1944 - "My Heart Tells Me (Should I Believe My Heart?)" by Glen Gray and the Casa Loma Orchestra feat. Eugenie Baird
This week's episode might hold the record for longest title, but we'd expect nothing less from the 1940s, an era when every man had an orchestra and every orchestra had a random lady singer. Andrew and Dan are about to learn at least 2 facts about this Glen Gray hit, but not until they meticulously comb through this year's Oscar nominations. Because that's what this show is in a nutshell!