatility for carry traders. As a result, the carry trade pattern exhibits a steady rise followed by a sudden crash, with the risk and potential rewards being higher for those willing to accept it. As a leading real estate manager, harnessing a 360-degree perspective can help investors navigate the complex carry trade landscape and uncover compelling opportunities in the market.
Impact of low interest rates and high liquidity on financial markets: Investors may need to adapt to increased skewness in asset prices and returns due to the current economic environment, and consider alternative investments to mitigate risk.
The current economic environment, characterized by low interest rates and high liquidity, has led to a carry regime that has significantly impacted the financial markets. This regime, which is linked to deflationary pressure, has changed the day-to-day nature of investing and trading. For financial professionals and traders, it has meant dealing with increased skewness in asset prices and returns. While some assets, like the S&P 500, have benefited from this skewness, it also comes with the risk of potential losses during market downturns. As a result, investors may need to allocate less to these assets and consider alternative investments to mitigate skewness risk. The authors of the book suggest that we may have passed the point of no return, and the end of the current monetary regime could lead to significant changes, including the demise of central banking and the emergence of new forms of money. However, it's important to note that the future is uncertain, and the implications for investors will depend on how these developments unfold.
Central bank actions leading to societal consequences: Central bank efforts to suppress market volatility can fuel social instability and populist discontent in inequitable societies, ultimately undermining the social fabric.
The suppression of volatility in financial markets by central banks can have far-reaching consequences beyond the economy. According to the discussion, this suppression of volatility can lead to increased dispersion and decreased correlation, which can manifest outside the market in society, particularly in inequitable societies. The Deutsche Bank note mentioned in the conversation argues that this suppressed volatility can fuel social instability and populist discontent. The speakers in the discussion agree with this notion and emphasize that the carry regime they describe, which is associated with rising inequality and deteriorating real growth, ultimately undermines the social fabric. However, they also caution against placing too much blame on central banks and instead emphasize the larger structural issues at play in society.
Central banks favor the wealthy in carry trade: Central banks prioritize wealthy investors in carry trade, impacting people's livelihoods and lives, normalized by financial industry and conventional wisdom.
Central banks act on behalf of the wealthy and powerful, despite their perceived role as agents for specific countries. The carry trade, a financial strategy that involves borrowing in a low-interest currency and investing in a higher-yielding one, disproportionately benefits the wealthy due to their access to larger balance sheets. Furthermore, people's livelihoods and lives have become increasingly tied to asset values, making them unwitting participants in the carry trade. The financial industry and conventional wisdom have adapted to this new normal, leading to greater acceptance and expectation of large-scale central bank intervention. This shift in perspective, as discussed in the book, has significantly altered the way people think about finance and markets compared to just a few decades ago.
The 'rise of carry' mindset and its impact on risk and asset prices: This mindset, which encourages buying dips and providing liquidity to leveraged traders, can lead to an increased focus on asset prices and potential volatility suppression in a sluggish growth environment, with implications for the economy as a whole.
The "rise of carry" mindset, which originated in financial markets but has spread beyond, has significantly changed how people think about risk, volatility, and asset prices. This mindset, which encourages buying dips and providing liquidity to leveraged traders, is highly analogous to market making strategies. The prevalence of this mindset, particularly among younger generations, has important implications for the economy as a whole. In a sluggish growth environment, people may feel compelled to engineer profits in more creative ways, leading to an increased focus on asset prices and potential volatility suppression. This perspective shares some similarities with the views of those who advocate for Modern Monetary Theory (MMT), highlighting the potential for synthesis between these seemingly disparate frameworks. The conversation between Tim, Jamie, and Kevin underscores the growing recognition that our economic system may be overly reliant on asset prices and the need for continuous volatility suppression, potentially masking underlying issues and setting the stage for future crises.
The economy's impact on financial markets: Bad economic news can boost risk assets due to investor reliance on central banks, leading to wealth being tied to financial assets and influencing policymakers' actions
The relationship between the economy and financial markets has become significantly skewed, with investors increasingly relying on central banks to stabilize markets during economic downturns. This perception, as discussed on the Odd Lots podcast, has led to a situation where bad economic news can actually be good for risk assets, such as stocks or real estate. This trend, driven in part by historically low interest rates and stagnant wage growth, has resulted in a large portion of people's wealth being tied to financial assets. This dynamic, in turn, influences policymakers' thinking and actions, potentially perpetuating the cycle. Potential solutions to this issue include more aggressive fiscal policy or macro prudential measures to regulate certain market behaviors. Overall, the discussion highlights the importance of understanding the complex interplay between the economy, financial markets, and policymakers.
New Bloomberg Podcast: Money Stuff with Matt Levine and Katie Greifelt: Bloomberg launches a new podcast, Money Stuff, featuring Matt Levine and Katie Greifelt discussing finance and related topics. American Express Business Gold Card offers enhanced rewards in top spending categories.
Bloomberg is launching a new podcast called Money Stuff, hosted by Matt Levine and Katie Greifelt. This podcast is based on Levine's popular Wall Street finance newsletter. Listeners can tune in every Friday to hear in-depth discussions on finance and related topics. Additionally, American Express Business Gold Card offers four times points on top two eligible spending categories each month, such as transit, US restaurants, and gas stations, with a yearly limit of $150,000. Listeners are encouraged to follow Laura Carlson, Francesca Levy, and Bloomberg Podcasts on various social media platforms for more business-related content.
